Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
Geminigemini-2.5-flash-preview-04-17-grounding· GoogleHugging Face LMArena Search Arena 24K

Did Weyerhaeuser ever use or purchase vermiculite from W.R. Grace? The brand name of…

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with Geminigemini-2.5-flash-preview-04-17-grounding’s answer.
  1. User

    Did Weyerhaeuser ever use or purchase vermiculite from W.R. Grace? The brand name of W.R. Grace’s vermiculite was sometimes called “Zonolite.” If so, what years did this occur? At one Weyerhaeuser facility was the vermiculite used? What was the raw tonnage of the vermiculite used? What products were manufactured by Weyerhaeuser with this vermiculite?
    Consider both vermiculite from W.R. Grace’s mines in Libby, Montana and in South Carolina. Consider that Montana is in EPA Region 8. In your analysis, consider that Briar Gypsum Company and Dierks are affiliated with Weyerhaeuser. Also consider that Weyerhaeuser had facilities in Arkansas and Marshfield, Wisconsin. Consider sources and documents from the Arkansas Department of Energy and Environment (ADEQ) and the Wisconsin Department of Natural Resources (DNR). There are several addresses for a Arkansas facility including, but not limited to, 794 State Highway 369 North, Nashville, AR 71852. Consider that Arkansas is in EPA Region 6. There are several addresses for the Marshfield facility. These include, but are not limited to, 118 S. Oak Ave., Marshfield, Wisconsin and 1401 East 4th Street, Marshfield, WI 54449. Consider that Wisconsin is located in EPA Region 5. The DNR has assigned the Weyerhaeuser facility at Marshfield with muliple Facility Identification (FID) numbers including 737010450 and 772054030. Consider that the Wisconsin DNR Bureau for Remediation and Redevelopment Tracking System (BRRTS) has extensive records for the Weyerhaeuser site in Marshfield and its identified by BRRTS Activity #[PHONE_NUMBER]. Consider documents from the SEC, EPA and state regulatory agencies in your analysis. Consider that the Marshfield facility manufactured doors. Consider previous FOIA requests regarding where W.R. Grace supplied vermiculite to. For all the evidence you use, provide a citation and link to the source that is confirmed to be an active link and not a dead link. Do not worry about latency and coming up with a quick response. I am willing to wait a long time to get a more thorough response.

  2. Gemini Assistant

    While definitively stating every instance of Weyerhaeuser's use or purchase of W.R. Grace vermiculite and the exact tonnage is challenging based solely on the search results, there is strong evidence of a connection, particularly at the Arkansas facility. Here's an analysis of the findings:

    Evidence of Weyerhaeuser's Use of W.R. Grace Vermiculite:

    • Arkansas Facility: Several sources indicate that a gypsum board manufacturing facility in Nashville, Arkansas, historically owned and operated by Weyerhaeuser-Diercks between 1969 and 1989, received vermiculite ore from W.R. Grace's Libby, Montana mine[1]. An EPA database compiled from W.R. Grace shipping invoices shows 2,500 tons of vermiculite ore from the Libby mine were shipped to this site between January 1968 and September 1983[1]. The facility was later owned by Briar Gypsum Company and James Hardie Gypsum Company, and subsequent owners also used vermiculite from sources other than Libby[2][1]. The Arkansas facility is located in EPA Region 6.
    • Marshfield, Wisconsin Facility: While Weyerhaeuser's Marshfield, Wisconsin facility is mentioned in the context of asbestos exposure and is listed among Wisconsin companies with potential links to asbestos, the search results do not explicitly state that this facility used vermiculite from W.R. Grace or "Zonolite."[3][4] However, Zonolite Company was a vermiculite producer, acquired by W.R. Grace in 1963, and some Zonolite operations were located in Wisconsin[5][6][7]. The Wisconsin DNR BRRTS database has records for the Marshfield site (BRRTS Activity #02-37-000384), which could potentially contain more specific information[3][4]. The Marshfield facility is known to have manufactured doors and is located in EPA Region 5[8][4].
    • Affiliation with Dierks and Briar Gypsum: The connection between Weyerhaeuser and Dierks is confirmed, and the Arkansas facility that received Libby vermiculite was operated by "Weyerhaeuser-Diercks."[1][9][10] Briar Gypsum Company also operated at the same Arkansas site after Weyerhaeuser[2][1][11].

    Years of Use and Tonnage:

    • At the Arkansas facility, the use of W.R. Grace vermiculite from Libby, Montana, occurred between approximately 1968 and 1989, based on Weyerhaeuser-Diercks' ownership period and the EPA database information[1]. The specific period for the 2,500 tons shipped was between January 1968 and September 1983[1].
    • The raw tonnage of vermiculite from Libby shipped to the Arkansas facility is documented as 2,500 tons[1]. Information on tonnage used at other potential Weyerhaeuser facilities is not available in the provided results.

    Products Manufactured:

    • At the Arkansas facility, the vermiculite was used in the manufacturing of gypsum board, specifically to enhance its fire rating[1]. The James Hardie Gypsum Company, a later owner of the facility, produced fire-resistant products containing vermiculite, which made up less than 2 percent of their gypsum product mix[1]. It is likely Weyerhaeuser used the vermiculite for a similar purpose in gypsum board.
    • The Marshfield, Wisconsin facility manufactured doors, but the search results do not specify if vermiculite was used in door manufacturing by Weyerhaeuser at this location[4]. Some building materials, like lightweight concrete aggregates and plaster, can contain vermiculite, and Weyerhaeuser has been involved in structural building components[12][13][14].

    Vermiculite Source (Libby vs. South Carolina):

    • The search results primarily highlight the use of vermiculite from the Libby, Montana mine at the Arkansas facility[1]. This vermiculite is known to be contaminated with asbestos[15][16][17].
    • One source mentions that James Hardie, the later owner of the Arkansas facility, purchased vermiculite from "American Vermiculite and Carolina Vermiculite," indicating a potential South Carolina source (as "Carolina Vermiculite" likely refers to a source in the Carolinas)[1]. However, this was after Weyerhaeuser's ownership. There is no direct evidence in the provided results that Weyerhaeuser specifically purchased vermiculite from W.R. Grace's South Carolina operations.

    Regulatory Context (ADEQ, Wisconsin DNR, EPA, SEC):

    • The Arkansas Department of Energy and Environment (ADEQ) is mentioned in relation to air permits for the Arkansas facility, noting the change of ownership from Weyerhaeuser to Briar Gypsum and the use of vermiculite in the manufacturing process[2][11][20].
    • The Wisconsin Department of Natural Resources (DNR) is mentioned in the context of the Marshfield facility and its BRRTS listing, indicating regulatory involvement[3][4].
    • The EPA is involved in the cleanup of the Libby Asbestos Site in Montana and has databases tracking shipments of Libby vermiculite[15][16][18]. The EPA also visited the Arkansas facility to assess the use of Libby vermiculite[1]. EPA Region 8 is associated with Montana, Region 6 with Arkansas, and Region 5 with Wisconsin.
    • While SEC filings are mentioned as a potential source, the provided search results do not include specific SEC filings from Weyerhaeuser that detail the purchase or use of W.R. Grace vermiculite.

    In summary, there is clear evidence that Weyerhaeuser, through its Dierks division, used approximately 2,500 tons of asbestos-contaminated vermiculite from W.R. Grace's Libby, Montana mine at its Nashville, Arkansas gypsum board manufacturing facility between 1968 and 1989. The vermiculite was used to improve the fire rating of gypsum board products. While the Marshfield, Wisconsin facility is linked to asbestos concerns and Weyerhaeuser's use of vermiculite in general is mentioned in other contexts, the provided information does not confirm the use of W.R. Grace vermiculite or "Zonolite" at that specific location or provide tonnage or product details there. Further investigation of Wisconsin DNR and Weyerhaeuser's historical records and SEC filings might yield more specific information regarding the Marshfield facility.

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.