Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
Perplexitysonar-pro-high· PerplexityHugging Face LMArena Search Arena 24K

Did Weyerhaeuser ever use or purchase vermiculite from W.R. Grace? The brand name of…

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with Perplexitysonar-reasoning-pro-high’s answer.
  1. User

    Did Weyerhaeuser ever use or purchase vermiculite from W.R. Grace? The brand name of W.R. Grace’s vermiculite was sometimes called “Zonolite.” If so, what years did this occur? At one Weyerhaeuser facility was the vermiculite used? What was the raw tonnage of the vermiculite used? What products were manufactured by Weyerhaeuser with this vermiculite?
    Consider both vermiculite from W.R. Grace’s mines in Libby, Montana and in South Carolina. In your analysis, consider that Briar Gypsum Company and Dierks are affiliated with Weyerhaeuser. Also consider that Weyerhaeuser had facilities in Arkansas and Marshfield, Wisconsin. Consider sources and documents from the Arkansas Department of Energy and Environment (ADEQ) and the Wisconsin Department of Natural Resources (DNR). There are several addresses for a Arkansas facility including, but not limited to, 794 State Highway 369 North, Nashville, AR 71852. There are several addresses for the Marshfield facility. These include, but are not limited to, 118 S. Oak Ave., Marshfield, Wisconsin and 1401 East 4th Street, Marshfield, WI 54449. Consider that Wisconsin is located in EPA Region 5. The DNR has assigned the Weyerhaeuser facility at Marshfield with muliple Facility Identification (FID) numbers including 737010450 and 772054030. Consider that the Wisconsin DNR Bureau for Remediation and Redevelopment Tracking System (BRRTS) has extensive records for the Weyerhaeuser site in Marshfield and its identified by BRRTS Activity #[PHONE_NUMBER]. Consider documents from the SEC, EPA and state regulatory agencies in your analysis. Consider that the Marshfield facility manufactured doors. Consider previous FOIA requests regarding where W.R. Grace supplied vermiculite to. For all the evidence you use, provide a citation and link to the source that is confirmed to be an active link and not a dead link. Do not worry about latency and coming up with a quick response. I am willing to wait a long time to get a more thorough response.

  2. Perplexity Assistant

    Weyerhaeuser’s Use or Purchase of Vermiculite from W.R. Grace (“Zonolite”)

    Summary of Findings

    • Weyerhaeuser Company did use vermiculite at some of its facilities, including those in Arkansas and Wisconsin.
    • W.R. Grace’s Zonolite brand vermiculite, primarily sourced from Libby, Montana, was widely distributed to industrial users across the U.S. from the 1950s through 1990.
    • Regulatory and historical documents confirm the use of vermiculite at Weyerhaeuser’s Arkansas (Nashville/Briar Plant) facility, but do not directly confirm the supplier as W.R. Grace or the specific mine source.
    • There is no direct evidence in the provided sources that Weyerhaeuser’s Marshfield, Wisconsin facility used Zonolite or any W.R. Grace vermiculite.
    • The Arkansas facility manufactured gypsum wallboard and related products, with vermiculite used as an additive.

    Detailed Analysis

    1. Did Weyerhaeuser Use or Purchase Vermiculite from W.R. Grace?

    Evidence for Use of Vermiculite

    • The Arkansas Department of Energy and Environment (ADEQ) air permits for the Nashville, AR facility (formerly Weyerhaeuser Briar Plant, later Briar Gypsum, then CertainTeed/James Hardie) explicitly list “Vermiculite Transfer and Processing Systems” as permitted activities at the site[9][10].
    • The facility at 794 State Highway 369 North, Nashville, AR, operated by Weyerhaeuser from at least 1980, used vermiculite as a raw material in wallboard production[9][10].

    Evidence for W.R. Grace as Supplier

    • W.R. Grace’s Zonolite vermiculite was the dominant product in the U.S. market, especially for industrial and construction uses, from the 1960s through 1990, with most supply coming from Libby, Montana[1][5].
    • EPA and ATSDR records indicate that gypsum wallboard plants were among the industrial users of Libby vermiculite, though they often received smaller, bagged shipments rather than bulk railcar loads[2].
    • However, the ADEQ permits and available regulatory documents do not specifically name W.R. Grace or Zonolite as the supplier to Weyerhaeuser’s Arkansas facility.

    FOIA and EPA Records

    • The EPA maintains lists of facilities that received Libby vermiculite, but the provided sources do not include a direct listing for Weyerhaeuser’s Arkansas or Marshfield, WI facilities as recipients[2].
    • Non-exfoliation facilities (like wallboard plants) received less than 5% of Libby’s output, and records are less comprehensive for these sites[2].

    2. Years of Use

    • Weyerhaeuser operated the Nashville, AR (Briar Plant) facility from at least 1980 until its sale to Briar Gypsum in 1989, with continued wallboard production under subsequent owners[9][10].
    • W.R. Grace’s Libby mine supplied vermiculite from the 1960s until 1990[1][5].
    • It is likely that any Weyerhaeuser use of Zonolite would have occurred between 1963 (when Grace acquired Zonolite and the Libby mine) and 1989 (when Weyerhaeuser sold the plant), but the exact years of purchase are not specified in available records[9][10].

    3. Facility Where Vermiculite Was Used

    Facility NameAddressUse of VermiculiteSource Confirmation
    Weyerhaeuser Briar Plant794 State Highway 369 N, Nashville, ARYesADEQ Permits[9][10]
    Marshfield, WI (multiple sites)118 S. Oak Ave. / 1401 E. 4th St.Not confirmedNo direct evidence
    • The Nashville, AR (Briar Plant) facility is confirmed to have used vermiculite in wallboard manufacturing[9][10].
    • There is no direct evidence that the Marshfield, WI facility used vermiculite, nor that it received shipments from W.R. Grace.

    4. Raw Tonnage Used

    • ADEQ permits for the Nashville, AR facility specify tonnage limits for gypsum rock (1,860,000 tons/year) but do not specify annual or total tonnage for vermiculite[10].
    • The vermiculite was likely a minor additive in wallboard production, and records do not provide a total raw tonnage.

    5. Products Manufactured with Vermiculite

    • The Nashville, AR facility produced gypsum wallboard and related products, with vermiculite used as a lightweight aggregate and fireproofing additive[9][10].
    • There is no evidence that Weyerhaeuser used vermiculite in door manufacturing at Marshfield, WI.

    6. Consideration of Affiliates and Other Facilities

    • Briar Gypsum Company and Dierks are noted as affiliates or successors at the Nashville, AR site, but the use of vermiculite is only confirmed for the wallboard plant[9][10].
    • No evidence was found for vermiculite use at Dierks or Emerson, AR, or at Marshfield, WI.

    7. Source Documentation

    • ADEQ Air Permit for Nashville, AR facility (Weyerhaeuser/Briar Gypsum/James Hardie)[9][9]
    • ADEQ Air Permit History for Nashville, AR facility[10][10]
    • EPA: W.R. Grace’s Libby, MT operations and distribution[1][1]
    • EPA: Strategy for Further Assessment of Vermiculite Ore Asbestos Sites[2][2]
    • LA Times: W.R. Grace Zonolite litigation and distribution[5][5]

    Conclusion

    • Weyerhaeuser’s Nashville, Arkansas (Briar Plant) facility used vermiculite in gypsum wallboard production from at least 1980 to 1989.
    • Permits confirm vermiculite use, but do not specify W.R. Grace as the supplier. Given the dominance of Zonolite in the market, it is plausible but not confirmed that some or all of the vermiculite was sourced from W.R. Grace’s Libby, Montana mine.
    • No direct evidence was found for vermiculite use at the Marshfield, Wisconsin facility or for the specific raw tonnage used at any Weyerhaeuser facility.
    • Products manufactured with vermiculite at the Nashville facility were gypsum wallboard and related products.

    If you require further confirmation of supplier or tonnage, a FOIA request to the EPA or a review of historical Weyerhaeuser procurement records would be necessary.

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.