In rust. Is it possible to give a better error message when someone is using my…
- User
In rust. Is it possible to give a better error message when someone is using my typestate pattern?
I currently get this error: error[E0599]: no method named
buildfound for structStateMachineBuilder<_, &str, {integer}, Initial>in the current scope --> examples\cd_player_str.rs:9:10 | 8 | let mut cd_player = StateMachineBuilder::new( track, "Stopped") | _______________________- 9 | | .build(); | | -^^^^^ method not found inStateMachineBuilder<_, &str, {integer}, Initial>| |_______| | | = note: the method was found for -StateMachineBuilder<Event, State, Store, StateSelected>-StateMachineBuilder<Event, State, Store, TransitionStarted>When someone does this: let mut cd_player = StateMachineBuilder::new( track, "Stopped").build();
For this library code:
pub struct Transition<Event, State, Store> { event: Event, from_state: State, to_state: State, before_event: fn(&mut Store), after_event: fn(&mut Store), condition: fn(&Store) -> bool, }
impl<Event, State, Store> Transition<Event, State, Store> { fn new(event: Event, from_state: State) -> Self where State: Copy, { Self { event, from_state, to_state: from_state, // Default to same state before_event: || {}, // Default to no-op after_event: || {}, // Default to no-op condition: |_| true, // Default to always true } } }
pub struct StateMachine<Event, State, Store> { global_function_after_transition: fn(&mut Store, &State, &Event), transitions: Vec<Transition<Event, State, Store>>, pub state: State, pub store: Store, }
impl<Event, State, Store> StateMachine<Event, State, Store> where State: Copy + PartialEq, Event: PartialEq, { #[allow(clippy::needless_pass_by_value)] pub fn trigger(&mut self, event: Event) { for transition in &mut self.transitions { if transition.event != event || self.state != transition.from_state { continue; }
(transition.before_event)(&mut self.store); if (transition.condition)(&self.store) { (transition.after_event)(&mut self.store); self.state = transition.to_state; (self.global_function_after_transition)(&mut self.store, &self.state, &event); break; } } }}
pub struct Initial; pub struct StateSelected; pub struct TransitionStarted;
pub trait BuilderState {} impl BuilderState for Initial {} impl BuilderState for StateSelected {} impl BuilderState for TransitionStarted {}
#[must_use] pub struct StateMachineBuilder<Event, State, Store, BuilderStateType: BuilderState> { state_machine: StateMachine<Event, State, Store>, current_state: State, _builder_state: std::marker::PhantomData, }
impl<Event, State, Store> StateMachineBuilder<Event, State, Store, Initial> where State: Copy + PartialEq, Event: PartialEq, { pub fn new(data_store: Store, initial_state: State) -> Self { Self { state_machine: StateMachine { transitions: Vec::new(), state: initial_state, store: data_store, global_function_after_transition: |,,_| {}, }, current_state: initial_state, _builder_state: std::marker::PhantomData, } }
pub fn set_global_action( mut self, global_action: fn(&mut Store, &State, &Event) ) -> Self { self.state_machine.global_function_after_transition = global_action; self } pub fn state(mut self, state: State) -> StateMachineBuilder<Event, State, Store, StateSelected> { self.current_state = state; StateMachineBuilder { state_machine: self.state_machine, current_state: state, _builder_state: std::marker::PhantomData, } }}
impl<Event, State, Store> StateMachineBuilder<Event, State, Store, StateSelected> where State: Copy + PartialEq, Event: PartialEq, { pub fn state(mut self, state: State) -> Self { self.current_state = state; self }
pub fn on(mut self, event: Event) -> StateMachineBuilder<Event, State, Store, TransitionStarted> { let transition = Transition::new(event, self.current_state); self.state_machine.transitions.push(transition); StateMachineBuilder { state_machine: self.state_machine, current_state: self.current_state, _builder_state: std::marker::PhantomData, } } pub fn build(self) -> StateMachine<Event, State, Store> { self.state_machine }}
impl<Event, State, Store> StateMachineBuilder<Event, State, Store, TransitionStarted> where State: Copy + PartialEq, Event: PartialEq, { pub fn state(mut self, state: State) -> StateMachineBuilder<Event, State, Store, StateSelected> { self.current_state = state; StateMachineBuilder { state_machine: self.state_machine, current_state: state, _builder_state: std::marker::PhantomData, } }
pub fn on(mut self, event: Event) -> Self { let transition = Transition::new(event, self.current_state); self.state_machine.transitions.push(transition); self } pub fn go_to(mut self, target: State) -> Self { let last_idx = self.state_machine.transitions.len() - 1; self.state_machine.transitions[last_idx].to_state = target; self } pub fn update(mut self, before_event: fn(&mut Store)) -> Self { let last_idx = self.state_machine.transitions.len() - 1; self.state_machine.transitions[last_idx].before_event = before_event; self } pub fn only_if(mut self, condition: fn(&Store) -> bool) -> Self { let last_idx = self.state_machine.transitions.len() - 1; self.state_machine.transitions[last_idx].condition = condition; self } pub fn then(mut self, after_event: fn(&mut Store)) -> Self { let last_idx = self.state_machine.transitions.len() - 1; self.state_machine.transitions[last_idx].after_event = after_event; self } pub fn build(self) -> StateMachine<Event, State, Store> { self.state_machine }}
- Assistant
Yes, it is possible to improve the error message experience for users of your typestate-based builder pattern in Rust, but the extent of improvement depends on Rust's compile-time error handling capabilities. Rust's compiler provides detailed error messages based on the code structure, and in your case, the error already gives useful information by listing the types for which the
build()method is available (StateSelectedandTransitionStarted). However, you can't directly customize compile-time error messages in Rust (as of Rust 1.79), since error messages are generated by the compiler based on trait implementations and type mismatches.That said, you can make the API more user-friendly and the error messages more actionable by adjusting your design. Here's a step-by-step explanation and recommendations based on your code and the error you're seeing:
Understanding the Current Issue
- Your typestate pattern enforces a specific sequence of method calls:
- After
StateMachineBuilder::new(), the builder is in theInitialstate. - The
build()method is only implemented forStateSelectedandTransitionStarted, meaning the user must callstate()or a sequence of methods to reach one of these states before callingbuild().
- After
- In the user's erroneous code (
StateMachineBuilder::new(track, "Stopped").build()), the builder remains in theInitialstate, sobuild()is not available. The error message is already somewhat helpful, as it lists the states wherebuild()is defined, but it could be more intuitive if the API guided the user better.
Ways to Improve the Error Message Experience
Since Rust doesn't support custom compile-time error messages, the best approaches involve:
- Modifying the API to reduce common errors: Make the builder more forgiving or enforce the sequence in a way that provides better hints through the error messages.
- Leveraging documentation and compiler suggestions: Use Rust's existing error reporting features (like the notes in the error message) and add documentation to guide users.
- Design changes: Adjust the typestate pattern to make invalid states less common or add methods that hint at the correct usage.
Here are specific recommendations:
1. Add
build()to theInitialState (Make the API More Forgiving)-
Your current design requires calling
state()beforebuild()or adding transitions, but this might be unnecessary if the user doesn't intend to add any transitions. Since the initial state is already set innew(), allowingbuild()in theInitialstate could prevent the error entirely in cases like the user's code. -
Code Change: Add a
build()implementation to theInitialstate:impl<Event, State, Store> StateMachineBuilder<Event, State, Store, Initial> where State: Copy + PartialEq, Event: PartialEq, { // ... existing methods ... /// Builds the state machine. Can be called directly after `new()` if no transitions are needed. pub fn build(self) -> StateMachine<Event, State, Store> { self.state_machine } }- This would allow the user's code (
StateMachineBuilder::new(track, "Stopped").build()) to compile successfully, as the builder would no longer be stuck in an invalid state forbuild(). - Pros:
- Reduces the chance of this specific error occurring.
- Simplifies the API for users who don't need transitions.
- Cons:
- It slightly weakens the typestate enforcement. If you want to ensure that
state()is called before adding transitions, you might need to keepon()restricted toStateSelectedor later states. - If
state()is intended to explicitly define states (e.g., for validation or clarity), this change might bypass that.
- It slightly weakens the typestate enforcement. If you want to ensure that
After this change, the error message for missing
build()would rarely appear, but if it does (e.g., in other misuse cases), the compiler's suggestions would still apply. - This would allow the user's code (
2. Add a Dummy Method or Hint in the
InitialState- You could add a method to the
Initialstate that isn't intended for direct use but helps the compiler suggest the correct next step. For example, add a method likeselect_state_first()that panics or does nothing, but use documentation to explain it. However, this is a bit hacky and might not improve the error message significantly. - Code Example (not recommended as a primary solution):
impl<Event, State, Store> StateMachineBuilder<Event, State, Store, Initial> where State: Copy + PartialEq, Event: PartialEq, { // ... existing methods ... /// This method is a placeholder to guide users. Call `state()` before building or adding transitions. #[deprecated(note = "Call `state()` before building or adding transitions.")] pub fn build(&self) { unreachable!("This should not be called; use `state()` first."); } }- Why this might not help: Rust's deprecation attribute adds a warning, but it doesn't replace the "no method found" error. The compiler might still report the method as missing, and this could confuse users or lead to runtime panics if called incorrectly.
- Better Alternative: Rely on documentation instead (see below).
3. Improve Documentation to Complement Error Messages
- The compiler already provides a note about where
build()is available (StateSelectedandTransitionStarted). You can make this more actionable by adding clear documentation to your public methods. - Code Change:
Add doc comments to
new()and other methods to explain the required sequence:impl<Event, State, Store> StateMachineBuilder<Event, State, Store, Initial> where State: Copy + PartialEq, Event: PartialEq, { /// Creates a new state machine builder with the given data store and initial state. /// /// # Usage /// - If you need to add transitions, call `state()` to select a starting state, then use `on()` to define events. /// - You can build the state machine directly with `build()` if no transitions are needed, but ensure you reach a valid state (e.g., by calling `state()`). /// - Example: /// ``` /// let mut builder = StateMachineBuilder::new(store, initial_state); /// builder = builder.state(some_state).on(some_event).go_to(new_state); /// let machine = builder.build(); /// ``` pub fn new(data_store: Store, initial_state: State) -> Self { // ... } /// Transitions the builder to the `StateSelected` state by setting the current state for transitions. pub fn state(mut self, state: State) -> StateMachineBuilder<Event, State, Store, StateSelected> { // ... } }- Why this helps: When users see the error, they can refer to the documentation for
new()or the crate's overall docs. This doesn't change the error message but makes it easier for users to understand and fix the issue. - Consider adding a crate-level tutorial or examples in your README to demonstrate common usage patterns.
- Why this helps: When users see the error, they can refer to the documentation for
4. Refine the Typestate Pattern for Better Ergonomics
- Your current design requires calling
state()beforebuild()oron(), which might be overly restrictive. Consider simplifying the state machine:- Option: Make
on()available inInitial: If the initial state is sufficient for starting transitions, addon()to theInitialimpl. This way, users can chain methods more flexibly.impl<Event, State, Store> StateMachineBuilder<Event, State, Store, Initial> where State: Copy + PartialEq, Event: PartialEq, { // ... existing methods ... pub fn on(mut self, event: Event) -> StateMachineBuilder<Event, State, Store, TransitionStarted> { let transition = Transition::new(event, self.current_state); self.state_machine.transitions.push(transition); StateMachineBuilder { state_machine: self.state_machine, current_state: self.current_state, _builder_state: std::marker::PhantomData, } } }- This allows users to call
new().on(event).build()withoutstate(), reducing errors. However, it might make theStateSelectedstate redundant, so you could consider merging states for simplicity.
- This allows users to call
- Pros: Fewer states mean fewer opportunities for errors, and the compiler's suggestions might become more intuitive.
- Cons: It could reduce the strictness of your typestate pattern, so weigh this against your design goals.
- Option: Make
5. Leverage Rust Features for Better Error Handling
- Use
#[must_use]Attribute: You've already applied#[must_use]to the builder struct, which is good—it warns users if they create a builder but don't use it. Consider adding it to methods likestate()to emphasize that they must be chained. - Custom Error Types for Runtime Checks: If you have runtime validation (e.g., in
trigger()), you could add custom error types with better messages, but this won't help with compile-time errors like the one you're seeing. - Future Rust Features: Rust is improving error diagnostics (e.g., with better suggestion algorithms in newer compilers). Keep an eye on Rust editions or features like "diagnostic attributes" if they become available.
Final Recommendation
- Short-term Fix: Add
build()to theInitialimpl to make the API more forgiving and reduce the occurrence of this error. This directly addresses the user's issue and aligns with common builder patterns where building is possible at multiple points. - Long-term Improvement: Enhance documentation and consider simplifying the typestate pattern if the strict sequence isn't critical. This will make your library easier to use and the error messages more effective in context.
- Testing: After making changes, test your API with invalid sequences (e.g., using
cargo testor manual examples) to ensure the errors are still handled gracefully.
By making these adjustments, you'll provide a better user experience without relying on unsupported custom error messages. If you share more details about your design goals (e.g., why
state()is required), I can refine these suggestions further! - Your typestate pattern enforces a specific sequence of method calls:
Other models, same or similar prompt
Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.