Whats better for an intro to a EMNLP paper?""" 1. Characters in narratives are shaped by…
- User
Whats better for an intro to a EMNLP paper?"""
- Characters in narratives are shaped by the continuous interplay of internal and external events they experience, each influencing their thoughts, feelings, and behaviors. As narratives progress, these events unfold along various dimensions. Some are common to essentially all narratives, such as changes in location, while others are specific to particular genres \cite{eder2010understanding}. Personal narratives, told in the first person, offer insights into the inner-life development of the protagonist \cite{lifestories}. Within the domain of Holocaust testimonies, as people experience unimaginable atrocities, the change in religious dispositions plays a central role \cite{Brenner1980TheFA}. \citet{schweid1988faith} discusses the post-Holocaust crisis of theodicy in Jewish and Christian religious thought, necessitating substantial changes in religious content and norms. \textcolor{violet}{Specifically, the question of how religious faith evolves under extreme circumstances remains actively debated in Holocaust studies, with scholars like \citet{berkovits1973faith} stressing that the majority of survivors maintained their faith, and \citet{Leo2021} discussing the role of faith as a stabilizing force, arguing that most individuals do not change their religious beliefs following traumatic experiences. In contrast, \citet{benezra} describe common processes of change in both directions. This ongoing argument makes Holocaust testimonies a suitable test case for religious evolution analysis, offering further insight by analyzing a large corpus of testimonies through a holistic computational approach that could extend to other dimensions of character development.} Applying NLP for analyzing these testimonies has been advocated \citep{artstein-etal-2016-new, wagner-etal-2022-topical}, offering the potential to extract valuable insights from the vast number of testimonies, instead of relying on small-scale, manual studies \cite{ToddPresner}. Following this approach, we utilize NLP technology to examine religious trajectories across an entire corpus of testimonies, instead of focusing on individual cases. Leveraging off-the-shelf LLMs for inferring the character arc of the protagonist, we explore the progression of their religious trajectory throughout the narrative. We conduct a dual perspective analysis that captures the protagonist's descriptions of their beliefs and religious practices. % Religious Trajectories As people change and adapt, their disposition towards religion and level of observance constantly evolve. This is particularly relevant when addressing Holocaust testimonies, which follow survivors’ experiences in extreme conditions. We expect to reveal different patterns of change in religiosity throughout the testimonies, each telling the story of an individual and covering a wide range of periods and locations. We define a {\it religious trajectory} as a series of mentions of religiosity throughout a given storyline of an individual's life course. Separate trajectories are held for religious practices and beliefs, assuming they each describe religiosity from a unique perspective. This distinction is discussed in the sociology of religion and is reflected by incongruities among religious observers. \citet{Chaves2010SSSRPA} illustrates this: \textit{
Ideas and practices exist as bits and pieces that come and go as situations change, producing many inconsistencies... Religious ideas, values, and practices generally are not congruent.''} \begin{figure}[t!] \centering \includegraphics[width=0.9\linewidth]{latex/second_version_pipeline_religion.drawio.pdf} \caption{Our pipeline for identifying the religious trajectories from a set of Holocaust survivor testimonies: (1) \textbf{Segmentation:} segment the testimonies by question-answer pairs; (2) \textbf{Filtration:} train and run a classifier to filter all segments containing religious content; (3) \textbf{Determining Valence:} use LLMs to identify the protagonist's valence of religious practice and/or beliefs in a given segment; (4) \textbf{Schematization:} cluster the resulting trajectories to identify common patterns of evolution of religiosity in the testimony dataset.} \label{fig:pipeline-palceholder} \end{figure} For extracting the trajectories, we identify the segments within the text that constitute the trajectory, and assess the protagonist's religious valence and intensity in each segment. We then cluster the resulting trajectories, identifying common sequences (\autoref{fig:pipeline-palceholder}). Our research contributes to a deeper understanding of character evolution within narratives by highlighting the potential of machine learning techniques to study thematic trajectories. 2.Characters in narratives are shaped by the continuous interplay of internal and external events they experience, each influencing their thoughts, feelings, and behaviors. As narratives progress, these events unfold along various dimensions. Some are common to essentially all narratives, such as changes in location, while others are specific to particular genres \cite{eder2010understanding}. Personal narratives, told in the first person, offer insights into the inner-life development of the protagonist \cite{lifestories}. Within the domain of Holocaust testimonies, as people experience unimaginable atrocities, the change in religious dispositions plays a central role \cite{Brenner1980TheFA}. \citet{schweid1988faith} discusses the post-Holocaust crisis of theodicy in Jewish and Christian religious thought, necessitating substantial changes in religious content and norms. \textcolor{violet}{Specifically, the question of how religious faith evolves under extreme circumstances remains actively debated in Holocaust studies, with scholars like \citet{berkovits1973faith} stressing that the majority of survivors maintained their faith, and \citet{Leo2021} discussing the role of faith as a stabilizing force, arguing that most individuals do not change their religious beliefs following traumatic experiences. In contrast, \citet{benezra} describe common processes of change in both directions. This ongoing argument makes Holocaust testimonies a suitable test case for religious evolution analysis, offering further insight by analyzing a large corpus of testimonies through a holistic computational approach that could extend to other dimensions of character development.} Holocaust survivor testimonies are indispensable for both scholarship and collective memory. Applying NLP for analyzing these testimonies has been advocated \citep{artstein-etal-2016-new, wagner-etal-2022-topical}, offering the potential to extract valuable insights from the vast number of testimonies, instead of relying on small-scale, manual studies \cite{ToddPresner}. Following this approach, we utilize NLP technology to examine religious trajectories across an entire corpus of testimonies, instead of focusing on individual cases. Leveraging off-the-shelf LLMs for inferring the character arc of the protagonist, we explore the progression of their religious trajectory throughout the narrative. We conduct a dual perspective analysis that captures the protagonist's descriptions of their beliefs and religious practices. % Religious Trajectories As people change and adapt, their disposition towards religion and level of observance constantly evolve. This is particularly relevant when addressing Holocaust testimonies, which follow survivors’ experiences in extreme conditions. We expect to reveal different patterns of change in religiosity throughout the testimonies, each telling the story of an individual and covering a wide range of periods and locations. We define a {\it religious trajectory} as a series of mentions of religiosity throughout a given storyline of an individual's life course. Separate trajectories are held for religious practices and beliefs, assuming they each describe religiosity from a unique perspective. This distinction is discussed in the sociology of religion and is reflected by incongruities among religious observers. \citet{Chaves2010SSSRPA} illustrates this: \textit{Ideas and practices exist as bits and pieces that come and go as situations change, producing many inconsistencies... Religious ideas, values, and practices generally are not congruent.''} \begin{figure}[t!] \centering \includegraphics[width=0.9\linewidth]{latex/second_version_pipeline_religion.drawio.pdf} \caption{Our pipeline for identifying the religious trajectories from a set of Holocaust survivor testimonies: (1) \textbf{Segmentation:} segment the testimonies by question-answer pairs; (2) \textbf{Filtration:} train and run a classifier to filter all segments containing religious content; (3) \textbf{Determining Valence:} use LLMs to identify the protagonist's valence of religious practice and/or beliefs in a given segment; (4) \textbf{Schematization:} cluster the resulting trajectories to identify common patterns of evolution of religiosity in the testimony dataset.} \label{fig:pipeline-palceholder} \end{figure} For extracting the trajectories, we identify the segments within the text that constitute the trajectory, and assess the protagonist's religious valence and intensity in each segment. We then cluster the resulting trajectories, identifying common sequences (\autoref{fig:pipeline-palceholder}). Our research contributes to a deeper understanding of character evolution within narratives by highlighting the potential of machine learning techniques to study thematic trajectories. """
- Characters in narratives are shaped by the continuous interplay of internal and external events they experience, each influencing their thoughts, feelings, and behaviors. As narratives progress, these events unfold along various dimensions. Some are common to essentially all narratives, such as changes in location, while others are specific to particular genres \cite{eder2010understanding}. Personal narratives, told in the first person, offer insights into the inner-life development of the protagonist \cite{lifestories}. Within the domain of Holocaust testimonies, as people experience unimaginable atrocities, the change in religious dispositions plays a central role \cite{Brenner1980TheFA}. \citet{schweid1988faith} discusses the post-Holocaust crisis of theodicy in Jewish and Christian religious thought, necessitating substantial changes in religious content and norms. \textcolor{violet}{Specifically, the question of how religious faith evolves under extreme circumstances remains actively debated in Holocaust studies, with scholars like \citet{berkovits1973faith} stressing that the majority of survivors maintained their faith, and \citet{Leo2021} discussing the role of faith as a stabilizing force, arguing that most individuals do not change their religious beliefs following traumatic experiences. In contrast, \citet{benezra} describe common processes of change in both directions. This ongoing argument makes Holocaust testimonies a suitable test case for religious evolution analysis, offering further insight by analyzing a large corpus of testimonies through a holistic computational approach that could extend to other dimensions of character development.} Applying NLP for analyzing these testimonies has been advocated \citep{artstein-etal-2016-new, wagner-etal-2022-topical}, offering the potential to extract valuable insights from the vast number of testimonies, instead of relying on small-scale, manual studies \cite{ToddPresner}. Following this approach, we utilize NLP technology to examine religious trajectories across an entire corpus of testimonies, instead of focusing on individual cases. Leveraging off-the-shelf LLMs for inferring the character arc of the protagonist, we explore the progression of their religious trajectory throughout the narrative. We conduct a dual perspective analysis that captures the protagonist's descriptions of their beliefs and religious practices. % Religious Trajectories As people change and adapt, their disposition towards religion and level of observance constantly evolve. This is particularly relevant when addressing Holocaust testimonies, which follow survivors’ experiences in extreme conditions. We expect to reveal different patterns of change in religiosity throughout the testimonies, each telling the story of an individual and covering a wide range of periods and locations. We define a {\it religious trajectory} as a series of mentions of religiosity throughout a given storyline of an individual's life course. Separate trajectories are held for religious practices and beliefs, assuming they each describe religiosity from a unique perspective. This distinction is discussed in the sociology of religion and is reflected by incongruities among religious observers. \citet{Chaves2010SSSRPA} illustrates this: \textit{
Assistant
Looking at these two versions, Version 2 is better for an EMNLP paper introduction. Here's why: Key improvement in Version 2: The addition of "Holocaust survivor testimonies are indispensable for both scholarship and collective memory" provides crucial contextual grounding that strengthens the narrative flow and justification for the work. Why Version 2 works better:
Smoother transition: The added sentence creates a more natural bridge between the theoretical discussion of religious evolution debates and the practical application of NLP methods. It acknowledges the broader significance of these testimonies before diving into computational approaches. Stronger motivation: By explicitly stating the importance of Holocaust testimonies for scholarship and memory, it reinforces why computational analysis of this corpus is valuable and timely. Better positioning: The sentence helps position your work not just as a technical NLP contribution, but as research that serves the important scholarly and memorial functions these testimonies fulfill.
Minor suggestions for both versions:
The purple/violet highlighted text is quite long for a single emphasis block - consider breaking it up or shortening it The transition from the theoretical discussion to the methodology could be even smoother with a brief preview of your main findings or contributions
Overall, Version 2 demonstrates better awareness of the interdisciplinary nature of EMNLP work and shows sensitivity to the gravity of the subject matter, which will resonate well with the conference's diverse audience of computational linguists and domain experts.
- User
Whats better between the two:We received 1000 Holocaust survivor testimony transcripts archived by the Shoah Foundation\footnote{\url{https://sfi.usc.edu/}} (SF), originally recorded as interviews on video in English. The significance of this resource in the study and remembrance of the Holocaust cannot be overstated. \textcolor{violet}{As the number of surviving witnesses diminishes, there is an urgent need to find new approaches to engage with the extensive collection of testimonies, with computational methods offering novel approaches to trace patterns of belief, resilience, identity, and trauma \citep{wagner2025unsupervised, toth2022studying}.}We received 1000 Holocaust survivor testimony transcripts archived by the Shoah Foundation\footnote{\url{https://sfi.usc.edu/}} (SF), originally recorded as interviews on video in English. The significance of this resource in the study and remembrance of the Holocaust cannot be overstated. \textcolor{violet}{As the number of surviving witnesses diminishes, there is an urgent need to find new approaches to engage with the extensive collection of testimonies, with computational methods showing holistic approaches to trace patterns of belief, resilience, identity, and trauma \citep{wagner2025unsupervised, toth2022studying}.} We received 1000 Holocaust survivor testimony transcripts archived by the Shoah Foundation\footnote{\url{https://sfi.usc.edu/}} (SF), originally recorded as interviews on video in English. The significance of this resource in the study and remembrance of the Holocaust cannot be overstated. \textcolor{violet}{As the number of surviving witnesses diminishes, there is an urgent need to find new approaches to engage with the extensive collection of testimonies, with computational methods offering interdisciplinary pathways to trace patterns of belief, resilience, identity, and trauma \citep{wagner2025unsupervised, toth2022studying}.}
Assistant
Version 3 is the best choice. Here's the comparison: Version 1: "novel approaches"
Sounds like you're claiming computational methods are entirely new to this domain Could be problematic if there's existing computational work on Holocaust testimonies
Version 2: "holistic approaches"
"Holistic" is vague and doesn't clearly convey the advantage of computational methods Less precise about what computational methods actually offer
Version 3: "interdisciplinary pathways"
Most accurate and appropriate for an EMNLP audience Acknowledges that this work bridges computer science with Holocaust studies, sociology of religion, and digital humanities "Pathways" suggests opening up new research directions rather than claiming to be the first Reflects the collaborative nature of computational humanities work Shows awareness that meaningful analysis requires domain expertise beyond just technical methods
Why "interdisciplinary pathways" works best:
It's humble yet significant - you're not claiming to revolutionize the field, but to contribute new methodological bridges It aligns with EMNLP's values of applying NLP to important real-world problems It acknowledges the expertise needed from multiple fields to do this work responsibly It suggests sustainability and future research directions
Version 3 positions your work most appropriately within the broader scholarly ecosystem while still emphasizing the valuable contribution of computational approaches.
Other models, same or similar prompt
Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.