Prove that the dual of a Hilbert space is itself.
- User
Prove that the dual of a Hilbert space is itself.
- Assistant
Proof that the Dual of a Hilbert Space is Isometrically Isomorphic to Itself
Let be a Hilbert space over (the real case is analogous, without conjugates). Thus, is a complete inner product space with inner product , which is linear in the second argument, conjugate-linear in the first, positive definite, and induces the norm . Let denote the dual space of , i.e., the Banach space of all continuous linear functionals equipped with the operator norm .
We will prove that via an isometric isomorphism using the Riesz representation theorem.
Step 1: Define the canonical map
For each , define the functional by [ \varphi_y(x) = \langle x, y \rangle \quad \forall x \in H. ] Let be the map . Clearly, each is continuous (in fact, ), so is well-defined.
Step 2: is linear
For and , [ T(ay + bz)(x) = \langle x, ay + bz \rangle = a \langle x, y \rangle + b \langle x, z \rangle = a T(y)(x) + b T(z)(x). ] Thus, is linear.
Step 3: is isometric (in particular, continuous and injective)
First, : [ |\varphi_y(x)| = |\langle x, y \rangle| \leq |x| \cdot |y| \quad \Rightarrow \quad |\varphi_y| \leq |y|. ] For the reverse inequality, if , take . Then [ |\varphi_y(x)| = \left| \langle y/|y|, y \rangle \right| = \frac{|y|^2}{|y|} = |y|, ] so (the case is trivial). Thus, for all , so is an isometry.
Injectivity follows immediately: If , then for all . Taking gives , so .
Step 4: is surjective (Riesz representation theorem)
Let be arbitrary. We construct such as for all .
- Consider the kernel . This is a closed hyperplane (closed subspace of codimension 1, since if ; the zero functional is handled by ).
- By Zorn's lemma (or Gram-Schmidt), for some with .
- Define . For arbitrary , write with , . Then [ \langle x, y \rangle = \langle u + \alpha z, \overline{\varphi(z)} z \rangle = \alpha \langle z, \overline{\varphi(z)} z \rangle + \langle u, \overline{\varphi(z)} z \rangle = \alpha \cdot |\varphi(z)|^2 + 0 = \alpha \cdot 1 = \varphi(x), ] since and allows normalization if needed, but here it works directly.
- Uniqueness: Suppose for all . Then for all , so as above.
- Moreover, by Step 3.
Thus, is surjective.
Conclusion
is a linear isometry that is bijective, hence an isometric isomorphism. In particular, (anti-canonically, via the inner product).
This completes the proof. ∎
(For real Hilbert spaces, replace with and drop conjugates; the proof is identical.)
Other models, same or similar prompt
Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.