Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
Coherecommand-a-03-2025· CohereHugging Face Arena Expert 5K

Is static void foo() {} always equivalent to inline void foo() {} in terms of linkage?

  1. User

    Is static void foo() {} always equivalent to inline void foo() {} in terms of linkage?

  2. Cohere Assistant

    In C++, the keywords static and inline have different effects on the linkage of a function, so static void foo() {} is not always equivalent to inline void foo() {} in terms of linkage.

    Key Differences:

    1. static void foo() {}:

      • This declares a function with internal linkage. The function is only visible within the translation unit (source file) where it is defined. Other translation units cannot access this function, even if they declare a function with the same name.
      • Example:
        // file1.cpp
        static void foo() {}
        
        // file2.cpp
        void foo() {} // This is a different function, not a redefinition error
        
    2. inline void foo() {}:

      • This declares a function with no linkage if it appears in a block scope (e.g., inside a function), or external linkage if it appears in namespace scope (e.g., at file scope).
      • When used at file scope, inline allows the function to be defined in multiple translation units without violating the One Definition Rule (ODR), as long as all definitions are identical.
      • Example:
        // file1.cpp
        inline void foo() {}
        
        // file2.cpp
        inline void foo() {} // Allowed if definitions are identical
        

    Summary:

    • Linkage:

      • static void foo() {} has internal linkage.
      • inline void foo() {} has external linkage (when at file scope) or no linkage (when in block scope).
    • Visibility:

      • static restricts the function to the current translation unit.
      • inline allows the function to be defined in multiple translation units (with external linkage).

    Thus, they are not equivalent in terms of linkage.

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.