If I liked robin hobb and alantris but not lord of the rings, what else would you…
- User
If I liked robin hobb and alantris but not lord of the rings, what else would you recommend?
- Assistant
Got it — that's actually a really telling combo! You liked Robin Hobb (so you're into deep character work, emotional journeys, and intimate world-building), and you liked Elantris (so you’re cool with creative magic systems and a bit of optimism baked into fantasy)... But you didn’t like Lord of the Rings — meaning you might not be into super-dense descriptions, a slow, sprawling epic tone, or the classic good-vs-evil setup. (Correct me if I’m wrong!) Based on that, I think you'd vibe with these:
Top Recommendations:
"The Goblin Emperor" by Katherine Addison
Deep, lovable main character, court intrigue, low on battles, high on emotional intelligence. Similar feels to Hobb.
"The Curse of Chalion" by Lois McMaster Bujold
Smart, character-driven, with an original take on gods and magic. (Bujold is a master at making fantasy personal.)
"The Bone Ships" by RJ Barker
Adventure fantasy with a lot of heart and rough, lovable characters. Plus ships made of dragon bones!
"The Long Price Quartet" by Daniel Abraham
Incredibly deep characters and worldbuilding; very slow-burn but so rewarding. It's about the cost of power, but super fresh.
"Foundryside" by Robert Jackson Bennett
Fun, clever magic system (sort of like programming reality) and a scrappy protagonist you root for. If you liked Elantris’s inventiveness, this is a good match.
Also worth checking out:
"City of Stairs" by Robert Jackson Bennett (if you like mystery with your fantasy)
"Piranesi" by Susanna Clarke (super different vibe, very dreamlike, but emotionally resonant)
"A Taste of Gold and Iron" by Alexandra Rowland (political fantasy, slow but very character-driven)
Would you want me to tailor it even tighter? Like, are you in the mood for more adventure, court intrigue, magic puzzles, or just feels and character growth? 🎯 Depending on what you're craving, I can zero in even more!
- User
Read the goblin emperor, quite good, slightly descriptive in the sense that it is not leading to anything but just "happening" passively, but interesting nontheless.
- Assistant
Great insight — that totally tracks. The Goblin Emperor has that gentle, almost slice-of-life pacing, where the story unfolds more by presence and observation than by driving plot. So while you appreciated its uniqueness and character depth, you're maybe wanting a bit more momentum or sharper cause-effect tension in the narrative? Based on that refinement, here's a next tier of recommendations that might hit closer to your sweet spot:
🧭 More Active, Character-Driven Fantasy (with Emotion + Momentum)
- "The Hands of the Emperor" by Victoria Goddard
Like The Goblin Emperor in tone, but with more agency and an introspective MC who gets things done while being incredibly human. If you liked Maia but wanted him to do more, this is your book.
- "The Winnowing Flame Trilogy" by Jen Williams
Starts with The Ninth Rain — has quirky characters, solid pacing, a rich world, and real stakes. Emotionally compelling but faster-moving than Goblin Emperor or even Hobb.
- "The Tensorate Series" by Neon Yang
Novella format, so it's punchier. Beautifully written, with inventive magic and politics. If you liked Hobb’s exploration of identity but want it in a more active, weird, and poetic package, give this a shot.
🔥 If You Want Elantris-style Inventive Magic + Action: 4. "Mistborn" (Book 1) by Brandon Sanderson
If you haven't read it yet — it fixes most pacing issues Elantris had, and has a super clean cause-effect structure with cool magic and solid emotional arcs.
- "The Blacktongue Thief" by Christopher Buehlman
Witty, fast-paced, and oddly heartfelt. Not grimdark exactly, but definitely has grit and stakes. Great if you're tired of overly “noble” or passive protagonists.
🐉 And if You Want the Hobb-Level Depth, But a Tighter Plot: 6. "The Queen’s Thief" series by Megan Whalen Turner
Starts light (with The Thief) but builds into something deeply satisfying. Politics, character twists, and quietly brilliant writing — it never over-explains, just trusts you to notice.
- "The Dagger and the Coin" series by Daniel Abraham
More plot momentum than The Long Price Quartet but still very much about people, decisions, and consequences.
Would you prefer to lean more into philosophical/emotional themes, adventurous/mystery plots, or more genre-bending/weird fantasy next?