Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
Geminigemini-2.5-pro-exp-03-25-grounding· GoogleHugging Face LMArena Search Arena 24K

Help me figure out this medical condition: I have pain in both sides of my hips just…

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with Geminigemini-2.5-flash-preview-04-17-grounding’s answer.
  1. User

    Help me figure out this medical condition: I have pain in both sides of my hips just behind the bone. This pain is connected to nerve issues that cause my feet to tingle and the front side of my thighs to be very sensitive to clothing. The problem seems to be inside the hip but effect both sides. I have had a nerve conduction study which concluded nothing was wrong. I have had a lumber spine MRI as well as a spinal neck MRI and brain scan all finding nothing wrong. Still the problem persists with constant pain in my upper leg where it meets the hip area. I often press hard on the outside of the hip to try to relieve the pain. The pain is on both sides and not just one. Could this be an STD? Could this be something related to hernia surgery? Could this be related to prostate issues even though I have no problem peeing? I have had the problem three years and the doctors have all given up and even ruled out small fiber neuropathy and major concerns like MS

  2. Gemini Assistant

    Okay, let's break down these symptoms and explore potential avenues. It's understandably frustrating when you're experiencing persistent pain and nerve issues without a clear diagnosis despite numerous tests.

    Disclaimer: I am an AI assistant and cannot provide medical advice. The information below is for informational purposes only and should not replace consultation with qualified healthcare professionals.

    Based on your description – bilateral pain behind the hip bones, connected nerve issues causing tingling feet and anterior thigh hypersensitivity, negative nerve conduction study, clear lumbar/cervical/brain MRIs – here's an analysis of your questions and some possibilities to discuss with your doctors:

    Analysis of Your Specific Questions:

    1. Could this be an STD? It is highly unlikely that a sexually transmitted disease would cause this specific cluster of symptoms: bilateral deep hip pain with associated nerve pain in the feet and anterior thighs. STDs typically present with genital, urinary, or sometimes systemic symptoms (like fever, rash, or more generalized joint pain) rather than this localized neuro-musculoskeletal pattern.
    2. Could this be something related to hernia surgery? This is a possibility, depending on the type and location of the hernia surgery and when the symptoms began relative to the surgery. Some types of hernia repair, particularly inguinal hernia repair using mesh, can potentially entrap or irritate nerves in the groin and pelvic region. Nerves that could be affected include the ilioinguinal nerve, genitofemoral nerve, and importantly for your anterior thigh symptoms, the lateral femoral cutaneous nerve (causing meralgia paresthetica) or even the femoral nerve itself. If the surgery was bilateral or if mesh caused issues on both sides, it could potentially explain bilateral symptoms, although simultaneous bilateral nerve injury from surgery is less common. Discuss the timing of your symptom onset relative to any hernia surgery with your doctor.
    3. Could this be related to prostate issues? Similar to STDs, it's very unlikely that prostate issues would cause this specific combination of bilateral hip pain and nerve symptoms in the anterior thighs and feet, especially without any urinary symptoms. While advanced prostate cancer can spread to bones (including the pelvis/hips) causing pain, it typically wouldn't cause the specific nerve distribution you describe (anterior thigh sensitivity, tingling feet) unless the metastases were directly compressing those nerves, which is less typical. Prostatitis (inflammation) usually causes pelvic or perineal pain and urinary issues.

    Other Potential Conditions to Consider Discussing with Doctors:

    Given the negative results so far, doctors often have to think about less common conditions or reconsider previous findings.

    1. Meralgia Paresthetica: This condition involves compression of the Lateral Femoral Cutaneous Nerve (LFCN), which supplies sensation to the skin on the outer and front part of the thigh. Symptoms include tingling, numbness, burning pain, and increased sensitivity to touch (like clothing) in that area. It can be bilateral in about 20% of cases. While it strongly fits your anterior thigh symptoms, it doesn't typically explain deep hip pain behind the bone or tingling in the feet. However, it could be one component of your symptoms. NCS for LFCN can sometimes be normal.
    2. Lumbar Plexus Issues / Femoral Nerve Involvement: The lumbar plexus is a network of nerves deep in the pelvis/abdomen formed by lumbar nerve roots. The femoral nerve originates here and supplies muscles and sensation in the front of the thigh and part of the lower leg. Issues higher up affecting the plexus or femoral nerve bilaterally (e.g., due to retroperitoneal hematoma, tumors, inflammation, or possibly complications from surgery like hernia repair) could potentially cause anterior thigh symptoms and possibly pain referred to the hip area. Tingling feet would be less directly explained unless lower lumbar roots (part of the same plexus contributing to sciatic nerve) were also involved.
    3. Sacroiliac (SI) Joint Dysfunction: The SI joints connect the spine to the pelvis, located on either side of the sacrum, roughly "behind the hip bone". Dysfunction or inflammation here can cause pain in the low back, buttock, groin, and sometimes refer pain down the leg. It can be bilateral. While it can cause leg pain/numbness/tingling, it doesn't classically cause anterior thigh hypersensitivity or isolated foot tingling in the way you describe, but referred pain patterns can vary.
    4. Revisiting Spinal Causes (Subtle Findings?): While the lumbar MRI was reported as clear, sometimes subtle central stenosis, foraminal stenosis (where nerves exit the spine), or nerve root irritation might not be prominently reported or could be dynamic (worse in certain positions). Given the bilateral nature and involvement of different nerve levels (L2-L4 for anterior thigh, L4-S1 for feet), a central spinal issue or multi-level bilateral foraminal issues could theoretically cause this, though usually, something is seen on MRI. A second opinion on the MRI reading could be considered.
    5. Small Fiber Neuropathy (SFN): You mentioned this was ruled out, but it's worth knowing how. SFN typically causes burning pain, tingling, and numbness, often starting in the feet and progressing upwards, and can cause hypersensitivity. Standard nerve conduction studies are often normal because they test large nerve fibers. Diagnosis usually requires specific tests like a skin biopsy to measure nerve fiber density or quantitative sudomotor axon reflex testing (QSART). If these specific tests weren't done, SFN might still be a possibility fitting the tingling feet and hypersensitivity, though less so the deep hip pain.
    6. Greater Trochanteric Pain Syndrome (GTPS) / Gluteal Tendinopathy: This involves pain on the outer side of the hip, over the bony prominence (greater trochanter). It's often due to bursitis or, more commonly, tears or inflammation in the gluteal tendons that attach there. Pressing on the area is usually painful, but perhaps you are pressing nearby for counter-stimulation. While it explains lateral hip pain well, it doesn't explain the nerve symptoms in the anterior thigh or feet. It could co-exist with another condition.
    7. Pelvic Floor Dysfunction or Entrapment Syndromes: Issues within the complex musculature and nerves of the pelvis could potentially refer pain to the hips. Conditions like pudendal neuralgia are usually associated with more perineal symptoms, but complex pelvic pain can sometimes have wider referral patterns.

    Recommendations:

    • Seek Specialist Care: If you haven't already, consider seeing specialists such as a Neurologist (especially one with neuromuscular expertise), a Physiatrist (Physical Medicine & Rehabilitation - PM&R specialist, often good at complex neuro-musculoskeletal diagnostics), or possibly an Orthopedic surgeon specializing in hip/pelvis, or a Pain Management specialist.
    • Gather All Records: Bring all your previous test results (MRI reports and images, NCS report, blood work) to any new consultation.
    • Second Opinions: Consider requesting a second opinion on your lumbar spine MRI from a neuroradiologist.
    • Specific Testing Discussion: Discuss with your specialist if tests like MR Neurography (detailed nerve imaging), diagnostic nerve blocks (injecting anesthetic around specific nerves like the LFCN or SI joint to see if pain resolves temporarily), or specific SFN testing (skin biopsy, QSART) might be warranted.
    • Physical Therapy Evaluation: A skilled physical therapist can assess musculoskeletal imbalances, pelvic alignment, SI joint function, and potential muscle trigger points that could be contributing.

    It's challenging when the cause isn't obvious, but continuing to work systematically with specialists, revisiting previous tests, and considering less common diagnoses or combinations of issues is key.

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.