organize in a logic way based on text context, then highlight the techinical terms and…
- User
organize in a logic way based on text context, then highlight the techinical terms and ideas. dont use markdowns: hey everybody hey everybody we have an exciting show for you today this is the 15th and the final episode from the all in summit 2022 i wanted to take a quick moment to thank my team they worked tirelessly over a hundred days to make the event magical for everybody who is able to make it thanks to the audience for coming next year we'll try to have twice as many of you there just a quick thank you to amber ashley jackie nick fresh marine molly big mike andre times 2 rachel reporting producer justin jamie jimmy d my brother josh everybody who came and supported the event we had an incredible crew we had an incredible time and of course i would be remiss if i didn't thank the amazing speakers who joined us from all around the world so candid so insightful my pal bill gurley brett gerstner edina mark tandis tim elon antonio nate ryan claire my boy or a boy antonio garcia martinez joe lonsdale james mattaiby glenn greenwald and of course today's guest the one and the only mr palmer lucky and most of all i'd like to thank my besties saks and freeberg who did an amazing job of hosting the event now a little preamble here before we start this episode many of you have heard uh that this is a controversial episode it is a little controversial there may be a little twist in it so i will be coming back after palmer lucky's talk to give you a little context because it might get a little confusing i don't want to spoil the surprise for you so enjoy this episode but before we go to this episode a lot of you have questions you have questions about the future of the online podcast and those questions are important and um they're never going to be answered they're never going to be answered but just so you know i'm not leaving i'm not leaving i'm not leaving the show goes on this is my home they're gonna need a wrecking ball to take me out of here they're gonna need to send in the national guard because i ain't going nowhere the show goes on all right everybody pommeler lucky fantastic um so hang on did a video play that showed my stuff or no that was going to play at some point you guys want to play that video all right all i can do is stand here i don't have actually any power so now that the comedy routine is over we can get started so my name is palmer lucky i founded two companies my first was a company called oculus vr that i founded when i was 19 years old and living in a camper trailer thank you thank you um sold that to for a few billion dollars to facebook and then got fired a few years later and then started andrew because i wanted to work in the national security space for a variety of reasons and i'll get into some of those reasons today so the technology industry for many years has prided itself on being the first to understand where things are heading so they can build the things that are going to be relevant for the future on national security though and on the rise of our strategic adversaries it was one of the last industries to realize where things were going due to a variety of ideological reasons but also business reasons now silicon valley didn't just predict the importance of defense in the 2020s it largely took the exact wrong position the opposite position first of all you have the obvious examples like big technology companies explicitly refusing to do work with the department of defense google is one big example but the worst examples are really in the startups that don't exist because people didn't want to even get into such a controversial space unless it ruined their careers you know when i started anderl i had already sold a company for billions of dollars and investors still didn't want to invest i still had a tough time in a lot of meetings with venture capitalists and none of the conversations with vcs that i had were about my ability to hire or execute or build products everyone believed that i could do those things even the ones who didn't like me much the vast majority of conversations that we had were about whether or not it was even ethically okay to ever build a company that would build weapons and the people who turned us down the ones who decided not to invest in anderl actually believed that we had a good team and good people and good product market fit the issue is that they thought that it was inherently wrong to build tools capable of being used for violence because they believed that the idea of deterring violence through having a strong arsenal was fundamentally obsolete and itself wrong uh even you know imagine how hard it would have been to raise money if i hadn't found it oculus would have been impossible even after we raised money and got traction the negativity continued there was a really interesting uh cover story in bloomberg in 2019 they called us tech's most controversial startup this was a year where tick-tock was banning users for calling attention to the weaker genocide in in china and banning users for posting homosexual content this is a year in which adam newman paid himself tens of millions of dollars for the right to use the word we it's a year that uber was under a federal investigation for its workplace culture immediately after a board coup that ejected much of the leadership it's a time where facebook was getting hauled in front of congress to testify but of course as a tiny defense company making a handful of purely defensive base security systems that committed the crime of building technology for the military andrew was the one that claimed the belt for the world's most controversial technology company i'd say that the war in europe has totally shattered the idea that we live at the end of history every few decades we start to believe that economic ties have ended all prospect of war and every few decades reminded this isn't true that's a very popular idea especially in dc that we live at what they call the end of history it's this idea that economic ties and interconnections make the prospect of conflict fundamentally unthinkable ignoring the fact that many people see this as a matter of destiny in economics in 1909 english economist and politician norman angel published an entire book called the great illusion and it was entirely about how war in europe was impossible and that spending money on building militaries that could deter conflict was a waste of time that could be better spent building utopia he specifically argued that any european country annexing another would be as absurd as london annexing hertford and the book was actually the number one bestseller in 1909. now we've had some version of this argument for a few decades now ever since the cold war started and luckily a lot of people are waking up but unfortunately it's not because they've come to a reasoned decision based on the fundamental principles at play it's because right now supporting the military supporting defense and supporting ukraine in particular has become the current thing and in current year current thing is the thing that you have to support regardless of what you think of the underpinnings unfortunately for issues like defense and national security the stakes are too high and the relevant timeline is far too long for people to start caring about things at the moment that they need to start caring about them so today i want to talk a little bit about why i started anderle and why you should all think exactly the same way that i do so why i founded anderall i thought that i would work on virtual reality for my entire life i had no plans on leaving oculus at all and i loved virtual reality i loved virtual reality i started oculus as a teenager and i would have been there for another 50 years i said as much less than 30 days before i was fired there's there's a lot of reasons for that some of which i'll get into later uh but the decision was made for me i gave nine thousand dollars against the wrong political candidate and it was pretty unpopular in silicon valley before i worked on oculus i actually worked in an army affiliate research center on a program called bravemind which was an army project to treat veterans with post-traumatic stress disorder using virtual reality exposure therapy basically putting them into virtual reality environments that would set off their symptoms and then under the guidance of a licensed therapist who's also in the simulation they could be taught coping skills it would reduce their dependency on medication and medical aid it was a really fantastic program i wasn't doing anything important on it i was just a lab technician a cable monkey but i got a lot of exposure to both the virtual reality technology side but also how broken defense procurement was how slow it was how old a lot of the technology was how the incentives were totally misaligned and ever since then i'd always wanted to make a contribution to national security if i could just took a few years for the right for the right set of circumstances to come up the defense industry in america is fundamentally broken uh you know before even getting into the specific problems of our defense industry the united states has the strongest commercial artificial intelligence industry in the world followed closely by china but at the same time the united states military and the prime contractors that dominate the military industrial complex have none of the right tools talent or incentives to apply autonomy to the system to do there's no reason to save costs because they don't get paid for making things that work they get paid for doing work and in a world where you get more prestige and more money by having more people working on bigger things there's no reason to use autonomy to reduce costs and increase capability the us military is well behind the chinese people liberate people's liberation army and the implementation of artificial intelligence there's more better ai in john deere tractors than there is in any u.s military vehicle there's better computer vision in the snapchat app on your phone than any system that the us department of defense has deployed and other countries are taking notice of this countries like russia and china do not want to compete with us toe to toe with the tools that we have people will make fun of china and say oh they have they don't have a blue water navy they only have one aircraft carrier coming up on two they could never fight us the reality is that that's not where they're going to fight us they're going to arm proxies or if they engage directly they're going to use technologies that give them an asymmetrical advantage in the areas where we are the least competent these are the areas where they are putting a lot of their resources the reason vladimir putin is saying that the ruler of the world is going to be the country that masters artificial intelligence is not because he thinks that they're going to lose at this it's because he thinks that that is one of the only ways that they're going to be able to get the best of us now the people who are building technology for our military the large defense primes i won't name any names because i'm not i i i don't wanna i don't wanna wrestle too many feathers in that area and i've never known who's in the room but the people who are building the technology for the united states military the people who spend all their time do not have access to the best talent they do not have access to the people of the technology industry has largely had a monopoly on in areas like autonomy artificial int intelligence sensor fusion high-end networking and then at the same time the people who can build who can build good software the ones who do work in these technology companies are largely prohibited from doing so and even if they're working on something that military buys let's say all the people at apple who are working on an iphone that can be sold to the us air force that same iphone is also being sold to russian intelligence that same iphone is being sold to the chinese navy working on technologies that help the united states don't give us a strategic or competitive advantage if everyone else is getting the exact same thing the other problem to consider is that asymmetric technologies like artificial intelligence are almost certainly going to empower nations that we aren't thinking about today some of them are a little more obvious like iran it was a close u.s ally until the late 1970s and today obviously isn't a very different position there's about a dozen countries in africa south america and asia that were they to acquire extremely advanced artificial intelligence either through coincidence or by proxy arming would almost certainly start to wage war on their neighbors in a very destabilizing way it would have been a mature bet for me to found a second unicorn in a different industry that wasn't so fundamentally broken uh gaming fast casual dining fintech i could have made some apecoins but there have actually been more mattress unicorns than defense unicorns in the last 35 years but i decided the best thing that i could do to try and solve this problem was to use the fact that i had a bunch of money and i had a bunch of credibility to do something that was hugely popular to ignore the fact that people were belittling me for it and tried to convince a bunch of brilliant people to come along with me so they wouldn't waste their lives spending augmented reality mustache emojis and instead they could do some work for our armed forces but it's worth looking at the past and realizing that this is a recent problem it's not something that has been the case for a very long time silicon valley was largely built on the back of defense in 1947 half of stanford's engineering budget came from the department of defense fred turman stanford dean brought dod contracts and interest to the west coast in a way that had fundamentally been limited almost entirely to the east coast and silicon valley helped power a lot of the things that are powering the modern military machine in the 1950s alone we built the pentagon well sorry i i i i have an error in my notes this is wrong um in the lead up to the 50s and the early 50s we built the pentagon in 16 months we completed the manhattan project in three years we put a man on the moon in under a decade and just between 1951 and 1959 we built five generations of fighter jets three generations of bombers two classes of carriers nuclear powered submarines and ballistic missiles to go on top of them if you look at the current state of the industry we're lucky to do even one of these things in a decade and i can't really blame the the defense industry for not working with the dod entirely it's not just an ideological problem it's also an economic problem when the cold war ended the government really became a pretty terrible customer the technology industry drifted away most engineers in silicon valley do not remember a great power conflict because they haven't lived in a world where a great power was an existential threat to the united states and so you have a lot of people who are ideologically opposed to working with the military now we could spend an entire talk i only have a few minutes to talk today we talked we spent a whole talk talking about the ethics of defense and you know what what the reasonable critiques of the military are and how you can change what you build for them in a good way but i'll i'll throw out a factor that i think most people don't think about enough even the people who do agree on working with the military there's a lot of companies in silicon valley and and and elsewhere who look at those employees who are ideologically opposed to working with the military and they use them as a smoke screen pretending that it's principled opposition that drives their decision when in reality they want access to chinese markets they want access to chinese investment they want access to other countries that are tied into these things and so they're able to use these people who are ideologically opposed to working with the military which actually make up a pretty small fraction of the u.s population as a smoke screen for their real intention which is to preserve access to those markets preserve access to those capital our largest companies are not making these decisions based on what is best for the united states certainly not what is best for the united states in the long term they're largely making the decisions based on short-term ideas that are not based in any kind of long-term thinking if you look at the recent ships bill that congress passed saying that they're the the united states government is going to put uh 50 billion 52 billion dollars into building semiconductors in the united states you have to compare that with the recent news that well it leaked it wasn't what wasn't news on purpose but apple has pledged to put 275 billion dollars as one company into chinese manufacturing you have one company putting in more than five times as much money into manufacturing advanced technology as what is supposed to be a landmark piece of u.s legislation the situation that we're in is is pretty weird uh this is going to sound hyperbolic but bear with me the situation we were in right now would be like if in the build-up to world war ii general electric had said you know what we really like the united states but we're actually very bullish on imperial japan we think it's going to be a huge growth opportunity for us and our metrics just aren't going to look the same if we wipe those off of our road map imagine if in the build up to the cold war if you had had westinghouse and other major u.s technology companies say ah you know we love manufacturing in the united states but we actually think communist manufacturing is a really interesting experiment that we need to see through and you know we're not sure that we really want to take a side on this uh the situation that we are in today is as dire or worse the only reason that it seems ridiculous and the only reason it seems hyperbolic is because conflict has not actually broken out yet if a conflict does break out we're going to look at the current situation where we are hugely strategically and economically dependent at the highest levels of our technology industry and government on an adversary that is literally committing genocide and slaving millions of people we are going to look back on ourselves and feel really stupid now the good news is that because of russia's invasion of ukraine defense is now the current thing uh in the united states there is this idea that any problem can be fixed at the last second with just a really incredible twist if we just come up with the right thing but there's a lot of problems out there that cannot be solved that way national security economic policy environmental policy these are things that require non-political bipartisan agreement on the problem decades before it becomes a really big problem those are not things that are acceptable current things uh shape rotation this is an acceptable current thing to debate uh whether or not will smith was wrong to uh to to wrong to take the slap or if he's just you know a representative of warrior culture you know that's that's a that's a fair debate to have the idea of the united states having a military that is strong enough to deter conflict should not be in that category so why is it two why is it too late to care about defense now at this exact moment in time why is it too late for everybody to suddenly change their minds uh well a few things one you go to war with the tools that you have not the tools that you wish you had or the tools that you start working on when things become a problem if you look at the weapons that were given to ukraine they were built in the 80s 90s and 2000s 40 billion dollars plus worth of them and for all their differences defense is one of the few things that republicans and democrats alike have realized transcends the partisan divide on one level it's obviously very bad that we don't have more modern weapons to give to ukraine but on the other it shows a level of foresight and planning that we've been stockpiling and building these legacy weapons systems for decades explicitly for a situation like today which has been war gamed out to the nth degree imagine if the department of defense had done nothing to prepare for war for 40 years and then as soon as war broke out they started tweeting a lot and changed their profile pictures to ukraine flag and then started saying you know we stand with ukraine uh the the people who are actually tasked with solving these problems are uh they generally have good planning but there's only so much they can do without good technology so i want to reiterate if you only start building now you've lost the chance to deter war from happening that's the real purpose of the defense industry it's not to fight wars it's not to win wars it's to prevent wars from happening wars happen when one or both sides misestimate their probability of winning if both sides agree that one side or the other is going to win typically you end up with diplomatic resolution it's when both sides disagree about the possibility of winning that conflict actually actually breaks out and so if you actually want to prevent conflict from happening in the first place you have to get involved well ahead of time if you get involved after conflict breaking out breaks out like so many companies have you're ensuring that you're only going to be a part of the killing you're only going to be a part of the bloodshed you're only going to be a part of the war you're not going to be a part of preventing the war from happening in the first place so i would argue that people in the technology industry need to work on defense not because it's the current thing but because it's the right thing i have one more thing that i want to say thank you i talked earlier about npc thinking that prioritizes popularity over principles what i'm about to do is in very very bad taste but i'm going to do it anyway yeah we'll see one of the people who i think embodies this type of npc thinking of going with what's popular and not being willing to to to ever reverse their position even when they're proven wrong is jason calcanis let me read about some of the things he said about me over the years just just a small sampling palmer lucky hideous what an idiot a [ __ ] this guy parker lucky parker lucky a complete and utter [ __ ] jesus this kid is an idiot palmer lucky is just an idiot and a troll he is dumb so so so dumb oh no we got to keep going for him to pull the plug in the palmer lucky experience was brilliant kudos zuckerberg a complete lack of moral character and leadership palmer lucky a complete [ __ ] palmer doesn't care about any of his employees family members or team members now this doesn't include any of the lies that he's told about me this doesn't including the lies he's told about my businesses this doesn't include any of the terrible things that his co-hosts and guests have said about me over the years that went unchallenged and egged on if i'm a hideous stupid person with no morals who doesn't care about my family or my employees i shouldn't be invited here no matter how relevant ukraine is he's had many chances to retract or apologize these statements and rather than taking any of them he keeps telling people that the reason i won't be on the show is because i'm too thin-skinned because i disagree with him on some of the things he said about oculus this is not the case i've explicitly told him why i've refused to be on a show it's because he and his crew of bullies have been vicious liars who've attacked me for years and berated me for years and spread lies about me for real years in a way that i've been able to overcome that very few entrepreneurs would have the money or the resources or the credibility to do and being nice to a few people like i'm sure he's being nice to you does not excuse this this isn't debatable whether it happened or not it clearly happened it's these are all direct quotes from things that he said over the years both while i was at oculus and during my time after oculus and jason like many influential people some of them even in this room who have treated me like [ __ ] for years suddenly changed their tune as soon as andrew was on the upswing as soon as we were doing good things they started inviting me on their podcasts liking all my social media posts putting me on their innovator lists all without any acknowledgement whatsoever that they were the ones that were attacking me when it was popular kicking me while i was on the ground and treating me like garbage it's really pathetic because a lot of my remaining critics at least are basing their opinions on some kind of consistent world view a lot of other people are attacking me and the work that i do because it's popular when it's popular to attack me they attack me when it's unpopular to attack me when ukraine is being attacked they are suddenly friends and those are the same people that i know are going to go back to [ __ ] on me the second that it becomes popular again um i'm coming to the end of this and i know that you guys are probably thinking wow this guy's pretty thin skin for a billionaire that's fair that's fair but i want to remind you something jason and the people like him are the reason i was fired for my from oculus my own company the company it was my heart and my soul for my entire teenage and adult life for him it was a game it was his show and for me it was everything and i lost everything it almost destroyed me i'm still filled with rage about it i always will be i'll end with this i was able to create andro because a small group of people were willing to give me a second chance to let me build something great in an important but controversial industry that was being constantly berated by people who thought we lived at the end of history they invested in me while jason was trying to poison my career and keep me on the ground thank god he failed thank god for investors who ignore him and people like him the market conditions suggest they're going to be a lot of founders hopefully none of the people in this room losing their startups over the next year or so and i pray that they get a second chance like i did i pray they aren't deterred from working on important but unpopular problems i pray that they will successfully claw their way back to success that they aren't deterred from working on things that really matter i pray that they manage to do this despite the inevitably stupid and hot takes sorry inevitably stupid and spiteful hot takes that jason his associates and the many people like him who make money spewing [ __ ] are certainly going to be putting out there amen thank you join us great to meet you in person um jason what lessons have we learned here today well i mean i guess we were talking backstage and jason's like oh you know i had to do so much to get this guy here because i think he hates me and this was before this [ __ ] happened and i was like well maybe you shouldn't talk [ __ ] about people well the good thing is i was able to make it to this stage to say this most of the people that you've gone after this way will never have that opportunity because they won't start a second unicorn i'm only here because i managed to claw my way back and remember this is personal because it's not just you it's you you're one of the most influential certainly but it's you and really a small cadre of people that by attacking me ceaselessly made it impossible for me to continue my tenure at oculus i'm really lucky i clawed my way back because that's exceedingly rare for a company to do the person to do that what i was hoping to talk about your new thing but i guess since we have no choice but go here what happened at facebook and maybe you can just explain that and what i i got wrong about what happened well it's not just what's wrong this is actually why i i went out of my way there's actually a lot of lies you told and spread and your co-hosts and your guests uh but i'm not even talking about those the things that i listed you'll notice these aren't material accusations these are just personal attacks you've made on my character these are just things you've said about me personally as a founder and entrepreneur vicious personal attacks separately there's all of the lies you've said about how oculus didn't have any differentiated technology it was totally commoditized anybody could have done it it really was just right thing at the right time we could spend all day talk about why these aren't true but the real reason that it became untenable for me and the real reason that i'm not in the vr industry is because people like you were enabling those lies and then being vicious about it and attacking me personally it became clear i couldn't be a representative in an industry where people are going to treat me like fairly or not imagine doing a podcast with them what's that impact you're doing a podcast i guess if you have no choice but to keep i'll just ask you do you want us to just describe what palmer's talking about can i can i try my best no no hold on what what what because my memory of of the events uh you just read all the things you said right but what is the what were we talking about at the time well there was a lot of controversy at facebook about some donations anonymous accounts things just said well so those that wasn't one thing that was over the course of years so that was just a small sampling um i had to really find a small sample you know you can't you can't ever do it but i'll tell you what this would be fired from facebook what was the controversy there because that's what i was commenting on in this well no some of those were after i w
- Assistant
Palmer Luckey, the founder of Oculus VR and Anduril Industries, delivered a compelling address at the All-In Summit 2022, focusing on the intersection of technology and national security.
Introduction and Acknowledgments
The event commenced with expressions of gratitude towards the organizing team and the audience. Special thanks were extended to notable speakers, including Bill Gurley, Brett Gerstner, Edina, Mark Tandis, Tim, Elon, Antonio, Nate, Ryan, Claire, Antonio Garcia Martinez, Joe Lonsdale, James Matt Taibbi, Glenn Greenwald, and the featured guest, Palmer Luckey.
Palmer Luckey's Professional Journey
Palmer Luckey recounted his entrepreneurial path:
-
Oculus VR: Founded at 19, developed virtual reality headsets, and later sold to Facebook for several billion dollars.
-
Anduril Industries: Established to innovate in the national security sector, focusing on defense technology.
Technology Industry's Stance on National Security
Luckey highlighted the tech industry's delayed recognition of national security's importance, attributing it to ideological and business factors. He criticized major tech companies, such as Google, for refusing to collaborate with the Department of Defense, and noted the absence of startups in the defense sector due to concerns over potential career repercussions.
Challenges in Defense Innovation
He addressed the difficulties in securing investment for defense startups, even with a proven track record. Investors often questioned the ethics of developing military technologies, doubting the relevance of deterrence through a strong arsenal. Luckey emphasized the necessity of a robust defense to prevent conflicts, referencing historical misconceptions like Norman Angell's 1909 assertion that war in Europe was impossible due to economic interdependence.
Founding of Anduril Industries
Luckey's decision to establish Anduril was driven by:
-
Previous Experience: Work on military projects like "Bravemind," a virtual reality therapy for veterans with PTSD.
-
Defense Industry's Shortcomings: Observations of outdated technology and misaligned incentives within the defense sector.
Critique of the U.S. Defense Industry
He criticized the U.S. defense industry's inefficiencies:
-
Artificial Intelligence: Despite leading in commercial AI, the U.S. military lags behind adversaries like China in implementing AI in defense systems.
-
Procurement Processes: Incentives favor prolonged projects over cost-effective, functional solutions.
Historical Context and Call for Innovation
Luckey reminisced about past defense achievements, such as the rapid construction of the Pentagon and the Manhattan Project, contrasting them with current stagnation. He urged the tech industry to re-engage with defense, emphasizing the need for proactive innovation to deter future conflicts.
Personal Reflections and Industry Critique
He shared personal experiences of public criticism and the challenges of re-entering the tech industry post-Oculus. Luckey condemned the opportunistic nature of some industry figures who shift their stance based on prevailing sentiments.
Conclusion
Luckey concluded by advocating for the tech industry's involvement in defense, not as a trend but as a moral imperative. He encouraged resilience among entrepreneurs facing adversity and emphasized the importance of focusing on impactful, albeit controversial, sectors.
Highlighted Technical Terms and Concepts
-
Virtual Reality (VR): Simulated experiences that can be similar to or completely different from the real world.
-
Artificial Intelligence (AI): Simulation of human intelligence in machines programmed to think and learn.
-
Defense Procurement: Process by which governments acquire military equipment and technology.
-
Asymmetrical Advantage: Leveraging unique strengths to counteract an opponent's advantages.
-
Autonomous Systems: Machines or software capable of performing tasks without human intervention.
-
Sensor Fusion: Combining sensory data from disparate sources to produce more accurate information.
-
National Security: Protection of a nation from threats through economic, military, and political power.
-
Military-Industrial Complex: Relationship between a country's military and the defense industry.
-
Strategic Adversaries: Nations or entities posing significant threats to a country's interests.
-
Deterrence: Preventing hostile actions by demonstrating the ability to respond effectively.
This structured overview encapsulates the key points from Palmer Luckey's address, emphasizing the critical intersection of technology and national security.
-
Other models, same or similar prompt
Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.