Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
Perplexitysonar-pro-high· PerplexityHugging Face LMArena Search Arena 24K

Who is most likely to be elected pope at the upcoming conclave? How will their papacy…

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with Geminigemini-2.5-flash-preview-04-17-grounding’s answer.
  1. User

    Who is most likely to be elected pope at the upcoming conclave? How will their papacy differ from Pope Francis?

  2. Perplexity Assistant

    Leading Contenders for the Next Pope

    The upcoming 2025 conclave is widely considered one of the most unpredictable in modern history, largely due to Pope Francis's efforts to diversify the College of Cardinals and shift its center of gravity away from Europe[1][5][6]. While predicting the next pope is notoriously difficult, several names consistently emerge as frontrunners among Vatican watchers, journalists, and betting markets:

    NameCountryAgeProfile & Likely Direction
    Pietro ParolinItaly70Vatican Secretary of State; skilled diplomat; seen as a continuity candidate with Francis’s reforms but more managerial and less pastoral[5][7].
    Luis Antonio TaglePhilippines67Progressive, close ally of Francis, champion of the poor and marginalized, strong advocate for a global, inclusive Church[1][2][3].
    Matteo ZuppiItaly69President of Italian Bishops’ Conference, known for outreach to marginalized, peace efforts, and progressive stances on LGBTQ+ and migrants[1][2][7].
    Peter ErdőHungary72Leading conservative, canon law expert, appeals to those seeking a return to traditional doctrine[1][2][3][4].
    Pierbattista PizzaballaItaly60Patriarch of Jerusalem, respected for Middle East expertise, but considered young for the papacy[1][2][4].

    Other names occasionally mentioned include Cardinal Fridolin Ambongo (Congo), Cardinal Peter Turkson (Ghana), and Cardinal Mario Grech (Malta), but the above are the most frequently cited[1][3][4][7].

    Who Is Most Likely to Be Elected?

    Pietro Parolin is widely regarded as the front-runner, primarily because he is a familiar figure to many cardinals, has extensive diplomatic experience, and is seen as a unifying choice in a highly diverse and sometimes divided College[5][7]. His election would likely represent a continuation of Francis’s reforms, but with a more measured, diplomatic, and managerial approach.

    Luis Antonio Tagle is the favorite among those seeking a strong continuation of Francis’s progressive legacy, especially regarding inclusion, global outreach, and social justice. His election would be historic as the first Asian pope and would further shift the Church’s focus toward the Global South[1][2][3].

    Matteo Zuppi is also a strong contender, especially for those who want a pope in full continuity with Francis, but with a more charismatic and media-savvy style[1][2][7].

    Peter Erdő is the leading conservative candidate, appealing to those who wish to see a return to more traditional doctrine and practices[1][2][3][4].

    How Might Their Papacy Differ from Pope Francis?

    CandidateLikely Differences from Francis
    Pietro ParolinMore managerial and diplomatic, less charismatic; would likely maintain many of Francis’s reforms but with a steadier, less confrontational style. Less emphasis on pastoral outreach, more focus on Vatican diplomacy and internal governance[5][7].
    Luis TagleWould likely double down on Francis’s progressive agenda: greater inclusion, focus on the poor, and a more global, less Eurocentric Church. Tagle is seen as even more open to LGBTQ+ inclusion and dialogue with other faiths[1][2][3].
    Matteo ZuppiWould continue Francis’s focus on the marginalized and social justice, but with a more energetic and public-facing approach. Zuppi is known for his peace efforts and support for LGBTQ+ Catholics, and may push further on synodality and Church modernization[1][2][7].
    Peter ErdőWould represent a clear shift back to conservative doctrine, likely rolling back some of Francis’s reforms on issues like LGBTQ+ inclusion, communion for divorced/remarried Catholics, and synodality. Erdő is also more restrictive on migration and liturgical changes[1][2][3][4].

    Why the Outcome Is So Unpredictable

    • Diversity of the College: Francis appointed cardinals from across the globe, many of whom are unfamiliar with each other, making alliances and voting blocs less predictable[5][6].
    • Ideological Divisions: The College is split between those wanting to continue Francis’s reforms and those seeking a return to tradition[1][3][4].
    • Personality and Politics: The conclave is as much about the candidate’s character and ability to unify as about their policies[4][7].
    • Secrecy and Surprises: History shows that papal elections often defy expectations, with compromise candidates sometimes emerging late in the process[1][7].

    Summary Table: Top Contenders and Their Likely Papal Direction

    NameLikely Papal Direction Compared to Francis
    Pietro ParolinContinuity, but more diplomatic and managerial
    Luis Antonio TagleStronger progressive, global focus
    Matteo ZuppiProgressive, charismatic, modernizing
    Peter ErdőConservative, traditionalist

    In conclusion: Pietro Parolin is the most likely to be elected, but Luis Tagle and Matteo Zuppi are also strong contenders. The next papacy could either consolidate Francis’s reforms or mark a return to tradition, depending on which faction prevails in the conclave. The outcome remains highly unpredictable due to the unprecedented diversity and unfamiliarity among the cardinal electors[1][5][6][7].

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.