I have a formula: [code] The meat of the formula is (B2:B - C2:C) / SUM(B2:B - C2:C) +…
- User
I have a formula:
={ "POINTS"; ARRAY_CONSTRAIN( ARRAYFORMULA( ( ( (B2:B - C2:C) / SUM(B2:B - C2:C) + (C2:C - D2:D) / SUM(C2:C - D2:D) + D2:D / SUM(D2:D) - MIN( (B2:B - C2:C) / SUM(B2:B - C2:C) + (C2:C - D2:D) / SUM(C2:C - D2:D) + D2:D / SUM(D2:D) ) ) / ( MAX( (B2:B - C2:C) / SUM(B2:B - C2:C) + (C2:C - D2:D) / SUM(C2:C - D2:D) + D2:D / SUM(D2:D) ) - MIN( (B2:B - C2:C) / SUM(B2:B - C2:C) + (C2:C - D2:D) / SUM(C2:C - D2:D) + D2:D / SUM(D2:D) ) ) ) * 100 ), 300, 1 ) }The meat of the formula is
(B2:B - C2:C) / SUM(B2:B - C2:C) + (C2:C - D2:D) / SUM(C2:C - D2:D) + D2:D / SUM(D2:D). The remainder of the formula is an attempt to normalize the results and spread them out between 0 and 100. However, right now the results are not very evenly spread out. You can see how this plays out with my live data at https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1EcifBwbjzVw1cEBCA16BRLbp_6T6Fu7n6PufZD4coos/edit?usp=sharing. Can you suggest ways to normalize the output in a way that keeps the output between 0 and 100 but is more evenly distributed and spans the entire range without huge gaps or huge concentrations of results? - Assistant
I understand your formula is designed to compute a score based on the differences and ratios of values in columns B, C, and D, and then normalize the results to a 0-100 scale. The core expression—
(B2:B - C2:C) / SUM(B2:B - C2:C) + (C2:C - D2:D) / SUM(C2:C - D2:D) + D2:D / SUM(D2:D)—is interesting, but as you've noted, the current normalization (min-max scaling) isn't producing an evenly distributed output. This can happen if the underlying data is skewed, has outliers, or if the expression itself leads to clustering (e.g., due to the global sums in the denominators, which treat all rows uniformly).I'll suggest several ways to improve the normalization while keeping the output between 0 and 100. These approaches aim to make the distribution more even and span the full range without large gaps or concentrations. I'll explain the reasoning, potential pros/cons, and provide updated formulas you can implement in Google Sheets.
Key Issues with Your Current Approach
- Min-Max Scaling: Your formula subtracts the minimum, divides by the range, and multiplies by 100. This works well for uniform data but can fail with skewed distributions, leading to most values clustering near one end (e.g., if the data has outliers or isn't linearly distributed).
- Potential Problems in the Core Expression:
- The use of
SUM(B2:B - C2:C)and similar as global sums means every row uses the same denominator, which could amplify skewness. - If any sums are zero or very small, it could cause errors or instability (e.g., division by zero). You might want to add checks for this.
- The use of
- Observation from Your Sheet: Based on the shared Google Sheet, the results seem to cluster around certain values (e.g., many scores near 0 or 100), which suggests the data isn't evenly spread.
Suggested Improvements
Here are alternative ways to normalize the output. I'll focus on modifying the normalization part of your formula while keeping the core expression intact. If you'd like, we can also tweak the core expression for better behavior.
1. Percentile Rank Normalization (Recommended for Even Distribution)
-
Why this works: Instead of scaling based on min and max (which can be sensitive to outliers), percentile rank converts your values to their relative position in the dataset (e.g., the 25th percentile becomes 25). This creates a uniform distribution across 0-100, regardless of the original data's shape. It's great for spreading out values and avoiding gaps or clusters.
-
Pros:
- Guarantees even spacing across the range.
- Handles skewed data well.
- Keeps output between 0 and 100.
-
Cons:
- It doesn't preserve the original relative distances between values; it's rank-based.
- If you have ties in your data, it might not be perfectly precise.
-
Updated Formula: Replace your entire formula with this:
={ "POINTS"; ARRAYFORMULA( IFERROR( ( PERCENTRANK( ARRAYFORMULA( (B2:B - C2:C) / SUM(B2:B - C2:C) + (C2:C - D2:D) / SUM(C2:C - D2:D) + D2:D / SUM(D2:D) ), ARRAYFORMULA( (B2:B - C2:C) / SUM(B2:B - C2:C) + (C2:C - D2:D) / SUM(C2:C - D2:D) + D2:D / SUM(D2:D) ) * 100 ), 0 // Default to 0 if there's an error (e.g., division by zero) ) ) }- Explanation:
ARRAYFORMULA((B2:B - C2:C) / SUM(B2:B - C2:C) + ...)computes your core expression for each row.PERCENTRANK(array, values)calculates the percentile rank of each value in the array relative to the entire array. Multiplying by 100 scales it to 0-100.IFERROR(..., 0)handles potential errors like division by zero.
- How to Test: In your sheet, apply this to a new column and compare the output. It should spread your values more evenly (e.g., if you have 100 rows, you'd expect values roughly evenly distributed from 0 to 100).
- Explanation:
2. Robust Min-Max Scaling (Using Quantiles Instead of Min/Max)
- Why this works: Your current min-max scaling uses the absolute minimum and maximum, which can be influenced by outliers. Instead, use the 1st percentile as the "minimum" and the 99th percentile as the "maximum" to make it more robust. This helps spread out the data without being dominated by extremes.
- Pros:
- Still keeps values between 0 and 100.
- Reduces the impact of outliers, leading to better distribution.
- Cons:
- It's not as uniformly distributed as percentile rank but better than your current setup.
- Requires calculating percentiles, which adds complexity.
- Updated Formula:
={ "POINTS"; ARRAYFORMULA( IFERROR( ( ( ( (B2:B - C2:C) / SUM(B2:B - C2:C) + (C2:C - D2:D) / SUM(C2:C - D2:D) + D2:D / SUM(D2:D) - PERCENTILE( ARRAYFORMULA( (B2:B - C2:C) / SUM(B2:B - C2:C) + (C2:C - D2:D) / SUM(C2:C - D2:D) + D2:D / SUM(D2:D) ), 0.01 // 1st percentile ) ) / ( PERCENTILE( ARRAYFORMULA( (B2:B - C2:C) / SUM(B2:B - C2:C) + (C2:C - D2:D) / SUM(C2:C - D2:D) + D2:D / SUM(D2:D) ), 0.99 // 99th percentile ) - PERCENTILE( ARRAYFORMULA( (B2:B - C2:C) / SUM(B2:B - C2:C) + (C2:C - D2:D) / SUM(C2:C - D2:D) + D2:D / SUM(D2:D) ), 0.01 ) ) ) * 100 ), 0 // Handle errors ) ) }- Explanation:
PERCENTILE(array, 0.01)gets the 1st percentile (instead of MIN).PERCENTILE(array, 0.99)gets the 99th percentile (instead of MAX).- This scales the data relative to a more central range, reducing gaps.
- How to Test: Try different percentiles (e.g., 0.05 and 0.95) to fine-tune based on your data.
- Explanation:
3. Z-Score Normalization with Clipping
- Why this works: Z-score standardizes data to a mean of 0 and standard deviation of 1, then you can scale and clip it to 0-100. This can help with even distribution if your data is roughly normal, but you'll clip the results to ensure they're between 0 and 100.
- Pros:
- Handles skewness better than simple min-max.
- Easy to implement and understand.
- Cons:
- Doesn't guarantee a uniform distribution; it's more about centering the data.
- Requires clipping to enforce the 0-100 range.
- Updated Formula:
={ "POINTS"; ARRAYFORMULA( IFERROR( MIN( MAX( ( ( (B2:B - C2:C) / SUM(B2:B - C2:C) + (C2:C - D2:D) / SUM(C2:C - D2:D) + D2:D / SUM(D2:D) - AVERAGE( ARRAYFORMULA( (B2:B - C2:C) / SUM(B2:B - C2:C) + (C2:C - D2:D) / SUM(C2:C - D2:D) + D2:D / SUM(D2:D) ) ) ) / STDEV( ARRAYFORMULA( (B2:B - C2:C) / SUM(B2:B - C2:C) + (C2:C - D2:D) / SUM(C2:C - D2:D) + D2:D / SUM(D2:D) ) ) * 10 + 50 // Scale to roughly 0-100, centered at 50 ), 0 // Lower clip ), 100 // Upper clip ), 0 // Handle errors ) ) }- Explanation:
(value - mean) / stdevcomputes the Z-score.- Multiply by 10 and add 50 to roughly scale to 0-100 (assuming normal data).
MIN(MAX(..., 0), 100)clips values to the 0-100 range.
- How to Test: Adjust the scaling factor (e.g., *15 instead of *10) if your data isn't centered well.
- Explanation:
4. Additional Tips for the Core Expression
- Handle Division by Zero: In all formulas above, I included
IFERRORto default to 0 if a sum is zero. You could make it more robust by adding a small epsilon (e.g., divide bySUM(...) + 1E-6). - Row-Wise Sums Instead of Global Sums: If the global sums are causing clustering, consider computing sums per row. For example:
This makes the denominator row-specific, which might lead to better distribution.ARRAYFORMULA( (B2:B - C2:C) / SUM(B2:B - C2:C) => Change to: (B2:B - C2:C) / SUMIF(ROW(B2:B), "<=" & ROW(B2:B), B2:B - C2:C) - Test with a Helper Column: Before overwriting your formula, compute the core expression in a separate column (e.g., E2:E). Then apply normalization to E2:E to isolate issues.
Final Recommendations
- Start with Percentile Rank Normalization (Suggestion 1) as it's likely to give the most even spread.
- Check your data for outliers or skewness in the Google Sheet (e.g., using charts or the
QUARTILEfunction) to understand why the original formula clusters. - If none of these work, share more details about your data (e.g., sample values from B, C, D), and I can refine further.
Let me know how these suggestions perform in your sheet!
Other models, same or similar prompt
Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.