What writing suggestions would you have on the following short research statement that…
- User
What writing suggestions would you have on the following short research statement that aims to convince the research is exciting and would require the compute stated? My research group will focus on building pretrained AI models for academic needs. Doing so is crucial for academia, not only in computer science, as demonstrated by the recent Nobel Prizes in Chemistry and Physics. However, the industry, which has been the leading force in the development of AI models, is not incentivized to pursue it (due to academic nature, high risk, or long-term research needed). My research plan includes ambitious technical goals, including pretraining with modest resources, low availability of data, pretraining that supports modularity (see scenario 2) and tackling issues not commonly addressed in industrial pretraining (e.g., ensuring a model of 1800-1900 scholarly knowledge does not contain/leak 1900+ knowledge, which renders it unuseful as a tool for chronological study). While smaller than industry standards, the models we seek to train are still computationally intensive. Current models are trained with 400B parameters on thousands of GPUs, but even training a single 7B parameters’ model would take 10 years-worth of a single top-of-the-line GPU.
My group will pretrain AI for fields currently not dealt with, unlike Biology and Chemistry, and will also offer innovation in pretraining general large language models and devising efficient research methodologies for others to research these areas as well. We will design new architectures, devise data compilation methods and training algorithms in my group, and perhaps more importantly, efficient pretraining research methodologies, allowing academic research on pretraining. However, to show that an efficient method works, one must show that the efficient method consistently gives the same result as the inefficient method, which calls for high computing demands. This requires training multiple models of several sizes (with at least one 1B parameters = 1 GPU year) and repeating the experiments on various settings.
- Assistant
Here are some suggestions to enhance clarity, engagement, and persuasiveness in your research statement:
- Strengthen the Opening
The first sentence could be more engaging. Instead of stating, “My research group will focus on building pretrained AI models for academic needs,” consider something more compelling: Example: "Despite AI's transformative impact, academia lacks pretrained AI models tailored to its unique needs. My research group aims to bridge this gap by developing models optimized for academic inquiry across disciplines."
The connection to the Nobel Prizes in Chemistry and Physics is interesting but feels abrupt. Consider explicitly stating how those awards demonstrate the need for academic AI models.
- Clarify the Problem Statement
The argument about why the industry is not pursuing this is strong, but consider emphasizing the specific gap academia faces. Example: "While industry leads AI development, its focus is on commercial viability, leaving academia underserved. The high risk, long-term nature, and specialized needs of academic research deter industry investment, creating a crucial gap my group will address."
- Make the Technical Challenges and Innovation Clearer
The discussion on pretraining challenges (modular pretraining, historical containment, etc.) is strong but could be more clearly structured. Consider bullet points or breaking them into distinct sentences to improve readability.
The historical AI model example is intriguing but somewhat dense. It might be clearer as: Example: "For example, ensuring that an AI model trained on 1800–1900 scholarly texts does not inadvertently incorporate post-1900 knowledge is a unique challenge in academic AI research. Addressing such constraints is crucial for chronological studies and beyond."
- Justify the Computational Requirements More Strongly
The transition from stating AI model sizes to justifying computational needs could be smoother.
Consider a more compelling phrasing of the computational demand: Example: "State-of-the-art models in industry are trained with 400B parameters on thousands of GPUs. While our models are smaller, training even a 7B-parameter model would require a decade on a single top-tier GPU. To develop efficient pretraining methodologies, we must demonstrate that our optimized approach consistently matches results from traditional, computationally expensive methods. This necessitates training multiple models across various configurations, requiring significant computational power."
- Strengthen the Conclusion
The ending could be more persuasive and forward-looking. Example: "By pioneering efficient pretraining methodologies and architectures, my research group will empower academia with domain-specific AI models and advance the broader field of AI pretraining. This work not only addresses immediate academic needs but also establishes a foundation for sustainable AI research within academia, ensuring long-term innovation beyond the constraints of industry-driven development."
Would you like me to refine the entire statement based on these suggestions and present a revised version?
- User
Offer similar suggestions to:
Given no access to enough high-performance GPUs (scenario 1), which are necessary for creating technologies for new pretrained models, I would fall back to adapting existing models in ways where the research community together can substantially improve them. This is exciting as it offers an avenue for harnessing the unique expertise of different researchers and gradually improving models, just like knowledge is accumulated through decentralized scientific investigation, stepping on the shoulders of giants. While this option is more restrictive than scenario 1, which has the flexibility to create models that are meant to be built on and creating models in places they don’t currently exist, it still offers a potential change in the way language models are perceived, shifting power, incentives and technology from their current course.
Performing such adaptations is less computationally demanding than training models, but still requires training existing models. The adapted models should be quite capable already to manifest capabilities that are worth extending and improving. Thus, it likely calls for adapting at least 7B parameter models and likely 70B models. While adaptation is often much cheaper and more parallelizable, it still requires reasonably large GPUs to allow keeping the models in memory, and a substantial amount of compute as we now must simulate an entire community of developers. So if a single training of 70B on 10K examples may take just a few hours of GPU time, simulating 100 contributions to such a model would take a few GPU weeks, and having iterations of improvements, different experimental settings or larger groups of contributors (as is required by such research), will scale this number accordingly.
- Assistant
Here are suggestions to enhance clarity, engagement, and persuasiveness in your statement:
- Strengthen the Opening
The sentence structure in the first part is a bit complex and could be clearer.
Instead of "Given no access to enough high-performance GPUs (scenario 1), which are necessary for creating technologies for new pretrained models," consider: Example: "If access to high-performance GPUs (scenario 1) is limited—restricting the ability to develop new pretrained models from scratch—I would pivot toward adapting existing models in ways that enable the research community to collaboratively enhance them."
This keeps the sentence concise while maintaining its meaning.
The phrase “stepping on the shoulders of giants” is great, but making the analogy clearer could be beneficial. Example: "This approach mirrors the decentralized accumulation of scientific knowledge, where researchers collectively build upon prior work to drive progress."
- Clarify the Research Vision and Excitement
The current phrasing makes the idea sound reactive ("fall back to adapting existing models"). Instead, frame it as an opportunity: Example: "This shift presents an exciting opportunity: harnessing the unique expertise of diverse researchers to iteratively refine models, transforming the way AI is developed and shared."
The phrase "shifting power, incentives and technology from their current course" is impactful but somewhat vague. Consider specifying: Example: "This approach not only democratizes AI research but also challenges the current industry-driven paradigm, redistributing technological advancement and incentives toward a more open and collaborative framework."
- Justify the Computational Requirements More Clearly
The transition between adaptation being “less computationally demanding” and still requiring significant compute could be smoother. Example: "While adapting models is computationally less demanding than full-scale training, it still requires substantial resources. The adapted models must already be capable enough to exhibit meaningful improvements, necessitating work with models at the 7B to 70B parameter scale."
The explanation of why adaptation requires significant compute is strong but could be more structured. Consider breaking it into steps:
Why adaptation needs compute: "Although adaptation is generally more parallelizable and cost-efficient than pretraining, it still requires large GPUs to fit these models into memory."
The scaling challenge: "Additionally, our methodology involves simulating a distributed research community making iterative contributions. If a single adaptation run on a 70B model with 10K examples takes just a few hours, then simulating 100 such contributions requires several GPU weeks. Scaling further—through iterations, different experimental settings, or larger research groups—exponentially increases the compute demands."
- Strengthen the Conclusion
Instead of ending on a purely technical note, consider reinforcing the broader impact: Example: "By demonstrating how a decentralized research community can collectively refine and adapt models, this approach has the potential to reshape AI development—making it more inclusive, efficient, and aligned with the needs of academic research."
Would you like me to rewrite the entire statement incorporating these refinements?