Why doesm't the US and Israel have social security tax treaty?
- User
Why doesm't the US and Israel have social security tax treaty?
- Assistant
The United States and Israel do not have a totalization agreement (often called a Social Security tax treaty) because, although the two countries have a broad income tax treaty (in effect since 1975, with updates), they have never successfully negotiated a separate agreement covering Social Security. Here’s why:
- Different Social Security Structures
The U.S. Social Security system is funded primarily through payroll taxes (FICA), covering retirement, disability, and survivor benefits.
Israel’s system is run by the National Insurance Institute (Bituach Leumi), which has somewhat different eligibility rules, contribution structures, and benefit formulas.
Aligning these two systems legally and financially is complex, especially since benefits and tax bases don’t match neatly.
- Totalization Agreement Purpose The U.S. signs totalization agreements with countries to:
Prevent double Social Security taxation (when both countries require contributions on the same wages).
Allow workers who divide their careers between two countries to combine credits for benefits. The U.S. currently has agreements with about 30 countries (like Canada, UK, Germany, Japan), but not Israel.
- Geopolitical & Policy Priorities
Even though the U.S. and Israel are close allies, Social Security coordination has not been a policy priority compared to military, trade, and security cooperation.
Negotiating a totalization agreement requires long, technical discussions between both nations’ social insurance administrations. These talks have either not been pursued seriously or have stalled.
- Tax Treaty vs. Social Security
The U.S.–Israel income tax treaty (1975) covers things like dividends, royalties, pensions, and double income taxation.
But Social Security taxes are not included in most income tax treaties, because they are considered social contributions rather than income taxes. That’s why a separate totalization agreement is needed, and why the absence of one creates the current gap.
👉 In practice, this means that if you work in both countries, you may be required to pay into both U.S. Social Security and Israeli Bituach Leumi, with no way to combine credits or avoid double payment — unlike in countries with a U.S. totalization agreement. Would you like me to break down what this means for U.S. citizens working in Israel (or Israelis working in the U.S.) in terms of double contributions and retirement eligibility?