could you help me with the section order in the conclusion, do you think it make sense…
- User
could you help me with the section order in the conclusion, do you think it make sense like that? others suggested to put research questions upfront but somehow they also depend on the contributions \chapter{Conclusion} \label{chp:conclusion} This chapter concludes the thesis. We first summarize the presented research and derive general implications relevant for computational argumentation and beyond (\cref{sec:summary}). We then outline the contributions of this thesis and answer the initially raised research questions (\cref{sec:contributions}). Finally, we provide an outlook on possible future research (\cref{sec:outlook}). \section{Summary}\label{sec:summary} Assistive technologies powered by language models are increasingly effective in helping users navigate the growing amount of arguments available online. However, their usefulness is closely tied to the limitations of these models. Overestimating their human-likeness, generalizability, fairness, and safety may cause societal risks. A thorough understanding of these aspects—beyond task efficacy—is not only important for a general perception grounded in realistic and empirical assessments but also to form the basis for developing trusted and accepted technologies that support political participation in a digital age. To address this need, we introduce an \textit{integral view} on model reliability—a framework for comprehensively conducting model assessments and systematically structuring their findings. Unlike existing evaluation efforts that either focus solely on model behavior or predominantly on single tasks, this framework extends prior research along two dimensions: methods and scope. We present a methodological toolbox of existing and novel \textcolor{SpecEvalRed}{\textbf{specialization}}, \textcolor{SpecEvalRed}{\textbf{evaluation}}, and \textcolor{IntrRed}{\textbf{interpretability}} methods (\cref{chp:language_models}, \cref{chp:evaluation_interpretability}) that examine model behavior, internals, and their interplay. At the same time, we broaden the evaluation scope beyond task efficacy and disentangle model reliability into \textcolor{AttrGreen}{\textbf{language understanding}}, \textcolor{AttrBlue}{\textbf{generalizability}}, and \textcolor{AttrYellow}{\textbf{societal alignment}} (\cref{chp:reliability_attributes}). \paragraph{Implications} This integral view advances beyond prior evaluation work by systematically combining methodological perspectives with a structured evaluation scope. It promotes a structured and comprehensive approach to studying model reliability, making research design, execution, and communication more understandable, reproducible, and impactful. This is an essential aspect for computational argumentation, where aligning methods and terminology across disciplines is crucial to enable progress. For this purpose, we derive four general implications relevant for and beyond computational argumentation based on our empirical insights (\textbf{I1}–\textbf{I4}): \begin{itemize} \item[\textbf{I1}] \textbf{Joining interpretability perspectives is indispensable.} By evaluating only model behavior, we risk overestimating the reliability of language models, fostering an overly optimistic public perception that may create substantial societal risks. Thus, it is important to systematically integrate behavioral and internal perspectives, as we have done in all the presented studies, to provide empirical evidence for recalibrating perceptions. We further emphasize this integration through novel methods and community efforts, including a dedicated workshop connecting these perspectives. \item[\textbf{I2}] \textbf{Coherence does not imply language understanding.} Despite the coherence of generated outputs, language models lack human-like language comprehension, particularly for complex linguistic phenomena that span multiple tokens. At the same time, their reliance on superficial token-level semantics further questions their genuine understanding of language, suggesting that these models differ substantially in their language processing from humans \citep{hewitt2025position}. A clearer understanding of this divergence is essential to align perception with empirical and human-understandable evidence. \item[\textbf{I3}] \textbf{Evaluating generalization requires a fine-grained scope.} Evaluating the fine-grained generalization capabilities of language models is important to regularize their overly optimistic perceived reliability. While we introduce methods that improve generalizability, no single model specialization excels across the heterogeneous shifts relevant to computational argumentation. Instead, carefully characterizing the expected shift considering semantics, surface feature (such as number of tokens), or the distribution of task labels is important to select an appropriate method. Moreover, we emphasize generalizability from a user perspective and organize the first shared task on perspective argument retrieval. \item[\textbf{I4}] \textbf{Language models are susceptible to societal dynamics in language.} Although demonstrating coherent behavior in general scenarios, language models do not necessarily offer genuine comprehension of societal dynamics reflected in language. These models are susceptible to subtle gender-fair formulations that are irrelevant to the underlying task and fall short of internally encoding the nuanced types of toxic language, a property we show causally leads to less toxic models. Given that these models have become a societal artifact, we further emphasize this by organizing a community-driven summer school dedicated to junior researchers working on social aspects of NLP. \end{itemize} \section{Contributions}\label{sec:contributions} With the \textit{integral view}, we present a conceptual framework that has organically evolved from the research process in this thesis. Starting with limited generalizability in out-of-distribution scenarios, the focus shifted to investigating language understanding and societal alignment. Insights from this research highlight the entanglement of these model reliability attributes, necessitating comprehensive interpretability methods. Reflecting this process, the integral view provides a meta-level structure that relates findings and synthesizes conclusions and implications accessible across disciplines. Therefore, it focus on \textcolor{SpecEvalRed}{\textbf{specialization}}, \textcolor{SpecEvalRed}{\textbf{evaluation}}, and \textcolor{IntrRed}{\textbf{interpretability}} methods that systematically integrates behavioral and internal model perspectives and broadens the evaluation scope model reliability regarding \textcolor{AttrGreen}{\textbf{language understanding}}, \textcolor{AttrBlue}{\textbf{generalizability}}, and \textcolor{AttrYellow}{\textbf{societal alignment}}. Beyond this conceptual contribution of the thesis itself, the individual presented studies contribute novel resources (\emoji{green-book}), methods (\emoji{magic-wand}), and empirical insights (\emoji{light-bulb}) that extend prior work and provide new empirical evidence to regularize the general perception for calibrated reliability. We summarize these contributions by type and subsequently answer the overarching research questions. \paragraph{Methodological Contributions (\emoji{magic-wand})} We contribute new specialization, evaluation, and interpretability methods that improve model reliability and its analysis: \begin{itemize} \item We extend standard model evaluation protocols with a framework that comprehensively assesses model specialization by evaluating task efficacy, optimization reliability, and the influence of randomness. (\cref{chp:pub_argmin_task}) \item We present \texttt{INJECT}, the first method to robustly integrate potential incomplete and/or noisy external context into task-specific model specialization. (\cref{chp:pub_inject}) \item We introduce \textit{aligned probing}, an interpretability method that, for the first time, systematically connects model behavior and internals to better understand how inputs are transformed into subsequent outputs through model layers. (\cref{chp:pub_tacl_aligned_probing}) \end{itemize} \paragraph{Resource Contributions (\emoji{green-book})} We extend the narrow evaluation focus of prior work by creating datasets and benchmarks to assess model reliability systematically and comprehensively: \begin{itemize} \item We present \texttt{Holmes}, an extensive benchmark for studying the inherent linguistic competence of language models. Starting from a meta-study of existing literature, it addresses over 50 phenomena with more than 200 unique datasets. (\cref{chp:pub_tacl_holmes}) \item We propose a benchmark to assess the heterogeneous out-of-distribution scenarios of computational argumentation, covering text domains, topics, and languages, and introduce an empirical taxonomy to characterize the distribution shifts regarding semantics, surface, and label. (\cref{chp:pub_argmin_task}) \item We introduce \texttt{Lou}, a dataset that enables, for the first time, assessing the influence of gender-fair formulations on German classification tasks. It includes six gender-fair and gender-neutral strategies, such as using neutral formulations, and covers seven tasks, including stance detection. (\cref{chp:pub_emnlp_lou}) \end{itemize} \paragraph{Empirical Insights (\emoji{light-bulb})} With these methods and resources, we evaluate language models across the three reliability attributes and derive empirical insights that advance understanding of model reliability: \begin{itemize} \item Language models fail to inherently encode complex linguistic phenomena, such as negation and rhetorical structure, and the linguistic competence of models varies substantially across different model architectures. (\cref{chp:pub_tacl_holmes}) \item The efficacy gap between in- and out-of-distribution scenarios differs across models, while mixed pre-training objectives enable more generalizable representation spaces that rely less on token-level semantics. (\cref{chp:pub_eacl_chasm}) \item Carefully selecting model specialization methods for out-of-distribution scenarios is important, since they have varying strengths and thus excel for different types of distribution shifts. Moreover, model internals hint at better generalization abilities, as superior models internally preserve semantic information. (\cref{chp:pub_argmin_task}) \item Reported state-of-the-art stance detection models fail to excel on the full diversity of relevant datasets beyond the commonly evaluated ones. Instead, \texttt{INJECT}, which incorporates potential noisy or incomplete external knowledge, can improve task efficacy across this diverse range of tasks. (\cref{chp:pub_inject}) \item Models are susceptible to societal dynamics reflected in language, as gender-fair reformulations yield substantial changes in model predictions, even without altering the corresponding labels. Assessing internals reveals that these subtle formulations have a substantial impact on how models process inputs. (\cref{chp:pub_emnlp_lou}) \item Language models strongly encode input toxicity internally, and their output amplifies this toxicity beyond human behavior. This property is strongly encoded in lower to middle model layers and causally reduces output toxicity when encoded more robustly. (\cref{chp:pub_tacl_aligned_probing}) \end{itemize} \paragraph{Addressing the Research Questions} These contributions collectively address the initially raised overarching research questions. They approximate the overall reliability of language models (\textbf{Q1}), uncover relationships between the reliability attributes (\textbf{Q2}), and offer a better understanding of how reliable model behavior relates to and is reflected in model internals (\textbf{Q3}). \begin{itemize} \item[\textbf{Q1}] \textbf{How reliable are language models for computational argumentation?} Language models are often perceived as reliable due to their seemingly fluent outputs and apparent task efficacy. However, our empirical insights show that their reliability remains limited. They fail with complex linguistic phenomena and struggle to generalize consistently across diverse distribution shifts. While specific specialization methods can mitigate some challenges, no single approach performs reliably across all scenarios. Moreover, models remain sensitive to societal variations in language and substantially amplify toxicity beyond human baselines. \item[\textbf{Q2}] \textbf{How are the different reliability attributes related?} Language understanding, generalizability, and societal alignment are empirically related. Unlike humans, who abstract concepts such as fairness and apply them independently of stylistic variations, language models process text solely at the surface level. In doing so, they often rely on superficial lexical cues across all attributes, as they were trained with objectives like next-token prediction. As a result, these models, despite producing coherent text, lack genuine comprehension of language in general, and particularly in societal contexts. \item[\textbf{Q3}] \textbf{How does reliable model behavior interplay with model internals?} We present, for the first time, a series of studies that systematically assess and connect model behavior and internals, in general and in particular, regarding reliability. Empirical insights reveal that both perspectives offer distinct yet complementary understandings of how models work, hinting at potential degraded reliability, such as when they distort semantic information during specialization or weakly encode the toxicity of model inputs that causally increase output toxicity. Thus, only assessing the interplay between both perspectives fully captures model reliability and provides empirical evidence to calibrate perception. \end{itemize} \section{Outlook}\label{sec:outlook} The presented integral view on the reliability of language models in computational argumentation highlights the multidimensionality and heterogeneity of comprehensive evaluation. Thereby, it expands the scope of evaluation in this interdisciplinary field. As we reveal challenges of general relevance, we believe that future work towards more reliable language models goes beyond computational argumentation: \paragraph{Disentangle Seemingly Human-Like Capabilities} The studies presented and discussed in this thesis demonstrate that language models are becoming increasingly powerful across a wide range of tasks. Humans, however, tend to humanize and overestimate these systems \citep{kambhampati2025stop, blili-hamelin2025position}, creating a misalignment between the general perception and empirical evidence. We observe that much of this apparent efficacy arises as an artifact of specific pre-training procedures, which may align more closely with certain evaluation protocols than others. Building on the work of this thesis \citep{waldis-etal-2024-holmes,waldis2025aligned} and related studies \citep{hu-levy-2023-prompting,mahowald2023dissociating}, we argue that realistic and heterogeneous evaluations—incorporating multiple perspectives and input perturbations to stress-test findings—are essential to ensure that language models can reliably and responsibly benefit society. \paragraph{Improving Generalizability in Out-of-Distribution Scenarios} Although the efficacy of language models in out-of-distribution scenarios continues to improve, our findings indicate that no single specialized model consistently outperforms others across various types of shifts. From this observation, we identify two key avenues for future research. First, we demonstrate that selecting the right specialization paradigm can substantially enhance performance, even when tuning only a fraction of parameters, revealing the relevance and promising but unexplored potential of smaller language models. With methodological advances, such models may achieve even higher performance while remaining more efficient and easier to interpret \citep{waldis-etal-2024-handle}. Second, as the amount of pre-training data continues to grow, it remains uncertain how reliably we can approximate and compare model performance in out-of-distribution scenarios. Addressing this challenge requires identifying and quantifying data leakage—both at the data level \citep{balloccu-etal-2024-leak} and at the task level—since exposure to similar texts or tasks during pre-training may both favor memorization over genuine generalization \citep{DBLP:conf/iclr/0003AEAAZW25}. \paragraph{Stress-Test Interpretability Methods} In this thesis, we discussed a range of interpretability methods (\cref{chp:evaluation_interpretability}) and outlined the diversity of studies and resources in \citep{waldis-etal-2024-holmes}. We emphasize the importance of combining multiple perspectives and therefore introduced a new method \citep{waldis2025aligned}. But interpretability research must also be systematically stress-tested, as findings of different perspectives do not align or may fail to generalize under semantic shifts in texts—as demonstrated by our analysis of dependency relations in \citep{waldis-etal-2024-dive}. This observation aligns with previous work revealing biases in co-reference assessments toward popular entities \citep{diehl-martinez-etal-2024-mitigating}. Such limitations are particularly critical because interpretability research often depends on a narrow set of underlying text resources. For instance, numerous studies \citep{carlson-etal-2001, weischedel2013ontonotes, webber2019penn} addressing diverse linguistic phenomena are all based on the Penn Treebank corpora \citep{Taylor2003}, which primarily consist of articles from The Wall Street Journal. As a result, interpretability findings can unconsciously amplify underlying biases into the next generation of language models, as insights may not generalize to identities underrepresented in these corpora. \paragraph{Standardize Interpretability Research} With the growing interest in interpretability research, other sub-communities started to use these tools, including linguistics, computational linguistics, natural language processing, cognitive science, computational social science, and machine learning. However, these fields employ different experimental setups for conducting research and use varying terminologies to communicate their findings \citep{DBLP:journals/corr/abs-2405-05386,saphra-wiegreffe-2024-mechanistic}. As a result, these fields need to find common ground to integrate the diverse expertise, domain knowledge, and resources across fields, enabling fundamental advances through connected perspectives.
Assistant
This is a well-structured conclusion draft, and your current suggested order—Summary, Contributions/Research Questions, Outlook—is a standard, highly effective, and widely accepted structure for a thesis conclusion chapter.Here is a breakdown of why your current order makes sense and how you can address the suggestion to put Research Questions (RQs) upfront:Evaluation of Your Current OrderYour Proposed Order:Summary (\cref{sec:summary}): Summarizes the whole research context, introduces the "integral view," and presents high-level implications (I1-I4).Contributions & RQs (\cref{sec:contributions}): Details the specific technical/conceptual contributions (methods, resources, insights) and then explicitly answers the RQs.Outlook (\cref{sec:outlook}): Future work and general directions.Why this works well:Logical Flow: It follows a natural progression:What was the problem and my main framework? (Summary/Implications) → What exactly did I do to address it? (Contributions) → What did I find out? (RQs Answers, built on the contributions) → Where do we go next? (Outlook).Contextualizing RQs: Answering the RQs after summarizing the contributions is highly logical. The contributions (new methods, resources, insights) are the evidence you use to answer the RQs. By presenting the evidence first, the answers to Q1, Q2, and Q3 are immediately grounded in the preceding paragraphs.Engagement: The general implications (I1-I4) in the Summary provide a high-level takeaway before diving into the detail of the specific contributions.Addressing the Suggestion (Putting RQs Upfront)The suggestion to put RQs upfront likely stems from the desire to immediately show the reader the "story" of the thesis. While sometimes used, I would argue against moving them completely up, for the reason you stated: "they also depend on the contributions."A practical solution is to adjust the emphasis and titles within your existing structure, NOT change the order of the main sections.Recommended Minor Adjustment to Section 2:Your current section 2 is titled \section{Contributions}\label{sec:contributions} and it ends with the paragraph \paragraph{Addressing the Research Questions}.You can change the title to make the RQs more central, without sacrificing the flow:\text{Change: } \texttt{\section{Contributions}\label{sec:contributions}}$$$$\text{To: } \texttt{\section{Contributions and Answers to Research Questions}\label{sec:contributions}}Or, if you want a stronger emphasis on the RQs:And then begin the section with a clear transitional sentence: "This thesis presents three overarching research questions (Q1-Q3), which we address through a set of methodological and empirical contributions summarized below. We then synthesize our findings to provide explicit answers to each question."Summary of RecommendationKeep your current section order. It is excellent and logical:Summary (High-level context, framework, and implications I1-I4).Contributions and Answers to Research Questions (Detailed evidence: methods, resources, insights, followed by the answers Q1-Q3 that synthesize the evidence).Outlook (Future work).Your current structure naturally builds the case before providing the final, synthesized answers, which is the most robust way to conclude a lengthy piece of research.
- User
do you think we could hint the answers of the resarch questions in the summary?
Assistant
Yes, you absolutely should hint at the answers to your research questions (RQs) in the Summary section (\cref{sec:summary}).This approach strengthens the overall narrative of your conclusion and addresses the suggestion of putting RQs upfront without disrupting your excellent existing structure.Here's why and how to do it effectively:Why Hint at RQs in the Summary1. Previews the RQs AnswersThe Summary is where you establish the main claim and significance of your work. By briefly summarizing your findings (i.e., the answers to the RQs), you directly connect the problem you introduced with the key solution/insight you achieved. This is often called the "synthesis" step in a conclusion.2. Strengthens the FlowYour RQs (Q1-Q3) are currently answered in detail in the second section, Contributions. Hinting at them in the Summary provides a bridge between the big-picture context (integral view, implications I1-I4) and the detailed evidence (contributions) that follows.3. Justifies the ImplicationsYour four general Implications (I1-I4) are essentially high-level answers derived from the RQs. By directly stating the overall findings first, you provide immediate context for why those implications (e.g., I2: Coherence does not imply language understanding) are valid.How to Integrate the HintsYou don't need to use the formal Q1, Q2, Q3 labels, but you should incorporate the core findings from your answers into the Summary section's main body (before the Implications paragraph).Suggested Insertion PointIntegrate these findings right after you introduce the "integral view" framework and the three attributes (language understanding, generalizability, and societal alignment).Original Text SegmentProposed AdditionOriginal: At the same time, we broaden the evaluation scope beyond task efficacy and disentangle model reliability into language understanding, generalizability, and societal alignment (\cref{chp:reliability_attributes}).Addition: Our empirical findings reveal that model reliability remains limited across all three attributes, showing a strong entanglement between them (Q2) and highlighting that reliable behavior is often weakly reflected in model internals (Q3).Export to SheetsBreakdown of the Hinted Answers:Here are the specific elements from your detailed RQ answers (Q1-Q3) that you can distill and integrate into the Summary:RQ to Hint AtCore Finding (Distilled)Where to Hint (Example Wording)Q1 (Reliability)Reliability is limited: models fail complex phenomena, struggle to generalize, and are susceptible to societal variations."Despite apparent fluency, we demonstrate that models exhibit limited reliability, failing at complex linguistic phenomena, struggling to generalize consistently across distribution shifts, and remaining susceptible to societal dynamics in language."Q2 (Relationships)Attributes are related: models lack genuine comprehension because they rely on superficial surface-level cues."Crucially, we find that these attributes are empirically entangled, as models rely on superficial lexical cues, causing a lack of genuine language comprehension in both general and societal contexts."Q3 (Internals)Reliable behavior requires systematically assessing and connecting with internals, which often reveal potential degradations."This limited reliability necessitates an integral view connecting behavior with model internals, which provides the distinct, complementary evidence required to capture how models distort semantic information or amplify toxicity."Export to SheetsBy weaving these brief, high-level findings into the Summary, you immediately state your case upfront, enhancing the academic impact and clarity of your conclusion.
- User
could you reformulate the summary accordingly
Assistant
That's a great idea. Integrating the key findings into the Summary will make the conclusion much stronger and more cohesive.Here is a reformulated Summary section (\cref{sec:summary}) that hints at the answers to Q1, Q2, and Q3 before detailing the general Implications (I1-I4).Summary \label{sec:summary}Assistive technologies powered by language models are increasingly effective in helping users navigate the growing amount of arguments available online. However, their usefulness is closely tied to the limitations of these models. Overestimating their human-likeness, generalizability, fairness, and safety may cause societal risks. A thorough understanding of these aspects—beyond task efficacy—is not only important for a general perception grounded in realistic and empirical assessments but also to form the basis for developing trusted and accepted technologies that support political participation in a digital age.To address this need, we introduce an integral view on model reliability—a framework for comprehensively conducting model assessments and systematically structuring their findings. Unlike existing evaluation efforts that either focus solely on model behavior or predominantly on single tasks, this framework extends prior research along two dimensions: methods and scope. We present a methodological toolbox of existing and novel specialization, evaluation, and interpretability methods (\cref{chp:language_models}, \cref{chp:evaluation_interpretability}) that examine model behavior, internals, and their interplay. At the same time, we broaden the evaluation scope beyond task efficacy and disentangle model reliability into language understanding, generalizability, and societal alignment (\cref{chp:reliability_attributes}).Our empirical findings synthesized within this integral view reveal that model reliability remains limited despite perceived fluency. Language models fail with complex linguistic phenomena, struggle to generalize consistently across diverse distribution shifts, and remain susceptible to societal dynamics in language. Crucially, we demonstrate that these reliability attributes are empirically entangled (Q2): the models' lack of genuine comprehension stems from a reliance on superficial lexical cues across general and societal contexts. Consequently, only assessing the interplay between model behavior and internals (Q3) fully captures reliability, as internals often reveal degradations, such as the weak encoding of toxicity that causally increases model output toxicity.ImplicationsThis integral view advances beyond prior evaluation work by systematically combining methodological perspectives with a structured evaluation scope. It promotes a structured and comprehensive approach to studying model reliability, making research design, execution, and communication more understandable, reproducible, and impactful. This is an essential aspect for computational argumentation, where aligning methods and terminology across disciplines is crucial to enable progress. For this purpose, we derive four general implications relevant for and beyond computational argumentation based on our empirical insights (I1–I4):[... The rest of your I1-I4 implications follow unchanged]
- User
but I would like to still explicitly answer the RQs later on in more detail
Assistant
That's an excellent point. It is standard academic practice to use the Summary to present the high-level conclusions and then dedicate a subsequent section to provide a detailed, explicit, and structured answer to each Research Question (RQ), often using the original Q1, Q2, Q3 labels.The flow you have established is ideal for this:Summary (\cref{sec:summary}): Introduces the framework, presents the general implications (I1-I4), and previews the main findings (the hints).Contributions and Answers to Research Questions (\cref{sec:contributions}): Presents the evidence (methodological, resource, and empirical contributions) and then provides the detailed, explicit, text-based answers to Q1, Q2, and Q3, fully synthesizing the evidence.Conclusion Structure (Preserving the Detailed Answers)By using the reformulated Summary, the entire chapter flows as follows, with the detailed RQ answers clearly preserved in the second section:SectionPurposeRole of RQsStatusSummary (\cref{sec:summary})Sets the scope and presents high-level takeaways.Hints at findings to provide context for the implications (I1-I4).RevisedContributions (\cref{sec:contributions})Presents the specific work done (evidence).Provides the evidence that supports the full answers (Methods, Resources, Insights).UnchangedAddressing the Research Questions (\cref{sec:contributions})Within the Contributions section.Provides the explicit, detailed, paragraph-length answers to Q1, Q2, and Q3.Crucially preservedOutlook (\cref{sec:outlook})Future work.N/AUnchangedExport to SheetsThe detailed answers under your existing \paragraph{Addressing the Research Questions} remain necessary and serve as the final, most direct fulfillment of your thesis's core objectives, regardless of the hints in the summary. The hints only serve to better prime the reader for these final answers.
- User
could you rephrase the summary accordingly
Assistant
This is the reformulated Summary section, incorporating the essential findings (hints at Q1, Q2, and Q3) while setting up the expectation that the detailed answers will follow later in the chapter.Summary \label{sec:summary}Assistive technologies powered by language models are increasingly effective in helping users navigate the growing amount of arguments available online. However, their usefulness is closely tied to the limitations of these models. Overestimating their human-likeness, generalizability, fairness, and safety may cause societal risks. A thorough understanding of these aspects—beyond task efficacy—is not only important for a general perception grounded in realistic and empirical assessments but also to form the basis for developing trusted and accepted technologies that support political participation in a digital age.To address this need, we introduce an integral view on model reliability—a conceptual framework for comprehensively conducting model assessments and systematically structuring their findings. Unlike existing evaluation efforts that either focus solely on model behavior or predominantly on single tasks, this framework extends prior research along two dimensions: methods and scope. We present a methodological toolbox of existing and novel specialization, evaluation, and interpretability methods (\cref{chp:language_models}, \cref{chp:evaluation_interpretability}) that examine model behavior, internals, and their interplay. At the same time, we broaden the evaluation scope beyond task efficacy and disentangle model reliability into language understanding, generalizability, and societal alignment (\cref{chp:reliability_attributes}).Our empirical findings synthesized within this integral view reveal that model reliability remains limited despite perceived fluency (Q1). We find that models fail with complex linguistic phenomena, struggle to generalize consistently across distribution shifts, and are susceptible to societal dynamics in language. Crucially, these reliability attributes are empirically entangled (Q2): the lack of genuine language comprehension stems from a reliance on superficial lexical cues across general and societal contexts. This limited reliability necessitates systematically assessing the interplay between model behavior and internals (Q3), as internals often provide the distinct, complementary evidence required to capture phenomena like semantic distortion during specialization or the causal link between internal encoding and output toxicity. We provide explicit, detailed answers to the research questions later in .ImplicationsThis integral view advances beyond prior evaluation work by systematically combining methodological perspectives with a structured evaluation scope. It promotes a structured and comprehensive approach to studying model reliability, making research design, execution, and communication more understandable, reproducible, and impactful. This is an essential aspect for computational argumentation, where aligning methods and terminology across disciplines is crucial to enable progress. For this purpose, we derive four general implications relevant for and beyond computational argumentation based on our empirical insights (I1–I4):[\text{I1}] Joining interpretability perspectives is indispensable.[\text{I2}] Coherence does not imply language understanding.[\text{I3}] Evaluating generalization requires a fine-grained scope.[\text{I4}] Language models are susceptible to societal dynamics in language.
- User
you write in latex?
Assistant
I am designed to use LaTeX formatting for mathematical and scientific notations when appropriate.For example, if you ask me about the derivative of a function, I would write it as: dxd(x2)=2xHowever, I do not use LaTeX for regular prose (like resumes, letters, essays, or general text) unless you specifically instruct me to format the entire response in a LaTeX block.In short: I use LATEX for the math, but not for the words. How can I help you with your next question?
- User
no the above text in latex
Assistant
Here is the LATEX code for the reformulated Summary section.Code snippet\section{Summary}\label{sec:summary}
Assistive technologies powered by language models are increasingly effective in helping users navigate the growing amount of arguments available online. However, their usefulness is closely tied to the limitations of these models. Overestimating their human-likeness, generalizability, fairness, and safety may cause societal risks. A thorough understanding of these aspects—beyond task efficacy—is not only important for a general perception grounded in realistic and empirical assessments but also to form the basis for developing trusted and accepted technologies that support political participation in a digital age.
To address this need, we introduce an \textit{integral view} on model reliability—a conceptual framework for comprehensively conducting model assessments and systematically structuring their findings. Unlike existing evaluation efforts that either focus solely on model behavior or predominantly on single tasks, this framework extends prior research along two dimensions: methods and scope. We present a methodological toolbox of existing and novel \textcolor{SpecEvalRed}{\textbf{specialization}}, \textcolor{SpecEvalRed}{\textbf{evaluation}}, and \textcolor{IntrRed}{\textbf{interpretability}} methods (\cref{chp:language_models}, \cref{chp:evaluation_interpretability}) that examine model behavior, internals, and their interplay. At the same time, we broaden the evaluation scope beyond task efficacy and disentangle model reliability into \textcolor{AttrGreen}{\textbf{language understanding}}, \textcolor{AttrBlue}{\textbf{generalizability}}, and \textcolor{AttrYellow}{\textbf{societal alignment}} (\cref{chp:reliability_attributes}).
Our empirical findings synthesized within this integral view reveal that model reliability remains \textbf{limited} despite perceived fluency (Q1). We find that models \textbf{fail with complex linguistic phenomena}, struggle to \textbf{generalize consistently} across distribution shifts, and are \textbf{susceptible to societal dynamics} in language. Crucially, these reliability attributes are \textbf{empirically entangled} (Q2): the lack of genuine language comprehension stems from a reliance on \textbf{superficial lexical cues} across general and societal contexts. This limited reliability necessitates systematically assessing the \textbf{interplay between model behavior and internals} (Q3), as internals often provide the distinct, complementary evidence required to capture phenomena like semantic distortion during specialization or the causal link between internal encoding and output toxicity. We provide explicit, detailed answers to the research questions later in \cref{sec:contributions}.
\paragraph{Implications} This integral view advances beyond prior evaluation work by systematically combining methodological perspectives with a structured evaluation scope. It promotes a structured and comprehensive approach to studying model reliability, making research design, execution, and communication more understandable, reproducible, and impactful. This is an essential aspect for computational argumentation, where aligning methods and terminology across disciplines is crucial to enable progress. For this purpose, we derive four general implications relevant for and beyond computational argumentation based on our empirical insights (\textbf{I1}–\textbf{I4}):
\begin{itemize} \item[\textbf{I1}] \textbf{Joining interpretability perspectives is indispensable.} \item[\textbf{I2}] \textbf{Coherence does not imply language understanding.} \item[\textbf{I3}] \textbf{Evaluating generalization requires a fine-grained scope.} \item[\textbf{I4}] \textbf{Language models are susceptible to societal dynamics in language.} \end{itemize}
- User
do you think we need to explicitly state the the full research questions are answered latter on?
Assistant
Yes, explicitly stating that the full research questions are answered later is a good idea.Even though the reformulated Summary hints at the answers, the final sentence:"We provide explicit, detailed answers to the research questions later in \cref{sec:contributions}."... serves three important purposes:Manages Reader Expectations: It clearly tells the reader that the high-level findings in the Summary are not the final, formal fulfillment of the RQs. They know exactly where to look for the structured Q1/Q2/Q3 breakdown.Reinforces Structure: It provides a strong signpost, linking the Summary to the subsequent Contributions section.Addresses the Initial Concern: It acknowledges the need to discuss the RQs early (by hinting at them) while respecting the necessary flow where the detailed answers depend on the contributions that are presented first.By keeping that sentence, you make your conclusion's structure perfectly clear and academically sound.
- User
maybe we could remove section header "summary" and combine this text with the introductionary sentences?
Assistant
That's an excellent idea for making the conclusion flow more smoothly and academically. Combining the introductory paragraph with the summary text eliminates a redundant heading and moves the reader immediately into the core findings of your thesis.Here is the combined text, removing the "Summary" heading and integrating its content into the chapter's introduction:Code snippet\chapter{Conclusion} \label{chp:conclusion}
This chapter concludes the thesis. We first summarize the presented research by outlining the \textit{integral view} and discussing its high-level empirical findings (Q1, Q2, Q3) and general implications (I1-I4). We then outline the contributions of this thesis and provide the explicit, detailed answers to the initially raised research questions (\cref{sec:contributions}). Finally, we provide an outlook on possible future research (\cref{sec:outlook}).
\section{Synthesis of Findings and Implications}\label{sec:summary} Assistive technologies powered by language models are increasingly effective in helping users navigate the growing amount of arguments available online. However, their usefulness is closely tied to the limitations of these models. Overestimating their human-likeness, generalizability, fairness, and safety may cause societal risks. A thorough understanding of these aspects—beyond task efficacy—is not only important for a general perception grounded in realistic and empirical assessments but also to form the basis for developing trusted and accepted technologies that support political participation in a digital age.
To address this need, we introduce an \textit{integral view} on model reliability—a conceptual framework for comprehensively conducting model assessments and systematically structuring their findings. Unlike existing evaluation efforts that either focus solely on model behavior or predominantly on single tasks, this framework extends prior research along two dimensions: methods and scope. We present a methodological toolbox of existing and novel \textcolor{SpecEvalRed}{\textbf{specialization}}, \textcolor{SpecEvalRed}{\textbf{evaluation}}, and \textcolor{IntrRed}{\textbf{interpretability}} methods (\cref{chp:language_models}, \cref{chp:evaluation_interpretability}) that examine model behavior, internals, and their interplay. At the same time, we broaden the evaluation scope beyond task efficacy and disentangle model reliability into \textcolor{AttrGreen}{\textbf{language understanding}}, \textcolor{AttrBlue}{\textbf{generalizability}}, and \textcolor{AttrYellow}{\textbf{societal alignment}} (\cref{chp:reliability_attributes}).
Our empirical findings synthesized within this integral view reveal that model reliability remains \textbf{limited} despite perceived fluency (Q1). We find that models \textbf{fail with complex linguistic phenomena}, struggle to \textbf{generalize consistently} across distribution shifts, and are \textbf{susceptible to societal dynamics} in language. Crucially, these reliability attributes are \textbf{empirically entangled} (Q2): the lack of genuine language comprehension stems from a reliance on \textbf{superficial lexical cues} across general and societal contexts. This limited reliability necessitates systematically assessing the \textbf{interplay between model behavior and internals} (Q3), as internals often provide the distinct, complementary evidence required to capture phenomena like semantic distortion during specialization or the causal link between internal encoding and output toxicity. We provide explicit, detailed answers to the research questions later in \cref{sec:contributions}.
\paragraph{Implications} This integral view advances beyond prior evaluation work by systematically combining methodological perspectives with a structured evaluation scope. It promotes a structured and comprehensive approach to studying model reliability, making research design, execution, and communication more understandable, reproducible, and impactful. This is an essential aspect for computational argumentation, where aligning methods and terminology across disciplines is crucial to enable progress. For this purpose, we derive four general implications relevant for and beyond computational argumentation based on our empirical insights (\textbf{I1}–\textbf{I4}):
\begin{itemize} \item[\textbf{I1}] \textbf{Joining interpretability perspectives is indispensable.} \item[\textbf{I2}] \textbf{Coherence does not imply language understanding.} \item[\textbf{I3}] \textbf{Evaluating generalization requires a fine-grained scope.} \item[\textbf{I4}] \textbf{Language models are susceptible to societal dynamics in language.} \end{itemize}
\section{Contributions and Answers to Research Questions}\label{sec:contributions} With the \textit{integral view}, we present a conceptual framework that has organically evolved from the research process in this thesis. % [The rest of the section follows here...] Key Changes Made:Chapter Introduction Updated: The second and third original sentences were merged and updated to reflect the new flow:"We first summarize the presented research by outlining the \textit{integral view} and discussing its high-level empirical findings (Q1, Q2, Q3) and general implications (I1-I4). We then outline the contributions of this thesis and provide the explicit, detailed answers to the initially raised research questions (\cref{sec:contributions}). Finally, we provide an outlook on possible future research (\cref{sec:outlook})."New Section Heading: The heading \section{Summary} was replaced with the more descriptive and academic-sounding:\section{Synthesis of Findings and Implications}\label{sec:summary}Next Section Renamed (Optional but Recommended): To match the introduction, the second main section was renamed to be clearer:\section{Contributions and Answers to Research Questions}\label{sec:contributions}This new structure is highly effective. It creates a smooth narrative arc: Introduction → High-Level Synthesis → Detailed Evidence → Outlook.
- User
also no additional section just combine the following This chapter concludes the thesis. We first summarize the presented research by outlining the \textit{integral view} and discussing its high-level empirical findings (Q1, Q2, Q3) and general implications (I1-I4). We then outline the contributions of this thesis and provide the explicit, detailed answers to the initially raised research questions (\cref{sec:contributions}). Finally, we provide an outlook on possible future research (\cref{sec:outlook}). Assistive technologies powered by language models are increasingly effective in helping users navigate the growing amount of arguments available online. However, their usefulness is closely tied to the limitations of these models. Overestimating their human-likeness, generalizability, fairness, and safety may cause societal risks. A thorough understanding of these aspects—beyond task efficacy—is not only important for a general perception grounded in realistic and empirical assessments but also to form the basis for developing trusted and accepted technologies that support political participation in a digital age. To address this need, we introduce an \textit{integral view} on model reliability—a conceptual framework for comprehensively conducting model assessments and systematically structuring their findings. Unlike existing evaluation efforts that either focus solely on model behavior or predominantly on single tasks, this framework extends prior research along two dimensions: methods and scope. We present a methodological toolbox of existing and novel \textcolor{SpecEvalRed}{\textbf{specialization}}, \textcolor{SpecEvalRed}{\textbf{evaluation}}, and \textcolor{IntrRed}{\textbf{interpretability}} methods (\cref{chp:language_models}, \cref{chp:evaluation_interpretability}) that examine model behavior, internals, and their interplay. At the same time, we broaden the evaluation scope beyond task efficacy and disentangle model reliability into \textcolor{AttrGreen}{\textbf{language understanding}}, \textcolor{AttrBlue}{\textbf{generalizability}}, and \textcolor{AttrYellow}{\textbf{societal alignment}} (\cref{chp:reliability_attributes}). Our empirical findings synthesized within this integral view reveal that model reliability remains \textbf{limited} despite perceived fluency (Q1). We find that models \textbf{fail with complex linguistic phenomena}, struggle to \textbf{generalize consistently} across distribution shifts, and are \textbf{susceptible to societal dynamics} in language. Crucially, these reliability attributes are \textbf{empirically entangled} (Q2): the lack of genuine language comprehension stems from a reliance on \textbf{superficial lexical cues} across general and societal contexts. This limited reliability necessitates systematically assessing the \textbf{interplay between model behavior and internals} (Q3), as internals often provide the distinct, complementary evidence required to capture phenomena like semantic distortion during specialization or the causal link between internal encoding and output toxicity. We provide explicit, detailed answers to the research questions later in \cref{sec:contributions}.
Assistant
Here is the LATEX code for the combined introductory text and the synthesis of findings, without a separate section heading for the summary. This creates a very direct and impactful opening to your Conclusion chapter.Code snippet\chapter{Conclusion} \label{chp:conclusion}
This chapter concludes the thesis. We first summarize the presented research by outlining the \textit{integral view} and discussing its high-level empirical findings (Q1, Q2, Q3) and general implications (I1-I4). We then outline the contributions of this thesis and provide the explicit, detailed answers to the initially raised research questions (\cref{sec:contributions}). Finally, we provide an outlook on possible future research (\cref{sec:outlook}).
Assistive technologies powered by language models are increasingly effective in helping users navigate the growing amount of arguments available online. However, their usefulness is closely tied to the limitations of these models. Overestimating their human-likeness, generalizability, fairness, and safety may cause societal risks. A thorough understanding of these aspects—beyond task efficacy—is not only important for a general perception grounded in realistic and empirical assessments but also to form the basis for developing trusted and accepted technologies that support political participation in a digital age.
To address this need, we introduce an \textit{integral view} on model reliability—a conceptual framework for comprehensively conducting model assessments and systematically structuring their findings. Unlike existing evaluation efforts that either focus solely on model behavior or predominantly on single tasks, this framework extends prior research along two dimensions: methods and scope. We present a methodological toolbox of existing and novel \textcolor{SpecEvalRed}{\textbf{specialization}}, \textcolor{SpecEvalRed}{\textbf{evaluation}}, and \textcolor{IntrRed}{\textbf{interpretability}} methods (\cref{chp:language_models}, \cref{chp:evaluation_interpretability}) that examine model behavior, internals, and their interplay. At the same time, we broaden the evaluation scope beyond task efficacy and disentangle model reliability into \textcolor{AttrGreen}{\textbf{language understanding}}, \textcolor{AttrBlue}{\textbf{generalizability}}, and \textcolor{AttrYellow}{\textbf{societal alignment}} (\cref{chp:reliability_attributes}).
Our empirical findings synthesized within this integral view reveal that model reliability remains \textbf{limited} despite perceived fluency (Q1). We find that models \textbf{fail with complex linguistic phenomena}, struggle to \textbf{generalize consistently} across distribution shifts, and are \textbf{susceptible to societal dynamics} in language. Crucially, these reliability attributes are \textbf{empirically entangled} (Q2): the lack of genuine language comprehension stems from a reliance on \textbf{superficial lexical cues} across general and societal contexts. This limited reliability necessitates systematically assessing the \textbf{interplay between model behavior and internals} (Q3), as internals often provide the distinct, complementary evidence required to capture phenomena like semantic distortion during specialization or the causal link between internal encoding and output toxicity. We provide explicit, detailed answers to the research questions later in \cref{sec:contributions}.
\paragraph{Implications} This integral view advances beyond prior evaluation work by systematically combining methodological perspectives with a structured evaluation scope. It promotes a structured and comprehensive approach to studying model reliability, making research design, execution, and communication more understandable, reproducible, and impactful. This is an essential aspect for computational argumentation, where aligning methods and terminology across disciplines is crucial to enable progress. For this purpose, we derive four general implications relevant for and beyond computational argumentation based on our empirical insights (\textbf{I1}–\textbf{I4}):
\begin{itemize} \item[\textbf{I1}] \textbf{Joining interpretability perspectives is indispensable.} \item[\textbf{I2}] \textbf{Coherence does not imply language understanding.} \item[\textbf{I3}] \textbf{Evaluating generalization requires a fine-grained scope.} \item[\textbf{I4}] \textbf{Language models are susceptible to societal dynamics in language.} \end{itemize}
\section{Contributions}\label{sec:contributions} With the \textit{integral view}, we present a conceptual framework that has organically evolved from the research process in this thesis. % [The rest of the section follows here...]