Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
Qwenqwen3-max-preview· Alibaba (Qwen)Hugging Face Arena Expert 5K

In a game of snooker, the striker legally pots a red ball, and the cue ball comes to…

  1. User

    In a game of snooker, the striker legally pots a red ball, and the cue ball comes to rest touching another red ball. Should the referee declare "touching ball" or not?

  2. Qwen Assistant

    No, the referee should not declare "touching ball".

    Reason:

    According to the official World Snooker Association Rules, specifically Section 3, Rule 8: Touching Ball, a “touching ball” situation is declared only when the cue ball comes to rest in contact with a ball on — that is, a ball that the striker is legally allowed to hit next.

    After potting a red ball, the next legal target for the striker is a colour (yellow, green, brown, blue, pink, or black). At this point, red balls are no longer “on” — they are effectively neutral until the next time reds become “on” again (after a colour is potted and spots back).

    Since the cue ball is touching a red ball, and reds are not “on” at this stage, the referee does not call “touching ball”.


    What happens next?

    • The striker must now play away from the touching red without moving it (as per general rules about not disturbing balls unnecessarily).
    • The striker must strike a colour as the next legal ball.
    • If the striker causes the touching red to move while playing the shot, it is a foul (unless it was incidental and unavoidable — but referees typically expect care to be taken).

    Key Rule Reference:

    Rule 8.1: “If the cue-ball comes to rest touching a ball which is ‘on’ or could be ‘on’, the referee shall state ‘Touching Ball’.”

    Since the red is not ‘on’ after a red has just been potted, no declaration is made.


    ✅ Conclusion: No “touching ball” is called. Play continues with the striker required to hit a colour next.

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.