Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
GeminiGemini (model unspecified)· GoogleHugging Face ShareLM (browser-extension contributions)

Adjust the prompt to only capture the topics discussed and their novelty. The output…

  1. User

    Adjust the prompt to only capture the topics discussed and their novelty. The output dataframe must include the columns: turn_number, speaker, topic, and novelty. Example of the list of topics for the following discussion snippet: [Health Concerns, economic reality,  low-income communities, revenue generated from the sugar tax,  subsidize fresh produce, nutrition programs,  theory vs. practice, the high administrative cost, Cost–benefit concerns] Snippet: """ ELENA: Given the rising rates of type 2 diabetes and the massive strain on our public healthcare infrastructure, I believe a targeted excise tax on high-sugar beverages and snacks is a necessary intervention to disincentivize consumption and improve long-term health outcomes. MARCUS: While I acknowledge the health concerns, we must consider the economic reality; these taxes are inherently regressive, disproportionately penalizing low-income families who spend a larger percentage of their earnings on food and often reside in "food deserts" where fresh, untaxed alternatives are less accessible. ELENA: That is a valid concern, but if we earmark the revenue generated from the sugar tax specifically to subsidize fresh produce and improve nutrition programs in those same underserved communities, we could effectively offset the financial burden while steering behavior toward healthier choices. MARCUS: In theory, perhaps, but in practice, consumers often just substitute one unhealthy habit for another—such as switching from soda to cheap, high-sodium snacks—and the administrative cost of managing such a complex tax-and-subsidy scheme usually consumes the potential benefits before they reach the public. """ Original prompt: """ List all pairs of interactions in the discussion below. - The order must align with the original conversation trajectory. - Topic segmentation requirement: A single utterance may generate multiple interaction pairs when it addresses more than one substantive topic. For example, if a speaker discusses: “cost effects”, “provider choice”, and “patient–doctor relationships”, these must be recorded as three separate interactions, each with its own topic field, even though they originate from the same speaker turn. For each pair, focus on: 1. Its topic: the content that the interlocutors are interacting with. 2. Its novelty: True if the interaction's topic is first introduced in the discussion, False otherwise. 3. Participants: Which participants are involved? 4. Directionality: Identify who is addressing whom. For example: A -> [B, C]. 5. Stance: Is the response 'pro', 'con', or 'neutral' toward the Topic? 6. Sentiment: What is the emotional tone (e.g., aggressive, respectful, sarcastic, etc.)? 7. Power Dynamics: Does either participant exhibit linguistic authority or social dominance? 8. Rhetorical devices used 9. Speech act: Is the interaction a question, an answer, an elaboration, a new direction, or something else? Select from the list: 'ans', 'elab', 'new', 'other'. 10. Influence Score: The extent to which a participant’s utterance successfully shapes the direction, topic, or ideological framework of the conversation. On a scale of 1-5, where: 1 = Purely reactive; follows the lead of the other speaker without adding new dimensions; simple agreement or acknowledgement. 5 = Sets the primary agenda; introduces a new framework that the other participant adopts; successfully shifts the topic. 11. Power Move: The specific strategy used to claim authority, expertise, or social dominance within a turn. Category Schema: Framing = Defining the "problem" or the "reality" in a way that favors one’s own argument. Expertise-signaling =Using technical jargon, statistics, or historical references to establish intellectual superiority. Prescriptive Authority = Moving from "what is" to "what must be done" (giving advice or solutions). Grounding = Using "common sense," "real-world examples," or "moral appeals" to invalidate abstract arguments. Mirroring = A subtle move where one person agrees with the other's logic only to pivot or redirect it. Format the output as a JSON list of objects, to be loaded into a Pandas DataFrame. The JSON keys should be: ["turn_id", "topic", "novelty", "participants", "directionality", "stance", "sentiment", "power_dynamics", "rhetorical_devices", "speech_act", "influence_score", "power_move"] Discussion Content: {disc_content}"""

  2. Gemini Assistant

    To adjust the prompt for your specific needs, we will strip away the extra analytical dimensions (sentiment, power moves, etc.) and refine the instructions to ensure that a single turn is split into multiple JSON objects if it covers multiple topics.Here is the updated prompt:Revised PromptPlaintextAnalyze the discussion below to identify the topics discussed and their novelty.

    Guidelines:

    1. Topic Segmentation: A single speaker turn may address multiple substantive topics. If it does, you must create a separate record for each topic.
    2. Turn Number: Maintain the chronological order of the conversation. If a single turn is split into multiple topics, they should all share the same turn_number.
    3. Novelty: Mark as True if the topic is being introduced for the first time in this specific discussion. Mark as False if the topic has already been mentioned or is an immediate response to a topic introduced by the previous speaker.
    4. Speaker: Identify the name of the person speaking.
    5. Topic: A concise label for the specific subject matter (e.g., "Economic Regressivity", "Public Health Infrastructure").

    Format the output strictly as a JSON list of objects. The JSON keys must be: ["turn_number", "speaker", "topic", "novelality"]

    Discussion Content: {disc_content} How this looks with your snippet:If you run the provided snippet through this prompt, your resulting DataFrame (after pd.read_json or pd.DataFrame(json_data)) would look like this:turn_numberspeakertopicnovelty1ELENAPublic Health InfrastructureTrue1ELENASugar TaxTrue2MARCUSEconomic RegressivityTrue2MARCUSFood DesertsTrue3ELENARevenue EarmarkingTrue3ELENANutrition SubsidiesTrue4MARCUSConsumer Substitution PatternsTrue4MARCUSAdministrative CostsTrueExport to SheetsImplementation Note for your Python Script:Since you are using the google-genai library and wanting to ensure the output is a clean list of topics, remember to keep your temperature at 0.0 as you currently have it. This ensures the model doesn't "hallucinate" extra topics or vary the labels between runs.Would you like me to update your Python processing loop to handle the "split turn" logic specifically for the DataFrame index?

  3. User

    This is a wrong analysis. In turn number 2, Marcus acknowledges the health concern, and therefore, there are expected to be 3 rows for turn number 2: Topic: Public Health Infrastructure, Novelty: False Topic: economic reality, Novelty: True Topic:  low-income communities, Novelty: True

  4. Gemini Assistant

    You are absolutely right. To capture the flow of a discussion accurately, the model must record when a speaker acknowledges or addresses a topic previously introduced by someone else, marking it as novelty: False.Here is the adjusted prompt. I have added a "Few-Shot" example (using your specific Marcus correction) to the instructions to ensure the model follows this granular logic.Adjusted PromptPlaintextAnalyze the discussion below to extract topics and their novelty.

    Rules:

    1. Turn Splitting: A single speaker turn MUST be split into multiple records if it addresses more than one topic.
    2. Handling Continuity (Novelty=False): If a speaker acknowledges, responds to, or agrees/disagrees with a topic introduced earlier, create a row for that topic and set novelty to False.
    3. Handling Introduction (Novelty=True): If a speaker introduces a brand-new subject, set novelty to True.
    4. Turn Numbers: Use the same turn_number for all records originating from the same speaker utterance.

    Output Format: Return a JSON list of objects with these keys: ["turn_number", "speaker", "topic", "novelty"]

    Example logic for Turn 2 (Marcus):

    • Marcus says: "While I acknowledge the health concerns..." -> Topic: Public Health Infrastructure, Novelty: False.
    • Marcus says: "...consider the economic reality..." -> Topic: Economic Reality, Novelty: True.
    • Marcus says: "...penalizing low-income families..." -> Topic: Low-income Communities, Novelty: True.

    Discussion Content: {disc_content} How the resulting DataFrame will lookBased on your feedback, the analysis for the snippet will now correctly reflect the interaction:turn_numberspeakertopicnovelty1ELENAPublic Health InfrastructureTrue1ELENASugar TaxTrue2MARCUSPublic Health InfrastructureFalse2MARCUSEconomic RealityTrue2MARCUSLow-income CommunitiesTrue3ELENALow-income CommunitiesFalse3ELENARevenue EarmarkingTrue3ELENANutrition SubsidiesTrueExport to SheetsA Note on the JSON KeysIn the prompt, I corrected the spelling of the key from novelality to novelty to match your requested column names.Would you like me to rewrite the analyze_discussions function in your script to ensure it handles this specific JSON structure and converts it into the CSV format you need?

  5. User

    Is it clear now: TOPIC_PROMPT = """Analyze the discussion below to extract topics and their novelty. ## Rules: 1. Turn Splitting: A single speaker turn MUST be split into multiple records if it addresses more than one topic. 2. Handling Continuity (Novelty=False): If a speaker acknowledges, responds to, or agrees/disagrees with a topic introduced earlier, create a row for that topic and set novelty to False. 3. Handling Introduction (Novelty=True): If a speaker introduces a brand-new subject, set novelty to True. 4. Turn Numbers: Use the same turn_number for all records originating from the same speaker utterance. ## Output Format: Return a JSON list of objects with these keys: ["turn_number", "speaker", "topic", "novelty"] ## Output: Example logic: - "I believe a targeted excise tax on high-sugar beverages and snacks is a necessary intervention to disincentivize consumption and improve long-term health outcomes." Topic: Health Concerns, Novelty: True. - "While I acknowledge the health concerns, we must consider the economic reality; these taxes are inherently regressive, disproportionately penalizing low-income families who spend a larger percentage of their earnings on food" Topic: Health Concerns, Novelty: False. Topic: Economic Reality, Novelty: True. Topic: Low-Income Communities, Novelty: True. - "That is a valid concern, but if we earmark the revenue generated from the sugar tax specifically to subsidize fresh produce and improve nutrition programs in those same underserved communities, we could effectively offset the financial burden while steering behavior toward healthier choices." Topic: Low-Income Communities, Novelty: False. Topic: Expected Revenues: Fresh Produce Subsidization, Nutrition Programs, Novelty: True. Discussion Content: {disc_content} """

  6. Gemini Assistant

    This version is significantly clearer and much more likely to produce the structured data you need. The inclusion of the Example Logic is the most important part—it acts as "one-shot" or "few-shot" prompting, which is the most effective way to ensure the model understands your specific definition of "novelty."However, I have three small suggestions to make it even more robust for your Python script and to ensure the granularity matches your desired list of topics.1. Match Granularity to your ListIn your original snippet, you listed revenue generated, subsidize fresh produce, and nutrition programs as three separate items. In your current prompt example, you merged them into one topic. To get the most granular data, I recommend splitting them in the example as well.2. Add a "No Preamble" InstructionSince your Python script uses json.loads(), you want to prevent the model from saying "Here is the JSON analysis:" or adding other text. Adding Return ONLY the JSON list is a safe guardrail.3. Updated TOPIC_PROMPTHere is the refined version with those minor tweaks:PythonTOPIC_PROMPT = """Analyze the discussion below to extract topics and their novelty.

    Rules:

    1. Turn Splitting: A single speaker turn MUST be split into multiple records if it addresses more than one substantive topic.
    2. Handling Continuity (Novelty=False): If a speaker acknowledges, responds to, or agrees/disagrees with a topic introduced earlier, create a row for that topic and set novelty to False.
    3. Handling Introduction (Novelty=True): If a speaker introduces a brand-new subject, set novelty to True.
    4. Turn Numbers: Use the same turn_number for all records originating from the same speaker utterance.

    Output Format:

    Return ONLY a JSON list of objects with these keys: ["turn_number", "speaker", "topic", "novelty"]. Do not include any introductory or concluding text.

    Example logic for splitting and novelty:

    • Utterance: "While I acknowledge the health concerns, we must consider the economic reality; these taxes are inherently regressive, disproportionately penalizing low-income families..."
      • Row 1: {"turn_number": 2, "speaker": "MARCUS", "topic": "Health Concerns", "novelty": false}
      • Row 2: {"turn_number": 2, "speaker": "MARCUS", "topic": "Economic Reality", "novelty": true}
      • Row 3: {"turn_number": 2, "speaker": "MARCUS", "topic": "Low-Income Communities", "novelty": true}

    Discussion Content: {disc_content} """ Implementation Pro-Tip for your ScriptSince you are using the google.genai SDK (as seen in your conversation history), you can guarantee the output is JSON by setting the response_mime_type.When you call generate_content, add this to your config:Pythonconfig=types.GenerateContentConfig( temperature=0.0, response_mime_type="application/json", # This forces the model to output valid JSON thinking_config=types.ThinkingConfig( include_thoughts=True, thinking_level="high" ) ) By using both this refined prompt and the response_mime_type="application/json" setting, your script will be very stable.Would you like me to show you how to adjust your all_interactions.extend() logic in the script to handle these specific keys?