Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
Qwenqwen3-235b-a22b-instruct-2507· Alibaba (Qwen)Hugging Face Arena Expert 5K

ARE SOFTMAX LOSS (CATEGORICAL CROSS ENTROPY) AND Binary Cross-Entropy CONVEX OR…

  1. User

    ARE SOFTMAX LOSS (CATEGORICAL CROSS ENTROPY) AND Binary Cross-Entropy CONVEX OR NON-CONVEX LOSS FUNCTIONS USED IN DL ALGORITHM?

  2. Qwen Assistant

    Great question! Let's break down the convexity of Softmax Loss (Categorical Cross-Entropy) and Binary Cross-Entropy in the context of deep learning (DL).


    ✅ Short Answer:

    • Binary Cross-Entropy (BCE) and Categorical Cross-Entropy (Softmax Loss) are convex with respect to the model's output (logits).
    • However, they are non-convex with respect to the model parameters (weights) in deep neural networks due to the non-linear, multi-layer structure.

    🔍 Detailed Explanation:

    1. Binary Cross-Entropy (BCE)

    Used for binary classification: [ \mathcal{L} = -[y \log(\sigma(z)) + (1 - y) \log(1 - \sigma(z))] ] where:

    • ( y \in {0,1} ) is the true label,
    • ( z = w^T x + b ) is the linear input (logit),
    • ( \sigma(z) = \frac{1}{1 + e^{-z}} ) is the sigmoid function.

    🔹 Convex in ( z ): Yes — BCE is convex with respect to the logits ( z ).

    But in a neural network, ( z = f_\theta(x) ), where ( f_\theta ) is a non-linear function (e.g., multiple layers with activations). So:

    🔹 Convex in parameters ( \theta )? ❌ No — because the composition of non-linear layers makes the overall loss non-convex in ( \theta ).


    2. Categorical Cross-Entropy (Softmax Loss)

    Used for multi-class classification: [ \mathcal{L} = -\sum_{i} y_i \log(p_i), \quad \text{where } p_i = \frac{e^{z_i}}{\sum_j e^{z_j}} ]

    🔹 Convex in logits ( z ): Yes — the negative log-likelihood with softmax is convex in the logits.

    But again, if the logits are produced by a deep network: ( z = W_2 \sigma(W_1 x + b_1) + b_2 ), then:

    🔹 Convex in parameters ( \theta = {W_1, W_2, ...} )? ❌ No — due to non-linearities (e.g., ReLU, sigmoid) and deep composition, the loss becomes non-convex in the parameters.


    📌 Key Insight:

    FunctionConvex in logits ( z )?Convex in parameters ( \theta )?
    Binary Cross-Entropy✅ Yes❌ No (in DL models)
    Categorical Cross-Entropy✅ Yes❌ No (in DL models)

    The non-convexity in deep learning arises from the model architecture, not the loss function itself.


    🧠 Why This Matters:

    • Even though the loss is convex in the final layer outputs, the overall optimization problem is non-convex.
    • This leads to multiple local minima, saddle points, etc.
    • Yet, in practice, optimization (e.g., SGD) works well due to the special geometry of deep loss landscapes.

    ✅ Summary:

    • Softmax Loss (Categorical Cross-Entropy) and Binary Cross-Entropy are convex functions of the network outputs (logits).
    • But in deep learning, they are non-convex with respect to the model parameters due to non-linear, hierarchical transformations.
    • Hence, training deep networks is a non-convex optimization problem, even with convex loss functions.

    Let me know if you'd like a visual or mathematical proof of convexity in ( z )!

  3. User

    Categorical Cross-Entropy (Softmax loss)

    𝐿 ( 𝑦 , 𝑦 ^ )

    − ∑ 𝑖

    1 𝐶 𝑦 𝑖 log ⁡ ( 𝑦 ^ 𝑖 ) L(y, y ^ ​

    )=− i=1 ∑ C ​

    y i ​

    log( y ^ ​

    i ​

    )

  4. Qwen Assistant

    Yes, you've written the Categorical Cross-Entropy Loss (also known as Softmax Loss) correctly! Let's format it properly and break it down for clarity.


    ✅ Categorical Cross-Entropy Loss (Softmax Loss)

    L(y,y^)=−∑i=1Cyilog⁡(y^i)\mathcal{L}(\mathbf{y}, \hat{\mathbf{y}}) = -\sum_{i=1}^{C} y_i \log(\hat{y}_i)

    🔹 Explanation of Terms:

    • CC: Number of classes.
    • y\mathbf{y}: True label in one-hot encoded form.
      Example: For class 2 in a 3-class problem: y=[0,1,0]\mathbf{y} = [0, 1, 0]
      • yi=1y_i = 1 if class ii is the true class, else 00.
    • y^\hat{\mathbf{y}}: Predicted probability distribution from the softmax function.
      • y^i∈(0,1)\hat{y}_i \in (0, 1), and ∑i=1Cy^i=1\sum_{i=1}^C \hat{y}_i = 1
      • y^i=softmax(zi)=ezi∑j=1Cezj\hat{y}_i = \text{softmax}(z_i) = \frac{e^{z_i}}{\sum_{j=1}^C e^{z_j}}, where ziz_i are raw logits.

    🔹 How It Works:

    Because y\mathbf{y} is one-hot, only the term for the true class survives:

    L=−log⁡(y^k)where k is the true class\mathcal{L} = -\log(\hat{y}_k) \quad \text{where } k \text{ is the true class}

    So the loss penalizes low predicted probability for the correct class.


    🔹 Example:

    Let’s say:

    • True label: y=[0,1,0]\mathbf{y} = [0, 1, 0] → true class is 2
    • Predicted probabilities: y^=[0.1,0.7,0.2]\hat{\mathbf{y}} = [0.1, 0.7, 0.2]

    Then:

    L=−(0⋅log⁡(0.1)+1⋅log⁡(0.7)+0⋅log⁡(0.2))=−log⁡(0.7)≈0.357\mathcal{L} = -\left( 0 \cdot \log(0.1) + 1 \cdot \log(0.7) + 0 \cdot \log(0.2) \right) = -\log(0.7) \approx 0.357

    🔹 Connection to Softmax & Logits:

    In practice, we compute this from logits z\mathbf{z} (pre-softmax scores):

    L=−log⁡(ezk∑j=1Cezj)=−zk+log⁡(∑j=1Cezj)\mathcal{L} = -\log\left( \frac{e^{z_k}}{\sum_{j=1}^C e^{z_j}} \right) = -z_k + \log\left( \sum_{j=1}^C e^{z_j} \right)

    This form is numerically stable and commonly used in deep learning frameworks (often called log-softmax + NLL).


    ✅ Key Properties:

    PropertyDescription
    Domainy^i>0\hat{y}_i > 0 (hence logits are preferred to avoid log(0))
    MinimumAchieved when y^k→1\hat{y}_k \to 1 → L→0\mathcal{L} \to 0
    Convex in y^\hat{\mathbf{y}}?✅ Yes, with respect to output probabilities (under constraints)
    Convex in network parameters?❌ No — due to non-linear layers, overall loss is non-convex

    📌 Summary:

    The categorical cross-entropy loss:

    L=−∑i=1Cyilog⁡(y^i)\boxed{\mathcal{L} = -\sum_{i=1}^{C} y_i \log(\hat{y}_i)}

    is the standard loss function for multi-class classification in deep learning. It works with the softmax activation to encourage the model to assign high probability to the correct class.

    Let me know if you'd like the gradient derivation or implementation in PyTorch/TensorFlow!

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.