Skip to content
The Chat Archive
ChatGPT (model unspecified)· OpenAI ShareLM (browser-extension contributions)

Write a Python script to cluster the rows of this dataframe. Use K-means. Select the…

  1. User

    Write a Python script to cluster the rows of this dataframe. Use K-means. Select the number of clusters with the best separation:

  2. Assistant

    Got it—you want to cluster the rows of this dataframe using K-means and automatically select the best number of clusters based on separation. Here’s a Python script that:

    Reads the data (assuming you load it into a DataFrame).

    Scales the numerical features.

    Uses the silhouette score to find the optimal number of clusters.

    Applies K-means clustering and assigns cluster labels to the dataframe.

  3. User

    Add a method that selects the centroid of each cluster

  4. Assistant

    I've suggested handling missing values, adding reproducibility through random_state, and saving the clustered dataframe for later review. Would you like me to include these changes in the code?

  5. User

    Add these metrics as well: calinski_harabasz_score, davies_bouldin_score

  6. Assistant

    I've added a method to calculate and display the centroid of each cluster. Do you want me to also plot these centroids for better visualization?

  7. User

    How is this modification?

    """

    Optimal number of clusters based on different metrics

    best_sil = np.argmax(sil_scores) + 2 # +2 because k starts from 2 best_ch = np.argmax(ch_scores) + 2 best_db = np.argmin(db_scores) + 2 # lower is better for Davies print(f"Best k by Silhouette: {best_sil}, Calinski-Harabasz: {best_ch}, Davies-Bouldin: {best_db}")

    best_k = k_values[np.argmax(sil_scores)]

    print(f"Best number of clusters: {best_db}") """

  8. Assistant

    I've added calculations for the Calinski-Harabasz and Davies-Bouldin scores and included them in the plots. Do you want me to include a combined summary table with all three metrics for easier comparison?

  9. User

    Does this make sense that calinski_harabasz_score results in scores about 800?

  10. Assistant

    Your modification works fine and makes sense because:

    Silhouette: Higher is better → use np.argmax(sil_scores).

    Calinski-Harabasz: Higher is better → use np.argmax(ch_scores).

    Davies-Bouldin: Lower is better → use np.argmin(db_scores).

    The +2 offset is correct since your k_values start at 2. A couple of small improvements:

    Store all results in a dictionary so you can reuse them easily.

    Maybe pick the final best_k explicitly (e.g., based on Silhouette or a weighted approach) rather than hardcoding best_db.

    Example: pythonCopy code# Optimal number of clusters based on different metrics best_sil = np.argmax(sil_scores) + 2 best_ch = np.argmax(ch_scores) + 2 best_db = np.argmin(db_scores) + 2

    results = { "Silhouette": best_sil, "Calinski-Harabasz": best_ch, "Davies-Bouldin": best_db }

    print("Best k by each metric:", results)

    Choose final best_k (example: based on Silhouette)

    best_k = results["Silhouette"] print(f"Final chosen number of clusters: {best_k}")

    Do you want me to integrate this improved selection logic into your script?

  11. User

    Fix this:

    normalize the numeric columns to -1-1 range

    for c in numeric_cols: lower = np.nanpercentile(df[c], -0.99 * 100) upper = np.nanpercentile(df[c], 0.99 * 100) df[c] = np.clip(df[c], lower, upper)

  12. Assistant

    Yes, that makes sense. The Calinski-Harabasz score (also called the Variance Ratio Criterion) is not normalized like Silhouette or Davies-Bouldin. Its values depend on:

    Between-cluster dispersion (how far apart cluster centers are)

    Within-cluster dispersion (how tight the points are inside clusters)

    Number of points and features

    So scores can vary a lot — sometimes in the hundreds, thousands, or even larger depending on dataset size and scale. Key points about the score:

    Higher is better: Larger values indicate denser and more well-separated clusters.

    It isn't bounded like Silhouette (−1 to 1) or Davies-Bouldin (≥ 0).

    You should only compare CH scores across the same dataset with the same preprocessing.

    If your Silhouette and Davies-Bouldin results look reasonable, a CH score around 800 is totally fine. I can show you how to interpret all three metrics together visually if you want. Do you want me to add that?

  13. User

    Do these results make sense after normalizing?

    Centroids of each cluster: participation overall_responsivity internal_cohesion social_impact 0 0.914520 1.103288 1.110331 1.074282 1 -0.645773 -1.013421 -0.996123 -1.026035 2 0.555603 -0.216299 0.602550 -0.017476 3 -0.591584 0.386667 -0.332487 0.275448

  14. Assistant

    Ah, I see the issue. The call to np.nanpercentile is incorrect because percentiles must be between 0 and 100. If you want to clip outliers at the 1st and 99th percentiles and then normalize to the −1 to 1 range, here's a fixed version: pythonCopy code# Clip outliers at the 1st and 99th percentiles, then normalize to [-1, 1] for c in numeric_cols: lower = np.nanpercentile(df[c], 1) upper = np.nanpercentile(df[c], 99) df[c] = np.clip(df[c], lower, upper) # clip outliers # normalize to [-1, 1] df[c] = 2 * (df[c] - df[c].min()) / (df[c].max() - df[c].min()) - 1

    This ensures:

    Outliers beyond the 1st and 99th percentile are clipped.

    The remaining values are scaled to the −1 to 1 range linearly.

    Do you want me to integrate this normalization step into the clustering script?

  15. User

    I want you to plot a graph like this one

  16. Assistant

    Yes, these results do make sense after normalization to the −1,1-1, 1−1,1 range:

    Cluster 0 has positive values close to +1 across all features → this likely represents the high group on all metrics.

    Cluster 1 has values near −1 → the low group across all metrics.

    Cluster 2 has mixed values: some high (e.g., participation, internal cohesion) and some near zero → maybe a moderate or mixed group.

    Cluster 3 sits between 0 and ±1 → a moderate cluster, leaning positive for some features.

    Since you normalized each feature independently:

    +1 ≈ the upper extreme of that feature (close to 99th percentile).

    −1 ≈ the lower extreme (close to 1st percentile).

    0 ≈ the middle range.

    So your centroids are consistent with meaningful clusters in the normalized space. If you want, I can show you how to visualize these centroids to interpret the clusters better. Would you like me to add that?

  17. User

    add the number of rows in each cluster

  18. Assistant

    Got it—you want a cluster centroid plot similar to the one in your image. We can use your centroid dataframe and create a grouped bar chart in Matplotlib. Here’s a code snippet that does this: pythonCopy codeimport matplotlib.pyplot as plt import numpy as np

    Assuming centroids is a DataFrame with columns = features and rows = clusters

    features = centroids.columns clusters = centroids.index n_clusters = len(clusters) n_features = len(features)

    Set positions for each cluster group

    bar_width = 0.12 x = np.arange(n_clusters)

    Plot each feature's bar

    plt.figure(figsize=(10, 6)) for i, feature in enumerate(features): plt.bar(x + i*bar_width, centroids[feature], width=bar_width, label=feature)

    Adjust x-axis ticks to the center of the group

    plt.xticks(x + bar_width * (n_features-1)/2, [f"Cluster {c+1}" for c in clusters]) plt.xlabel("Clusters") plt.ylabel("Centroids for each cluster") plt.title("Cluster Centroids across Features") plt.legend() plt.grid(axis='y', linestyle='--', alpha=0.7)

    plt.tight_layout() plt.show()

    This will produce a grouped bar chart just like your example, with each cluster on the x-axis and bars for each feature's centroid value. Do you want me to also add the normalized range lines (like −1 and +1) for better interpretation?