Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
GeminiGemini (model unspecified)· GoogleHugging Face ShareLM (browser-extension contributions)

What are the common reasons that papers get stuck for a long time in arXiv how can…

  1. User

    What are the common reasons that papers get stuck for a long time in arXiv how can authors avoid it?

  2. Gemini Assistant

    Papers getting "stuck" in arXiv usually move from a Submitted status to On Hold. This status means your paper has been flagged for manual review by a volunteer moderator. While most papers are processed within 24 hours, a "hold" can last anywhere from a few days to several weeks.The following are the most common reasons for these delays and how you can prevent them.1. Metadata and Categorization IssuesThe most frequent reason for a hold is a mismatch between the paper’s content and its chosen category.Misclassification: If you submit a paper to "Machine Learning" (cs.LG) but it is primarily about "Optimization and Control" (math.OC), a moderator must manually reclassify it.Title/Abstract Mismatches: If your metadata (the title/abstract you typed into the form) differs significantly from what is in the PDF, the system flags it for a consistency check.Excessive Cross-listing: Selecting too many categories can trigger a review to see if the paper is truly relevant to all of them.How to avoid it: * Browse the "new" mailings for your target category to ensure your work fits the style and topic of that community.Stick to one primary category and no more than 1–2 cross-lists.2. Technical and Formatting ErrorsarXiv's automated system (AutoTeX) must be able to compile your source code perfectly. If it fails, the paper won't move forward.Absolute File Paths: Using paths like C:\Users\Desktop\image.png instead of relative paths like figures/image.png will cause the build to fail.Missing Files: Forgetting a .bbl file (for references) or a custom .sty file is a common culprit.Inappropriate Filenames: Using spaces, symbols (like & or $), or non-ASCII characters in filenames often breaks the automated scripts.How to avoid it: * Always use the "Preview" feature to ensure the PDF renders correctly on arXiv's servers before final submission.Clean your LaTeX project: remove unused files and ensure all filenames are lowercase with no spaces.3. Moderation and Quality FlagsModerators (who are volunteer academics) may hold a paper if it doesn't meet scholarly standards."Overlap" (Plagiarism Check): arXiv uses automated tools to check for text overlap. If you reuse large blocks of text from your own previous papers (or others') without proper citation, it triggers a manual review.New Policy for CS Surveys/Position Papers: As of late 2025, arXiv's Computer Science category has significantly tightened rules. Review articles or "position papers" without a record of peer review (e.g., a DOI or journal reference) are now frequently rejected or held indefinitely.AI-Generated Content: Papers flagged as "AI slop" (low-effort, LLM-generated summaries) are being heavily moderated and held for scrutiny.How to avoid it: * If your paper is a survey or review, include a note in the comments field indicating if it has been accepted to a conference or journal.Ensure your "Results" and "Conclusion" sections are distinct from your previous works to avoid high overlap scores.4. Submission PatternsDuplicate Submissions: If you get frustrated and delete a "held" paper to resubmit it, the system may flag you for "gaming" the moderation queue, which leads to even longer delays.Submission Bursts: Submitting 3 or more papers simultaneously can trigger a "rate limit" hold to ensure the work isn't "salami-slicing" (breaking one study into many tiny ones).Pro-Tips for a Smooth SubmissionTo DoTo AvoidInclude the .bbl file for your bibliography.Don't submit a PDF created from LaTeX; submit the source.Remove all LaTeX comments (lines starting with %).Don't use spaces or special characters in filenames.Submit between 14:00 and 20:00 ET for fastest visibility.Don't delete and resubmit a paper that is "On Hold."التصدير إلى "جداول بيانات Google"Would you like me to help you check if your LaTeX file structure is ready for an arXiv upload?