Do lyrics of a public song have a copyrihgt preventing training a machine learning model…
- User
Do lyrics of a public song have a copyrihgt preventing training a machine learning model on them (LLM)
Assistant
Yes, song lyrics typically have strong copyright protection that can restrict their use in training machine learning models, including LLMs. Here's the key information: Copyright Protection of Lyrics:
Song lyrics are considered literary works under copyright law They're protected even when the song is widely known or "public" in the sense of being popular Copyright typically lasts for the life of the author plus 70 years (in the US and many other countries) Both the lyrics and musical composition can have separate copyrights
Training Data Implications:
Using copyrighted lyrics to train an LLM without permission could constitute copyright infringement The scale of use in training datasets doesn't automatically qualify as fair use Even if lyrics are publicly available online, that doesn't mean they can be freely used for commercial training purposes
Current Legal Landscape:
This is an evolving area of law with ongoing litigation Some argue that training on copyrighted material constitutes fair use for transformative purposes Others contend that commercial LLM training infringes on creators' rights Courts are still working through these questions
Industry Response:
Many AI companies are increasingly seeking licensed training data Some are developing "opt-out" mechanisms for content creators There's growing focus on using public domain or specifically licensed content
The safest approach for training models is to use content that's either in the public domain, specifically licensed for such use, or covered by clear fair use guidelines - though the latter remains legally uncertain for large-scale commercial training.