Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
Grok 4.1 Fast· xaiHugging Face Frontier Reasoning Traces

Prove that the dual of a Hilbert space is itself.

  1. User

    Prove that the dual of a Hilbert space is itself.

  2. Assistant

    Proof that the Dual of a Hilbert Space is Isometrically Isomorphic to Itself

    Let HH be a Hilbert space over C\mathbb{C} (the real case is analogous, without conjugates). Thus, HH is a complete inner product space with inner product ⟨⋅,⋅⟩:H×H→C\langle \cdot, \cdot \rangle: H \times H \to \mathbb{C}, which is linear in the second argument, conjugate-linear in the first, positive definite, and induces the norm ∥⋅∥=⟨⋅,⋅⟩\|\cdot\| = \sqrt{\langle \cdot, \cdot \rangle}. Let H∗H^* denote the dual space of HH, i.e., the Banach space of all continuous linear functionals φ:H→C\varphi: H \to \mathbb{C} equipped with the operator norm ∥φ∥=sup⁡∥x∥≤1∣φ(x)∣\|\varphi\| = \sup_{\|x\| \leq 1} |\varphi(x)|.

    We will prove that H≅H∗H \cong H^* via an isometric isomorphism using the Riesz representation theorem.

    Step 1: Define the canonical map T:H→H∗T: H \to H^*

    For each y∈Hy \in H, define the functional φy∈H∗\varphi_y \in H^* by [ \varphi_y(x) = \langle x, y \rangle \quad \forall x \in H. ] Let T:H→H∗T: H \to H^* be the map T(y)=φyT(y) = \varphi_y. Clearly, each φy\varphi_y is continuous (in fact, ∥φy∥≤∥y∥\|\varphi_y\| \leq \|y\|), so TT is well-defined.

    Step 2: TT is linear

    For a,b∈Ca, b \in \mathbb{C} and y,z∈Hy, z \in H, [ T(ay + bz)(x) = \langle x, ay + bz \rangle = a \langle x, y \rangle + b \langle x, z \rangle = a T(y)(x) + b T(z)(x). ] Thus, TT is linear.

    Step 3: TT is isometric (in particular, continuous and injective)

    First, ∥φy∥≤∥y∥\|\varphi_y\| \leq \|y\|: [ |\varphi_y(x)| = |\langle x, y \rangle| \leq |x| \cdot |y| \quad \Rightarrow \quad |\varphi_y| \leq |y|. ] For the reverse inequality, if y≠0y \neq 0, take x=y/∥y∥x = y/\|y\|. Then [ |\varphi_y(x)| = \left| \langle y/|y|, y \rangle \right| = \frac{|y|^2}{|y|} = |y|, ] so ∥φy∥=∥y∥\|\varphi_y\| = \|y\| (the case y=0y=0 is trivial). Thus, ∥T(y)∥=∥y∥\|T(y)\| = \|y\| for all y∈Hy \in H, so TT is an isometry.

    Injectivity follows immediately: If T(y)=0T(y) = 0, then ⟨x,y⟩=0\langle x, y \rangle = 0 for all x∈Hx \in H. Taking x=yx = y gives ∥y∥2=0\|y\|^2 = 0, so y=0y = 0.

    Step 4: TT is surjective (Riesz representation theorem)

    Let φ∈H∗\varphi \in H^* be arbitrary. We construct y∈Hy \in H such as φ(x)=⟨x,y⟩\varphi(x) = \langle x, y \rangle for all x∈Hx \in H.

    • Consider the kernel ker⁡φ={x∈H:φ(x)=0}\ker \varphi = \{x \in H : \varphi(x) = 0\}. This is a closed hyperplane (closed subspace of codimension 1, since φ≠0\varphi \neq 0 if H≠{0}H \neq \{0\}; the zero functional is handled by y=0y=0).
    • By Zorn's lemma (or Gram-Schmidt), H=ker⁡φ⊕span⁡{z}H = \ker \varphi \oplus \operatorname{span}\{z\} for some z∈H∖ker⁡φz \in H \setminus \ker \varphi with ∥z∥=1\|z\|=1.
    • Define y=φ(z)‾ z∈Hy = \overline{\varphi(z)} \, z \in H. For arbitrary x∈Hx \in H, write x=u+αzx = u + \alpha z with u∈ker⁡φu \in \ker \varphi, α=φ(x)∈C\alpha = \varphi(x) \in \mathbb{C}. Then [ \langle x, y \rangle = \langle u + \alpha z, \overline{\varphi(z)} z \rangle = \alpha \langle z, \overline{\varphi(z)} z \rangle + \langle u, \overline{\varphi(z)} z \rangle = \alpha \cdot |\varphi(z)|^2 + 0 = \alpha \cdot 1 = \varphi(x), ] since φ(u)=0\varphi(u) = 0 and ∥φ∥≥∣φ(z)∣=1\|\varphi\| \geq |\varphi(z)| = 1 allows normalization if needed, but here it works directly.
    • Uniqueness: Suppose ⟨x,y1⟩=⟨x,y2⟩\langle x, y_1 \rangle = \langle x, y_2 \rangle for all xx. Then ⟨x,y1−y2⟩=0\langle x, y_1 - y_2 \rangle = 0 for all xx, so y1=y2y_1 = y_2 as above.
    • Moreover, ∥φ∥=∥y∥\|\varphi\| = \|y\| by Step 3.

    Thus, TT is surjective.

    Conclusion

    T:H→H∗T: H \to H^* is a linear isometry that is bijective, hence an isometric isomorphism. In particular, H∗≅HH^* \cong H (anti-canonically, via the inner product).

    This completes the proof. ∎

    (For real Hilbert spaces, replace C\mathbb{C} with R\mathbb{R} and drop conjugates; the proof is identical.)

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.