I the cross-cohesion matrix symmetric?
- User
I the cross-cohesion matrix symmetric?
- Assistant
The Responsivity matrix in the paper is not symmetric because it measures directional semantic relatedness in conversation. Here’s why:
Each cell rabr_{ab}rab in the responsivity matrix represents how much participant aaa responds to participant bbb across a window of prior contributions (Eq. 17 in the paper).
This is based on the semantic similarity between what aaa says and what bbb said earlier.
Importantly, rabr_{ab}rab ≠ rbar_{ba}rba because the roles of initiator and responder are reversed:
rabr_{ab}rab: Did aaa build on bbb’s ideas?
rbar_{ba}rba: Did bbb build on aaa’s ideas?
So if aaa frequently responds to bbb, but bbb rarely responds to aaa, the matrix will be asymmetric. This is very similar to a directed graph: edges represent influence or uptake in one direction, and two nodes don’t need to reciprocate equally. If you want, I can draw a simple example showing why this asymmetry happens mathematically and visually. Would you like me to do that?