What can be strengthened in the following recommendation letter? I’m writing to give…
- User
What can be strengthened in the following recommendation letter? I’m writing to give Craig Messner my wholehearted recommendation for a faculty position.1 We have been collaborating for about a year, in which Craig was leading the research team including him and two other students, to which I was joined to help in my expertise in pretraining. Among other things, I was delighted to join as I thought and still think his research pinpoints one of the best topics for AI and NLP in Academia. Where a large portion of this field aims to improve performance of efficiency, which hold great monetary value, Craig highlights the role of Academia as a source of knowledge. Craig Messner is visionary, a worthy researcher in the humanities and NLP together or separately and a true scholar. For his one of a kind research agenda or his company, you will enjoy having him in your department. Research: Some say AI won the Nobel prizes for Physics and Chemistry; the humanities, where language is most prominent, see almost no AI training with them in mind. Where the digital humanities for example are adopting technologies, Craig’s research comes to revolutionize the connection between AI and the humanities. In his research, he is fearlessly doing what little AI researchers in general are pursuing, and creates new models from scratch. This point should be emphasized, even in AI, a field with thousands of papers in each conference only tens or less in each would tackle pretraining, and those would mainly be from companies, this is a daunting field that requires expertise (especially without corporate funding). Moreover, he changes the training regimes, architecture and in general the way that AI is being done, to find solutions that are unique to the humanities’s needs. By doing so he innovates both in AI model creation and humanities and allows answering (or answers by himself) questions that we did not have the technological ability to answer, without years of human effort of studying and comparing documents, and perhaps even with them. For example, in our recent ACL submission, he led the creation of a large language model for diachronic language and information change. To deal with the data scarcity and information leakage from the fu- ture, he dated the data, ordered it and pretrained sequentially, keeping the checkpoints that know only information that preceded certain eras. Thanks to the topic choice’s uniqueness, the research ventured into largely virgin territory. As an outcome of that many meetings included ideas for new directions, often raised by Craig. After discussing them,Craig seamlessly prioritized the ideas, pursuing some, keeping some for later or judging them as not important enough. I see his methodological ability to raise ideas, test them and also step back and choose what not to pursue as wonderful assets to a professor, one which grad students who often deal with less projects and have shorter aims often lack, or do not have the chance to develop. Especially noteworthy in that regard is the types of new ideas Craig had and the implementation he and his team pursued. Craig is nothing if not a symbol for a scholar. In my work with hundreds of students and researchers over the years, less than a handful (%1) of people share this breadth of knowledge, depth of understanding and intellectual curiosity. In collaborating with him, I’ve learnt a lot about humanistic aspects, from history, to language change and such topics in which I am admittedly no expert, knowledge that allowed him to perform such research as I and other AI researchers would not be able to conduct. But, he also came up with and judged innovation and ideas in pretraining, adapting models, architectures, data, and other AI topics. Recently, we were investigating possibilities of interpretability or mechanistic interpretability research in aiding a project. This was a field Craig did not work in before, and has tremendous amount of jargon and knowledge that is quite separated from the rest of the research world. A week after starting it, he already had multiple relevant ideas, and clear understanding of the field, which just improved in the few weeks later with the way he was gulping the new field opened to him. To sum, Craig is curios, smart, able to integrate new ideas to propose directions as well as to discard ideas and not fall in love with the first idea, correspondingly he has diverse understanding in humanities and technological research and can integrate them in ways few can. Personal: If I had any doubts joining an ambitious project, remotely with someone I haven’t worked with before, meeting Craig for a second dissipated it immediately, when we met at a conference and started talking. He is cheerful, great conversationalist, and his interest in broad fields include also being knowledgeable and being interested in people which both make meetings with him a point in my week I am waiting for. I have more than 20 meetings a week, the meeting with him is one of the best, it is friendly, engaging and keeps me on my toes. Craig showed multiple traits I wish all mentors and professors had. In the projects we collaborated on Craig led the work, but also mentored the students. He was empathic, understanding and helping when one student had personal issues and a few months later when another had a death of a close relative. He was also appreciative of the teams success and practical and supportive on failures. He was delegating tasks and also taking upon himself, his decisions were easily accepted, as he was reasonable, down to earth and open for criticism, but still decisive. How he distinguished himself: pretraining, AI model creation, is a hard field that sees little innovation and most of it is from industrial labs. Craig is pioneering a distinctive direction, developing models tailored for the humanities. This rare space could fundamentally reshape how we pursue questions in the humanities, but only if approached with rigor, adopted widely, and grounded in genuine service to scholars. Doing so requires deep fluency in both AI and humanistic inquiry, a rare combination that he possesses. Craig follows a unique vision and has all the skills to get there. He is a real researcher in two fields and is one of the only ones in both. In summary: Craig is able to pick, lead and conduct research in AI per se as well as in the combination of AI and the humanities. He has proven to be a good mentor and a colleague you would enjoy having around. I recommend him without reservation for a faculty position and am confident he will become a field-defining scholar bridging AI and the humanities.
- Assistant
Below is an organized assessment and improvement plan for the recommendation letter. I focus on clarity, tone, impact, and academic norms—without changing your core message.
✅ What’s already strong
Authenticity and enthusiasm — the passion comes through.
Clear examples — e.g., diachronic LLM work, checkpointing over time.
Unique selling point — bridging AI + humanities + true pretraining research.
Strong personal endorsement — mentorship, collaboration, personal qualities.
These are major strengths. The content is powerful—it's mostly a matter of polishing structure and tone for academic standards.
🔧 Key areas to strengthen
- Tone & Professional Voice Some phrases sound conversational or informal for a faculty recommendation:
“Craig is nothing if not a symbol for a scholar” “meeting with him is one of the best” “he is cheerful” “a point in my week I am waiting for”
Pro Tip: Replace emotional phrasing with professional, confident wording.
- Clarity & Precision Some sentences are long or convoluted. Example:
“Among other things, I was delighted to join as I thought and still think his research pinpoints one of the best topics for AI and NLP in Academia.”
Aim for shorter, clearer sentences.
- Avoid Over-Comparative Claims Statements like:
“Less than a handful (%1) share this breadth…” “one of the only ones in both…”
These can seem exaggerated without numbers. Instead, use academic phrasing like:
“exceptional and rare among students and collaborators I have worked with”
- Structure & Flow The letter jumps between sections. Recommended structure:
Opening & Relationship
Research contributions & originality
Intellectual qualities
Teaching & mentorship skills
Personal/collegial qualities
Conclusion + unreserved endorsement
- Mechanistic Interpretability Example Strong anecdote—refine it to emphasize:
rapid mastery of new domain
research maturity
capacity for interdisciplinary synthesis
- Grammar & Polishing Minor grammar issues—verb agreement, punctuation, spacing. Example:
“where a large portion… which hold great monetary value,” → “where a large portion of the field aims to improve efficiency and performance — areas with clear monetary value — …”
✨ Rewritten sample paragraph (for demonstration) Original: Craig is nothing if not a symbol for a scholar. In my work with hundreds of students and researchers over the years, less than a handful (%1) of people share this breadth of knowledge… Improved tone & structure: Craig exemplifies the qualities of a true scholar. Among the hundreds of students and researchers I have worked with, only a very small number combine such breadth of knowledge, depth of understanding, and genuine intellectual curiosity. His expertise in both AI and the humanities enables research directions that very few scholars are prepared to pursue, and his ability to rapidly integrate new methodologies — demonstrated in our recent work where he independently mastered foundational ideas in mechanistic interpretability in a matter of weeks — highlights both exceptional capability and motivation.
🎯 Overall rewrite goals AreaActionToneFormal, confident, academic voiceStructureMore linear progressionClaimsPrecise, credible superlativesLengthSlightly tightened (5–10% shorter)ImpactHighlight mentorship + interdisciplinarity + pretraining rarity
🧠 Final advice You already have great substance. This letter will be very strong once:
The tone is slightly formalized
Claims are framed academically
Structure guides the reader smoothly
Sentences and grammar are polished
If you'd like, I can also: ✅ Provide a polished full rewrite ✅ Create two versions (1 page & full-length) ✅ Align with US/UK academic letter tone ✅ Ensure persuasive but measured language
Would you like me to produce a fully polished version using your content while keeping your voice and examples?
- User
compare for each paragraph now what it has and how it should be editted (e.g. split or moved) to fit a better structure and flow
- Assistant
Below is a paragraph-by-paragraph structural analysis with concrete editorial instructions on what each section currently does and how it should be reorganized or edited to improve clarity, academic tone, and flow. I do not rewrite paragraphs here — only diagnose and prescribe restructuring and edits.
✅ Paragraph-by-paragraph guidance Paragraph 1 — Opening and relationship
I’m writing to give Craig Messner… thought and still think his research pinpoints…
What it has
Purpose of the letter
Duration of collaboration
General praise + motivation for collaboration
Early argument about academic value of his topic
Issues
Too long and mixes relationship context with evaluation/philosophy
Informal tone (“I was delighted,” “one of the best topics”)
Thesis about academia vs corporate research belongs later in research section
Edits
Keep: first 2–3 sentences establishing relationship + duration + role
Move: critique of the field (Acad. vs corp goals) to research motivation paragraph
Shorten: overly long sentences
Clarify roles: emphasize mentor ≠ peer if true; state your title/standing
Goal Opening should cleanly present who you are, how you know him, and why you are qualified to evaluate him.
Paragraph 2 — Research vision & importance
Research: Some say AI won the Nobel prizes… unique to the humanities’s needs.
What it has
High-level field framing
Claim that his research is rare and bold
Argument about pretraining difficulty
Academic motivation — bridging humanities + AI
Praise for originality and rigor
Issues
Starts sloppy (“Some say AI won the Nobel prizes…” feels rhetorical)
Overly broad context before talking about candidate
Several ideas packed together (vision, rarity, difficulty, execution)
Edits
Remove rhetorical opener or turn into academic context later
Split paragraphs:
Field need + Craig’s vision
Technical difficulty + rarity of pretraining work
Innovation in tailoring models for humanities
Reduce sweeping generalizations (“AI is X,” “humanities see almost no…”)
Use more specific, formal framing (“the majority of published work focuses on efficiency and scaling…”)
Goal Create clean flow: field context → his unique contribution → why it's rare
Paragraph 3 — Specific research example
For example, in our recent ACL submission…
What it has
Clear concrete example
Demonstrates creativity + data difficulty handling
Shows novelty in training approach (time-ordered checkpoints)
Issues
Good content but should follow a short intro sentence signaling “concrete evidence”
Could be labeled as selected contribution
Edits
Keep content but add 1-sentence lead in: “A concrete example illustrating these qualities…”
Consider moving to later after general evaluation paragraphs
Keep technical details but tighten wording
Goal Anchor abstract praise in a specific demonstrable achievement.
Paragraph 4 — Research process & intellectual maturity
Thanks to the topic choice’s uniqueness…
What it has
Evaluation of research maturity
Ability to generate and prioritize ideas
Project management and discernment
Praise for innovative mindset
Issues
Repetition of ideas from paragraph 2 (uniqueness, new ideas)
Needs tightening and sharper academic language
“Wonderful assets to a professor” → formalize
Edits
Move this after the example paragraph to continue logic: “Here is an example → here is how he works”
Cut repetition
Emphasize:
Idea generation
Prioritization
Experimental judgment
Leadership and intellectual independence
Goal Show research leadership and maturity, not just creativity.
Paragraph 5 — Unique scholarly breadth
Craig is nothing if not a symbol for a scholar…
What it has
Strong claim about intellectual breadth
Humanities + AI dual expertise
Mechanistic interpretability anecdote
Issues
Tone too emotional/sweeping (“nothing if not,” “symbol for a scholar”)
Should be divided into (1) breadth and depth and (2) ability to learn fast
% claim unnecessary and informal
Edits
Split into two paragraphs:
Breadth across humanities + AI
Rapid mastery of mechanistic interpretability example
Soften superlatives while staying strong
Remove percentages / emotional tone
Goal Convey rare interdisciplinary strength + learning agility.
Paragraph 6 — Personal qualities
Personal: If I had any doubts…
What it has
Personal impression and collegial qualities
Conversation ability, enjoyment working with him
Issues
Informal tone, too personal (“point in my week I am waiting for”)
Excessive focus on social qualities
Edits
Reframe as collegiality, communication, collaboration
One short paragraph only
Remove anecdotes unless professional
Goal Demonstrate he would be a positive colleague & communicator.
Paragraph 7 — Mentoring & leadership
Craig showed multiple traits I wish all mentors…
What it has
Mentorship & empathy examples
Leadership & student support
Emotional intelligence
Issues
Good but some repetition with earlier leadership comments
Personal hardship examples need more professional framing
Edits
Condense & formalize
Emphasize practical contributions:
Student advising
Team management
Supportive academic leadership
Goal Evidence of readiness for faculty mentoring responsibilities.
Paragraph 8 — Distinguishing qualities
How he distinguished himself…
What it has
Summary of uniqueness
Restates field rarity and his niche
Issues
Redundant to earlier paragraphs
Good content but needs sharpening and condensing
Edits
Move key sentence to intro or conclusion
Leave only one strong thesis sentence here or merge into conclusion
Avoid repetition of “rare space” phrasing
Goal Crisp, non-repetitive positioning statement.
Paragraph 9 — Conclusion
In summary: Craig is able to pick…
What it has
Strong summary
Unreserved endorsement
Issues
Could be more concise and formal
Add confidence statement (fit, trajectory)
Edits
Keep strong endorsement “without reservation”
Consider adding:
“I would hire him in my own department without hesitation”
“He has my strongest recommendation”
Goal End with clarity, confidence, and professionalism.
📐 Resulting recommended structure SectionSources in originalActionIntroduction / RelationshipParagraph 1Trim + formalizeResearch VisionPara 1 + 2Split vision vs personal reasonTechnical Contribution & RarityPara 2New focused paragraphExample EvidencePara 3Keep, slightly polishResearch Process & MaturityPara 4Keep, move after exampleScholarly BreadthPara 5Split into twoInterdisciplinary AgilityPara 5Split; polishCollegialityPara 6Shorten, formalizeMentorship & LeadershipPara 7TightenDifferentiation StatementPara 8Merge major point into intro or conclusionConclusionPara 9Polish, formalize endorsement
🎯 Outcome Following these edits will produce a letter that is:
professional in tone
logically structured
high-credibility and academically persuasive
evidence-anchored rather than enthusiastic-sounding
concise and confident
Would you like me now to: ✅ produce a fully polished rewritten version or ✅ produce a lightly edited version that preserves your voice verbatim, but with structure & tone fixes? Tell me which style you prefer:
Formal faculty-search tone (Ivy/EPFL/Max Planck style)
Warm but professional liberal-arts tone
Industry + academia hybrid tone (for cross-disciplinary departments)
Just say the number.
- User
Explain the claim on paragraph 5 "% claim unnecessary and informal" Rephrase paragraph 6 Rephrase paragraph 7 Rephrase the conclusion (9)
- Assistant
Below are the requested clarifications and refined rewrites. I preserve your intent, voice, and praise — while giving them a more polished academic tone.
✅ Explanation: Why the “% claim” is unnecessary/informal Original idea:
“less than a handful (%1)”
Why it weakens the letter
Quantifying subjective judgment looks imprecise and unacademic
“%1” looks casual and not empirically grounded
Committees expect calibrated qualitative comparisons, not informal statistics
It can accidentally sound exaggerated or boastful, reducing credibility
Better alternative patterns
“exceptionally rare among the many scholars I have worked with”
“among the most gifted I have encountered in my career”
“one of the few researchers with such interdisciplinary depth”
These keep the strength of the praise without sounding casual or unverifiable.
✍️ Rephrased Paragraph 6 (Personal / Collegial qualities) Goal: Maintain warmth, but make it professional, faculty-appropriate, and concise. Rewrite:
On a personal level, Craig is a pleasure to work with. From our very first meeting, it was clear that he brings intellectual generosity, curiosity, and genuine enthusiasm for scholarly exchange. He is thoughtful, respectful, and an engaging communicator, creating an environment that is both stimulating and enjoyable. Even in a busy schedule of many weekly meetings, I consistently look forward to our discussions — they are productive, insightful, and energizing. Craig will be a collegial and constructive presence in any academic department.
✍️ Rephrased Paragraph 7 (Mentorship & leadership) Goal: Preserve examples of care for students, but frame them as evidence of faculty readiness. Rewrite:
Craig has consistently demonstrated the qualities of an excellent mentor and research leader. In our joint projects, he guided student collaborators with empathy, clarity, and intellectual rigor. He supported team members through both academic challenges and personal difficulties with professionalism and compassion, while maintaining momentum and high standards for the work. He delegates effectively, makes sound and thoughtful decisions, and welcomes critical discussion. His combination of empathy, practical leadership, and academic seriousness is exactly what we seek in successful faculty mentors.
✍️ Rephrased Conclusion (Paragraph 9) Goal: Strong, confident faculty-search closing language. Rewrite:
In summary, Craig has demonstrated exceptional ability to identify important research questions, lead and execute ambitious projects, and contribute meaningfully to both AI and the humanities. His rare interdisciplinary expertise, research creativity, and leadership skills make him extraordinarily well-suited for a faculty role. I recommend him without reservation and with great enthusiasm, and I am confident he will become a field-defining scholar and a valued colleague. Any department would be fortunate to have him.
📎 Optional additions you may want to include You might consider adding one of these “super-strong” closing lines depending on norms at your institution: Option A — Hiring level endorsement
If I had the opportunity, I would recruit him to my own department without hesitation.
Option B — Tenure trajectory signal
I believe he is on a clear trajectory to become a leading scholar in his field and a tenurable faculty member at a top institution.
Option C — Explicit strongest rating
This is among the strongest recommendations I have written in my career.
Would you like me next to:
Insert these rewrites into your full original text, preserving all your content but restructuring it?
Produce a fully polished final letter?
Produce two versions:
academic formal (R1/R2 university style)
cross-disciplinary humanities-friendly tone
Just tell me 1, 2, or 3.
- User
If I want to add hiring level endorsment but my university doesn't have the kind of positions he is applying to (STEM only and he aims at interdiciplenary positions). What wording would you suggest?
- Assistant
Got it! Since your university doesn’t have positions that match his interdisciplinary focus, you want to signal maximum confidence without implying direct hire authority. The goal is to convey: “If the right position existed, I would hire him without hesitation” — a strong endorsement appropriate for interdisciplinary hires. Here are several phrasing options you can use:
Option 1 — Conditional / hypothetical
If a faculty position aligned with Craig’s interdisciplinary expertise were available at my institution, I would recruit him without hesitation.
Pros: Strong, clear, accurate; emphasizes you would hire if possible.
Option 2 — Broad institutional praise
Any department with the right interdisciplinary focus would be fortunate to have Craig on its faculty.
Pros: Flexible, doesn’t tie to your university’s structure; emphasizes fit and value.
Option 3 — Focus on external impact
I can say with complete confidence that Craig would be a transformative addition to any faculty seeking a scholar bridging AI and the humanities.
Pros: Emphasizes impact, avoids direct hiring claims, very strong endorsement.
Option 4 — Combination (conditional + impact)
Were an interdisciplinary faculty position available in my department, I would hire him immediately; in any department aligned with his work, he will be an exceptional scholar and colleague.
Pros: Explicitly states hypothetical hire and external applicability; very persuasive.
💡 Recommendation: Option 4 reads strongest for faculty committees. It shows maximum confidence, keeps it honest, and highlights interdisciplinary value — without implying your own university currently has the right slot.
If you want, I can insert Option 4 directly into your polished conclusion so the closing reads fully formal and compelling for interdisciplinary hiring committees. Do you want me to do that?
- User
Where do those sentences come in comparison to the current ending? Should they replace it? Is the current one weak? weaker?
I recommend him without reservation for a faculty position and am confident he will become a field-defining scholar bridging AI and the humanities.
- Assistant
Here’s a careful comparison and assessment of your current ending versus the enhanced “hiring-level endorsement” options:
Current ending
I recommend him without reservation for a faculty position and am confident he will become a field-defining scholar bridging AI and the humanities.
Strengths
Clear, formal endorsement
Confident in his future impact
Concise
Weaknesses / Limitations
General; does not explicitly convey how strongly you would hire him
Lacks a signal of concrete faculty-level judgment (committees sometimes value statements about hiring readiness)
Less persuasive about interdisciplinary fit — especially for committees unfamiliar with bridging AI + humanities
Enhanced hiring-level options (like Option 4)
Were an interdisciplinary faculty position available in my department, I would hire him immediately; in any department aligned with his work, he will be an exceptional scholar and colleague.
Strengths
Stronger, more vivid endorsement
Signals hiring-level confidence even if your university cannot directly hire him
Highlights interdisciplinary fit and potential impact
Adds nuance: hypothetical but credible judgment
Potential caveats
Slightly longer; more complex sentence
Must be placed carefully to avoid redundancy with the prior “field-defining scholar” claim
How to integrate
Replace the current ending: The enhanced sentence carries all the confidence of your current one, plus the hiring-level endorsement.
Optional tweak: You could combine them for maximum impact:
Were an interdisciplinary faculty position available in my department, I would hire him immediately. I recommend him without reservation for a faculty position and am confident he will become a field-defining scholar bridging AI and the humanities.
This preserves your original “field-defining scholar” phrasing while adding the stronger hiring-level signal.
Verdict
Yes, the current ending is strong but slightly generic.
Enhanced phrasing is stronger, especially for interdisciplinary or unfamiliar departments.
Best placement: as the final sentences of the letter, replacing or augmenting the original closing.
If you want, I can rewrite the full conclusion paragraph with this integrated enhanced endorsement, keeping it formal and impactful. Do you want me to do that?