Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
ClaudeClaude Haiku 4.5· anthropicHugging Face Frontier Reasoning Traces

Derive the first-order energy correction formula in time-independent perturbation…

  1. User

    Derive the first-order energy correction formula in time-independent perturbation theory. Start with the perturbed Hamiltonian, expand energy and wavefunction as power series, and equate coefficients of lambda.

  2. Claude Assistant

    This is a classic problem in quantum mechanics. I'll walk through the derivation of the first-order energy correction in time-independent perturbation theory carefully and systematically.

    Setup

    We start with a perturbed Hamiltonian: H=H0+λH′H = H_0 + \lambda H'

    where:

    • H0H_0 is the unperturbed Hamiltonian (exactly solvable)
    • H′H' is the perturbation
    • λ\lambda is a small parameter (usually taken to be 1 at the end)

    We know the solutions to H0H_0 exactly: H0∣ψn(0)⟩=En(0)∣ψn(0)⟩H_0 |\psi_n^{(0)}\rangle = E_n^{(0)} |\psi_n^{(0)}\rangle

    We want to find the perturbed solutions: H∣ψn⟩=En∣ψn⟩H |\psi_n\rangle = E_n |\psi_n\rangle

    Power Series Expansion

    We expand the energy and wavefunction as power series in λ\lambda:

    En=En(0)+λEn(1)+λ2En(2)+...E_n = E_n^{(0)} + \lambda E_n^{(1)} + \lambda^2 E_n^{(2)} + ...

    ∣ψn⟩=∣ψn(0)⟩+λ∣ψn(1)⟩+λ2∣ψn(2)⟩+...|\psi_n\rangle = |\psi_n^{(0)}\rangle + \lambda |\psi_n^{(1)}\rangle + \lambda^2 |\psi_n^{(2)}\rangle + ...

    Eigenvalue Equation

    The time-independent Schrödinger equation is: (H0+λH′)∣ψn⟩=En∣ψn⟩(H_0 + \lambda H') |\psi_n\rangle = E_n |\psi_n\rangle

    Substituting the power series:

    (H0+λH′)[∣ψn(0)⟩+λ∣ψn(1)⟩+λ2∣ψn(2)⟩+...](H_0 + \lambda H')\left[|\psi_n^{(0)}\rangle + \lambda |\psi_n^{(1)}\rangle + \lambda^2 |\psi_n^{(2)}\rangle + ...\right]

    =[En(0)+λEn(1)+λ2En(2)+...][∣ψn(0)⟩+λ∣ψn(1)⟩+λ2∣ψn(2)⟩+...]= \left[E_n^{(0)} + \lambda E_n^{(1)} + \lambda^2 E_n^{(2)} + ...\right]\left[|\psi_n^{(0)}\rangle + \lambda |\psi_n^{(1)}\rangle + \lambda^2 |\psi_n^{(2)}\rangle + ...\right]

    Expanding Both Sides

    Now I expand each side systematically. The left side gives me terms from applying both H0H_0 and λH′\lambda H' to each order of the wavefunction expansion. The right side comes from multiplying the energy series by the wavefunction series, which generates cross terms between different orders.

    Coefficient of λ0\lambda^0: H0∣ψn(0)⟩=En(0)∣ψn(0)⟩H_0|\psi_n^{(0)}\rangle = E_n^{(0)}|\psi_n^{(0)}\rangle

    This recovers the unperturbed eigenvalue problem.

    Coefficient of λ1\lambda^1: H0∣ψn(1)⟩+H′∣ψn(0)⟩=En(0)∣ψn(1)⟩+En(1)∣ψn(0)⟩H_0|\psi_n^{(1)}\rangle + H'|\psi_n^{(0)}\rangle = E_n^{(0)}|\psi_n^{(1)}\rangle + E_n^{(1)}|\psi_n^{(0)}\rangle

    Rearranging to isolate the first-order wavefunction correction: (H0−En(0))∣ψn(1)⟩=En(1)∣ψn(0)⟩−H′∣ψn(0)⟩(H_0 - E_n^{(0)})|\psi_n^{(1)}\rangle = E_n^{(1)}|\psi_n^{(0)}\rangle - H'|\psi_n^{(0)}\rangle

    To find the first-order energy shift, I project this equation onto the unperturbed state by taking the inner product with ⟨ψn(0)∣\langle\psi_n^{(0)}|.

    The normalization condition requires ⟨ψn(0)∣ψn(1)⟩=0\langle\psi_n^{(0)}|\psi_n^{(1)}\rangle = 0 to maintain unit norm through first order. This orthogonality condition eliminates the first term on the left side when contracted with ⟨ψn(0)∣\langle\psi_n^{(0)}|, leaving:

    En(1)=⟨ψn(0)∣H′∣ψn(0)⟩E_n^{(1)} = \langle\psi_n^{(0)}|H'|\psi_n^{(0)}\rangle The right side simplifies using the normalization of ψn(0)\psi_n^{(0)}: En(1)⟨ψn(0)∣ψn(0)⟩−⟨ψn(0)∣H′∣ψn(0)⟩=En(1)−⟨ψn(0)∣H′∣ψn(0)⟩E_n^{(1)} \langle \psi_n^{(0)} | \psi_n^{(0)}\rangle - \langle \psi_n^{(0)} | H'|\psi_n^{(0)}\rangle = E_n^{(1)} - \langle \psi_n^{(0)} | H'|\psi_n^{(0)}\rangle

    Setting both sides equal gives me the first-order energy correction directly from the perturbation: En(1)=⟨ψn(0)∣H′∣ψn(0)⟩E_n^{(1)} = \langle \psi_n^{(0)} | H' | \psi_n^{(0)}\rangle

    This result shows that the energy shift to first order is simply the expectation value of the perturbation evaluated in the unperturbed state. To complete the picture, I can also work out the wavefunction correction by expanding ∣ψn(1)⟩|\psi_n^{(1)}\rangle as a superposition of unperturbed eigenstates, excluding the nn-th state due to normalization constraints. Projecting the perturbation equation onto states m≠nm \neq n then yields the coefficients for this expansion.

    The projection gives us ⟨ψm(0)∣ψn(1)⟩=⟨ψm(0)∣H′∣ψn(0)⟩En(0)−Em(0)\langle \psi_m^{(0)} | \psi_n^{(1)}\rangle = \frac{\langle \psi_m^{(0)} | H'|\psi_n^{(0)}\rangle}{E_n^{(0)} - E_m^{(0)}}, which means the first-order wavefunction correction is ∣ψn(1)⟩=∑k≠n⟨ψk(0)∣H′∣ψn(0)⟩En(0)−Ek(0)∣ψk(0)⟩|\psi_n^{(1)}\rangle = \sum_{k \neq n} \frac{\langle \psi_k^{(0)} | H'|\psi_n^{(0)}\rangle}{E_n^{(0)} - E_k^{(0)}} |\psi_k^{(0)}\rangle. This demonstrates how the perturbation causes the state to acquire admixtures from other eigenstates, with the mixing strength inversely proportional to the energy gap between states.

    First-Order Energy Correction in Time-Independent Perturbation Theory

    Setup

    Consider a perturbed Hamiltonian: H=H0+λH′H = H_0 + \lambda H'

    where H0H_0 is exactly solvable, H′H' is a small perturbation, and λ≪1\lambda \ll 1.

    We know: H0∣ψn(0)⟩=En(0)∣ψn(0)⟩H_0|\psi_n^{(0)}\rangle = E_n^{(0)}|\psi_n^{(0)}\rangle

    We seek: H∣ψn⟩=En∣ψn⟩H|\psi_n\rangle = E_n|\psi_n\rangle


    Power Series Expansions

    Expand energy and wavefunction in powers of λ\lambda:

    En=En(0)+λEn(1)+λ2En(2)+⋯E_n = E_n^{(0)} + \lambda E_n^{(1)} + \lambda^2 E_n^{(2)} + \cdots

    ∣ψn⟩=∣ψn(0)⟩+λ∣ψn(1)⟩+λ2∣ψn(2)⟩+⋯|\psi_n\rangle = |\psi_n^{(0)}\rangle + \lambda |\psi_n^{(1)}\rangle + \lambda^2|\psi_n^{(2)}\rangle + \cdots


    Substitute Into Schrödinger Equation

    (H0+λH′)∣ψn⟩=En∣ψn⟩(H_0 + \lambda H')|\psi_n\rangle = E_n|\psi_n\rangle

    Substitute the expansions:

    (H0+λH′)[∣ψn(0)⟩+λ∣ψn(1)⟩+⋯ ]=[En(0)+λEn(1)+⋯ ][∣ψn(0)⟩+λ∣ψn(1)⟩+⋯ ](H_0 + \lambda H')\left[|\psi_n^{(0)}\rangle + \lambda|\psi_n^{(1)}\rangle + \cdots\right] = \left[E_n^{(0)} + \lambda E_n^{(1)} + \cdots\right]\left[|\psi_n^{(0)}\rangle + \lambda|\psi_n^{(1)}\rangle + \cdots\right]


    Expand and Collect Powers of λ

    Left side: H0∣ψn(0)⟩+λ(H0∣ψn(1)⟩+H′∣ψn(0)⟩)+O(λ2)H_0|\psi_n^{(0)}\rangle + \lambda(H_0|\psi_n^{(1)}\rangle + H'|\psi_n^{(0)}\rangle) + O(\lambda^2)

    Right side: En(0)∣ψn(0)⟩+λ(En(0)∣ψn(1)⟩+En(1)∣ψn(0)⟩)+O(λ2)E_n^{(0)}|\psi_n^{(0)}\rangle + \lambda(E_n^{(0)}|\psi_n^{(1)}\rangle + E_n^{(1)}|\psi_n^{(0)}\rangle) + O(\lambda^2)


    Equate Coefficients of Powers of λ

    Zeroth Order (λ0\lambda^0):

    H0∣ψn(0)⟩=En(0)∣ψn(0)⟩✓H_0|\psi_n^{(0)}\rangle = E_n^{(0)}|\psi_n^{(0)}\rangle \quad \checkmark (Known solution)

    First Order (λ1\lambda^1):

    H0∣ψn(1)⟩+H′∣ψn(0)⟩=En(0)∣ψn(1)⟩+En(1)∣ψn(0)⟩H_0|\psi_n^{(1)}\rangle + H'|\psi_n^{(0)}\rangle = E_n^{(0)}|\psi_n^{(1)}\rangle + E_n^{(1)}|\psi_n^{(0)}\rangle

    Rearrange: (H0−En(0))∣ψn(1)⟩=En(1)∣ψn(0)⟩−H′∣ψn(0)⟩(H_0 - E_n^{(0)})|\psi_n^{(1)}\rangle = E_n^{(1)}|\psi_n^{(0)}\rangle - H'|\psi_n^{(0)}\rangle


    Apply Normalization Condition

    Require that ⟨ψn(0)∣ψn⟩=1\langle\psi_n^{(0)}|\psi_n\rangle = 1 to first order in λ\lambda. This gives:

    ⟨ψn(0)∣ψn(1)⟩=0\langle\psi_n^{(0)}|\psi_n^{(1)}\rangle = 0

    Take the inner product of the first-order equation with ⟨ψn(0)∣\langle\psi_n^{(0)}|:

    ⟨ψn(0)∣(H0−En(0))∣ψn(1)⟩=En(1)⟨ψn(0)∣ψn(0)⟩−⟨ψn(0)∣H′∣ψn(0)⟩\langle\psi_n^{(0)}|(H_0 - E_n^{(0)})|\psi_n^{(1)}\rangle = E_n^{(1)}\langle\psi_n^{(0)}|\psi_n^{(0)}\rangle - \langle\psi_n^{(0)}|H'|\psi_n^{(0)}\rangle

    Left side evaluation: ⟨ψn(0)∣H0∣ψn(1)⟩−En(0)⟨ψn(0)∣ψn(1)⟩=En(0)⟨ψn(0)∣ψn(1)⟩−En(0)⋅0=0\langle\psi_n^{(0)}|H_0|\psi_n^{(1)}\rangle - E_n^{(0)}\langle\psi_n^{(0)}|\psi_n^{(1)}\rangle = E_n^{(0)}\langle\psi_n^{(0)}|\psi_n^{(1)}\rangle - E_n^{(0)} \cdot 0 = 0

    (using Hermiticity of H0H_0 and the orthogonality condition)


    Final Result

    0=En(1)−⟨ψn(0)∣H′∣ψn(0)⟩0 = E_n^{(1)} - \langle\psi_n^{(0)}|H'|\psi_n^{(0)}\rangle

    En(1)=⟨ψn(0)∣H′∣ψn(0)⟩\boxed{E_n^{(1)} = \langle\psi_n^{(0)}|H'|\psi_n^{(0)}\rangle}

    Physical Interpretation

    The first-order correction to an energy eigenvalue equals the expectation value of the perturbation in the unperturbed state.

    This is remarkably simple and forms the basis for many practical quantum calculations!

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.