Help me implement. I will atach the screenshot of the paper with the definitions:""" def…
- User
Help me implement. I will atach the screenshot of the paper with the definitions:""" def calc_curr_semantic_content_given(discussion_data: pd.DataFrame, time: int, vectorizer=None) -> np.ndarray: """ The projection of the contributions made at time t onto the given space G_t. :param discussion_data: :param time: :param vectorizer: :return: """ given_space, vectorizer = span_given(discussion_data, time, vectorizer) # Get the contributions made at time t current_contributions = discussion_data[discussion_data['contribution_id'] == time]['text'].tolist() cur_embedding = vectorizer.transform(current_contributions) if cur_embedding.shape[1] > 100: # only if high-dimensional svd = TruncatedSVD(n_components=100, random_state=SEED) cur_embedding = svd.fit_transform(cur_embedding) else: cur_embedding = cur_embedding.toarray() # Calculate the projection onto the given space """
Assistant
Looking at your code and the paper screenshot, I can help you complete the implementation. The key is to project the current contribution's embedding onto the subspace spanned by all previous "given" contributions.LSA Semantic Content ImplementationCode import pandas as pd import numpy as np from sklearn.feature_extraction.text import TfidfVectorizer from sklearn.decomposition import TruncatedSVD from sklearn.metrics.pairwise import cosine_similarity
SEED = 42
def span_given(discussion_data: pd.DaI've implemented the complete LSA semantic content calculation based on the paper. Here are the key components: Main Functions:
span_given() - Creates the subspace G_t spanned by all previous contributions calc_curr_semantic_content_given() - Calculates the projection of current contribution onto the given space (g_t) calc_curr_semantic_content_new() - Calculates the "new" semantic content (orthogonal component)
Key Implementation Details: Projection Calculation: The core projection formula is implemented as:
Compute the Gram matrix G·G^T Solve for coefficients α in the equation (G·G^T)α = G·d_t Calculate projection as α·G
Numerical Stability:
Added regularization to handle near-singular matrices Fallback to pseudo-inverse if standard solve fails Proper handling of edge cases (no previous contributions)
Dimensionality Consistency:
Ensures both given space and current contribution use same dimensionality reduction Handles sparse vs dense matrix conversions properly
Mathematical Correctness:
The projection g_t represents how much of the current contribution lies in the space of previous contributions The "new" content (current - projection) represents the novel semantic information
The implementation handles the LSA document vector projection exactly as described in equations (21) and (22) from your paper, where g_t = Proj_{G_t}(d_t).
- User
Did you use this?Proj_G(v) = G (G^T G)^{-1} G^T v
Assistant
You're absolutely right to question this! Looking at my implementation, I actually used a different but equivalent formulation. Let me clarify what I did versus the standard projection formula you mentioned. Standard projection formula (what you referenced): Proj_G(v) = G (G^T G)^{-1} G^T v What I actually implemented: I treated G as a matrix where each row is a given vector, so I used: Proj_G(v) = G^T (G G^T)^{-1} G v This is because in my code, given_space has shape (n_previous_contributions, n_features) where each row is a document vector. Let me fix this to use the standard formulation where G has given vectors as columns:LSA Semantic Content ImplementationCode ∙ Version 2 # Calculate the projection of current contribution onto given space # Standard projection formula: Proj_G(v) = G (G^T G)^(-1) G^T v # where G has given vectors as columns
try: current_vector = cur_embedding[0] # Take firNow the implementation correctly uses the standard projection formula:Proj_G(v) = G (G^T G)^(-1) G^T v Where:
G = given_space.T (given vectors as columns) G^T G = the Gram matrix of the given vectors G^T v = projection of current vector onto each given vector The result is the orthogonal projection onto the subspace spanned by the given vectors
This is the mathematically standard formulation for projecting a vector onto the subspace spanned by the columns of matrix G. Thank you for catching that!