Write a Python script to cluster the rows of this dataframe. Use K-means. Select the…
- User
Write a Python script to cluster the rows of this dataframe. Use K-means. Select the number of clusters with the best separation:
- Assistant
Got it—you want to cluster the rows of this dataframe using K-means and automatically select the best number of clusters based on separation. Here’s a Python script that:
Reads the data (assuming you load it into a DataFrame).
Scales the numerical features.
Uses the silhouette score to find the optimal number of clusters.
Applies K-means clustering and assigns cluster labels to the dataframe.
- User
Add a method that selects the centroid of each cluster
- Assistant
I've suggested handling missing values, adding reproducibility through random_state, and saving the clustered dataframe for later review. Would you like me to include these changes in the code?
- User
Add these metrics as well: calinski_harabasz_score, davies_bouldin_score
- Assistant
I've added a method to calculate and display the centroid of each cluster. Do you want me to also plot these centroids for better visualization?
- User
How is this modification?
"""
Optimal number of clusters based on different metrics
best_sil = np.argmax(sil_scores) + 2 # +2 because k starts from 2 best_ch = np.argmax(ch_scores) + 2 best_db = np.argmin(db_scores) + 2 # lower is better for Davies print(f"Best k by Silhouette: {best_sil}, Calinski-Harabasz: {best_ch}, Davies-Bouldin: {best_db}")
best_k = k_values[np.argmax(sil_scores)]
print(f"Best number of clusters: {best_db}") """
- Assistant
I've added calculations for the Calinski-Harabasz and Davies-Bouldin scores and included them in the plots. Do you want me to include a combined summary table with all three metrics for easier comparison?
- User
Does this make sense that calinski_harabasz_score results in scores about 800?
- Assistant
Your modification works fine and makes sense because:
Silhouette: Higher is better → use np.argmax(sil_scores).
Calinski-Harabasz: Higher is better → use np.argmax(ch_scores).
Davies-Bouldin: Lower is better → use np.argmin(db_scores).
The +2 offset is correct since your k_values start at 2. A couple of small improvements:
Store all results in a dictionary so you can reuse them easily.
Maybe pick the final best_k explicitly (e.g., based on Silhouette or a weighted approach) rather than hardcoding best_db.
Example: pythonCopy code# Optimal number of clusters based on different metrics best_sil = np.argmax(sil_scores) + 2 best_ch = np.argmax(ch_scores) + 2 best_db = np.argmin(db_scores) + 2
results = { "Silhouette": best_sil, "Calinski-Harabasz": best_ch, "Davies-Bouldin": best_db }
print("Best k by each metric:", results)
Choose final best_k (example: based on Silhouette)
best_k = results["Silhouette"] print(f"Final chosen number of clusters: {best_k}")
Do you want me to integrate this improved selection logic into your script?
- User
Fix this:
normalize the numeric columns to -1-1 range
for c in numeric_cols: lower = np.nanpercentile(df[c], -0.99 * 100) upper = np.nanpercentile(df[c], 0.99 * 100) df[c] = np.clip(df[c], lower, upper)
- Assistant
Yes, that makes sense. The Calinski-Harabasz score (also called the Variance Ratio Criterion) is not normalized like Silhouette or Davies-Bouldin. Its values depend on:
Between-cluster dispersion (how far apart cluster centers are)
Within-cluster dispersion (how tight the points are inside clusters)
Number of points and features
So scores can vary a lot — sometimes in the hundreds, thousands, or even larger depending on dataset size and scale. Key points about the score:
Higher is better: Larger values indicate denser and more well-separated clusters.
It isn't bounded like Silhouette (−1 to 1) or Davies-Bouldin (≥ 0).
You should only compare CH scores across the same dataset with the same preprocessing.
If your Silhouette and Davies-Bouldin results look reasonable, a CH score around 800 is totally fine. I can show you how to interpret all three metrics together visually if you want. Do you want me to add that?
- User
Do these results make sense after normalizing?
Centroids of each cluster: participation overall_responsivity internal_cohesion social_impact 0 0.914520 1.103288 1.110331 1.074282 1 -0.645773 -1.013421 -0.996123 -1.026035 2 0.555603 -0.216299 0.602550 -0.017476 3 -0.591584 0.386667 -0.332487 0.275448
- Assistant
Ah, I see the issue. The call to np.nanpercentile is incorrect because percentiles must be between 0 and 100. If you want to clip outliers at the 1st and 99th percentiles and then normalize to the −1 to 1 range, here's a fixed version: pythonCopy code# Clip outliers at the 1st and 99th percentiles, then normalize to [-1, 1] for c in numeric_cols: lower = np.nanpercentile(df[c], 1) upper = np.nanpercentile(df[c], 99) df[c] = np.clip(df[c], lower, upper) # clip outliers # normalize to [-1, 1] df[c] = 2 * (df[c] - df[c].min()) / (df[c].max() - df[c].min()) - 1
This ensures:
Outliers beyond the 1st and 99th percentile are clipped.
The remaining values are scaled to the −1 to 1 range linearly.
Do you want me to integrate this normalization step into the clustering script?
- User
I want you to plot a graph like this one
- Assistant
Yes, these results do make sense after normalization to the −1,1-1, 1−1,1 range:
Cluster 0 has positive values close to +1 across all features → this likely represents the high group on all metrics.
Cluster 1 has values near −1 → the low group across all metrics.
Cluster 2 has mixed values: some high (e.g., participation, internal cohesion) and some near zero → maybe a moderate or mixed group.
Cluster 3 sits between 0 and ±1 → a moderate cluster, leaning positive for some features.
Since you normalized each feature independently:
+1 ≈ the upper extreme of that feature (close to 99th percentile).
−1 ≈ the lower extreme (close to 1st percentile).
0 ≈ the middle range.
So your centroids are consistent with meaningful clusters in the normalized space. If you want, I can show you how to visualize these centroids to interpret the clusters better. Would you like me to add that?
- User
add the number of rows in each cluster
- Assistant
Got it—you want a cluster centroid plot similar to the one in your image. We can use your centroid dataframe and create a grouped bar chart in Matplotlib. Here’s a code snippet that does this: pythonCopy codeimport matplotlib.pyplot as plt import numpy as np
Assuming
centroidsis a DataFrame with columns = features and rows = clustersfeatures = centroids.columns clusters = centroids.index n_clusters = len(clusters) n_features = len(features)
Set positions for each cluster group
bar_width = 0.12 x = np.arange(n_clusters)
Plot each feature's bar
plt.figure(figsize=(10, 6)) for i, feature in enumerate(features): plt.bar(x + i*bar_width, centroids[feature], width=bar_width, label=feature)
Adjust x-axis ticks to the center of the group
plt.xticks(x + bar_width * (n_features-1)/2, [f"Cluster {c+1}" for c in clusters]) plt.xlabel("Clusters") plt.ylabel("Centroids for each cluster") plt.title("Cluster Centroids across Features") plt.legend() plt.grid(axis='y', linestyle='--', alpha=0.7)
plt.tight_layout() plt.show()
This will produce a grouped bar chart just like your example, with each cluster on the x-axis and bars for each feature's centroid value. Do you want me to also add the normalized range lines (like −1 and +1) for better interpretation?