Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
ChatGPT (model unspecified)· OpenAIHugging Face ShareLM (browser-extension contributions)

is this a error, as this was genrated as carlini on bloodmnsit

  1. User

    is this a error, as this was genrated as carlini on bloodmnsit

  2. Assistant

    From the tiny preview, it looks like a small, zoomed-in, noisy medical image — likely one cell from the BloodMNIST dataset — but with distortions or unusual outlines (like the green border) that could be the result of an adversarial perturbation. If you generated this using the Carlini & Wagner (C&W) attack on BloodMNIST, then yes — that “unnatural” greenish outline and the slightly warped texture are signs the image has been intentionally modified to fool a classifier while still being mostly recognizable to humans. It’s not an error in the sense of code failure — it’s just that adversarial attacks can produce strange pixel artifacts that don’t occur in the original dataset. If you want, I can check exactly how different this is from the original BloodMNIST sample it came from by computing the pixel-wise difference and visualizing the perturbation. That would confirm whether it’s behaving as intended for a C&W adversarial example. Do you want me to do that?

  3. User

    but carlini mean no change visuaklly, right

  4. Assistant

    Exactly — the Carlini & Wagner (C&W) attack is designed so that the perturbations are imperceptible to the human eye. If you’re seeing something as obvious as a bright green outline or visible distortions, that’s not typical for a correctly tuned C&W attack. It usually means one of two things happened:

    Perturbation scale (ε or confidence) is too high – The attack is allowed to make bigger changes than necessary, so artifacts become visible.

    Image normalization/denormalization issue – If the model expects normalized values (e.g., in [-1, 1] or [0, 1]) but you save the adversarial image without converting back, pixel values can clip into strange colors.

    Colormap or channel mismatch – Medical datasets like BloodMNIST are single-channel (grayscale) but may have been saved/displayed as RGB, leading to odd color effects.

    A properly tuned C&W on BloodMNIST should still look like the original cell image, with no obvious colored borders. If you want, I can walk you through how to make C&W truly imperceptible on BloodMNIST by adjusting the attack’s parameters and fixing possible normalization mistakes. That way, you’ll get the classic “same to the human eye, deadly to the model” result.

  5. User

    i used 0.1 for 1000 iter

  6. Assistant

    Yep — 0.1 for 1000 iters (I’m assuming that’s your step size / learning rate) is almost certainly the culprit. C&W relies on small, finely-tuned steps; a large step over many iterations will create visible artifacts instead of imperceptible perturbations. What to check & quick fixes

    Learning rate too large

    Try lr = 0.01 or 0.001 (keep max_iter=1000 if you want many steps).

    If you used 0.1 as the optimization constant c, that’s different — still tune c with a small search (common values: 1e-3 → 1e2 depending on scale).

    Normalization / Denormalization bug

    Model usually expects normalized tensor (mean/std or [0,1]→[-1,1]). If you save the adversarial tensor without properly denormalizing to [0,1] (or [0,255]), you’ll see odd colors/clipping.

    Always undo whatever preprocessing you applied before imshow/save.

    Channel mismatch (grayscale → RGB)

    BloodMNIST is single-channel. If you convert incorrectly to 3-channel (stacking or colormap) it can create color edges. Display the raw single-channel image to check.

    Clip final image to valid range

    After generating adv, clip: adv = torch.clamp(adv, min=0.0, max=1.0) (if using [0,1] range).

    Visualize the perturbation (quick diagnostic)

    If pert = adv - orig, compute pert.max(), pert.min(), ||pert||_2 to see magnitude. For truly imperceptible C&W, pert.max() should be very small (<< 0.1 in [0,1] scale).

    Handy PyTorch snippets Denorm & save (assumes orig and adv in tensor range [0,1] or normalized — adapt to your pipeline): pythonCopyEditimport torch import numpy as np from PIL import Image

    if model used mean/std normalization, undo it:

    mean = torch.tensor([...]) ; std = torch.tensor([...])

    adv_denorm = adv * std[:,None,None] + mean[:,None,None]

    if already in [0,1]:

    adv_clipped = torch.clamp(adv, 0.0, 1.0).cpu().numpy() # shape C,H,W

    if grayscale single-channel:

    img = (adv_clipped[0] * 255).as*_

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.