the 3 options are individual to the tracks uneder a duplicate group, so they are…
- User
the 3 options are individual to the tracks uneder a duplicate group, so they are processed according to what is clicked, so a Master goes to that logic and a Combine or Keep does that logic, currently all tracks under group and taking the same option
Assistant
Good catch — the bug is that Traktor's
AUDIO_IDis an audio fingerprint, so genuine duplicate files share the sameAUDIO_ID. I was keying the action map (and the playlist lookup) byaudioId, so clicking one track set the action for every track in the group. Let me give each entry a truly unique id.Now let me update the reverse playlist map and the add/remove helpers to key by
uidinstead ofaudioId:Now updating
App.tsxto key actions by the uniqueuid, and removing the leftover no-op state update:Now let me rewrite
applyActionsso each track is processed strictly according to its own individual choice:Now let me add the
appliedVersionstate and update the detail component to useuid:Now let me rewrite the
DupGroupDetailcomponent to use per-trackuid:Now let me update the group header to include a per-track summary and clear button:
Now the track cards — switching them from
audioIdtouid:Let me add a per-track badge so it's visually clear each track holds its own choice:
Build succeeded. Here's what was wrong and what I fixed.
Root cause
Traktor's
AUDIO_IDis an audio fingerprint of the file's content. Two duplicate copies of the same track produce the sameAUDIO_ID. I was using it as the key for:- the action map (
actionsMap[groupKey][audioId]) - the playlist-membership lookup (
playlistsForEntry) - the React
keyon each card
So clicking "Keep" on track 1 wrote to the exact same map slot as tracks 2 and 3 — making all tracks in the group light up and get processed identically.
Fixes
1. Unique per-entry id (
src/nml.ts) Each<ENTRY>now gets auid(e0,e1,e2…) assigned at parse time.entryById,playlistsForEntry,addEntryToPlaylistandremoveEntryFromPlaylistall key offuidnow. A side benefit: each duplicate now shows its own real playlist memberships instead of a merged blob.2. Truly individual selection (
setAction) Only the clickeduidis written. Every other track in the group keeps its existing choice. Clicking an active button toggles it off. The one deliberate cross-track rule: selecting a new Master demotes a previous Master to Combine (a group can only have one master) — nothing else is altered.3.
applyActionsprocesses per-track The group is split into three independent buckets by each track's own choice:- Keep → tagged into
Z_DUP_KEEP, left in all its existing playlists - Combine → added to
Z_DUP_COMBINE - Master → inherits playlist memberships from only the tracks marked Combine, skipping
Z_DUP_KEEP/Z_DUP_COMBINEand any playlist it's already in
Tracks left unset are not touched at all. Master inheritance runs before combines are tagged, so membership is still intact when read. The master is no longer dumped into
Z_DUP_COMBINE— it's the survivor.4. UI reinforcement
- Colored badge on each track card showing its individual choice
- A "What Apply will do for this group" preview listing each track and its outcome by filename
- Warning when a Master is set but nothing is marked Combine
- "Clear N" button to reset a group
actionsMapresets after Apply so a second click can't double-process
One caveat worth flagging:
uidis positional, so it's stable only for the currently loaded file. That's fine here since everything is in-memory per session, but selections won't survive a re-import of the same collection.Files built:
src/nml.ts,src/App.tsx- the action map (
Other models, same or similar prompt
Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.