computationalanalysissocial_roles.pdfPDFI'm implementing this paper. I already…
- User
computational_analysis_social_roles.pdfPDFI'm implementing this paper. I already implemented all GCA aspects with minor changes and clustered the resulting GCA vectors. Then I ran LLM as a Judge on 20% of the discussions to evaluate the aspects.
Help me implement the next part
- Assistant
Great, so you’ve already:
Implemented all the GCA aspects.
Clustered the GCA vectors (to derive social roles).
Validated them partially with an LLM-as-Judge on ~20% of discussions.
👉 The next part in the paper is to connect these roles to learning outcomes and group performance using linear mixed-effects models (LMMs). Here’s the pipeline from the paper:
- Define Outcome Variables
Student-level outcome: learning gains = (%PostTest−%PreTest)/(100−%PreTest)(%\text{PostTest} - %\text{PreTest}) / (100 - %\text{PreTest})(%PostTest−%PreTest)/(100−%PreTest)computational_analysis_social_r….
Group-level outcome: group performance (depends on your dataset — could be aggregated score, task success, etc.).
- Set Up Models They used multilevel / mixed-effects models because of the nested structure (students within groups).
Model 1: Learning gains ~ Social roles + (1 | Group)computational_analysis_social_r…
Model 2: Learning gains ~ Role diversity + (1 | Group)
Model 3: Group performance ~ Role diversity + (1 | Group)
Models 4–6: Learning gains ~ Proportion of productive/unproductive roles + (1 | Group)computational_analysis_social_r…
Models 7–9: Group performance ~ Proportion of productive/unproductive roles + (1 | Group)
Random effects: group membership (sometimes also student nested within group).
- Interpret Results
Roles significantly predicted individual learning gains (e.g., Drivers > Lurkers/Chatterers)computational_analysis_social_r….
Role diversity didn’t matter much, but the proportion of productive vs. unproductive roles strongly affected group performancecomputational_analysis_social_r….
They reported AIC, log-likelihood, likelihood ratio tests, and pseudo- Rm2R^2_mRm2, Rc2R^2_cRc2computational_analysis_social_r….
- How You Can Implement In Python (using statsmodels or lme4 in R): pythonCopy codeimport statsmodels.formula.api as smf
Example: individual-level model
model1 = smf.mixedlm( "learning_gain ~ C(role)", data=df, groups=df["group_id"] ).fit()
print(model1.summary())
For group-level: pythonCopy codemodel2 = smf.mixedlm( "group_performance ~ proportion_productive_roles + proportion_unproductive_roles", data=df, groups=df["group_id"] ).fit()
✅ So your next implementation step after clustering + LLM validation is: Run multilevel mixed-effects models to test how roles (and their distribution) predict individual learning gains and group performance.
Do you want me to draft Python code templates for each of the models (1–9 from the paper), so you can plug in your clustered roles + outcome measures?
- User
I thought the next step was to meassure the group performance with Topic Modeling
- Assistant
You’re absolutely right — I jumped ahead to the modeling step. In the paper, before running the mixed-effects models, they constructed the group performance measure using topic modeling (LDA)computational_analysis_social_r…. Here’s the flow:
🔹 Step: Group Performance via Topic Modeling The idea is to quantify how much of the group’s discussion was on-task (relevant to the assigned domain).
Build corpus
They created a “seed corpus” = transcripts + any associated reading material.
Then expanded it with external documents (e.g., Wikipedia articles) on those seed termscomputational_analysis_social_r….
This becomes your background corpus for topic modeling.
Run LDA (Latent Dirichlet Allocation)
Fit LDA on the expanded corpus to learn KKK latent topics.
Each contribution ctc_tct gets a topic distribution: tq(ct)=P(topic q∣ct)t_q(c_t) = P(\text{topic } q \mid c_t)tq(ct)=P(topic q∣ct) with ∑qtq(ct)=1\sum_q t_q(c_t) = 1∑qtq(ct)=1.
Identify on-task vs. off-task topics
Manually (or semi-automatically) label topics into two sets:
Q′Q′Q′ = on-task (relevant) topics.
Q°Q°Q° = off-task topics.
Compute group performance
For each contribution: T′(ct)=∑q∈Q′tq(ct)T′(c_t) = \sum_{q \in Q′} t_q(c_t)T′(ct)=q∈Q′∑tq(ct)
For the entire discussion: T′=1n∑t=1nT′(ct)T′ = \frac{1}{n} \sum_{t=1}^{n} T′(c_t)T′=n1t=1∑nT′(ct) where nnn = number of contributions.
This gives the proportion of on-task discussion = group performance.
🔹 Implementation (Python sketch) pythonCopiedfrom sklearn.decomposition import LatentDirichletAllocation from sklearn.feature_extraction.text import CountVectorizer import numpy as np import pandas as pd
Suppose df has: group_id, contribution_text
1. Vectorize text
vectorizer = CountVectorizer(stop_words='english') X = vectorizer.fit_transform(df['contribution_text'])
2. Fit LDA
lda = LatentDirichletAllocation(n_components=K, random_state=42) topic_distributions = lda.fit_transform(X)
3. Label topics manually
Example: let's say topics [0, 2, 5] are relevant
on_task_topics = [0, 2, 5]
4. Compute T′(c_t)
df['on_task_score'] = topic_distributions[:, on_task_topics].sum(axis=1)
5. Compute group-level performance
group_perf = df.groupby('group_id')['on_task_score'].mean().reset_index() group_perf.rename(columns={'on_task_score': 'group_performance'}, inplace=True)
✅ So yes — the next step is topic modeling to derive group performance. Then you feed that group performance (and individual learning gains, if available) into the mixed-effects models. Do you want me to help you set up the seed corpus + expansion step (like they did with Wikipedia enrichment), or should we start with a simpler baseline LDA directly on your transcripts?
- User
I will run LDA directly on the transcripts. I don't want to use manual selection - Use an LLM as an annotator/Judge
- Assistant
Perfect — you can absolutely swap the manual topic labeling step with an LLM-as-Judge pipeline. That way, you stay consistent with how you already used LLMs to evaluate GCA aspects. Here’s a concrete plan:
🔹 Pipeline for Group Performance with LDA + LLM Annotation
- Run LDA on your transcripts
Fit an LDA model on all contributions (just as you planned).
Get the top-NNN keywords per topic + representative contribution snippets.
pythonCopy code# Extract top words per topic def get_top_words(model, feature_names, n_top_words=10): topics = {} for idx, topic in enumerate(model.components_): top_words = [feature_names[i] for i in topic.argsort()[:-n_top_words - 1:-1]] topics[idx] = top_words return topics
feature_names = vectorizer.get_feature_names_out() topic_keywords = get_top_words(lda, feature_names, n_top_words=15)
- Ask the LLM to label topics
Instead of manually deciding on-task vs. off-task, feed the top words + sample contributions to your Judge prompt.
The Judge can classify each topic as “Relevant/On-task” or “Irrelevant/Off-task” given your task definition.
Example Judge prompt: pgsqlCopy codeYou are a domain expert. The following keywords and excerpts represent a topic discovered by LDA. Task definition: [insert your group’s discussion domain]. Question: Is this topic relevant to the assigned task, or off-task?
Topic keywords: [list of words] Sample excerpts: [3–5 short contributions]
Answer: Relevant or Off-task
- Compute topic relevance scores
Once each topic is labeled by the LLM, build sets Q′Q′Q′ (on-task topics) and Q°Q°Q° (off-task).
For each contribution ctc_tct, its on-task score is:
T′(ct)=∑q∈Q′P(topic q∣ct)T′(c_t) = \sum_{q \in Q′} P(\text{topic } q \mid c_t)T′(ct)=q∈Q′∑P(topic q∣ct)
Group performance = average of these scores per group.
pythonCopy code# Suppose llm_labels is {topic_id: "Relevant"/"Off-task"} on_task_ids = [tid for tid, label in llm_labels.items() if label == "Relevant"]
df['on_task_score'] = topic_distributions[:, on_task_ids].sum(axis=1)
group_perf = ( df.groupby("group_id")['on_task_score'] .mean() .reset_index() .rename(columns={'on_task_score': 'group_performance'}) )
- (Optional) Add consistency checks
Run the Judge multiple times and aggregate (e.g., majority vote).
Or, use confidence scoring (e.g., ask for 1–5 relevance rating instead of binary).
✅ That gives you a fully automated group performance metric: LDA → LLM annotates topics → compute proportion of on-task talk per group.
Do you want me to draft the LLM Judge prompt template (with few-shot examples) so you can apply it directly to your LDA topics?
Other models, same or similar prompt
Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.