Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
Geminigemini-2.5-pro-exp-03-25-wo-search· GoogleHugging Face LMArena Search Arena 24K

Find the closest reddit thread to the theme of this comment: Tiler: I did not learn…

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with Geminigemini-2.0-flash-grounding’s answer.
  1. User

    Find the closest reddit thread to the theme of this comment:

    Tiler: I did not learn anything in childhood, school, vocational school/college, university, courses. All his youth was a merrymaker and a hooligan. He has to learn nothing on weekdays after work, on holidays and weekends. His knowledge is never out of date. Can work all his life, will not be replaced by a neuroset deepseek ever. Does not work for hire. He has no bosses, he has only completed contracts. Does not work with other people's bugs from dawn to dusk. He has a wife and children, but he is cheerful, athletic and sociable. His colleagues are adequate adult men. They are solidaristic, friendly, help each other and defend their profession. Cannot be replaced by an Uzbek, as there are not really that many Uzbeks. And Uzbeks already prefer South Korea to Russia. In the course of work he acquires blat and connections, for example, when he lays tiles for wealthy people in expensive cottages in the private sector of the city. Clients don't demand to change absolutely everything every two weeks on ajail/scrum. Will never face a dead end situation where all the tiles in the world have already been laid. Doesn't scream all over the internet that tilers are shoveling lots of money, doesn't go anywhere to teach or groom competitors. Never experienced that YouTube, VK, Facebook, Instagram, Telegram turned out to be littered with courses and propaganda of entry to tilers. Does not blush with shame, does not humiliate himself at 10-stage interviews in front of bullied jerks twice younger and twice lighter in weight than himself. He can take his own unclaimed leftover building materials from work - they can be sold. He gets a tip. He is thanked from the bottom of his heart. His work makes sense, people understand what they are paying for. He has a free schedule. Works without overtime. Can easily change careers. For example, become a drywaller, plumber, electrician. His hard- and soft-skills are in demand in other professions. He didn't learn English. At the same time, he can go to another country without a diploma and knowledge of a foreign language and immediately find a job in his specialty there. He considers himself to be the most ordinary person, but he is respected by strong and brave men, and ass and boob women fall in love with him. He earns 2200 rubles an hour. A programmer taken at random: He sat all his childhood behind the most boring books on lambda-calculus and in front of the monitor, played with linker and compiler all day long, played QWERTY piano, won math Olympiads at school. Has a red university degree, also took courses as a child and young adult. Killed many hours in English. Must study on weekdays after work, holidays and weekends. Until retirement or the date of termination. His knowledge becomes obsolete every few years. May not work all his life in his specialty, as he will either be replaced by a deepseek neuroset, or he will be told that at 40 he is too old for the team and thrown overboard the galley. A lifelong employee. He's commanded by a supervisor, like a grandfather in the army. Drowns in legacy code. Curses the other programmers and everything they had done years before he came to the project. Lives without a wife, without children, sad 24/7, uncommunicative and unsportsmanlike. His colleagues are infantilized: they are not solidaristic, atomized, act in the interests of employers and against the interests of programmers. He can easily be replaced by an Indian or a Russian-speaking Uzbek from Tashkent (a city of millions with a metro) on a remote basis. In the process of work he does not acquire any connections, blat. In IT, clients are constantly generating crazy ideas, demanding to change absolutely everything every two weeks on ajail/scrum. In a few years will face a situation where all the needed software in the world is already written. “The station is terminal, with your stuff out!” Shouts all over the internet that programmers are raking in a lot of money, teaches courses or universities, proactively trains competitors. Faces the fact that YouTube, VK, Facebook, Instagram, Telegram are now littered with courses and propaganda for entering his profession. Humiliates himself in 10-step interviews in front of cocky bespectacled men half his age. Can't take non-liquids and leftovers from work except an old mouse and keyboard. The old mouse and keyboard can't be sold to anyone. He never gets left a tip for chips and bugs written down. People don't understand well what programmers do and how the world benefits from them. And his work itself has no sense, because every couple-three years all his code is thrown away, gradually replacing it with new, rewritten code. He works without a free schedule, like a worker on an assembly line. He also has to endure overtime, all sorts of “well, answer email on Saturday night”, “well, pick up the fallen production on Sunday morning”. He can't change his profession, it's become a prison for him. Neither hard- nor soft-skills of a programmer are in demand outside the world of shifting jasons. A programmer doesn't know where to get out of ai. Can't go to another country without a degree, not able to immediately find a job these days.

  2. Gemini Assistant

    Okay, the provided text is a very specific and somewhat satirical comparison highlighting the perceived downsides of a programming career versus the idealized upsides of a skilled trade (using a tiler as the example). It touches on themes of:

    1. Job Security & Obsolescence: Trades seen as stable and immune to AI/ageism vs. programming seen as precarious.
    2. Work-Life Balance & Stress: Trades depicted as having better hours, less stress, more social connection vs. programming with overtime, pressure, and isolation.
    3. Learning Curve & Skill Decay: Trades skills seen as timeless vs. programming requiring constant, stressful relearning.
    4. Tangibility & Fulfillment: Tilers producing visible, appreciated results vs. programmers dealing with abstract, often discarded code.
    5. Respect & Social Status: Tilers respected by peers and clients vs. programmers facing humiliating interviews and lack of understanding.
    6. Competition & Market Saturation: Programming seen as oversaturated with courses and global competition vs. trades having localized demand and less hype.
    7. Bureaucracy vs. Autonomy: Tilers working independently on contracts vs. programmers stuck in corporate structures (Agile/Scrum) with bosses.

    Finding the Closest Reddit Thread:

    You won't find a single thread that perfectly mirrors this exact, detailed, and somewhat exaggerated comparison. However, the themes are very common in certain subreddits. The closest types of threads you'll find are typically located in:

    1. r/cscareerquestions: This is probably the most likely place. You'll find countless threads discussing:

      • Burnout in software development.
      • Concerns about ageism in tech.
      • Fears about AI replacing programmers (especially entry-level).
      • Frustration with the constant need to learn new technologies ("learning treadmill").
      • Complaints about interview processes (multiple rounds, LeetCode).
      • Discussions about market saturation, especially at the entry-level due to bootcamps and online courses (similar to the "propaganda" point).
      • Threads titled like "Is software development still worth it?", "Thinking of leaving tech for trades," or "Regretting my CS degree."
    2. r/programming: While more technical, discussions about the state of the industry, AI threats, burnout, and occasionally comparisons to other fields pop up.

    3. r/antiwork: This sub focuses on worker dissatisfaction across many fields, but the tech industry's pressures (long hours, demanding culture, potential precarity despite high initial salaries) are frequent topics that resonate with the programmer side of the comparison.

    4. r/ExperiencedDevs: Similar to r/cscareerquestions, but focused on mid-to-senior level developers. Discussions here often touch upon ageism, burnout, the value of experience vs. chasing new trends, and long-term career sustainability, mirroring the anxieties expressed in the text.

    5. r/findapath or r/careerguidance: People exploring career changes often post threads comparing their current (sometimes tech) jobs to alternatives, including skilled trades, touching upon work-life balance, fulfillment, and stability.

    Search Terms to Find Similar Threads:

    • "leaving tech for trades reddit"
    • "software developer burnout reddit"
    • "programmer vs trades reddit"
    • "tech job saturation reddit"
    • "ageism tech reddit"
    • "ai replacing programmers reddit"
    • "is programming worth it reddit"

    In Summary:

    The closest match won't be a single thread replicating the tiler/programmer narrative verbatim. Instead, look for threads on r/cscareerquestions discussing burnout, disillusionment with tech, fears of AI/ageism/saturation, and comparisons between software development and skilled trades as potential alternative career paths. These threads capture the spirit and many of the specific complaints leveled against the programming profession in the provided text.

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.