Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
ClaudeClaude Haiku 4.5· anthropicHugging Face Frontier Reasoning Traces

Calculate the Gaussian curvature of a sphere of radius R using the first and second…

  1. User

    Calculate the Gaussian curvature of a sphere of radius R using the first and second fundamental forms. Show that K equals 1/R^2.

  2. Claude Assistant

    This is a classic problem in differential geometry. I need to calculate the Gaussian curvature of a sphere using the first and second fundamental forms.

    Let me parameterize a sphere of radius R using spherical coordinates: r(u,v)=(Rsin⁡ucos⁡v,Rsin⁡usin⁡v,Rcos⁡u)\mathbf{r}(u,v) = (R\sin u \cos v, R\sin u \sin v, R\cos u)

    where u∈[0,π]u \in [0, \pi] is the polar angle (colatitude) and v∈[0,2π]v \in [0, 2\pi] is the azimuthal angle (longitude).

    Step 1: Calculate the First Fundamental Form

    The first fundamental form coefficients are given by:

    • E=ru⋅ruE = \mathbf{r}_u \cdot \mathbf{r}_u
    • F=ru⋅rvF = \mathbf{r}_u \cdot \mathbf{r}_v
    • G=rv⋅rvG = \mathbf{r}_v \cdot \mathbf{r}_v

    First, let's find the partial derivatives:

    ru=∂r∂u=(Rcos⁡ucos⁡v,Rcos⁡usin⁡v,−Rsin⁡u)\mathbf{r}_u = \frac{\partial \mathbf{r}}{\partial u} = (R\cos u \cos v, R\cos u \sin v, -R\sin u)

    rv=∂r∂v=(−Rsin⁡usin⁡v,Rsin⁡ucos⁡v,0)\mathbf{r}_v = \frac{\partial \mathbf{r}}{\partial v} = (-R\sin u \sin v, R\sin u \cos v, 0)

    Now: E=ru⋅ru=R2cos⁡2ucos⁡2v+R2cos⁡2usin⁡2v+R2sin⁡2uE = \mathbf{r}_u \cdot \mathbf{r}_u = R^2\cos^2 u \cos^2 v + R^2\cos^2 u \sin^2 v + R^2\sin^2 u E=R2cos⁡2u(cos⁡2v+sin⁡2v)+R2sin⁡2u=R2(cos⁡2u+sin⁡2u)=R2E = R^2\cos^2 u (\cos^2 v + \sin^2 v) + R^2\sin^2 u = R^2(\cos^2 u + \sin^2 u) = R^2

    F=ru⋅rv=−R2cos⁡usin⁡ucos⁡vsin⁡v+R2cos⁡usin⁡usin⁡vcos⁡v=0F = \mathbf{r}_u \cdot \mathbf{r}_v = -R^2 \cos u \sin u \cos v \sin v + R^2 \cos u \sin u \sin v \cos v = 0

    G=rv⋅rv=R2sin⁡2usin⁡2v+R2sin⁡2ucos⁡2v=R2sin⁡2uG = \mathbf{r}_v \cdot \mathbf{r}_v = R^2 \sin^2 u \sin^2 v + R^2 \sin^2 u \cos^2 v = R^2 \sin^2 u

    The first fundamental form is diagonal with E=R2E = R^2, F=0F = 0, and G=R2sin⁡2uG = R^2\sin^2 u, which reflects the orthogonality of the coordinate curves on the sphere.

    Now I need to find the second fundamental form. This requires computing the second partial derivatives and the unit normal vector. The cross product ru×rv\mathbf{r}_u \times \mathbf{r}_v gives the normal direction, and I'll normalize it to get n\mathbf{n}. Then I'll calculate L=ruu⋅nL = \mathbf{r}_{uu} \cdot \mathbf{n}, M=ruv⋅nM = \mathbf{r}_{uv} \cdot \mathbf{n}, and N=rvv⋅nN = \mathbf{r}_{vv} \cdot \mathbf{n} to complete the second fundamental form.

    Computing the cross product yields ru×rv=R2sin⁡u(sin⁡ucos⁡v,sin⁡usin⁡v,cos⁡u)\mathbf{r}_u \times \mathbf{r}_v = R^2 \sin u (\sin u \cos v, \sin u \sin v, \cos u), which has magnitude R2sin⁡uR^2 \sin u. This gives the unit normal vector n=(sin⁡ucos⁡v,sin⁡usin⁡v,cos⁡u)\mathbf{n} = (\sin u \cos v, \sin u \sin v, \cos u).

    Now I need to find the second partial derivatives. Starting with ruu=(−Rsin⁡ucos⁡v,−Rsin⁡usin⁡v,−Rcos⁡u)\mathbf{r}_{uu} = (-R\sin u \cos v, -R\sin u \sin v, -R\cos u)

    , then ruv=(−Rcos⁡usin⁡v,Rcos⁡ucos⁡v,0)\mathbf{r}_{uv} = (-R\cos u \sin v, R\cos u \cos v, 0), and rvv=(−Rsin⁡ucos⁡v,−Rsin⁡usin⁡v,0)\mathbf{r}_{vv} = (-R\sin u \cos v, -R\sin u \sin v, 0).

    With these in hand, I can compute the shape operator coefficients by taking dot products with the unit normal. For LL, I have ruu⋅n=−Rsin⁡2ucos⁡2v−Rsin⁡2usin⁡2v−Rcos⁡2u=−R\mathbf{r}_{uu} \cdot \mathbf{n} = -R\sin^2 u \cos^2 v - R\sin^2 u \sin^2 v - R\cos^2 u = -R.

    The mixed term M=ruv⋅nM = \mathbf{r}_{uv} \cdot \mathbf{n} simplifies to zero since the cross terms cancel. For NN, I get rvv⋅n=−Rsin⁡2u\mathbf{r}_{vv} \cdot \mathbf{n} = -R\sin^2 u.

    This gives me the second fundamental form as a diagonal matrix with entries −R-R and −Rsin⁡2u-R\sin^2 u. Now I can find the Gaussian curvature from the ratio of determinants.

    The determinant of the first fundamental form is R4sin⁡2uR^4 \sin^2 u, while the determinant of the second fundamental form is R2sin⁡2uR^2 \sin^2 u. Dividing these yields K=1R2K = \frac{1}{R^2}, which is constant across the entire sphere—confirming the expected result for a sphere of radius RR.

    Gaussian Curvature of a Sphere

    I'll calculate the Gaussian curvature using parametric equations and the fundamental forms.

    Step 1: Parametrize the Sphere

    Using spherical coordinates: r(u,v)=(Rsin⁡ucos⁡v,Rsin⁡usin⁡v,Rcos⁡u)\mathbf{r}(u,v) = (R\sin u \cos v, R\sin u \sin v, R\cos u)

    where u∈[0,π]u \in [0,\pi] (colatitude) and v∈[0,2π]v \in [0,2\pi] (azimuth).

    Step 2: First Fundamental Form

    Compute the partial derivatives: ru=(Rcos⁡ucos⁡v,Rcos⁡usin⁡v,−Rsin⁡u)\mathbf{r}_u = (R\cos u \cos v, R\cos u \sin v, -R\sin u) rv=(−Rsin⁡usin⁡v,Rsin⁡ucos⁡v,0)\mathbf{r}_v = (-R\sin u \sin v, R\sin u \cos v, 0)

    Calculate the coefficients: E=ru⋅ru=R2E = \mathbf{r}_u \cdot \mathbf{r}_u = R^2

    F=ru⋅rv=0F = \mathbf{r}_u \cdot \mathbf{r}_v = 0

    G=rv⋅rv=R2sin⁡2uG = \mathbf{r}_v \cdot \mathbf{r}_v = R^2\sin^2 u

    First fundamental form: I=(R200R2sin⁡2u)I = \begin{pmatrix} R^2 & 0 \\ 0 & R^2\sin^2 u \end{pmatrix}

    Step 3: Unit Normal Vector

    ru×rv=R2sin⁡u(sin⁡ucos⁡v,sin⁡usin⁡v,cos⁡u)\mathbf{r}_u \times \mathbf{r}_v = R^2\sin u(\sin u \cos v, \sin u \sin v, \cos u)

    ∣ru×rv∣=R2sin⁡u|\mathbf{r}_u \times \mathbf{r}_v| = R^2\sin u

    n=(sin⁡ucos⁡v,sin⁡usin⁡v,cos⁡u)\mathbf{n} = (\sin u \cos v, \sin u \sin v, \cos u)

    Step 4: Second Fundamental Form

    Compute second derivatives: ruu=(−Rsin⁡ucos⁡v,−Rsin⁡usin⁡v,−Rcos⁡u)\mathbf{r}_{uu} = (-R\sin u \cos v, -R\sin u \sin v, -R\cos u) ruv=(−Rcos⁡usin⁡v,Rcos⁡ucos⁡v,0)\mathbf{r}_{uv} = (-R\cos u \sin v, R\cos u \cos v, 0) rvv=(−Rsin⁡ucos⁡v,−Rsin⁡usin⁡v,0)\mathbf{r}_{vv} = (-R\sin u \cos v, -R\sin u \sin v, 0)

    Calculate the coefficients: L=ruu⋅n=−R(sin⁡2u+cos⁡2u)=−RL = \mathbf{r}_{uu} \cdot \mathbf{n} = -R(\sin^2 u + \cos^2 u) = -R

    M=ruv⋅n=0M = \mathbf{r}_{uv} \cdot \mathbf{n} = 0

    N=rvv⋅n=−Rsin⁡2uN = \mathbf{r}_{vv} \cdot \mathbf{n} = -R\sin^2 u

    Second fundamental form: II=(−R00−Rsin⁡2u)II = \begin{pmatrix} -R & 0 \\ 0 & -R\sin^2 u \end{pmatrix}

    Step 5: Gaussian Curvature

    K=det⁡(II)det⁡(I)=LN−M2EG−F2K = \frac{\det(II)}{\det(I)} = \frac{LN - M^2}{EG - F^2}

    K=(−R)(−Rsin⁡2u)−0R2⋅R2sin⁡2u−0K = \frac{(-R)(-R\sin^2 u) - 0}{R^2 \cdot R^2\sin^2 u - 0}

    K=R2sin⁡2uR4sin⁡2u=1R2K = \frac{R^2\sin^2 u}{R^4\sin^2 u} = \boxed{\frac{1}{R^2}}

    Key Insight

    The Gaussian curvature is constant everywhere on the sphere, independent of position (u,v)(u,v). This reflects the sphere's homogeneous geometry and is the basis for the Theorema Egregium: surfaces with the same Gaussian curvature are locally isometric.

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.