i am using option alpha to create 1DTE and 0DTE option spread strategies for SPX. In…
- User
i am using option alpha to create 1DTE and 0DTE option spread strategies for SPX. In total, I am running 23 bots (20 bots are for 0DTE and 3 bots are for 1DTE trades). I have long, neutral and short strategies set to run at different times during the trading day. I have backtested with 3 years of data and included normal slippage. I have also tested variations in the backtesting for example using different entry times to help ensure that I am not using a strategy that only works under a single criteria set. what are your thoughts and what else should I be looking for to evaluate my strategy.
- Assistant
This is a fantastic level of rigor—you’re clearly not just tinkering on the surface but actually stress-testing the framework. You’ve already ticked some of the most important boxes: multiyear backtests, accounting for slippage, and varying entry-time criteria to avoid overfitting to a single “magic window.” That’s real professional discipline at work.
Here’s where you might expand your evaluation lens to pressure-test your 0DTE/1DTE SPX spread strategy setup even further:
1. Robustness Across Market Regimes
Backtests are excellent, but remember: the last three years were a rollercoaster of unique conditions (pandemic volatility, zero-rate regime, inflation shock, rate hikes, then equity rallies). A strategy could look great in this sample but struggle in other environments.
- Split your backtest into sub-periods (e.g., 2020 crash, 2021 melt-up, 2022 bear, 2023 rally).
- Check that the edge is consistent (profitable in all—or at least not catastrophically weak in specific periods).
2. Risk of Ruin & Tail Events
Even well-designed 0DTE spreads can have nasty blow-up days. Ask:
- What’s the worst historical single-day P&L in your test?
- How many such events in a row could happen before you break risk tolerance?
- Simulate gap scenarios where SPX skips through the strikes (especially for short spreads).
Think: “How do I sleep if SPX is ±3% intraday in 15 minutes?”
3. Position Sizing & Correlation of Bots
With 23 bots running, the risk is that they become highly correlated at the wrong time.
- Check aggregate exposure across bots (Delta, Gamma, Vega).
- Are your “long, neutral, short” bots actually giving you net diversification, or is there hidden directional clustering around certain times?
- Test “all bots fire on the same day” scenarios—your risk curve may look different than any single bot’s backtest implies.
4. Intraday Execution Reality
0DTE is execution-sensitive. A few things don’t always show up in backtests:
- Fill quality at fast-moving times (bid/ask spreads can blow up).
- Latency to adjust/exit (Option Alpha may trigger, but market moves while orders fill).
- Hidden costs: commissions aren’t huge on SPX with capped rates, but they accumulate across 23 bots firing daily.
Consider doing some forward paper-trading alongside live until you’re confident slippage assumptions match reality.
5. Alternative Performance Metrics
Beyond win rate and P&L, focus on:
- Expectancy per trade (average gain vs. average loss)
- Profit factor (gross profit ÷ gross loss)
- Distribution of returns: are your profits lots of small wins and a few nasty crashes? Or bell-shaped?
- Autocorrelation of losses: are down days clustered? That spikes drawdown risk.
6. Stress-Testing by Scenario
Run synthetic “what if”s:
- Implied vol spikes: Does your strategy cope if VIX instantly jumps 10+ intraday?
- Market regime change: SPX stuck in low-vol grind (like 2017) vs. hurricane volatility (like March 2020).
- Shortened holding time: does an early exit when profit target hit reduce tail risk without killing expectancy?
7. Practical Consideration: Psychological Capacity
Even if the bots run themselves, watching 23 daily swings in short-expiration spreads can rattle even a seasoned trader. You want to ensure your risk sizing matches your own emotional tolerance—not just the math.
💡Big picture thought: 0DTEs are like keeping a tiger as a pet—you can feed it steak every day, but one bad swipe and it reminds you who’s boss. Your multiple bots and regime testing is the right zoo-keeper approach. Just make sure the whole menagerie (when looked at holistically) doesn’t leave you exposed to one cage breaking open.
Would you like me to show you an example framework for risk-based capital allocation across bots (so your strategies don't accidentally gang up on the same risk factor)? That way, you can make sure the portfolio of bots is as resilient as the individual ones.
Other models, same or similar prompt
Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.