Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
ChatGPT (model unspecified)· OpenAIHugging Face ShareLM (browser-extension contributions)

Does this make sense? maxjudgescore = merged["judgescore"].max() maxgcascore =…

  1. User

    Does this make sense?

        max_judge_score = merged["judge_score"].max()
        max_gca_score = merged["gca_score"].max()
        min_judge_score = merged["judge_score"].min()
        min_gca_score = merged["gca_score"].min()
        merged["judge_norm"] = merged["judge_score"].apply(lambda x: x / max_judge_score)
        merged["gca_norm"] = merged["gca_score"].apply(lambda x: x / max_gca_score)
    
  2. Assistant

    I see what you’re doing — normalizing each score column to a 0,10,10,1 range. A few points:

    Yes, it makes sense: dividing each score by the column max scales them to 0,10,10,1, with the maximum mapped to 1.

    But you’re ignoring the minimum. If your data contains negative values or if you want the true min-max normalization, you’d usually do:

    pythonCopy codemerged["judge_norm"] = (merged["judge_score"] - min_judge_score) / (max_judge_score - min_judge_score) merged["gca_norm"] = (merged["gca_score"] - min_gca_score) / (max_gca_score - min_gca_score)

    That way, the minimum maps to 0 and the maximum to 1.

    If your scores are guaranteed non-negative (e.g. 0–100), then dividing by the max alone is fine — it just won’t “anchor” the min at 0 if it’s not already.

    👉 Do you want simple max-scaling (relative to the top score) or full min-max normalization?

  3. User

    here too

        max_judge_score = merged["judge_score"].max()
        max_gca_score = merged["gca_score"].max()
        min_judge_score = merged["judge_score"].min()
        min_gca_score = merged["gca_score"].min()
        merged["judge_norm"] = merged["judge_score"].apply(lambda x: x/max_judge_score)
        merged["gca_norm"] = merged["gca_score"].apply(lambda x: x/max_gca_score)
    
  4. Assistant

    Yes — same situation here. What your code does:

    Takes the max for each column.

    Normalizes each value by dividing by that max.

    Result: the maximum score becomes 1.0, everything else is in 0,10,10,1 only if all scores are ≥ 0.

    What’s unused: you also compute min_judge_score and min_gca_score, but never use them. If you meant to do full min–max normalization, you’d want: pythonCopy codemerged["judge_norm"] = merged["judge_score"].apply( lambda x: (x - min_judge_score) / (max_judge_score - min_judge_score) ) merged["gca_norm"] = merged["gca_score"].apply( lambda x: (x - min_gca_score) / (max_gca_score - min_gca_score) )

    So:

    ✅ If you want relative-to-max scaling: your code is fine (but you don’t need the min_* lines).

    ✅ If you want true min–max normalization: update to the formula above.

    Do you want the two methods compared on a small example so you can see the difference in outputs?