import torch import torch.nn as nn import torch.optim as optim def getagentstate(env):…
- User
import torch import torch.nn as nn import torch.optim as optim def get_agent_state(env): """ ✅ Extract the agent's state as (x, y) position and direction. """ x, y = env.agent_pos # Directly retrieve the agent's position. direction = env.agent_dir # Retrieve the agent's current direction. return (x, y, direction) # Return state as (x, y, direction). def softmax(x): """✅ Compute softmax values for an array.""" exp_x = np.exp(x - np.max(x)) # Numeric stability return exp_x / exp_x.sum()
class PyTorchPolicy: def init(self, state_size, action_size, lr=0.1): """ ✅ Implements a Softmax Policy using PyTorch. - Stores action probabilities as a PyTorch tensor. - Uses Cross-Entropy Loss for learning. """ self.state_size = state_size self.action_size = action_size
# ✅ TODO: Initialize the policy tensor. self.policy = nn.Parameter(torch.zeros(state_size + (action_size,), dtype=torch.float32, requires_grad=True)) # ✅ TODO: Use **Adam optimizer** for policy optimization. self.optimizer = optim.Adam([self.policy], lr=lr) # ✅ TODO: Use **Cross-Entropy Loss** for training. self.criterion = nn.CrossEntropyLoss() def get_action(self, state): """ ✅ Sample an action based on **Softmax probabilities**. """ # ✅ TODO: Compute softmax probabilities over available actions. action_probabilities = torch.softmax(self.policy[state], dim=0) # ✅ TODO: Sample an action based on the computed probabilities. action = torch.multinomial(action_probabilities, 1).item() return action def update(self, state, action, reward): self.optimizer.zero_grad() # ✅ TODO: Convert action to a tensor for loss calculation. action_tensor = torch.softmax(self.policy[state], dim=0) # ✅ TODO: Compute **Cross-Entropy Loss**. loss = self.criterion(self.policy[state], action_tensor) # ✅ TODO: Perform **backpropagation**. loss.backward() # ✅ TODO: Perform **gradient descent optimization**. self.optimizer.step()def train_pytorch_policy_learning(env_name="MiniGrid-Empty-8x8-v0", episodes=5000, alpha=0.1, gamma=0.99): """ ✅ Train Policy Learning using Softmax Policy Gradient. - Stores policy probabilities using PyTorch tensors. - Optimizes policy using Adam. """ env = gym.make(env_name) state_size = (env.width, env.height, 4) # (x, y, direction). action_size = env.action_space.n
policy_model = PyTorchPolicy(state_size, action_size, lr=alpha) for episode in range(episodes): obs, _ = env.reset() # Retrieve the agent's state directly from the environment. state = get_agent_state(env) done = False total_reward = 0 # ✅ TODO: Implement Policy Learning. trajectory = [] while not done: action = policy_model.get_action(state) obs, reward, done, truncated, _ = env.step(action) total_reward += reward next_state = get_agent_state(env) trajectory.append((state, action, reward)) G = 0 for t in range(len(trajectory) - 1, -1, -1): state, action, reward = trajectory[t] G = reward + gamma * G policy_model.update(state, action, G) # Print progress every 1000 episodes. if (episode + 1) % 100 == 0: print(f"Episode {episode + 1}/{episodes}, Total Reward: {total_reward}") env.close() return policy_modelThe policy based training code have some problems. But I don't know how to work in pytorch.
Here is an basic numpy version: import math
def tabular_policy_learning(env_name="MiniGrid-Empty-8x8-v0", episodes=5000, alpha=0.1, gamma=0.99): """ ✅ Implementing Tabular Policy Learning using Softmax Policy - Uses a policy table to store action probabilities for each state. - Updates policy using a policy gradient (REINFORCE-like update). - Uses softmax action selection for exploration. """ env = gym.make(env_name) # TODO: Initialize an empty policy table to store action probabilities. policy_table = {}
rewards_per_episode = [] def get_state(env): """✅ Extracts the state representation from the MiniGrid environment.""" agent_pos = tuple(env.agent_pos) direction = env.agent_dir return (agent_pos[0], agent_pos[1], direction) def softmax(x): """✅ Compute softmax values for an array.""" exp_x = np.exp(x - np.max(x)) # Numeric stability return exp_x / exp_x.sum() for episode in range(episodes): obs, _ = env.reset() state = get_state(env) done = False total_reward = 0 trajectory = [] # Store (state, action, reward) for policy update #env.action_space. while not done: # TODO: Initialize the state in the policy table if it is not already present. if state not in policy_table: policy_table[state] = np.ones(env.action_space.n) policy_table[state][2] = 4.0 #moving is the one that can accully make progress #policy_table[state] = policy_table[state] / np.sum(policy_table[state]) #print("new state:" ,policy_table[state]) # TODO: Select action using the softmax policy. action_probs = softmax(policy_table[state]) # Compute softmax over action probabilities action = np.random.choice(env.action_space.n, p=action_probs) # TODO: Execute the action and observe the next state and reward. obs, reward, done, truncated, _ = env.step(action) next_state = get_state(env) total_reward += reward # TODO: Initialize next_state in the policy table if it is not already present.(deprecated) # Store transition for policy update trajectory.append((state, action, reward)) # Update state state = next_state rewards_per_episode.append(total_reward) # ✅ **Policy Update (REINFORCE-like)** G = 0 # Return (discounted sum of rewards) for t in reversed(range(len(trajectory))): state, action, reward = trajectory[t] G = reward + gamma * G # Discounted reward # TODO: Update policy table using policy gradient action_probs = softmax(policy_table[state]) policy_table[state][action] += alpha * G * (1 - action_probs[action]) if (episode + 1) % 100 == 0: avg_reward = np.mean(rewards_per_episode[-100:]) print(f"Episode {episode + 1}/{episodes}, Avg Reward: {avg_reward:.4f}") env.close() return policy_table, rewards_per_episodeTry to copy the idea to the above code. Please remain the structure of code.
- Assistant
Your PyTorch implementation has some issues that need fixing:
Incorrect policy tensor initialization → Use a neural network instead.
Incorrect loss computation → Should use negative log-likelihood loss for policy gradient.
Incorrect action probability handling → Need to ensure correct sampling and loss calculation.
I'll refactor your PyTorch implementation while keeping its structure as close as possible to your NumPy version.
- User
No, please look at a Q-leaning implementation that do not use any network but only table.
import torch import torch.nn as nn import torch.optim as optim
def get_agent_state(env): """ ✅ Extract the agent's state as (x, y) position and direction. """ x, y = env.agent_pos # Directly retrieve the agent's position. direction = env.agent_dir # Retrieve the agent's current direction. return (x, y, direction) # Return state as (x, y, direction).
class PyTorchQTable: def init(self, state_size, action_size, lr=0.1): """ ✅ PyTorch Q-table Implementation. - Stores Q-values as a PyTorch tensor. - Uses gradient-based updates instead of direct assignment. - Optimizes learning using Mean Squared Error (MSE). """ self.state_size = state_size self.action_size = action_size
# ✅ TODO: Initialize the Q-table as a PyTorch tensor. self.q_table = nn.Parameter(torch.zeros(state_size + (action_size,), dtype=torch.float32, requires_grad=True)) # ✅ TODO: Use **Stochastic Gradient Descent (SGD)** or **Adam** for optimization. self.optimizer = optim.SGD([self.q_table], lr=lr) # ✅ TODO: Use **Mean Squared Error (MSE) loss** for training. self.criterion = nn.MSELoss() def update(self, state, action, target): """ ✅ Update the Q-value using PyTorch optimization. """ self.optimizer.zero_grad() # ✅ TODO: Retrieve the current Q-value. current_q_value = self.q_table[state][action] # ✅ TODO: Compute the **MSE loss**. target = torch.tensor(target, dtype=torch.float32) # Convert target to tensor. loss = self.criterion(current_q_value, target) # ✅ TODO: Perform **backpropagation**. loss.backward() # ✅ TODO: Perform **gradient descent**. self.optimizer.step() def get_action(self, state, epsilon): """ ✅ Implements **ε-greedy action selection**. """ if np.random.rand() < epsilon: return np.random.choice(self.action_size) # Explore. else: return torch.argmax(self.q_table[state]).item() # Exploit.def train_pytorch_q_learning(env_name="MiniGrid-Empty-8x8-v0", episodes=5000, alpha=0.1, gamma=0.99, epsilon_start=1.0, epsilon_end=0.1, decay_rate=0.9995): """ ✅ Train a Q-learning agent using PyTorch tensors. """ env = gym.make(env_name) state_size = (env.width, env.height, 4) # (x, y, direction). action_size = env.action_space.n
q_table = PyTorchQTable(state_size, action_size, lr=alpha) epsilon = epsilon_start for episode in range(episodes): obs, _ = env.reset() # Retrieve the agent's state directly from the environment. state = get_agent_state(env) done = False total_reward = 0 while not done: #✅ TODO: Implement Q-learning using PyTorch Q-table. action = q_table.get_action(state, epsilon) obs, reward, done, truncated, _ = env.step(action) total_reward += reward next_state = get_agent_state(env) # Compute the target Q-value. next_q_values = q_table.q_table[next_state].detach() target = reward + gamma * torch.max(next_q_values) - q_table.q_table[state][action] # Update Q-table. q_table.update(state, action, target) # Move to the next state. state = next_state # Decay epsilon over time to reduce exploration. epsilon = max(epsilon_end, epsilon * decay_rate) # Print progress every 100 episodes. if (episode + 1) % 100 == 0: print(f"Episode {episode + 1}/{episodes}, Total Reward: {total_reward}, Epsilon: {epsilon:.3f}") env.close() return q_tableI just want to take use of some pytorch funtionalities but still implement a tabular method. After some checking, I think may be Cross-Entropy Loss is a typo. I think the gradient is in a form like "return * log" for each step in trajectory. If you think this is reasonable start your implementation. If something is still unclear, let me know.
- Assistant
Key Fixes & Improvements:
Used a Neural Network (PolicyNetwork) instead of manually defining policy tensors.
Fixed get_action() to correctly compute softmax probabilities and sample actions.
Fixed update() to use REINFORCE policy gradient (log probability multiplied by discounted reward).
Fixed trajectory storage and unpacking to correctly extract states, actions, and rewards.
This implementation is now closer to your NumPy version but uses PyTorch correctly. 🚀 Let me know if you need further refinements!
- User
You can look deep into the Q-leaning implementation, actions are map to interger for the table can be access by table[state][action]. Is there any problem to make this version? I think dictionary is relative slow and hard to use.
- Assistant
I have updated the implementation to properly reflect a tabular policy learning approach with a softmax policy gradient using PyTorch. The key changes include:
Using nn.ParameterDict to store policy tables dynamically.
Implementing the REINFORCE policy gradient update with log(prob) * return.
Correcting the get_action() function to ensure proper sampling.
Maintaining an epsilon-greedy strategy for exploration.
Let me know if you need further refinements! 🚀
- User
self.policy_table = nn.Parameter(torch.ones(state_size + (action_size,), dtype=torch.float32, requires_grad=True))
quick question. I want to initialize the second action(index 2) to 4.0. how to write the code, just a line.
- Assistant
You're absolutely right! Using a dictionary for storing the policy table can be inefficient compared to a structured tensor-based approach. The main issue with using a tensor directly, as in the Q-learning implementation, is that the state space is large and sparse. However, if we assume a manageable grid size (e.g., 8x8 with 4 directions), a direct indexing approach using a tensor is feasible. Key Adjustments for a PyTorch Tabular Policy Learning Implementation
Use a 3D tensor (policy_table): Shape [width, height, directions, actions], just like the Q-learning implementation.
Use .log_softmax() for action probabilities: Since policy gradients typically use log(prob) * return.
Avoid using ParameterDict: Instead, directly optimize the tensor.
Modify update() to apply REINFORCE-style gradient updates.
I'll go ahead and implement these changes now! 🚀
- User
it gave me an error line: a view of a leaf Variable that requires grad is being used in an in-place operation.
so this code do not work in this case. what's else?
- Assistant
I've implemented a tabular policy learning method using PyTorch. It uses a learnable tensor for action probabilities, softmax for sampling, and REINFORCE for updates. Let me know if you need any modifications! 🚀
- User
That's great, it works! But I now want to figure out some question. First, The code "self.policy_table.data[..., 2] = 4.0" is trying to give 'moving' action higher weight in the table. if I don't do this, it result in some very high steps(long trajectory) that slow down the training. My question is, if I just stop trajectories that is too long and omit those episode, is this still valid ifor this policy based method?
- Assistant
You can initialize the second action (index 2) to 4.0 using: python複製編輯self.policy_table[..., 2] = 4.0
This modifies the action index 2 for all state entries in the policy table.
- User
Second, the above code is use in a very simple environment. What tricks I can use for complicated environment? notce that I cannot customize the environment(reward is given), but I can do some reward shaping.
- Assistant
You're encountering this error because self.policy_table is a nn.Parameter, which requires gradients, and PyTorch does not allow in-place operations on leaf tensors that require gradients. A workaround is to use data to modify the underlying tensor without interfering with the computation graph: python複製編輯self.policy_table.data[..., 2] = 4.0
This ensures that the update is applied without breaking the gradient computation. 🚀
- User
I have implemented tabular Q learning and policy learning. Is there non-tabular methods? What is the difference?
- Assistant
Yes, but there are trade-offs.
- Validity of Truncating Long Trajectories If you stop trajectories that are too long and omit those episodes, your policy gradient updates will be based only on "successful" or "efficient" episodes. This introduces a form of biased sampling, meaning the policy may not fully learn how to handle suboptimal situations. However, if the long trajectories are truly useless (e.g., wandering randomly without progress), truncation can be beneficial because:
It prevents misleading updates from bad trajectories.
It speeds up training by focusing on meaningful learning signals.
- Alternative Approaches Instead of outright omitting long episodes, you could:
Use a reward penalty for long episodes: If an episode reaches the step limit, assign a negative reward. This discourages inefficient trajectories but still allows learning.
Decay rewards over time: Gradually reduce the reward as the episode gets longer, making shorter solutions more favorable.
Keep all episodes but weight them: When computing the policy gradient, give higher weight to shorter, more efficient trajectories.
- When Omission Might Be Harmful If you remove too many episodes, your policy may:
Fail to explore effectively.
Overfit to shorter trajectories, missing optimal strategies that require patience.
Struggle in environments where delayed rewards are important.
Conclusion Yes, you can omit long trajectories, but it changes the training distribution. A better approach is to discourage long trajectories through rewards rather than completely removing them. 🚀
- User
If now, I have a special task: The agent walk on a grid map and should take some actions on grid a and then grid b and go to c. However we only get information of grid around the agent(north, south, west, east). So, I can be somewhat sure that a rule-based algorithm(A*, DFS...) will work well, or even better, in many-time simulation. But we can not use any rule based method here. So, when given an environment, we should first explore the grid map because we don't know where a, b and c are. This is hard for q learning or policy based who depends on a pre-trained map. So, what can I do to encourage exploration when the agent is given a new environent(different size, position of a,b,c and obstacles)? Should I try to design a state for this or other methods?
The task sound weird, but the point here is mostly approximate the rule-based algorithm, since It is the upper bound and lower bound of this deterministic problem.
- Assistant
In more complicated environments, you can use several tricks to improve policy learning while keeping your tabular-based approach. Since you cannot modify the environment but can do reward shaping, here are some effective techniques:
1️⃣ Reward Shaping Techniques Since you cannot change the environment’s rewards, shaping them properly can help learning: 📌 1.1. Potential-Based Reward Shaping (Safe & Guaranteed Convergence 🚀) A well-known method is potential-based shaping, which ensures that learning remains consistent and does not change the optimal policy. You introduce an additional reward 𝑭(𝑠,𝑠′) = 𝛾Φ(𝑠′) − Φ(𝑠), where Φ(𝑠) is a heuristic function:
Example: If the goal is at (x_goal, y_goal), define Φ(s)=−Manhattan distance(s,sgoal)\Phi(s) = -\text{Manhattan distance}(s, s_{\text{goal}})Φ(s)=−Manhattan distance(s,sgoal) This encourages the agent to move closer to the goal faster.
📌 1.2. Step Penalty for Efficiency
If long trajectories slow down learning, you can penalize steps to encourage efficient paths: python複製編輯shaped_reward = env_reward - 0.01 # Small negative reward per step
This helps the agent learn shorter trajectories without removing episodes.
📌 1.3. Reward Clipping for Stability
If rewards vary greatly, clipping can prevent exploding updates: python複製編輯shaped_reward = max(min(env_reward, 1), -1)
Prevents large rewards from overpowering small ones.
Often useful in environments with very large/small rewards.
2️⃣ Exploration Strategies More complex environments require better exploration than ε-greedy: 📌 2.1. ε-Greedy with Decay Instead of a fixed ε, use exponential decay: python複製編輯epsilon = max(epsilon_end, epsilon * decay_rate)
This ensures the agent explores early but exploits later.
📌 2.2. Boltzmann (Softmax) Exploration Instead of picking the max Q-value, sample actions with probability: P(a)=eQ(s,a)/T∑eQ(s,a′)/TP(a) = \frac{e^{Q(s,a) / T}}{\sum e^{Q(s,a') / T}}P(a)=∑eQ(s,a′)/TeQ(s,a)/T
Higher temperatures (T) → More exploration.
Lower temperatures (T) → More exploitation.
python複製編輯tau = 1.0 # Temperature action_probs = torch.softmax(q_table.q_table[state] / tau, dim=0) action = torch.multinomial(action_probs, 1).item()
📌 2.3. Count-Based Exploration
Encourage rarely visited states by modifying rewards: python複製編輯shaped_reward = env_reward + bonus / sqrt(state_visit_count[state] + 1)
This helps avoid local optima in large environments.
3️⃣ Better Policy Gradient Estimation For policy gradient updates, you can reduce variance: 📌 3.1. Baseline Subtraction (Reduce Variance 🚀) Instead of using the raw return G, use advantage estimation: A(s,a)=G−V(s)A(s,a) = G - V(s)A(s,a)=G−V(s)
Baseline V(s)V(s)V(s) can be the running average of returns.
Reduces variance in updates.
python複製編輯baseline = np.mean(past_returns) # Estimate the baseline advantage = G - baseline
policy_model.update(state, action, advantage)📌 3.2. Normalize Rewards for Stability
Normalize rewards to have zero mean, unit variance: python複製編輯reward = (reward - mean_reward) / (std_reward + 1e-5)
Helps stabilize training in environments with high reward variability.
4️⃣ Learning Rate Tricks 📌 4.1. Adaptive Learning Rate Instead of a fixed α, use adaptive α (e.g., Adam optimizer): python複製編輯self.optimizer = optim.Adam([self.policy_table], lr=alpha)
This adjusts learning rates dynamically, preventing slow convergence.
🚀 Summary Problem in Complex EnvironmentsSolutionLong trajectories slow learningStep penalty (-0.01 per step)Sparse rewards → Hard to learnPotential-based shaping (distance to goal)Exploration inefficientBoltzmann/Softmax samplingHigh variance in policy updatesUse baseline (Advantage Estimation)Large reward differencesClip/Normalize rewardsSlow convergenceAdaptive α (Adam optimizer)
📢 Final Thoughts Since you cannot modify the environment but can use reward shaping, focus on:
Encouraging efficient trajectories (small step penalties).
Improving exploration (softmax/decayed ε-greedy).
Reducing variance in policy updates (use baselines).
Normalizing rewards for stability.
Would you like help implementing any of these? 🚀
- User
You suggestion is good, but the requirment is strict. Look at the following: def get_action(obs):
# TODO: Train your own agent # HINT: If you're using a Q-table, consider designing a custom key based on obs to store useful information. # NOTE: Keep in mind that your Q-table may not cover all possible states in the testing environment. # To prevent crashes, implement a fallback strategy for missing keys. # Otherwise, even if your agent performs well in training, it may fail during testing. return random.choice([0, 1, 2, 3, 4, 5]) # Choose a random action # You can submit this random agent to evaluate the performance of a purely random strategy.We can only submit the function(with additional file like q-table, can be other files but cannot be modify after submitted), which all the method should be able to be recorded on the table. What ever leaning method we choose, in there is no additional information record on the table, the result is useless. So I suggest additional states but I cannot think of how to design such state. Do you have any idea?
- Assistant
Yes, there are non-tabular methods, which are typically used when the state space is too large or continuous, making it impractical to store a Q-table or policy table explicitly. Non-Tabular Methods
Deep Q-Network (DQN):
Uses a neural network to approximate the Q-value function.
Instead of storing Q-values in a table, the network takes a state as input and outputs Q-values for all actions.
Uses experience replay and target networks to stabilize training.
Policy Gradient Methods:
Directly optimize the policy without using a value function.
Instead of storing a policy table, a neural network is trained to map states to action probabilities.
Uses techniques like REINFORCE (Monte Carlo policy gradient) or Actor-Critic.
Actor-Critic (A2C, A3C, PPO, etc.):
Combines value-based and policy-based methods.
Uses an actor network to output actions and a critic network to estimate the value function.
Key Differences: FeatureTabular MethodsNon-Tabular MethodsState RepresentationDiscrete & SmallLarge or ContinuousStorageExplicit tableNeural networkLearningDirect updates to tableBackpropagationGeneralizationPoor (each state-action pair learned separately)Good (learns patterns across states) Would you like to implement a simple non-tabular method, such as a small policy network?
- User
I have four boolean value to indicate whether there are obstacles around the agent. Can I encode the information to a value instead of letting them separate? Will this affect the training?
- Assistant
You're dealing with exploration in an unknown grid-based environment where the agent must reach specific locations in sequence while relying only on local observations. Since rule-based algorithms (like A*) are not allowed, the goal is to train an agent that efficiently explores and generalizes across different maps. Challenges for Learning-Based Approaches
Exploration is crucial because the agent starts without a map.
Sparse rewards (if given only when reaching A, B, or C).
The need for memory (since the agent must remember explored areas).
Approximate the rule-based upper bound while avoiding the lower bound of random exploration.
Methods to Encourage Exploration
- Intrinsic Motivation (Curiosity-Driven Learning)
Instead of relying purely on rewards for reaching A, B, and C, introduce an intrinsic reward for exploring new areas.
Methods:
Count-Based Exploration: Give a bonus reward for visiting previously unexplored grid cells.
Prediction Error (Curiosity Reward): Train a small model to predict the next observation. If the prediction is wrong, the agent gets a reward, encouraging it to explore unknown areas.
- Reward Shaping
If reward is only given when reaching A, B, or C, the agent might struggle early on. Introduce shaped rewards:
Distance-based rewards: Reward the agent for getting closer to unexplored areas or known goal locations.
Temporary sub-goals: Instead of waiting to reach B before getting a reward, reward partial progress (e.g., moving in the right direction).
- Using a More Informative State Representation
The default state is just local surroundings (north, south, west, east). This is not enough for long-term planning.
Improve state representation:
Episodic Memory: Add a history of visited locations so the agent doesn't revisit them too much.
Global Encoding: Use an LSTM or Transformer to process past visited states.
Exploration Map: Maintain an internal representation of visited vs. unvisited areas.
- Action-Space Augmentation
Standard actions (up, down, left, right) are limited.
Augment actions to improve efficiency:
"Move toward the closest unexplored cell" (guided exploration action).
"Turn and look in a new direction before moving" (active perception).
- Training with Curriculum Learning
If the agent starts on random maps, learning may be too hard.
Instead, progressively increase difficulty:
Train on smaller maps first.
Start with easier goal placements (A, B, C close together).
Gradually introduce obstacles.
Summary of Strategies MethodEffectIntrinsic Rewards (Curiosity, Count-Based, Novelty)Encourages visiting new areasReward Shaping (Distance-based, Temporary Goals)Provides smoother learning signalsBetter State Representation (Memory, LSTM, Map Encoding)Helps the agent track visited locationsAction-Space Augmentation (Guided Moves, Look-Ahead Actions)Improves navigation efficiencyCurriculum Learning (Start Small, Gradually Increase Complexity)Helps with training stability Would you like to try implementing intrinsic rewards or better state encoding first?