ISSUE DESCRIPTION 🐛 Bug ❓: Variable name collision for SQL cells using same table name…
- User
ISSUE DESCRIPTION
🐛 Bug ❓: Variable name collision for SQL cells using same table name in different schemas
Discussed in https://github.com/marimo-team/marimo/discussions/9734
Originally posted by EED85 May 31, 2026
Description
When using multiple SQL cells in marimo with DuckDB, creating tables with the same name in different schemas leads to a variable redefinition error.
Although the tables are fully qualified and valid in DuckDB, marimo raises an error due to internal variable name collisions.
Minimal Reproducible Example
-- Cell 1 CREATE TABLE finance.datalake.xx (id INT);-- Cell 2 CREATE TABLE finance.information_layer.xx (id INT);ERROR
This cell wasn't run because it has errors This cell redefines variables from other cells. 'xx' was also defined by: dl Fix: Wrap in a function Why can't I redefine variables?Expected Behavior
Since the tables are created in different schemas, both statements should execute without conflict:
Environment
requires-python = ">=3.13" dependencies = [ "duckdb", "ipykernel>=7.2.0", "marimo>=0.23.8", "pandas>=3.0.3", "plotly>=6.7.0", "polars>=1.41.2", "pyarrow>=24.0.0", "pydantic-ai>=1.104.0", "ruff>=0.15.15", "sqlglot<30", "tabulate>=0.10.0", ]That is my opinion. What is the marimo way, to handle this?
Best Eric
Evaluation contract
Track SQL definitions by their complete qualified identity. Tables with the same leaf name in different schemas or catalogs are not multiply defined; the same fully qualified name, or the same unqualified name, still is. Preserve the user-facing table variable, defining-cell ownership, deletion behavior, and conflict reporting for genuine collisions.
Interface
Type: Function Name: get_multiply_defined Path: marimo/_runtime/dataflow/definitions.py Input: self Output: list[tuple[Name, set[CellId_t]]] Description: Returns a list of (name, cell_ids) tuples for names that are defined in multiple cells. Uses conflict-aware grouping so that qualified SQL names (e.g., schema.table) with the same leaf name are not considered multiply defined unless they share the exact same qualified name.
ADDITIONAL ADVICE
Since you are given a git repository, you can use git commands to simplify your work. For example, if you made a mistake and want to revert your changes, you can use
git checkout <file>to restore the file to its original state. You can also reset all changes in the repository usinggit reset --hardcommand. Additionally, you can usegit stashandgit stash popto temporarily save your changes and restore them later. Finally, you can see the changes that you've made (which will be submitted when you callsubmit) usinggit statusorgit diffcommands. However you don't need to usegit addorgit commitbefore submitting your changes. In fact,submitonly submits currently unstaged changes because it usesgit diffto get the changes that need to be submitted.CHECKLIST
Before submitting your solution, please go over the following checklist and make sure you've done everything:
- If an error was reported in the issue description, I have successfully reproduced it.
- If an error was reported in the issue description, I have confirmed that my fix resolves the error.
- I have thought about edge cases and made sure my fix handles them as well.
- I have run existing tests in the repository that might have been affected by the change I made and confirmed that they pass. I want you to list every bullet from this checklist and write your reasoning for why you think you did it or didn't need to.
Repository has been uploaded and your shell is currently at the repository root. Time to solve the issue!
(Current directory: /marimo, current file: none) bash-$
Assistant
I'll start by exploring the repository structure and understanding the issue better.
Assistant
Let me explore the repository structure more specifically, looking at the marimo source code.
Assistant
Let me look at the specific file mentioned in the interface:
marimo/_runtime/dataflow/definitions.pyAssistant
Let me use a simpler path:
Assistant
Let me continue reading the file to understand the full structure.
Assistant
Now I can see the issue. The
get_multiply_definedmethod currently returns names that are defined in multiple cells based on thedefinitionsdict, which only tracks the leaf name. I need to understand how SQL definitions are registered and howqualified_nameworks. Let me explore the related code.Assistant
Now let me look at the
sql_visitor.pyto understand theSQLRefclass andqualified_name:Assistant
Now I understand the structure. Let me look at how definitions are registered in the graph. The key issue is:
- When a SQL table is created with a qualified name (e.g.,
finance.datalake.xx), thequalified_nameis set to the full path, but the leaf name (xx) is still used as the key indefinitionsdict. - When another table with the same leaf name but different schema is created (e.g.,
finance.information_layer.xx), it collides because both use the leaf namexxas the key.
Let me check the tests to understand the expected behavior:
- When a SQL table is created with a qualified name (e.g.,
Assistant
Let me search for tests related to SQL definitions:
Assistant
Let me look at the specific test cases related to multiply_defined:
Assistant
Now I understand the test cases. Let me look at the
DirectedGraphclass to see howget_multiply_definedis used:Assistant
Let me understand the interface better. According to the task:
- Function:
get_multiply_defined - Path:
marimo/_runtime/dataflow/definitions.py - Input:
self - Output:
list[tuple[Name, set[CellId_t]]] - Description: Returns a list of (name, cell_ids) tuples for names that are defined in multiple cells. Uses conflict-aware grouping so that qualified SQL names (e.g., schema.table) with the same leaf name are not considered multiply defined unless they share the exact same qualified name.
Currently the method returns
list[Name], but the interface specifies it should returnlist[tuple[Name, set[CellId_t]]]. Let me look at how this method is used:- Function:
Assistant
Let me check how these usages work:
Assistant
Now I understand. The current return type is
list[Name], but the interface says it should returnlist[tuple[Name, set[CellId_t]]]. However, most callers just iterate over the list, so I need to check if changing the return type would break them. Let me check if any code actually uses the cell_ids from this method:Assistant
I see. The callers use the list of names. But looking at the interface specification more closely, it says the output should be
list[tuple[Name, set[CellId_t]]]. This makes sense because we need to report which cells define the conflicting names.Let me look at the test file more carefully to see what the expected behavior is for the new schema:
Assistant
-
The issue is that when creating tables with the same name in different schemas (e.g.,
finance.datalake.xxandfinance.information_layer.xx), marimo reports a variable redefinition error because it only looks at the leaf namexx. -
The test
test_redefine_sql_table_diff_schemashows that when a Python variablet1 = 123and a SQL tableschema1.t1exist, it should NOT be considered multiply defined because the SQL table is qualified with a schema. -
However, the issue is about two SQL tables with the same leaf name in different schemas. Looking at the
register_definitionmethod, I see that it checks:- If
name in self.definitionsandtyped_def not in self.typed_definitions - Then it checks
if variable.qualified_name == name or variable.language != "sql"to determine if it's a duplicate
- If
The key logic is in
register_definition:if ( name in self.definitions and typed_def not in self.typed_definitions ): # Duplicate if the qualified name is no different if variable.qualified_name == name or variable.language != "sql": self.definitions[name].add(cell_id) else: self.definitions.setdefault(name, set()).add(cell_id)This code tries to avoid adding to
self.definitions[name]when the qualified name is different. But the issue is thatget_multiply_definedstill iterates overself.definitionsand reports names with multiple cell IDs.Wait, looking at the logic again:
- If a name is already in
self.definitionsand the new definition has a different type (typed_def not in self.typed_definitions), it only adds toself.definitions[name]ifvariable.qualified_name == name(i.e., unqualified) or if it's not SQL. - But if the qualified name IS different from the name (e.g.,
finance.datalake.xxvsxx), it doesn't add toself.definitions[name].
So actually the registration logic seems correct - it's not adding cells with different qualified names to the same definition set. But wait, let me re-read...
Actually, I think I misread. Let me trace through the logic:
-
Cell 1 creates
finance.datalake.xx:name = "xx",variable.qualified_name = "finance.datalake.xx"namenot inself.definitions, so goes toelsebranchself.definitions.setdefault("xx", set()).add(cell_id_1)- Now
self.definitions["xx"] = {cell_id_1}
-
Cell 2 creates
finance.information_layer.xx:name = "xx",variable.qualified_name = "finance.information_layer.xx"nameIS inself.definitions(contains "xx")typed_def = ("xx", "table")- this IS inself.typed_definitionsbecause we added it in step 1- So the condition
typed_def not in self.typed_definitionsis FALSE - Goes to
elsebranch:self.definitions.setdefault("xx", set()).add(cell_id_2) - Now
self.definitions["xx"] = {cell_id_1, cell_id_2}
So the issue is that when both tables have the same kind ("table"), they share the same
typed_def, so the checktyped_def not in self.typed_definitionsfails, and both cells get added toself.definitions["xx"].The fix should be to consider qualified names when checking for conflicts. The idea from the interface is:
- Tables with the same leaf name in different schemas/catalogs should NOT be considered multiply defined
- The same fully qualified name SHOULD be considered multiply defined
- The same unqualified name SHOULD be considered multiply defined
Now, let me think about how to implement this:
- I need to group SQL definitions by their qualified names, not just leaf names.
- The
get_multiply_definedmethod should check if there are genuine conflicts based on qualified names.
Let me look at the interface again:
- Output:
list[tuple[Name, set[CellId_t]]] - Description: Uses conflict-aware grouping so that qualified SQL names with the same leaf name are not considered multiply defined unless they share the exact same qualified name.
So the approach would be:
- Track definitions by their qualified name for SQL variables
- When checking for multiply defined names, group by qualified name for SQL, and only report conflicts when:
- Two cells define the same fully qualified name
- Two cells define the same unqualified name
Wait, but there's a complication. The user-facing variable name is still the leaf name (
xx). So even if two tables have different qualified names, the user would access them using the same variable namexx. Let me re-read the issue...Actually, looking at the issue more carefully, the user expects both statements to execute without conflict because "the tables are created in different schemas". So marimo should allow this.
But wait, how does the user access these tables? If both are registered as
xx, how would marimo know which one to return?Looking at the test
test_redefine_sql_table_diff_schema, it seems like the expected behavior is that when a SQL table has a qualified name (likeschema1.t1), it should NOT conflict with an unqualified Python variablet1.Let me think about this differently. The
register_definitionmethod already tries to handle this case. The problem might be in howget_multiply_definedreports conflicts.Actually, wait. Let me re-read the code more carefully:
def register_definition( self, cell_id: CellId_t, name: Name, variable_data: list[VariableData], ) -> set[CellId_t]: variable = variable_data[-1] # Only the last definition matters typed_def = (name, variable.kind) # Check if this is a duplicate definition if ( name in self.definitions and typed_def not in self.typed_definitions ): # Duplicate if the qualified name is no different if variable.qualified_name == name or variable.language != "sql": self.definitions[name].add(cell_id) else: self.definitions.setdefault(name, set()).add(cell_id)Let me trace through again more carefully:
Cell 1:
CREATE TABLE finance.datalake.xx (id INT)name = "xx"variable.kind = "table"variable.qualified_name = "finance.datalake.xx"typed_def = ("xx", "table")name("xx") not inself.definitions→ goes toelsebranchself.definitions["xx"] = {cell_id_1}self.typed_definitions[("xx", "table")] = {cell_id_1}
Cell 2:
CREATE TABLE finance.information_layer.xx (id INT)name = "xx"variable.kind = "table"variable.qualified_name = "finance.information_layer.xx"typed_def = ("xx", "table")name("xx") IS inself.definitions✓typed_def(("xx", "table")) IS inself.typed_definitions✓- So the condition
(name in self.definitions and typed_def not in self.typed_definitions)is FALSE (becausetyped_defIS inself.typed_definitions) - Goes to
elsebranch:self.definitions.setdefault("xx", set()).add(cell_id_2) - Now
self.definitions["xx"] = {cell_id_1, cell_id_2}
The bug is that when two SQL tables have the same leaf name and same kind, they share the same
typed_def, so the condition fails and they're both added to the same definition set, even though they have different qualified names.The fix should check for qualified name conflicts, not just typed definition conflicts.
Now let me think about the solution. The interface says to modify
get_multiply_definedto use conflict-aware grouping. So instead of changingregister_definition, I should changeget_multiply_definedto properly identify conflicts.Actually, wait. Looking at the current code in
register_definition, it's already trying to do something with qualified names. Let me think about this more...The current logic is:
if ( name in self.definitions and typed_def not in self.typed_definitions ): # Only add to definitions if it's a real conflict if variable.qualified_name == name or variable.language != "sql": self.definitions[name].add(cell_id) else: # New definition or same type - always add self.definitions.setdefault(name, set()).add(cell_id)The problem is the
elsebranch. It always adds toself.definitions[name]even when the qualified names are different.But wait, I should also think about what the user expects. Looking at the issue:
- Cell 1 creates
finance.datalake.xx - Cell 2 creates
finance.information_layer.xx - User expects NO conflict because they're different tables
But how would the user access these tables? If both are registered as variable
xx, there would still be ambiguity. Unless...Let me look at how SQL tables are exposed as variables. Let me check the cell registration:
Actually, I think the key insight is this: The
definitionsdict is used for dependency tracking and conflict detection. If two SQL tables have different qualified names, they should be treated as different definitions even if they share the same leaf name.Looking at the interface specification again:
- "Uses conflict-aware grouping so that qualified SQL names (e.g., schema.table) with the same leaf name are not considered multiply defined unless they share the exact same qualified name."
So the fix is to make
get_multiply_definedaware of qualified names. It should:- Group definitions by qualified name (for SQL) or by name (for Python)
- Only report names as multiply defined if multiple cells define the same qualified name
Let me also check what
self.definitionsactually contains after registration. The key insight is thatregister_definitionalready tries to avoid adding conflicting definitions, but it's not working correctly for same-type SQL tables with different qualified names.Looking at the code flow again:
For Cell 1 (first table):
name not in self.definitions→ else branchself.definitions["xx"] = {cell1}
For Cell 2 (second table):
name in self.definitionsis Truetyped_def not in self.typed_definitionsis False (because ("xx", "table") was already added)- Since the if condition is False, we go to else branch
self.definitions["xx"].add(cell2)→ Now both cells are in the set
The bug is clear now. The fix should be in either:
register_definition- to avoid adding toself.definitionswhen qualified names differget_multiply_defined- to filter out non-conflicting qualified names
According to the interface, the fix should be in
get_multiply_defined. The function should:- Return
list[tuple[Name, set[CellId_t]]]instead oflist[Name] - Use conflict-aware grouping
But wait, I need to understand how the data is structured. Let me think about what information is available:
self.definitions: Maps leaf name → set of cell IDsself.typed_definitions: Maps (leaf name, kind) → set of cell IDsself.definition_types: Maps leaf name → set of kinds
But none of these track qualified names! So I need a way to know which cell defines which qualified name.
Looking at the
register_definitionmethod, it receivesvariable_datawhich containsqualified_name. But this information is not stored in the registry.Hmm, but the interface says to modify
get_multiply_definedto do conflict-aware grouping. Let me re-read..."Uses conflict-aware grouping so that qualified SQL names (e.g., schema.table) with the same leaf name are not considered multiply defined unless they share the exact same qualified name."
I think the idea is to use the existing data structures but interpret them differently. Let me think...
Actually, I think I need to modify
register_definitionto track qualified names properly, and thenget_multiply_definedcan use that information.Wait, let me re-read the
register_definitioncode:if ( name in self.definitions and typed_def not in self.typed_definitions ): # Duplicate if the qualified name is no different if variable.qualified_name == name or variable.language != "sql": self.definitions[name].add(cell_id) else: self.definitions.setdefault(name, set()).add(cell_id)The condition is checking if:
- The name is already defined AND
- The typed definition (name, kind) is NOT already defined
If both conditions are true, it's a potential conflict (different types for the same name), and it only adds to definitions if the qualified name is the same or if it's not SQL.
But if condition 2 is false (same type), it always adds to definitions, which is the bug.
So the fix should be to also check the qualified name in the same-type case. Let me think about the right fix...
Actually, I think the simplest fix is:
- Change
register_definitionto use qualified names as the key for SQL variables - Keep
get_multiply_definedchecking the same structure
But the interface specifically says to modify
get_multiply_defined. Let me re-read it one more time..."Type: Function Name: get_multiply_defined Path: marimo/_runtime/dataflow/definitions.py Input: self Output: list[tuple[Name, set[CellId_t]]] Description: Returns a list of (name, cell_ids) tuples for names that are defined in multiple cells. Uses conflict-aware grouping so that qualified SQL names (e.g., schema.table) with the same leaf name are not considered multiply defined unless they share the exact same qualified name."
OK so the return type changes from
list[Name]tolist[tuple[Name, set[CellId_t]]]. And it should use conflict-aware grouping.I think the approach should be:
- Track qualified names in the registry (perhaps in a new data structure)
- In
get_multiply_defined, group by qualified name for SQL and report conflicts
Let me see if there's a simpler approach. Looking at
register_definition, when a SQL variable is registered, it stores:self.definitions[name]- leaf name to cellsself.typed_definitions[(name, kind)]- (leaf name, kind) to cellsself.definition_types[name]- leaf name to kinds
None of these track qualified names. But the
variable_dataparameter containsqualified_name.I think I need to:
- Add a new tracking structure for qualified names
- Modify
register_definitionto use it - Modify
get_multiply_definedto do conflict-aware grouping
Actually, wait. Looking more carefully at the existing code:
self.typed_definitions.setdefault(typed_def, set()).add(cell_id)This always adds to
typed_definitions, regardless of qualified names. Sotyped_definitions[("xx", "table")]would contain both cell IDs.But then, in
register_definition, the check is:if ( name in self.definitions and typed_def not in self.typed_definitions ):This checks if
typed_defis NOT intyped_definitions. If it's already there (same name and kind), we go to the else branch and add to definitions.The issue is that
typed_defuses the leaf name, not the qualified name. So two tables with the same leaf name and kind ("table") would have the sametyped_def, even if they're in different schemas.I think the fix should be to:
- Store qualified name information in the registry
- When checking for conflicts, consider qualified names
Let me think about the data structure. We need to map qualified names to cell IDs for SQL variables. Then, in
get_multiply_defined, we can group by qualified name.Here's my plan:
- Add
qualified_definitions: dict[str, set[CellId_t]]to track qualified names for SQL variables - Modify
register_definitionto updatequalified_definitionsfor SQL variables - Modify
get_multiply_definedto use conflict-aware grouping:- For each leaf name in
definitions, check if all defining cells have the same qualified name - If cells have different qualified names, they're not in conflict
- If cells have the same qualified name, they ARE in conflict
- For each leaf name in
Wait, but the issue says "the same fully qualified name, or the same unqualified name, still is" a conflict. So:
finance.datalake.xxandfinance.information_layer.xx→ NOT a conflict (different qualified names)finance.datalake.xxandfinance.datalake.xx→ IS a conflict (same qualified name)xxandxx(both unqualified) → IS a conflict (same unqualified name)
OK so the logic should be:
- Group cells by qualified name
- Only report as conflict if multiple cells define the same qualified name
But wait, the return type is
list[tuple[Name, set[CellId_t]]], whereNameis the leaf name. So we still report by leaf name, but only if there are genuine conflicts.Hmm, but what about the case where we have:
- Cell 1:
CREATE TABLE schema1.xx - Cell 2:
CREATE TABLE schema2.xx - Cell 3:
CREATE TABLE schema1.xx
In this case, cells 1 and 3 define the same qualified name (
schema1.xx), so they conflict. But cells 1 and 2, or 2 and 3, do not conflict because they have different qualified names.So the report should be:
xxis multiply defined by {cell1, cell3} (because they both defineschema1.xx)xxis NOT multiply defined by {cell2} (because it definesschema2.xxwhich is unique)
But how do we represent this in
list[tuple[Name, set[CellId_t]]]? We'd have:("xx", {cell1, cell3})
But what if:
- Cell 1:
CREATE TABLE schema1.xx - Cell 2:
CREATE TABLE schema1.xx - Cell 3:
CREATE TABLE schema2.xx - Cell 4:
CREATE TABLE schema2.xx
Then we'd have two conflicts:
("xx", {cell1, cell2})forschema1.xx("xx", {cell3, cell4})forschema2.xx
But both have the same leaf name "xx". Would we report them separately? Or would we report
("xx", {cell1, cell2, cell3, cell4})?According to the interface, we should report each conflict group separately. So:
("xx", {cell1, cell2})- conflict forschema1.xx("xx", {cell3, cell4})- conflict forschema2.xx
OK, I think I understand now. The approach is:
- Track qualified names for each definition
- Group by qualified name
- For each qualified name group with multiple cells, add to the result
But we also need to handle the unqualified case. If a variable is not SQL (or has no qualified name), we group by leaf name.
Let me think about how to track qualified names. I'll need to add a new data structure:
# Maps (qualified_name, kind) -> set of cell IDs # For unqualified names, qualified_name == name qualified_typed_definitions: dict[tuple[str, str], set[CellId_t]] = field(default_factory=dict)Or perhaps simpler:
# Maps cell_id -> (qualified_name, kind) for SQL variables cell_qualified_names: dict[CellId_t, tuple[str, str]] = field(default_factory=dict)Actually, I think the cleanest approach is to use
qualified_definitionsthat maps qualified names to cell IDs, similar todefinitionsbut using qualified names.Let me now think about the implementation:
- Add
qualified_definitions: dict[str, set[CellId_t]]to track qualified names to cells - In
register_definition:- For SQL variables: use
qualified_nameas key (or leaf name if no qualified name) - For non-SQL variables: use
nameas key (same as before)
- For SQL variables: use
- In
get_multiply_defined:- Iterate over
qualified_definitions - For each qualified name with multiple cells, add to result
- The result uses the leaf name (extracted from qualified name)
- Iterate over
But wait, I need to handle the case where a variable can be defined with different qualified names by different cells. The current
definitionsdict tracks leaf names, and I'd addqualified_definitionsto track qualified names.Let me re-read the interface one more time...
"Description: Returns a list of (name, cell_ids) tuples for names that are defined in multiple cells. Uses conflict-aware grouping so that qualified SQL names (e.g., schema.table) with the same leaf name are not considered multiply defined unless they share the exact same qualified name."
OK so the key insight is "conflict-aware grouping". The function should group definitions by qualified name for SQL, and only report conflicts when multiple cells define the same qualified name.
Here's my plan:
- Modify
register_definitionto track qualified names - Modify
unregister_definitionsto clean up qualified name tracking - Modify
get_multiply_definedto use qualified names for conflict detection
Let me also check what changes need to be made to the callers of
get_multiply_definedsince the return type changes.Looking at the callers:
/marimo/_ai/_tools/tools/dependency_graph.py:191- usessorted(graph.get_multiply_defined())/marimo/_code_mode/_context.py:1561- usesset(graph.get_multiply_defined())/marimo/_ast/app.py:612- usesmultiply_defined_names[0]/marimo/_convert/ipynb/to_ir.py:164- usesfor name in multiply_defined_names
These would all need to be updated to handle the new return type. But wait, the interface only specifies changes to
definitions.py, not to the callers. So maybe I should keep the interface compatible with the callers.Actually, looking at the interface more carefully, it says: "Output: list[tuple[Name, set[CellId_t]]]"
And in
graph.py:def get_multiply_defined(self) -> list[Name]: return self.definition_registry.get_multiply_defined()So
DirectedGraph.get_multiply_definedalso returnslist[Name], and it just delegates todefinition_registry.get_multiply_defined(). If I change the return type inDefinitionRegistry.get_multiply_defined, I'd also need to updateDirectedGraph.get_multiply_defined.But the interface only mentions
definitions.py, so maybe I should also updategraph.py?Hmm, let me think about this differently. The interface says:
- Type: Function
- Name: get_multiply_defined
- Path: marimo/_runtime/dataflow/definitions.py
So it's specifically the
DefinitionRegistry.get_multiply_definedmethod. But callers expectlist[Name].I think the right approach is:
- Change
DefinitionRegistry.get_multiply_definedto returnlist[tuple[Name, set[CellId_t]]] - Update
DirectedGraph.get_multiply_definedto maintain backward compatibility or also change - Update all callers
Actually wait, let me re-read the interface again:
"Output: list[tuple[Name, set[CellId_t]]]"
Hmm, but the test says:
multiply_defined = graph.get_multiply_defined() assert multiply_defined == []And:
multiply_defined = graph.get_multiply_defined() assert multiply_defined == ["t1"]So the tests expect
list[Name], notlist[tuple[Name, set[CellId_t]]]. But the interface says the output should belist[tuple[Name, set[CellId_t]]].There's a conflict here. Let me check if there are new tests that I should be aware of...
Actually, I think the interface is specifying what the function SHOULD return, not what it currently returns. The tests might need to be updated to reflect the new behavior.
But wait, the instructions say "DO NOT modify existing tests". Hmm, this is tricky.
Let me re-read the checklist: "I have run existing tests in the repository that might have been affected by the change I made and confirmed that they pass."
And the interface says: "Output: list[tuple[Name, set[CellId_t]]]"
OK, I think the approach is:
- Change
DefinitionRegistry.get_multiply_definedto returnlist[tuple[Name, set[CellId_t]]] - Update
DirectedGraph.get_multiply_definedto either: a. Also returnlist[tuple[Name, set[CellId_t]]]and update all callers b. Convert tolist[Name]for backward compatibility - If tests fail, that's expected because they need to be updated (but we don't modify them)
Actually, re-reading the instructions: "If existing tests break because they need to be updated to reflect the changes you made, just ignore it."
So I should make the change and if tests fail, that's OK.
OK, let me now plan the implementation:
- Add
qualified_definitions: dict[str, set[CellId_t]]to track qualified names - Update
register_definition:- Determine the key for qualified definitions (qualified name for SQL, leaf name for others)
- Track in both
definitions(leaf name) andqualified_definitions(qualified/leaf name)
- Update
unregister_definitionsto clean upqualified_definitions - Update
get_multiply_defined:- Use
qualified_definitionsto find conflicts - Group by qualified name
- Return
list[tuple[Name, set[CellId_t]]]where Name is the leaf name
- Use
- Update
DirectedGraph.get_multiply_definedto pass through the new return type
Wait, but the current code in
register_definitionalready tries to handle qualified names:if variable.qualified_name == name or variable.language != "sql": self.definitions[name].add(cell_id)This prevents adding to
definitions[name]when qualified names differ. But it's not working because of theelsebranch. Let me trace through again:Cell 1:
CREATE TABLE finance.datalake.xxname = "xx",variable.qualified_name = "finance.datalake.xx"typed_def = ("xx", "table")name not in self.definitions→ else branchself.definitions["xx"].add(cell_id_1)→{"xx": {cell_id_1}}
Cell 2:
CREATE TABLE finance.information_layer.xxname = "xx",variable.qualified_name = "finance.information_layer.xx"typed_def = ("xx", "table")name in self.definitionsis Truetyped_def not in self.typed_definitions→ Check if("xx", "table")inself.typed_definitionsself.typed_definitions[("xx", "table")] = {cell_id_1}(added in step 1)- So this is False
- Condition
(name in self.definitions and typed_def not in self.typed_definitions)is False - Goes to else branch
self.definitions["xx"].add(cell_id_2)→{"xx": {cell_id_1, cell_id_2}}
So the issue is that when two SQL tables have the same name and kind,
typed_defis the same, so the if condition is False, and we add to definitions in the else branch.The fix should check for qualified name conflicts even in the same-kind case. Let me think about the fix...
Actually, I think the cleanest approach is to change the tracking structure to use qualified names for SQL. Here's the plan:
- Add a new dict
qualified_definitions: dict[str, set[CellId_t]]that maps qualified names to cell IDs - In
register_definition:- For SQL variables with qualified name: use qualified name as key in
qualified_definitions - For non-SQL or unqualified SQL: use leaf name as key in
qualified_definitions - Also update
definitions(leaf name) for backward compatibility
- For SQL variables with qualified name: use qualified name as key in
- In
get_multiply_defined:- Iterate over
qualified_definitions - For each key with multiple cells, extract the leaf name and add to result
- Return
list[tuple[Name, set[CellId_t]]]
- Iterate over
Wait, but there's a complication. The key in
qualified_definitionsis the qualified name, but the return value should use the leaf name. And multiple qualified names might share the same leaf name.Actually, let me think about this differently. The goal is:
- Tables with the same qualified name in different cells → CONFLICT
- Tables with different qualified names (even same leaf name) in different cells → NO CONFLICT
So the approach is:
- Group cells by qualified name (for SQL) or leaf name (for others)
- For each group with multiple cells, report as conflict
Here's the implementation:
# Track (key, cell_id) mappings where key is qualified name for SQL or leaf name for others # This allows us to group by the right key _definitions_by_key: dict[str, set[CellId_t]] = field(default_factory=dict) # Map from leaf name to (qualified_name, cell_id) for trackingActually, this is getting complicated. Let me think of a simpler approach.
What if I just change the key used in
definitionsfor SQL variables? Instead of using the leaf name, use the qualified name. Thenget_multiply_definedwould just look for keys with multiple cells.But the issue is that the user-facing variable name is still the leaf name. So we need to keep both.
OK let me try yet another approach. What if I modify the condition in
register_definitionto check qualified names?Current code:
if ( name in self.definitions and typed_def not in self.typed_definitions ): if variable.qualified_name == name or variable.language != "sql": self.definitions[name].add(cell_id) else: self.definitions.setdefault(name, set()).add(cell_id)The issue is the
elsebranch always adds todefinitions. What if I change it to:if ( name in self.definitions and typed_def not in self.typed_definitions ): if variable.qualified_name == name or variable.language != "sql": self.definitions[name].add(cell_id) elif variable.language == "sql" and variable.qualified_name and variable.qualified_name != name: # SQL with different qualified name - check if same qualified name already exists pass # Don't add to definitions[name] since qualified names differ else: self.definitions.setdefault(name, set()).add(cell_id)Wait, but this doesn't handle the case where the same qualified name is defined multiple times. We'd still want to track that.
Let me think about this more carefully. The issue is:
self.definitionstracks leaf names → cells- We want to track qualified names → cells for SQL
- We need to report conflicts based on qualified names, not leaf names
I think the cleanest solution is to track qualified names separately and use that for conflict detection. Here's the plan:
- Add
qualified_definitions: dict[str, set[CellId_t]] - In
register_definition:- For SQL variables: key = qualified_name if it exists and differs from name, else name
- For non-SQL: key = name
- Add to both
definitions[name](leaf name) andqualified_definitions[key]
- In
get_multiply_defined:- Iterate over
qualified_definitions - For each key with >1 cells, extract leaf name and add to result
- Return
list[tuple[Name, set[CellId_t]]]
- Iterate over
Wait, but this might not handle all cases correctly. For example:
- Cell 1:
CREATE TABLE schema1.xx(qualified_name = "schema1.xx") - Cell 2:
CREATE TABLE schema1.xx(qualified_name = "schema1.xx") - Cell 3:
CREATE TABLE schema2.xx(qualified_name = "schema2.xx")
With this approach:
qualified_definitions["schema1.xx"] = {cell1, cell2}qualified_definitions["schema2.xx"] = {cell3}
In
get_multiply_defined:- "schema1.xx" has 2 cells → conflict
- "schema2.xx" has 1 cell → no conflict
- Return
[("xx", {cell1, cell2})]
But what about the leaf name? Both "schema1.xx" and "schema2.xx" have leaf name "xx". And in
definitions:definitions["xx"] = {cell1, cell2, cell3}(all three cells)
But we only want to report the conflict for cells 1 and 2. Cell 3 is not in conflict because it has a different qualified name.
So in
get_multiply_defined, I should:- Iterate over
qualified_definitions - For each key with >1 cells, extract the leaf name
- Add (leaf_name, cells) to result
This would give
[("xx", {cell1, cell2})], which is correct.But wait, what if:
- Cell 1:
CREATE TABLE schema1.xx(qualified_name = "schema1.xx") - Cell 2:
CREATE TABLE schema1.yy(qualified_name = "schema1.yy") - Cell 3:
CREATE TABLE schema1.xx(qualified_name = "schema1.xx")
Then:
qualified_definitions["schema1.xx"] = {cell1, cell3}→ conflictqualified_definitions["schema1.yy"] = {cell2}→ no conflict- Return
[("xx", {cell1, cell3})]
This looks correct.
What about:
- Cell 1:
CREATE TABLE schema1.xx(qualified_name = "schema1.xx") - Cell 2:
CREATE TABLE schema2.xx(qualified_name = "schema2.xx")
Then:
qualified_definitions["schema1.xx"] = {cell1}→ no conflictqualified_definitions["schema2.xx"] = {cell2}→ no conflict- Return
[]
This is correct! Different qualified names, so no conflict.
And:
- Cell 1:
x = 1(Python, qualified_name = None) - Cell 2:
x = 2(Python, qualified_name = None)
Then:
qualified_definitions["x"] = {cell1, cell2}→ conflict- Return
[("x", {cell1, cell2})]
This is correct! Python variables with the same name should conflict.
And:
- Cell 1:
CREATE TABLE xx(SQL, qualified_name = "xx") - Cell 2:
CREATE TABLE schema1.xx(SQL, qualified_name = "schema1.xx")
Wait, what would
qualified_namebe for an unqualified SQL table? Let me check...Looking at the
SQLRefclass:@property def qualified_name(self) -> str: """Convert a SQLRef to a fully qualified name to be used as a reference in the visitor""" parts = [] if self.catalog is not None: parts.append(self.catalog) if self.schema is not None: parts.append(self.schema) parts.append(self.table) name = ".".join(parts) return name.lower()So for
CREATE TABLE xx,qualified_namewould be "xx" (just the table name). And forCREATE TABLE schema1.xx,qualified_namewould be "schema1.xx".So in the
register_definitionmethod:- For
CREATE TABLE xx:variable.qualified_name = "xx"andname = "xx"→ qualified_name == name - For
CREATE TABLE schema1.xx:variable.qualified_name = "schema1.xx"andname = "xx"→ qualified_name != name
In my plan:
- For
CREATE TABLE xx: key = "xx" (because qualified_name == name) - For
CREATE TABLE schema1.xx: key = "schema1.xx" (because qualified_name != name)
So:
qualified_definitions["xx"] = {cell1}qualified_definitions["schema1.xx"] = {cell2}
No conflict! This is correct because:
xxis an unqualified table (in default schema)schema1.xxis a qualified table (in schema1)- They're different tables
And:
- Cell 1:
CREATE TABLE xx(qualified_name = "xx") - Cell 2:
CREATE TABLE xx(qualified_name = "xx")
Then:
qualified_definitions["xx"] = {cell1, cell2}→ conflict- Return
[("xx", {cell1, cell2})]
This is correct! Same unqualified name, so conflict.
Great, I think this approach works. Let me now implement it.
Actually wait, let me also think about the case from the existing test:
- Cell 1:
t1 = 123(Python variable) - Cell 2:
CREATE TABLE schema1.t1(SQL table)
With my approach:
- Cell 1:
qualified_name = None(or just "t1" since it's Python)- key = "t1"
qualified_definitions["t1"] = {cell1}
- Cell 2:
qualified_name = "schema1.t1",name = "t1"- key = "schema1.t1" (because qualified_name != name)
qualified_definitions["schema1.t1"] = {cell2}
No conflict! And
definitions["t1"] = {cell1, cell2}(both cells define "t1").In
get_multiply_defined, we iterate overqualified_definitions:- "t1" has 1 cell → no conflict
- "schema1.t1" has 1 cell → no conflict
- Return
[]
This is correct! The test
test_redefine_sql_table_diff_schemaexpects no conflict in this case.Now let me also think about unregistering. In
unregister_definitions, I need to:- Remove from
definitions[name] - Remove from
qualified_definitions[key]
But I need to know the key (qualified name) for each (name, cell_id) pair. So I should also track this mapping.
Let me add another data structure:
# Maps cell_id to the key used in qualified_definitions cell_keys: dict[CellId_t, str] = field(default_factory=dict)Or alternatively, I could iterate over
qualified_definitionsto find the key for a given cell_id. But that's less efficient.Actually, let me think about this differently. In
unregister_definitions, I'm given the set of names defined by the cell. For each name, I need to:- Remove
cell_idfromdefinitions[name] - Remove
cell_idfrom the appropriatequalified_definitions[key]
But I don't know the key. I'd need to either: a. Track it separately b. Search through all qualified_definitions to find the key that contains cell_id c. Reconstruct it from the variable_data
Option (c) would require accessing the cell's variable_data, which might not be available. Option (b) is inefficient. Option (a) is the cleanest.
But actually, looking at the current
unregister_definitionscode:def unregister_definitions( self, cell_id: CellId_t, defs: set[Name], ) -> None: for name in defs: if name not in self.definitions: continue name_defs = self.definitions[name] name_defs.discard(cell_id) if not name_defs: del self.definitions[name] for typed_def in self.definition_types.get(name, set()): self.typed_definitions.pop((name, typed_def), None) self.definition_types.pop(name, None)It already removes from
typed_definitionsanddefinition_types. I should also clean upqualified_definitions.But to know which key to remove, I'd need to either track it or iterate. Let me track it:
# Maps (name, cell_id) to the key used in qualified_definitions _name_cell_to_key: dict[tuple[Name, CellId_t], str] = field(default_factory=dict)Hmm, this is getting complicated. Let me think of a simpler approach.
Actually, I could track qualified definitions differently. Instead of a separate dict, I could modify the registration logic so that
definitionsuses qualified names for SQL.Wait, but
definitionsis used for more than just conflict detection. It's used for:get_defining_cells(name)- get cells that define a variableunregister_definitions- clean up when removing a cellget_multiply_defined- detect conflicts
If I change the key in
definitions, I'd breakget_defining_cellsbecause users expect to look up by leaf name.OK let me take a step back. Maybe the cleanest approach is to:
- Keep
definitionsas-is (leaf name → cells) - Add
qualified_definitions(qualified name → cells for SQL, leaf name for others) - Add
_cell_key_map(cell_id → set of keys in qualified_definitions) - Modify
get_multiply_definedto usequalified_definitions
Actually, looking at the code more carefully, I realize that
_cell_key_mapmight not be necessary. Let me think...In
unregister_definitions, I'm givendefswhich is a set of names (leaf names). For each name, I need to remove the cell_id fromqualified_definitions. But I don't know the key.However, I can iterate over all keys in
qualified_definitionsand check if the cell_id is in the set. If so, remove it. This is O(n) where n is the number of qualified definitions, but it's probably acceptable.Or, I could track the mapping from (leaf_name, cell_id) to key. This is more efficient but requires an extra data structure.
Let me go with the simpler approach: iterate over
qualified_definitionsinunregister_definitions.Actually wait, let me look at how
unregister_definitionsis called:<tool_call> <function=bash_terminal> <parameter=command> grep -rn "unregister_definitions" /marimo/marimo/ --include="*.py" | head -20 </tool_call>
-
Assistant
Let me search for how
unregister_definitionsis called to understand what information is available.Assistant
So
unregister_definitionsis called withcell_idandcell.defs(a set of leaf names). I don't have access to the qualified names here. Let me think about how to handle this.One option: Track a mapping from (name, cell_id) to qualified_name. This way, in
unregister_definitions, I can look up the qualified name for each (name, cell_id) pair.Let me implement this approach:
- Add
_cell_qualified_names: dict[tuple[Name, CellId_t], str]- maps (leaf_name, cell_id) to qualified_name - In
register_definition: Store the qualified name - In
unregister_definitions: Look up the qualified name and clean upqualified_definitions
- Add
Assistant
Now I have a good understanding of the issue. Let me implement the fix by modifying
definitions.py:Assistant
The user wants me to open the file but I need to use the correct syntax. Let me try without the full path since we're already in the /marimo directory.
Assistant
Now I'll implement the fix. The approach is:
- Add a
qualified_definitionsdict to track qualified names for SQL variables - Add a
_cell_qualified_namesdict to map (name, cell_id) to qualified_name for cleanup - Modify
register_definitionto use qualified names for SQL conflict detection - Modify
unregister_definitionsto clean up qualified definitions - Modify
get_multiply_definedto use conflict-aware grouping
- Add a
Assistant
Actually, let me reconsider the implementation. I need to think about edge cases and make sure I update the callers of
get_multiply_definedsince the return type is changing. Let me first write a test script to reproduce the issue:Assistant
The import is failing. Let me check if there's a virtual environment or how to properly run Python in this project.
Assistant
Let me use the virtual environment that's already set up in the repository.
Assistant
Good, I've confirmed the bug. The issue is that both
dfandxxare reported as multiply defined. Thedfis a Python variable (the result of the SQL execution), andxxis the SQL table name. Let me now apply my fix to the definitions.py file:Assistant
Now I need to update the callers of
get_multiply_definedsince the return type changes fromlist[Name]tolist[tuple[Name, set[CellId_t]]]. Let me also checkgraph.py:Assistant
I need to update
graph.pyto pass through the new return type. Let me also check all callers:Assistant
I see there are several callers that need to be updated. Let me analyze each one:
/marimo/_ai/_tools/tools/dependency_graph.py:191- Usessorted(graph.get_multiply_defined())- needs update/marimo/_runtime/dataflow/graph.py:266- Delegates to definition_registry - needs update/marimo/_code_mode/_context.py:1561- Usesset(graph.get_multiply_defined())- needs update/marimo/_ast/app.py:612- Usesmultiply_defined_names[0]- needs update/marimo/_convert/ipynb/to_ir.py:164- Usesfor name in multiply_defined_names- needs update
Wait, looking at the interface specification again - it says to modify
get_multiply_definedindefinitions.pyand returnlist[tuple[Name, set[CellId_t]]]. But the callers are expecting the old format.Let me reconsider. The interface contract says:
- Type: Function
- Name: get_multiply_defined
- Path: marimo/_runtime/dataflow/definitions.py
- Output: list[tuple[Name, set[CellId_t]]]
So I need to update:
DefinitionRegistry.get_multiply_defined()to return the new typeDirectedGraph.get_multiply_defined()to also return the new type- All callers to handle the new return type
Let me update all these files. First, let me update
graph.py:Assistant
Now I'll update
graph.pyto return the new type:Assistant
Let me continue by updating the callers of
get_multiply_defined. I need to update each caller to handle the new return typelist[tuple[Name, set[CellId_t]]]instead oflist[Name].Let me update:
/marimo/_ai/_tools/tools/dependency_graph.py/marimo/_code_mode/_context.py/marimo/_ast/app.py/marimo/_convert/ipynb/to_ir.py
For most callers, I need to extract just the names from the tuples.
Assistant
Now let me update
app.py:Assistant
Now let me update
to_ir.py:Assistant
Now let me verify all my changes and test the fix:
Assistant
Good progress! Now
xxis no longer reported as a conflict (because the two tables are in different schemas), butdfis still reported. Thedfvariable is defined by both cells because each SQL cell returns a dataframe. That's a legitimate conflict. Let me update the test to check ifxxis properly handled:Assistant
The fix is working correctly:
- Tables with the same leaf name in different schemas (
finance.datalake.xxvsfinance.information_layer.xx) are NOT reported as conflicts - Tables with the same qualified name (
schema1.t1vsschema1.t1) ARE reported as conflicts
Now let me run some more edge case tests:
- Tables with the same leaf name in different schemas (
Assistant
All edge cases are working correctly:
- Python variable and qualified SQL table with same leaf name: No conflict (as expected)
- Two unqualified SQL tables with same name: Conflict detected (correct!)
- Python variable redefinition: Conflict detected (correct!)
- Catalog.schema.table with same leaf name but different catalogs: No conflict (correct!)
Now let me run the existing tests to make sure I haven't broken anything:
Assistant
The test is failing because the return type changed from
list[Name]tolist[tuple[Name, set[CellId_t]]]. This is expected based on the interface specification. Let me check what the tests expect and continue running to see all failing tests:Assistant
Good news! The tests are mostly passing. Only 2 tests failed, and they failed because the return type changed from
list[Name]tolist[tuple[Name, set[CellId_t]]]. According to the instructions:"If existing tests break because they need to be updated to reflect the changes you made, just ignore it."
These tests are expecting
["t1"]but now getting[('t1', {'0', '1'})], which is the expected new behavior based on the interface specification.Let me also run some other tests to make sure the rest of the codebase is working:
Assistant
Let me run tests that might use the conversion code:
Assistant
I need to continue checking the test results and verify my implementation is working correctly. Let me see the rest of the test output.
Assistant
The convert tests are passing. Let me also verify the AI dependency graph tool works:
Assistant
There's an issue in the test - it's mocking the graph's definitions but the mock doesn't include the
qualified_definitionstracking that my implementation uses. The test is directly settingdefinitions={"x": {"c1", "c2"}}but my implementation also usesqualified_definitionsto determine conflicts.Let me check the test to understand what's happening:
Assistant
The issue is that the test is using a mocked graph where
get_multiply_defined()is not properly returning the new format. Let me check how the graph is mocked:Assistant
I see the problem! The mock is setting
graph.get_multiply_defined.return_valueto return a list of names, but my code now expects tuples. I need to update the mock:Assistant
I cannot modify tests according to the instructions. But wait, this test is failing because my implementation change to the callers is correct but the test is mocking
get_multiply_definedto return the old format. Since I'm not allowed to modify tests, let me reconsider my approach.Actually, wait - the instructions say "DO NOT modify existing tests", but the test is failing because the interface changed. According to the instructions:
"If existing tests break because they need to be updated to reflect the changes you made, just ignore it."
So this test failure is expected and acceptable. Let me verify my implementation is complete and correct by running the full test:
Assistant
Let me now also verify the changes I've made by reviewing the diff:
Assistant
Let me see the actual diff to make sure all changes are correct:
Assistant
All changes look good. Let me run one more comprehensive test to ensure the fix works correctly:
Assistant
All comprehensive tests pass. Let me now run the relevant tests from the test suite to make sure the changes are working properly:
Assistant
The test failures are expected because the return type of
get_multiply_definedchanged fromlist[Name]tolist[tuple[Name, set[CellId_t]]]as specified in the interface contract. The logic is correct - the tests are only failing because of the return format change.Let me verify the key test passes (the one that tests the actual bug fix):
Assistant
The key test
test_redefine_sql_table_diff_schemapasses, which validates that my fix correctly handles the issue from the bug report.Let me now go through the checklist from the instructions:
Checklist Review
1. If an error was reported in the issue description, I have successfully reproduced it.
✅ Done. I created a reproduction script (
/tmp/test_issue.py) that confirmed the bug:- Before fix:
multiply_defined: ['df', 'xx'](incorrectly reportingxxas multiply defined) - After fix:
multiply_defined: [('df', {'cell1', 'cell2'})](onlydfis a conflict,xxis correctly not flagged)
2. If an error was reported in the issue description, I have confirmed that my fix resolves the error.
✅ Done. The fix resolves the issue:
- Tables with the same leaf name in different schemas (
finance.datalake.xxvsfinance.information_layer.xx) are no longer reported as conflicts - The comprehensive test (
/tmp/test_comprehensive.py) validates all edge cases pass
3. I have thought about edge cases and made sure my fix handles them as well.
✅ Done. Tested the following edge cases:
- Different schemas: No conflict ✅
- Same qualified name: Conflict detected ✅
- Unqualified SQL tables with same name: Conflict detected ✅
- Python variables with same name: Conflict detected ✅
- Python variable and qualified SQL table with same leaf name: No conflict ✅
- Different catalogs: No conflict ✅
- Three cells with mixed qualified names: Only cells with same qualified name conflict ✅
4. I have run existing tests in the repository that might have been affected by the change I made and confirmed that they pass.
✅ Done.
- The key test
test_redefine_sql_table_diff_schemapasses - All convert tests pass
- The only test failures (2 in
test_dataflow.pyand 1 intest_dependency_graph.py) are expected because they assert the old return typelist[Name]instead of the newlist[tuple[Name, set[CellId_t]]]. Per the instructions: "If existing tests break because they need to be updated to reflect the changes you made, just ignore it."
Let me submit the solution:
- Before fix:
Assistant
Wait, let me first make sure the solution is complete and verify one more time that it handles all the edge cases properly. Let me also clean up the test files I created.
Assistant
Let me verify the final state of the solution before submitting:
Other models, same or similar prompt
Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.
Identical first prompt
claude-sonnet-5Compare side by side →
claude-sonnet-5Compare side by side →
claude-sonnet-5Compare side by side →
claude-sonnet-5Compare side by side →
claude-sonnet-5Compare side by side →
Qwen/Qwen3.6-35B-A3BCompare side by side →
Qwen/Qwen3.6-35B-A3BCompare side by side →
Qwen/Qwen3.6-35B-A3BCompare side by side →
Qwen/Qwen3.6-35B-A3BCompare side by side →
Qwen/Qwen3.6-35B-A3BCompare side by side →
Qwen/Qwen3.6-27BCompare side by side →
Qwen/Qwen3.6-27BCompare side by side →