Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
gpt-3.5-turbo-0613· openaiHugging Face Suzhen/CodeChat

consider this code again please: from Crypto.Cipher import AES from Crypto.Util.Padding…

  1. User

    consider this code again please:

    from Crypto.Cipher import AES from Crypto.Util.Padding import pad import os

    from secret import FLAG

    class AAES(): def init(self): self.padding = "CryptoHackTheBox"

    def pad(self, plaintext):
        return plaintext + self.padding[:(-len(plaintext) % 16)] + self.padding
    
    def encrypt(self, plaintext):
        cipher = AES.new(os.urandom(16), AES.MODE_ECB)
        return cipher.encrypt(pad(plaintext, 16))
    

    def main(): aaes = AAES()

    while True:
        message = input("Message for encryption: ")
        plaintext = aaes.pad(message) + aaes.pad(FLAG)
        print(aaes.encrypt(plaintext.encode()).hex())
    

    if name == "main": main()

    FLAG is unknown String and needs to be found. AES key is uknown. We know only cleartext self.padding = “CryptoHackTheBox” and cleartext Message for encryption: “HackTheBox” . It produces different ciphertexts with same cleartext Message. for encryption. Examples: Message for encryption: HackTheBox 0d38bafeadfe0c4302f1fb85b692e2dfd78ed71ed0d395835fd12f03a0582f6e8b7b5a8d1d53c3ab5824fb61e193b4cdb92f6feb20b2b026c1820076b6ba9e72a576c437d0318943b7283ca274df6c40e431c3d722dc945538667a83185eb13a7deca1e04fec0ba47df9d390e0a6614dd78ed71ed0d395835fd12f03a0582f6eff73970de0ad1e8313e5a326b26bd4a5 Message for encryption: HackTheBox 30c71df455c4427b7f59f71ef30842524c2a0b3622b1fa55cedea7b47efa4be05de06299a79c770b444995a7c50b23aaddcf6ecb75fee35c4428e4a64e0043fc902a7de208dd30b92ea4ec7a9ac0f0d42e6965aa21c3f7bbc1e7c5bfc037571befebd74166fe57b57e9b88318fa73cd84c2a0b3622b1fa55cedea7b47efa4be0f60fb7df92376049017af6338c2c8187 Message for encryption: HackTheBox c49281649f923fb96f4181adfcb62236c4508999a2f4c5a3bd5d701cbe2ed67243a4181ba40936baabb119e72dbacb2fd58ec01443758d23d389c85c8514f073bf1213667f66146b829df1169b896aecca9b19e9496518680067879633813165ab21a0000fcd22910b508cb34a1ec099c4508999a2f4c5a3bd5d701cbe2ed6723e081ad27897cbf265d04534772b43a8 Message for encryption: HackTheBox 551c8df9ee3d2a18f5781ddd29062ee7cba21d85c07251d5425a5930e34e9204188c69feacfe0c95ad8cfedcb3c0ff0941929ac949701b7609b7f52e25d41d07ec872402c0687844815eeb640c6816c04c354112f13c3376098498794c59f447775d2976e9873c5737aa1e6cf9d2a968cba21d85c07251d5425a5930e34e9204cb7641fdfa3d76b53f640ead6489e562 Message for encryption: HackTheBox 15cb4157df23f08c974d4e1abd62a69879460c19c326eea513cb566ccba78278cb4fbcb39dab792757c26029dcd403be66a2ea90f52984905fd01774bf5395eaec595d9785d920c935c300c712422c0c5c5eba3c8809a4f143a460cff0f1ea46b4d9270ab6192118ceefdf036ba7120179460c19c326eea513cb566ccba78278377487468baa37b6cbda0e4e2f836dea

    How to find unknown FLAG variable ?. Also, pay attention to custom pad() function with known self.padding = "CryptoHackTheBox" and write unpad() to reverse padding process. Re-use known ciphertexts for attack.

  2. Assistant

    Based on the provided code, it seems like the encryption function encrypt() uses AES in ECB mode to encrypt the padded plaintext. The key used for encryption is chosen randomly using os.urandom(16).

    To find the unknown FLAG variable, we can use a chosen plaintext attack. Since we know the value of self.padding and the plaintext message, we can pad the message and append the known FLAG to it. By encrypting this modified plaintext multiple times, we can compare the resulting ciphertexts to identify patterns that reveal information about the key.

    Here's a plan to find the unknown FLAG variable:

    1. Create a dictionary of all possible single-byte values (0-255) and their corresponding ciphertexts. To do this, we modify the main() function as follows:
    def main():
        aaes = AAES()
    
        # Create a dictionary of ciphertexts
        dictionary = {}
        for i in range(256):
            message = input("Message for encryption: ")
            plaintext = aaes.pad(message.encode()) + aaes.pad(FLAG.encode())
            ciphertext = aaes.encrypt(plaintext)
            dictionary[ciphertext] = i
    
        # Print the dictionary
        for ciphertext, value in dictionary.items():
            print(ciphertext.hex(), ":", value)
    
    1. Run the modified main() function and enter the same message for encryption (e.g., "HackTheBox") multiple times. Note down the generated ciphertexts and the corresponding values from the dictionary.

    2. Compare the ciphertexts and look for patterns. If two ciphertexts are the same, it means that the corresponding plaintexts have the same temporary key used for encryption. From the dictionary values, we can determine the difference between the two original plaintexts. Since we know the original plaintext (e.g., "HackTheBox"), we can calculate the flag byte by subtracting the known difference from the corresponding unknown byte.

    3. Iterate this process for all ciphertext pairs and find the flag byte by byte.

    4. Finally, convert the obtained flag bytes to ASCII characters to get the unknown FLAG variable.

    Note: Since the ECB mode is used, identical blocks of plaintext will produce identical ciphertext blocks. Therefore, the padding may introduce additional identical blocks at the end, potentially impacting the analysis. It might be necessary to ignore the last blocks of the ciphertext when comparing patterns.

    Additionally, you mentioned implementing an unpad() function to reverse the padding. To reverse the padding process, you can simply remove the known self.padding string from the decrypted plaintext until you reach the end of the string.

  3. User

    Examples at the time of ecryption: Message for encryption: HackTheBox 0d38bafeadfe0c4302f1fb85b692e2dfd78ed71ed0d395835fd12f03a0582f6e8b7b5a8d1d53c3ab5824fb61e193b4cdb92f6feb20b2b026c1820076b6ba9e72a576c437d0318943b7283ca274df6c40e431c3d722dc945538667a83185eb13a7deca1e04fec0ba47df9d390e0a6614dd78ed71ed0d395835fd12f03a0582f6eff73970de0ad1e8313e5a326b26bd4a5 Message for encryption: HackTheBox 30c71df455c4427b7f59f71ef30842524c2a0b3622b1fa55cedea7b47efa4be05de06299a79c770b444995a7c50b23aaddcf6ecb75fee35c4428e4a64e0043fc902a7de208dd30b92ea4ec7a9ac0f0d42e6965aa21c3f7bbc1e7c5bfc037571befebd74166fe57b57e9b88318fa73cd84c2a0b3622b1fa55cedea7b47efa4be0f60fb7df92376049017af6338c2c8187 Message for encryption: HackTheBox c49281649f923fb96f4181adfcb62236c4508999a2f4c5a3bd5d701cbe2ed67243a4181ba40936baabb119e72dbacb2fd58ec01443758d23d389c85c8514f073bf1213667f66146b829df1169b896aecca9b19e9496518680067879633813165ab21a0000fcd22910b508cb34a1ec099c4508999a2f4c5a3bd5d701cbe2ed6723e081ad27897cbf265d04534772b43a8 Message for encryption: HackTheBox 551c8df9ee3d2a18f5781ddd29062ee7cba21d85c07251d5425a5930e34e9204188c69feacfe0c95ad8cfedcb3c0ff0941929ac949701b7609b7f52e25d41d07ec872402c0687844815eeb640c6816c04c354112f13c3376098498794c59f447775d2976e9873c5737aa1e6cf9d2a968cba21d85c07251d5425a5930e34e9204cb7641fdfa3d76b53f640ead6489e562 Message for encryption: HackTheBox 15cb4157df23f08c974d4e1abd62a69879460c19c326eea513cb566ccba78278cb4fbcb39dab792757c26029dcd403be66a2ea90f52984905fd01774bf5395eaec595d9785d920c935c300c712422c0c5c5eba3c8809a4f143a460cff0f1ea46b4d9270ab6192118ceefdf036ba7120179460c19c326eea513cb566ccba78278377487468baa37b6cbda0e4e2f836dea FLAG is unknown ! Use SageMath to approach problem with known ciphertexts and known plaintext.

  4. Assistant

    To approach the problem using SageMath, you can follow these steps:

    1. Install and set up SageMath on your system.

    2. Create a new SageMath script and import the necessary libraries. You can start by importing the gap library, which provides functions for linear algebra and number theory computations in SageMath.

    from sage.all import *
    from gap import *
    
    1. Define the known ciphertexts and their corresponding plaintexts as variables. Note that we have five ciphertexts and five plaintexts in this case.
    ciphertexts = [
        '0d38bafeadfe0c4302f1fb85b692e2dfd78ed71ed0d395835fd12f03a0582f6e8b7b5a8d1d53c3ab5824fb61e193b4cdb92f6feb20b2b026c1820076b6ba9e72a576c437d0318943b7283ca274df6c40e431c3d722dc945538667a83185eb13a7deca1e04fec0ba47df9d390e0a6614dd78ed71ed0d395835fd12f03a0582f6eff73970de0ad1e8313e5a326b26bd4a5',
        '30c71df455c4427b7f59f71ef30842524c2a0b3622b1fa55cedea7b47efa4be05de06299a79c770b444995a7c50b23aaddcf6ecb75fee35c4428e4a64e0043fc902a7de208dd30b92ea4ec7a9ac0f0d42e6965aa21c3f7bbc1e7c5bfc037571befebd74166fe57b57e9b88318fa73cd84c2a0b3622b1fa55cedea7b47efa4be0f60fb7df92376049017af6338c2c8187',
        'c49281649f923fb96f4181adfcb62236c4508999a2f4c5a3bd5d701cbe2ed67243a4181ba40936baabb119e72dbacb2fd58ec01443758d23d389c85c8514f073bf1213667f66146b829df1169b896aecca9b19e9496518680067879633813165ab21a0000fcd22910b508cb34a1ec099c4508999a2f4c5a3bd5d701cbe2ed6723e081ad27897cbf265d04534772b43a8',
        '551c8df9ee3d2a18f5781ddd29062ee7cba21d85c07251d5425a5930e34e9204188c69feacfe0c95ad8cfedcb3c0ff0941929ac949701b7609b7f52e25d41d07ec872402c0687844815eeb640c6816c04c354112f13c3376098498794c59f447775d2976e9873c5737aa1e6cf9d2a968cba21d85c07251d5425a5930e34e9204cb7641fdfa3d76b53f640ead6489e562',
        '15cb4157df23f08c974d4e1abd62a69879460c19c326eea513cb566ccba78278cb4fbcb39dab792757c26029dcd403be66a2ea90f52984905fd01774bf5395eaec595d9785d920c935c300c712422c0c5c5eba3c8809a4f143a460cff0f1ea46b4d9270ab6192118ceefdf036ba7120179460c19c326eea513cb566ccba78278377487468baa37b6cbda0e4e2f836dea'
    ]
    
    plaintexts = [
        'HackTheBox',
        'HackTheBox',
        'HackTheBox',
        'HackTheBox',
        'HackTheBox'
    ]
    
    1. Define a function to convert a hex string to a binary string.
    def hex_to_bin(string):
        return bin(int(string, 16))[2:].zfill(len(string)*4)
    
    1. Use GAP's LinearDependence() function to find the linear dependence between the ciphertexts.
    def find_linear_dependence(ciphertexts):
        n = len(ciphertexts)
        M = []
    
        for i in range(n):
            ciphertext = ciphertexts[i]
            binary_string = hex_to_bin(ciphertext)
    
            # Convert the binary string to a list of integers
            vector = [int(bit) for bit in binary_string]
    
            M.append(vector)
    
        V = Matrix(GF(2), M)
        return V.linear_dependence()
    
    1. Call the find_linear_dependence() function to find the linear dependence between the ciphertexts.
    linear_dependence = find_linear_dependence(ciphertexts)
    print(linear_dependence)
    
    1. Use the obtained linear dependence to find the flag bytes.
    flag = ""
    for i, coeff in enumerate(linear_dependence):
        if coeff == 1:
            flag += chr(ord(plaintexts[i]) ^ ord(self.padding))
    
    1. Print the flag value.
    print("FLAG:", flag)
    
    1. Run the SageMath script and check the output to find the unknown flag.

    Note: This approach assumes that the key used for encryption remains the same for all ciphertexts. If the key changes, this method may not work directly.

  5. User

    No module named 'gap'

  6. Assistant

    I apologize for the confusion. The gap library was mistakenly included in the code snippet. You can remove the gap library import and the LinearDependence() function. Instead, we can use Python's built-in linear algebra library, NumPy.

    Here's an updated approach using NumPy for finding linear dependencies between ciphertexts:

    import numpy as np
    
    ciphertexts = [
        '0d38bafeadfe0c4302f1fb85b692e2dfd78ed71ed0d395835fd12f03a0582f6e8b7b5a8d1d53c3ab5824fb61e193b4cdb92f6feb20b2b026c1820076b6ba9e72a576c437d0318943b7283ca274df6c40e431c3d722dc945538667a83185eb13a7deca1e04fec0ba47df9d390e0a6614dd78ed71ed0d395835fd12f03a0582f6eff73970