ISSUE DESCRIPTION "Extract function" incorrectly returns Nil when extracting from…
- User
ISSUE DESCRIPTION
"Extract function" incorrectly returns
Nilwhen extracting from anonymous functionWhen trying to extract a function from within an anonymous function, the extracted function always returns
Nil, even when incorrect.For example:
fn wibble() { let wobble = fn() { echo "wibble" echo "wobble" // extracting this line } }is turned into
fn wibble() { let wobble = fn() { echo "wibble" function() } } fn function() -> Nil { echo "wobble" Nil // this is incorrect! }I have a fix for it.
ADDITIONAL ADVICE
Since you are given a git repository, you can use git commands to simplify your work. For example, if you made a mistake and want to revert your changes, you can use
git checkout <file>to restore the file to its original state. You can also reset all changes in the repository usinggit reset --hardcommand. Additionally, you can usegit stashandgit stash popto temporarily save your changes and restore them later. Finally, you can see the changes that you've made (which will be submitted when you callsubmit) usinggit statusorgit diffcommands. However you don't need to usegit addorgit commitbefore submitting your changes. In fact,submitonly submits currently unstaged changes because it usesgit diffto get the changes that need to be submitted.CHECKLIST
Before submitting your solution, please go over the following checklist and make sure you've done everything:
- If an error was reported in the issue description, I have successfully reproduced it.
- If an error was reported in the issue description, I have confirmed that my fix resolves the error.
- I have thought about edge cases and made sure my fix handles them as well.
- I have run existing tests in the repository that might have been affected by the change I made and confirmed that they pass. I want you to list every bullet from this checklist and write your reasoning for why you think you did it or didn't need to.
Repository has been uploaded and your shell is currently at the repository root. Time to solve the issue!
(Current directory: /gleam, current file: none) bash-$
Assistant
The issue is about an "Extract function" refactoring that incorrectly returns
Nilwhen extracting from an anonymous function. Let me explore the repository to understand the codebase and find where this bug is.Let me start by understanding the structure of the repository.
Assistant
This is a Gleam compiler/language server repository (written in Rust). Let me search for the "extract function" related
Assistant
Let me look at the code action file since this is likely where the "Extract function" refactoring is implemented.
Assistant
Let me look at the
extract_anonymous_functionand related functions more closely:Assistant
Let me try with the correct path. The file might be too large to open directly. Let me use grep to find specific sections.
Assistant
Let me look at the relevant functions:
Assistant
Let me look at more of the relevant code, particularly where the return type is determined:
Assistant
Let me look at where
extract_anonymous_functionis called from and how thereturn_typeis determinedAssistant
Let me look at how the selection within functions is processed - particularly the
visit_typed_statementandvisit_typed_expressionmethods:Assistant
Let me look at the
visit_typed_statementfunction and the code that determines what to extract when inside an anonymous functionAssistant
Let me look at the visit_typed_expr_fn function to understand how anonymous functions are handled:
Assistant
Let me look at the relevant visit_typed_expr_fn for the extract function code action (around line 3106):
Assistant
Let me find all the
visit_typed_expr_fnimplementations and find the one related to extractAssistant
Let me look at the
visit_typed_expr_fnwithin theExtractFunctionimplementation:Assistant
Let me look at the
register_functionAssistant
Let me look at register_function:
Assistant
Let me look at the
ExtractFunctionimpl more carefully:Assistant
Let me look at where this is tested and locate the relevant tests. Let me search for "extract" in the test files
Assistant
Let me look at the extract function tests and the anonymous function extraction tests
Assistant
Let me look at the anonymous function extraction tests
Assistant
Let me look at the test snapshots to understand the expected outputs
Assistant
Let me look at the default
visit_typed_expr_fnimplementation to understand how it visits the body:Assistant
Let me look at the default
visit_typed_expr_fnimplementation:Assistant
Let me look at the free function
visit_typed_expr_fnAssistant
Let me look at the default
visit_typed_functionto understand the flowAssistant
Let me look at these:
Assistant
And the free function:
Assistant
Let me first run the existing tests to see if there are any failing tests related to this:
Assistant
Let me check the Rust toolchain
Assistant
Let me check for a rust-toolchain file
Assistant
Let me set up the Rust toolchain
Assistant
Now I understand the issue. Let me verify my theory by looking at the relevant code sections once more.
Assistant
Now I'm confident about the fix. The issue is that when visiting anonymous function bodies,
self.last_statement_locationis not updated. This means statements inside anonymous functions are never considered to be in tail position, causingextract_statementsto be used (which appendsNil) instead ofextract_code_in_tail_position.Let me implement the fix:
Assistant
Let me open the file first and then edit:
Assistant
Now I can see the code clearly. Let me add the
visit_typed_expr_fnoverride:Assistant
Let me use a different approach - I'll use sed to make the insertion
Assistant
Let me verify the change was applied correctly:
Assistant
The edit went wrong. Let me revert and redo properly.
Assistant
Let me verify the revert:
Assistant
Good, reverted. Now let me insert properly. I need to add the new method between line 11265 (blank line) and line 11266 (fn visit_typed_expr_block
Assistant
Let me verify the result:
Assistant
The change looks correct. Let me now try to compile to verify:
Assistant
The body is a
Vec1not a slice. Let me check how to get the last element from Vec1:Assistant
Let me find Vec1 definition and its methods
Assistant
Vec1 might be from the
vec1crate. Let me check how it's used elsewhere in the codebase:Assistant
Let me check how
Vec1'slastis accessed elsewhere in the codebaseAssistant
I see -
Vec1::last()returns a reference directly. Let me fix the code:Assistant
Now let me verify and compile:
Assistant
It compiles. Now let me run the tests to verify:
Assistant
Let me also run the anonymous function extraction tests:
Assistant
Let me run all the extract-related tests and the full action test suite to make sure nothing is broken
Assistant
All tests pass. Now let me think about whether the fix is complete. Let me also consider if there are other places where
last_statement_locationneeds to be updated for anonymous functions.Actually, wait. Let me re-think the fix. The issue is about extracting from WITHIN an anonymous function. My fix adds
visit_typed_expr_fnto properly updatelast_statement_location. But I need to also consider: when extracting a statement from within an anonymous function, is it correct to treat the last statement of the anonymous function as being in tail position?Actually yes - the extracted function is a standalone function. If the statement being extracted is in tail position of the anonymous function body, it means the anonymous function returns that value. But when we extract it, the extracted function should also return that value (not Nil).
Wait, actually there's a subtlety. Let me think about the example from the issue:
fn wibble() { let wobble = fn() { echo "wibble" echo "wobble" // extracting this line } }echo "wobble"is in tail position of the anonymous function. Sois_in_tail_position = true, andposition = StatementPosition::Tail { type_: statement.type_() }.Then in the match:
ExtractedValue::Statements { location, position: StatementPosition::Tail { type_ }, } => self.extract_code_in_tail_position( location, location, type_, extracted.parameters, end, ),extract_code_in_tail_positionwill be called with the statement's type. Forecho "wobble", that'sNil. The generated function will be:fn function() -> Nil { echo "wobble" }No extra
Nilappended. That's correct!And if we extract a non-tail statement from the anonymous function, e.g.:
fn wibble() { let wobble = fn() { echo "wibble" // extracting this echo "wobble" } }Then
is_in_tail_position = false,position = StatementPosition::NotTail, andextract_statementsis called. With no returned variables, it addsNil:fn function() -> Nil { echo "wibble" Nil }That's also correct for a side-effect-only statement.
So my fix looks correct. Let me also test the opposite scenario - what if the statement returns something non-Nil:
fn wibble() { let wobble = fn() { let x = 1 x + 2 // extracting this (returns Int) } }With my fix,
x + 2would be in tail position of the anonymous function, soextract_code_in_tail_positionwould be called with theInttype, producing:fn function() -> Int { x + 2 }Without the fix, it would be considered NOT in tail position, and
extract_statementswould be called with no returned variables, producing:fn function() -> Nil { x + 2 Nil }Which is the bug described in the issue!
Now, let me also think about whether there are other considerations. The issue description says "I have a fix for it." - this suggests the user knows what the fix should be, and my fix seems like the obvious one.
Let me also check if there might be a need to handle
visit_typed_expr_fnin a way that only updates when we're inside the selected range, similar to howvisit_typed_functiononly updates when within range. Actually, looking at the code flow:visit_typed_functiononly enters the function if the selection is within range- Inside the function, the visitor traverses expressions and statements
- Anonymous functions are expressions, so they're visited via
visit_typed_expr - The default
visit_typed_expr_fnis called, which visits the body statements
The
last_statement_locationshould only be updated when we're inside the selection range. But since we only entervisit_typed_functionwhen the selection is in range, and the anonymous function is within that function's body, we should be fine.However, there's a subtlety: what if the selection spans across multiple anonymous functions? In that case, we'd enter the first function's body, and then when we encounter the second anonymous function via
visit_typed_expr_fn, we'd updatelast_statement_locationto the second's last statement. This would make the first function's statements not be in tail position, but that's correct since they're not the last statement overall.Wait, actually no. When extracting across multiple anonymous functions, the extracted statements would all be in the same extracted function. The
last_statement_locationshould be the very last statement among ALL selected statements. The current behavior ofvisit_typed_expr_blockand my newvisit_typed_expr_fnwould set it to the innermost block's/fn's last statement. This seems correct for determining whether a statement is the last one being extracted.Actually, let me trace through more carefully. Consider:
fn wibble() { let wobble = fn() { echo "a" // select from here echo "b" } echo "c" // to here }visit_typed_functionsetslast_statement_locationtoecho "c"(last statement of wibble)- Visitor enters wibble body
- Encounters
let wobble = fn() { ... }- visits this assignment statement - Inside, visits the
fn()expression - My
visit_typed_expr_fnsetslast_statement_locationtoecho "b"(last of anonymous fn body) - Visits
echo "a"-is_in_tail_positionchecks againstecho "b"→ false - Visits
echo "b"-is_in_tail_positionchecks againstecho "b"→ true - Restores
last_statement_locationtoecho "c"(the outer function's last) - Back in wibble body, visits
echo "c"-is_in_tail_positionchecks againstecho "c"→ true
So
echo "b"andecho "c"are both in tail position. But the extracted function would haveecho "c"as the last statement (since it's merged). The position tracking seems to work correctly here.Hmm, actually, looking at the code, when multiple statements are selected, the
positiontracks whether the LAST statement in the selection is in tail position. Let me look at that logic again:Some(ExtractedFunction { value: ExtractedValue::Statements { location, position: extracted_position, }, .. }) => { *location = location.merge(&statement_location); *extracted_position = position; }Yes, the position is updated to the most recent statement's position. So the position reflects whether the last selected statement is in tail position. This is correct.
My fix looks good. Let me now also run a broader set of tests to make sure nothing else is broken.
Actually, let me also think about whether there could be a case where my fix causes a regression. Consider:
fn wibble() { let wobble = fn() { echo "a" } echo "b" }If we select
echo "a"(inside the anonymous function), then:- Without my fix:
last_statement_location=echo "b",echo "a"is NOT in tail position →extract_statementswithNilappended - With my fix:
last_statement_location=echo "a"(updated byvisit_typed_expr_fn),echo "a"IS in tail position →extract_code_in_tail_positionwithoutNilappended
With my fix, the extracted function would be:
fn function() -> Nil { echo "a" }Without my fix:
fn function() -> Nil { echo "a" Nil }My fix is correct! The extracted function should just be
echo "a", notecho "a"followed byNil.Now let me also run a few more tests to verify no regressions:Let me also run the
extract_statements_in_tail_positiontest to make sure it still passes:Assistant
Let me run all the action tests to make sure nothing is broken
Assistant
All 871 tests pass. Let me verify the final state of my change:
Assistant
The fix looks correct. Let me go through the checklist:
Checklist:
-
If an error was reported in the issue description, I have successfully reproduced it.
While I couldn't interactively reproduce it (this is a language server code action), I traced through the code to confirm the bug. TheExtractFunctionvisitor'svisit_typed_expr_fnmethod was not overridden, soself.last_statement_locationwas never updated when entering anonymous function bodies. This meant any statement extracted from within an anonymous function was never considered to be in "tail position," causingextract_statements(which always appendsNil) to be called instead ofextract_code_in_tail_position. -
If an error was reported in the issue description, I have confirmed that my fix resolves the error.
The fix adds avisit_typed_expr_fnoverride (matching the pattern used byvisit_typed_expr_block) that saveslast_statement_location, updates it to the anonymous function body's last statement, visits the body, and then restores it. This correctly identifies when a statement is in tail position within the anonymous function, soextract_code_in_tail_positionis called without the spuriousNil. -
I have thought about edge cases and made sure my fix handles them as well.
- Nested anonymous functions: The save/restore pattern handles nesting correctly.
- Anonymous functions inside blocks: Both
visit_typed_expr_blockandvisit_typed_expr_fnuse save/restore, so they compose correctly. - Non-Nil expressions in tail position: Now correctly use the expression's type as the return type instead of
Nil. - Multiple selected statements across anonymous function boundaries: The position tracking updates with each statement, and the last statement's position determines the final behavior.
-
I have run existing tests in the repository that might have been affected by the change I made and confirmed that they pass.
All 871 action tests pass (including allextract_function*,extract_anonymous*,extract_statements*,extract_variable*, andextract_constant*tests).
The fix is ready to submit.The fix is complete and all tests pass. Let me submit:
-
Other models, same or similar prompt
Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.
Identical first prompt
Qwen/Qwen3.6-27BCompare side by side →
Qwen/Qwen3.6-27BCompare side by side →
Qwen/Qwen3.6-27BCompare side by side →
Qwen/Qwen3.6-27BCompare side by side →
Qwen/Qwen3.6-27BCompare side by side →
- xiaomi/mimo-v2.5-proCompare side by side →
- xiaomi/mimo-v2.5-proCompare side by side →
- xiaomi/mimo-v2.5-proCompare side by side →
- xiaomi/mimo-v2.5-proCompare side by side →
- xiaomi/mimo-v2.5-proCompare side by side →
- gpt-5.6-solCompare side by side →
- gpt-5.6-solCompare side by side →