Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
GeminiGemini (model unspecified)· GoogleHugging Face ShareLM (browser-extension contributions)

could you rework the following text to match as subsection 2.2 behavioral assessment and…

  1. User

    could you rework the following text to match as subsection 2.2 behavioral assessment and 2.3 internal assessment, but remove everything about toxicity and make it match this work \section{Aligned Probing}\label{sec:aligned_probing} We introduce \textit{aligned probing}, an interpretability framework that explicitly \textit{aligns} model behavior and internals to examine their interplay in the context of toxic language. We first evaluate the behavior of LMs (\autoref{subsec:behavioral_scope}), based on the toxicity scores (\boldmath{tI\color{blue}t_I} and \boldmath{tO\color{yellow}t_O}) of the input (\boldmath{I\color{blue}I}) and the corresponding output (\boldmath{O\color{yellow}O}).   Next, we analyze how strongly LMs encode information about these toxicity scores within their internal representations of the input (\boldmath{hI\color{blue}h_I}) and output (\boldmath{hO\color{yellow}h_O}), extracted during generation (\autoref{subsec:internal_scope}).   Finally, we correlate the resulting information strength (\boldmath{ss}) with model behavior to investigate their interplay (\autoref{subsec:interplay}).   While this study focuses on toxic text, \textit{language that likely makes people leave a discussion}, the method we present (\textit{aligned probing}) generalizes to any textual property describing the input and/or output. \subsection{Evaluating Model Behavior}\label{subsec:behavioral_scope} In toxicity research, language model behavior is analyzed via the toxicity of generations. Given the serious implications of toxic language in generations, the standard evaluation protocol considers multiple outputs (\boldmath{Oj∈O\color{yellow}O_j \in O}) for a single input (\boldmath{I\color{blue}I}) to capture the model’s worst-case behavior \citep{gehman-etal-2020-realtoxicityprompts, DBLP:journals/corr/abs-2405-09373,gallegos-etal-2024-bias}.   Following this approach, we generate 25 samples per input using a temperature of 1.01.0 and nucleus sampling with p=0.9p=0.9 \citep{DBLP:conf/iclr/HoltzmanBDFC20}.   We then evaluate the toxicity of these generations using the \texttt{PERSPECTIVE API}\footnote{\href{https://perspectiveapi.com}{https://perspectiveapi.com}}, a widely-used industry standard for toxicity assessment \citep{wen-etal-2023-unveiling, DBLP:journals/tmlr/LiangBLTSYZNWKN23, groeneveld-etal-2024-olmo}. With these toxicity scores, we compute two metrics:% to answer different questions: \paragraph{Expected Maximum Toxicity (\color{yellow}EMT\color{black})} We compute the maximum toxicity across multiple generations for a given input (\boldmath{max⁡Oj∈OtOj\color{yellow}\max_{O_j\in O} t_{O_j}}). Since \boldmath{EMT\color{yellow}EMT} captures the model's worst-case behavior, it answers: \textit{How toxic is a language model?}    \paragraph{Toxicity Correlation (TC)} We compute the Pearson correlation between the toxicity scores of the input (\boldmath{tI\color{blue}t_I}) and the corresponding model toxicity (\boldmath{EMT\color{yellow}EMT}). This metric quantifies how input toxicity relates to generation toxicity, to answer the question: \textit{Do models replicate input toxicity?} \subsection{Evaluating Model Internals}\label{subsec:internal_scope} To evaluate how models encode information about toxicity, we extract the hidden states (\boldmath{h[l]\color{black}h^{[l]}}) averaged across all input (\boldmath{I\color{blue}I}) and output tokens (\boldmath{O\color{yellow}O}) at every model layer \boldmath{ll}.  We then adopt the \textit{probing classifier} methodology \citep{tenney-etal-2019-bert,DBLP:conf/iclr/TenneyXCWPMKDBD19,belinkov-2022-probing} to assess how these these internals (\boldmath{h[l]\color{black}h^{[l]}}) linearly map to the corresponding toxicity scores (\boldmath{tt}):   \begin{equation}     f:\color{black}h^{[l]} \longmapsto t \end{equation} Concretely, we first train\footnote{For details on training, see Appendix \autoref{app:experiments}.} a probe \boldmath{ff} (linear model) to predict \boldmath{t^\hat{t}} from \boldmath{h[l]\color{black}h^{[l]}}, where the prediction follows: \begin{equation}     \hat{t} = f(h^{[l]}) \end{equation} We then approximate the encoding strength (\boldmath{ss}) as the Pearson correlation between the predicted (\boldmath{t^\hat{t}}) and actual (\boldmath{tt}) toxicity scores.   Since the learning capacity of the probe \boldmath{ff} is limited, a high correlation suggests that substantial information about toxicity is encoded in \boldmath{h[l]h^{[l]}}, while a low correlation indicates weaker encoding.  Using this method, we formulate four scenarios (\autoref{fig:overview}) to analyze the encoding of input and output toxicity (\boldmath{tI\color{blue}t_I} and \boldmath{tO\color{yellow}t_O}) within the averaged input and output internals (\boldmath{hI[l]\color{blue}h_I^{[l]}} and \boldmath{hO[l]\color{yellow}h_O^{[l]}}): \paragraph{Scenario \texttt{Input}}\boldmath{f:hI[l]⟼tIf:\color{blue}h_I^{[l]} \color{black} \longmapsto \color{blue}{t_I}}   \newline We first assess how strongly an LM encodes the toxicity of the input within its internals.   Thus, we probe how strongly the input internals (\boldmath{hI[l]\color{blue}h_I^{[l]}}) encode information about the input toxicity score (\boldmath{tI\color{blue}t_I}), yielding the information strength \boldmath{sInps_{Inp}}. \paragraph{Scenario \texttt{Forward}}\boldmath{f:hO[l]⟼tIf:\color{yellow}h_O^{[l]} \color{black} \longmapsto \color{blue}{t_I}}   \newline Secondly, we examine how much information about the input's toxicity is \textit{forwarded} and retained during generation.   To quantify this, we measure the information strength \boldmath{sFors_{For}} by probing whether the input toxicity score (\boldmath{tI\color{blue}t_I}) is encoded within the internals of the output (\boldmath{hO[l]\color{yellow}h_O^{[l]}}). \paragraph{Scenario \texttt{Output}} \boldmath{f:hO[l]⟼tOf:\color{yellow}h_O^{[l]} \color{black} \longmapsto \color{yellow}{t_O}}   \newline The third scenario assesses how much information LMs encode about the toxicity of their generations.  Thus, we measure the information strength \boldmath{sOuts_{Out}} by probing whether the output toxicity score (\boldmath{tO\color{yellow}t_O}) is reflected in the output internals (\boldmath{hO[l]\color{yellow}h_O^{[l]}}). \paragraph{Scenario \texttt{Backward}} \boldmath{f:hI[l]⟼EMTf:\color{blue}h_I^{[l]} \color{black} \longmapsto \color{yellow}{EMT}}   \newline Finally, we analyze how much information about output toxicity an LM encodes within its internal representations of the input, i.e., we measure the information strength \boldmath{sBacks_{Back}} by probing whether the model’s internal representations of the input (\boldmath{hI[l]\color{blue}h_I^{[l]}}) strongly encode the aggregated \textit{expected maximum toxicity} score (\boldmath{EMT\color{yellow}\text{EMT}}) of generations. \subsection{The Interplay of Behavior and Internals}\label{subsec:interplay}   Since we analyze both model behavior and information strength within internal representations for the same toxicity attributes, we can address: \textit{How are the internals of models related to their behavior?}  To quantify this interplay, we examine the relationship between information strength in different probing scenarios (\boldmath{si∈{sInp,sFor,sOut,sBack}s_i \in \{s_{Inp}, s_{For}, s_{Out}, s_{Back}\}}) and the model's toxicity.   For instance, if we aim to investigate how strongly the encoding of input toxicity within input internals (Scenario \texttt{Input}) relates to model behavior, we compute the Pearson correlation between the information strength values across models (\boldmath{\vvsInp\vv{s_{Inp}}}) and their corresponding expected maximum toxicity scores (\boldmath{\vvEMT\vv{\color{yellow}EMT}}):   \begin{equation}     \vv{s_{Inp}} \times \vv{\color{yellow}EMT} \end{equation}

  2. Gemini Assistant

    Here is the reworked text, adapted to match the framework and terminology of the provided research paper on instruction processing.2.2 Behavioral AssessmentWe systematically investigate how text instructions impact model behavior by evaluating the generated output tokens across five binary judgment tasks. Following established protocols for assessing instruction-following, we measure performance based on the model's ability to produce the correct verbalized label (e.g., "yes" or "no") for a given task sample.To capture the sensitivity of language models to different task formulations, we evaluate behavior across three distinct prompting strategies:Instruction First (P∩​): The task-specific instruction precedes the task sample.Sample First (P∼​): The task sample is provided before the instruction.In-Context Learning (Pw/o​): No explicit instructions are provided; the model relies on a series of few-shot examples.The primary metric for behavioral assessment is Exact Match (EM) accuracy, which quantifies the model's success in aligning its output with the ground-truth task label.2.3 Internal AssessmentTo understand the internal mechanisms driving these behaviors, we evaluate how task-specific information is encoded within the model's representations (h) during two distinct stages: language processing and language production.We extract internal representations for the task sample (hS​) and the subsequent output tokens (hO​) at every model layer l. We then employ classifier-based probing to approximate the strength of task-specific information within these representations. A linear probe f is trained to map the hidden states to the task-specific property p:f:h(l)↦pWe approximate the information strength as the Probing Accuracy, representing the lower bound of task-specific information available to the model at that layer. Using this method, we analyze two primary scenarios:Language Processing (Encoding): We probe the internal representations of the sample tokens (hS​) to determine how instructions influence the initial encoding of the input.Language Production (Decoding): We probe the internal representations of the output tokens (hO​) to assess how encoded task-specific information is transformed into the final generated response.The Interplay of Behavior and InternalsBy aligning behavioral performance with internal information strength, we investigate the causal and correlative relationships between a model's latent representations and its observable actions. We quantify this interplay using Kendall and Pearson correlation analyses between probing accuracies (internal) and EM scores (behavioral) across different tasks and prompting strategies. This allows us to determine whether improvements in task performance are driven by better initial encoding of the input or by more effective transformation of information during the decoding stage.Would you like me to generate a table comparing the specific results of the three prompting strategies across the different model families?

  3. User

    generate latex code

  4. Gemini Assistant

    Here is the LaTeX code for the reworked sections, formatted to integrate with your existing document structure and using the information from the provided research paper.Code snippet\subsection{2.2 Behavioral Assessment}\label{subsec:behavioral_assessment} We systematically investigate how text instructions impact model behavior by evaluating the generated output tokens across five binary judgment tasks[cite: 114, 116]. Following established protocols for assessing instruction-following, we measure performance based on the model's ability to produce the correct verbalized label for a given task sample[cite: 175].

    To capture the sensitivity of language models to different task formulations, we evaluate behavior across three distinct prompting strategies[cite: 66]: \begin{itemize} \item \textbf{Instruction First (P∩\mathcal{P}_{\cap}):} The task-specific instruction precedes the task sample[cite: 66, 176]. \item \textbf{Sample First (P∼\mathcal{P}_{\sim}):} The task sample is provided before the instruction[cite: 66, 176]. \item \textbf{In-Context Learning (Pw/o\mathcal{P}_{w/o}):} No explicit instructions are provided; the model relies on a series of examples of samples and labels[cite: 66, 176]. \end{itemize} The primary metric for behavioral assessment is \textbf{Exact Match (EM)} accuracy, which quantifies the model's success in aligning its output with the ground-truth task label[cite: 137, 175].

    \subsection{2.3 Internal Assessment}\label{subsec:internal_assessment} To understand the internal mechanisms driving these behaviors, we evaluate how task-specific information is encoded within the model's representations (h⃗\vec{h}) during two distinct stages: language processing and language production[cite: 124, 172].

    We extract internal representations for the task sample tokens (hSh_S) and the subsequent output tokens (hOh_O) at every model layer ll[cite: 95, 114]. We then employ classifier-based probing to approximate the strength of task-specific information within these representations[cite: 100, 101]. A linear probe ff is trained to map the hidden states to the task-specific property pp[cite: 105, 109]:

    \begin{equation} f : \vec{h}^{(l)} \mapsto p \end{equation}

    We approximate the information strength as the \textbf{Probing Accuracy}, representing the lower bound of task-specific information available to the model at that layer[cite: 109, 145]. Using this method, we analyze two primary scenarios: \begin{itemize} \item \textbf{Language Processing (Encoding):} We probe the internal representations of the \textbf{sample tokens} (hSh_S) to determine how instructions influence the initial encoding of the input[cite: 114, 172]. \item \textbf{Language Production (Decoding):} We probe the internal representations of the \textbf{output tokens} (hOh_O) to assess how encoded task-specific information is transformed into the final generated response[cite: 114, 172]. \end{itemize}

    \paragraph{The Interplay of Behavior and Internals} By aligning behavioral performance with internal information strength, we investigate the causal and correlative relationships between a model's latent representations and its observable actions[cite: 11, 114]. We quantify this interplay using \textbf{Kendall and Pearson correlation} analyses between probing accuracies (internal) and EM scores (behavioral) across tasks and prompting strategies[cite: 181, 222]. This allows us to determine whether improvements in task performance are driven by better initial encoding of the input or by more effective transformation of information during the decoding stage[cite: 82, 124]. Would you like me to also generate the LaTeX code for the Summary of Impact paragraph found at the end of section 4?

  5. User

    a little bit loger

  6. Gemini Assistant

    Here is the extended LaTeX code for sections 2.2 and 2.3, expanded to include the task-specific details, model families, and the correlation metrics described in the research paper.Code snippet\subsection{2.2 Behavioral Assessment}\label{subsec:behavioral_assessment} We systematically investigate how text instructions impact model behavior by evaluating the generated output tokens across five distinct binary judgment tasks: linguistic acceptability (BLiMP), stereotypical mentions (StereoSet), reasoning coherence (oLMpics), world knowledge consistency (EWOK), and theory-of-mind (ToM)[cite: 116]. Following established protocols for assessing instruction-following, we measure performance based on the model's ability to produce the correct verbalized label (e.g., yes'' or no'') for a given task sample[cite: 117]. To ensure a robust evaluation, we assess behavior across three diverse model families: Llama-3.1 (8B), OLMo-2 (7B), and Qwen-2.5 (7B)[cite: 113].

    To capture the sensitivity of language models to different task formulations, we evaluate behavior across three distinct prompting strategies: \begin{itemize} \item \textbf{Instruction First (P∩\mathcal{P}_{\cap}):} The task-specific instruction precedes the task sample, which typically yields the highest performance[cite: 67, 176]. \item \textbf{Sample First (P∼\mathcal{P}_{\sim}):} The task sample is provided before the instruction to test the model's ability to retroactively apply task constraints[cite: 66, 176]. \item \textbf{In-Context Learning (Pw/o\mathcal{P}_{w/o}):} No explicit instructions are provided; the model must infer the task from a series of few-shot examples of samples and corresponding labels[cite: 66]. \end{itemize} The primary metric for behavioral assessment is \textbf{Exact Match (EM)} accuracy, which quantifies the model's success in aligning its generated output with the ground-truth task label[cite: 137].

    \subsection{2.3 Internal Assessment}\label{subsec:internal_assessment} To understand the internal mechanisms driving these behaviors, we evaluate how task-specific information is encoded within the model's representations (h⃗\vec{h}) during two distinct stages: language processing and language production[cite: 84, 124]. We extract internal representations for the task sample tokens (hSh_S) and the subsequent output tokens (hOh_O) at every model layer ll[cite: 114].

    We then employ classifier-based probing to approximate the strength of task-specific information within these representations[cite: 100]. A linear probe ff is trained to map the hidden states to the task-specific property pp[cite: 101, 105]:

    \begin{equation} f : \vec{h}^{(l)} \mapsto p \end{equation}

    By using a simple linear model, we ensure the probe acts as a sensor for the lower bound of encoded information rather than adding its own learning capacity[cite: 109]. We approximate the information strength as the \textbf{Probing Accuracy} and analyze two primary scenarios: \begin{itemize} \item \textbf{Language Processing (Encoding):} We probe the internal representations of the \textbf{sample tokens} (hSh_S) to determine if instructions influence the initial encoding of the input[cite: 114, 219]. \item \textbf{Language Production (Decoding):} We probe the internal representations of the \textbf{output tokens} (hOh_O) to assess how encoded information is transformed into the final generated response[cite: 114, 179]. \end{itemize}

    \paragraph{The Interplay of Behavior and Internals} We investigate the interplay between internals and behavior by correlating information strength with performance[cite: 114]. We utilize \textbf{Kendall correlation} (τ\tau) to compare rankings across tasks and \textbf{Pearson correlation} (rr) to measure direct linear relationships[cite: 181, 222]. This allows us to reveal the fundamental decoupling between stages, where behavioral performance strongly correlates with output token information (τ=0.61\tau=0.61) but shows negligible correlation with sample token information (τ=0.02\tau=0.02)[cite: 181, 222]. Would you like me to include the specific causal intervention details where attention flow is blocked to verify these internal mechanisms?

  7. User

    yes

  8. Gemini Assistant

    Here is the extended LaTeX code for sections 2.2 and 2.3. This version includes more technical detail regarding the judgment tasks, the model architectures, and the specific correlation findings as described in the research paper.Code snippet\subsection{2.2 Behavioral Assessment}\label{subsec:behavioral_assessment} We systematically investigate how text instructions impact model behavior by evaluating the generated output tokens across five distinct binary judgment tasks: linguistic acceptability (BLiMP), stereotypical mentions (StereoSet), reasoning coherence (oLMpics), world knowledge consistency (EWOK), and theory-of-mind (ToM)[cite: 116]. Following established protocols for assessing instruction-following, we measure performance based on the model's ability to produce the correct verbalized label (e.g., yes'' or no'') for a given task sample[cite: 133]. To ensure a robust evaluation, we assess behavior across three diverse model families: Llama-3.1 (8B), OLMo-2 (7B), and Qwen-2.5 (7B)[cite: 65, 113].

    To capture the sensitivity of language models to different task formulations, we evaluate behavior across three distinct prompting strategies: \begin{itemize} \item \textbf{Instruction First (P∩\mathcal{P}_{\cap}):} The task-specific instruction precedes the task sample, which consistently yields the highest performance across all model families[cite: 67, 176]. \item \textbf{Sample First (P∼\mathcal{P}_{\sim}):} The task sample is provided before the instruction to test the model's ability to retroactively apply task constraints[cite: 66, 176]. \item \textbf{In-Context Learning (Pw/o\mathcal{P}_{w/o}):} No explicit instructions are provided; the model must infer the task from a series of few-shot examples of samples and corresponding labels[cite: 66, 171]. \end{itemize} The primary metric for behavioral assessment is \textbf{Exact Match (EM)} accuracy, which quantifies the model's success in aligning its generated output with the ground-truth task label[cite: 137, 175]. Our results show that model behavior is highly sensitive to these instructions, with accuracy ranging from 0.63 to 0.66 depending on the strategy used[cite: 175].

    \subsection{2.3 Internal Assessment}\label{subsec:internal_assessment} To understand the internal mechanisms driving these behaviors, we evaluate how task-specific information is encoded within the model's representations (h⃗\vec{h}) during two distinct stages: language processing and language production[cite: 84, 114]. We extract internal representations for the task sample tokens (hSh_S) and the subsequent output tokens (hOh_O) at every model layer ll[cite: 114].

    We then employ classifier-based probing to approximate the strength of task-specific information within these representations[cite: 100, 104]. A linear probe ff is trained to map the hidden states to the task-specific property pp[cite: 101, 105]:

    \begin{equation} f : \vec{h}^{(l)} \mapsto p \end{equation}

    By using a simple linear model, we ensure the probe acts as a sensor for the lower bound of encoded information rather than adding its own learning capacity[cite: 109]. We approximate the information strength as the \textbf{Probing Accuracy} and analyze two primary scenarios: \begin{itemize} \item \textbf{Language Processing (Encoding):} We probe the internal representations of the \textbf{sample tokens} (hSh_S) to determine if instructions influence the initial encoding of the input. We find that information within these tokens remains stable and correlates only weakly with subsequent behavior[cite: 13, 219, 220]. \item \textbf{Language Production (Decoding):} We probe the internal representations of the \textbf{output tokens} (hOh_O) to assess how encoded information is transformed into the final generated response. Information in these tokens varies significantly across prompting strategies, mirroring the observed behavioral changes[cite: 70, 179, 180]. \end{itemize}

    \paragraph{The Interplay of Behavior and Internals} We investigate the interplay between internals and behavior by correlating information strength with performance. We utilize \textbf{Kendall correlation} (τ\tau) to compare rankings across individual tasks and \textbf{Pearson correlation} (rr) to measure direct linear relationships[cite: 181, 222]. This allows us to reveal a fundamental decoupling: behavioral performance strongly correlates with output token information (τ=0.61\tau=0.61) but shows negligible or even negative correlation with sample token information (r=−0.15r=-0.15)[cite: 181, 222]. These findings suggest that instructions primarily steer the language production phase rather than altering the fundamental task representation formed during processing[cite: 223, 224]. Would you like me to add the LaTeX code for Section 4.3 Causal Analysis, which details the attention-blocking interventions used to prove these findings?

  9. User

    yes

  10. Gemini Assistant

    Here is the comprehensive LaTeX code for the Causal Analysis subsection. This section details the attention-based interventions used to prove that instructions primarily modulate the language production stage.Code snippet\subsection{4.3 Causal Analysis via Interventions}\label{subsec:causal_analysis} [cite_start]To move beyond correlative evidence and establish a causal link between instructions and model behavior, we employ attention-based interventions[cite: 73, 244]. [cite_start]By selectively blocking the attention flow within the transformer architecture, we can isolate the impact of instruction tokens on subsequent representations[cite: 245].

    [cite_start]We implement two distinct intervention strategies (see \autoref{fig:4}) to assess the dependencies of the processing and production stages[cite: 246]:

    \begin{itemize} [cite_start]\item \textbf{Full Intervention:} We block the attention flow between the instruction tokens and all subsequent tokens, including both the task sample and the generated output[cite: 246, 271]. [cite_start]This intervention drastically reduces behavioral performance (−0.58-0.58 accuracy), as the model loses the necessary context to produce a task-coherent response[cite: 326]. [cite_start]\item \textbf{Prompt-Only Intervention:} We block the attention flow specifically between the instruction tokens and the task sample tokens, while maintaining the connection between instructions and output tokens[cite: 246, 327]. [cite_start]This allows us to test if the instruction must be integrated during the encoding of the input to be effective[cite: 246]. \end{itemize}

    \paragraph{Findings from Causal Interventions} [cite_start]The results of these interventions provide robust evidence for the decoupling of language processing and production[cite: 224, 329]: \begin{itemize} [cite_start]\item \textbf{Instruction-Independent Processing:} Under the prompt-only intervention, we observe only a marginal impact on the behavior (−0.04-0.04) and a negligible decrease in task-specific information within the sample tokens (−0.003-0.003)[cite: 327, 328]. [cite_start]This confirms that the internal representation formed during the encoding stage is largely independent of the provided instruction[cite: 271, 329]. [cite_start]\item \textbf{Instruction-Steered Production:} In contrast, both interventions show a significantly larger impact on the information strength within the output tokens compared to the sample tokens[cite: 331]. [cite_start]This provides causal proof that instructions primarily act as a steering mechanism during the language production phase, rather than altering the fundamental task representation during the initial encoding[cite: 75, 332]. \end{itemize}

    [cite_start]This mechanism is consistent across different model families and sizes, suggesting a fundamental internal property of how current decoder-only language models process instructions[cite: 17, 337]. Would you like me to generate the LaTeX code for Section 4.4, which summarizes the stability and variance of these findings across different tasks?