Skip to content
The Chat Archive
sonar-pro-high LMArena Search Arena 24K

What is the best physically possible efficency for computers?

  1. User

    What is the best physically possible efficency for computers?

  2. Assistant

    Theoretical Limits of Computer Efficiency

    Physical and Thermodynamic Limits

    The ultimate efficiency of computers is governed by the laws of physics, particularly thermodynamics, quantum mechanics, and relativity. The key theoretical limits are:

    • Landauer's Principle: This sets a lower bound on the energy required to irreversibly erase one bit of information, given by ( E \geq kT \ln 2 ), where ( k ) is Boltzmann's constant and ( T ) is the temperature of the environment. At room temperature, this is about ( 2.8 \times 10^{-21} ) joules per bit. This is the minimum energy cost for any irreversible computation, such as resetting memory or deleting data[1][2][6].

    • Reversible Computing: If computation is performed in a logically reversible way (no information is erased), in principle, it can be done with arbitrarily little energy, limited only by practical imperfections. However, most real-world computing is not fully reversible, so Landauer's limit remains a fundamental bound for conventional computers[2][6].

    Maximum Computational Speed and Density

    • Bremermann's Limit: This is the maximum rate at which information can be processed by a physical system of a given mass. It is approximately ( 1.36 \times 10^{50} ) bits per second per kilogram. For example, a 1 kg computer cannot process more than this number of bits per second, no matter how advanced the technology[3][5][9].

    • Bekenstein Bound: This limits the maximum amount of information (in bits) that can be stored within a given finite region of space containing a finite amount of energy. For a 1-liter, 1-kg "ultimate laptop," the bound is about ( 10^{31} ) bits[2][4].

    • Seth Lloyd's "Ultimate Laptop": By converting all its mass to energy (as in a black hole), a 1-kg computer could theoretically perform up to ( 10^{51} ) operations per second, but only for a fleeting moment before evaporating due to Hawking radiation[4].

    Summary Table: Key Physical Limits

    Limit/PrincipleWhat It BoundsValue (for 1 kg)Notes
    Landauer's PrincipleMin. energy per bit erased( kT \ln 2 )At room temp: ( \sim 2.8 \times 10^{-21} ) J
    Bremermann's LimitMax. bit ops per second( 1.36 \times 10^{50} )Per kilogram of mass
    Bekenstein BoundMax. bits stored in volume( \sim 10^{31} )For 1 liter, 1 kg
    Lloyd's Ultimate LaptopMax. ops per second( 10^{51} )If all mass converted to energy

    Practical vs. Theoretical Efficiency

    • Current Technology: Modern computers are still many orders of magnitude less efficient than these physical limits. For example, CPUs and GPUs waste much energy as heat and are far from the Landauer limit[6][8].
    • Approaching the Limit: As technology advances, especially with reversible computing and quantum computing, we may get closer to these bounds, but practical engineering, cooling, and material constraints will always keep us below the absolute theoretical maximum[2][6][7].

    Conclusion

    The best physically possible efficiency for computers is set by the Landauer limit for energy per bit operation and the Bremermann limit for computational speed per unit mass. In theory, a perfectly efficient computer would approach these bounds, but in practice, real devices are far less efficient due to engineering, material, and thermodynamic constraints[1][2][3][4][5][6][9].

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.