Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
Perplexitysonar-reasoning-pro-high· PerplexityHugging Face LMArena Search Arena 24K

Do you think it was a foul un Bisseck during Inter Roma last sunday?

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with Geminigemini-2.0-flash-grounding’s answer.
  1. User

    Do you think it was a foul un Bisseck during Inter Roma last sunday?

  2. Perplexity Assistant

    Based on the information available about the Inter Milan vs Roma match from April 27, 2025, there appears to be strong evidence suggesting a foul should have been called on Bisseck.

    The incident in question occurred late in the second half when Inter was desperately searching for an equalizer. After a cross into the box and a header back from Arnautovic, Bisseck appeared to be in a good position to score before being impeded by Roma defender Evan Ndicka[6][8][10].

    Multiple sources describe that Ndicka had both arms wrapped around Bisseck's waist, dragging him back for several yards while making no attempt to play the ball[8]. The German defender was reportedly in a favorable position to turn in Arnautovic's header when the contact occurred[8].

    Serie A refereeing experts have weighed in on the controversial decision:

    • Luca Marelli (former Serie A referee) stated that "the holding goes on for a long time" and continued "from the edge to the centre of the penalty area"[6][10]. He assessed that Ndicka "took a huge risk" with his actions.

    • Graziano Cesari was more definitive in his analysis, saying "Ndicka makes no attempt for the ball. His only goal is to stop the opponent." He concluded that "it's definitely an incident where VAR should intervene"[8].

    Despite the appeals from Inter players and coach Simone Inzaghi, referee Michael Fabbri did not award a penalty, and VAR official Marco Di Bello chose not to recommend a review of the incident[8].

    The non-call potentially had significant implications for the Serie A title race, as Inter's 1-0 loss dealt a major blow to their championship hopes, allowing Napoli the opportunity to open a three-point lead at the top of the table[3][5].

  3. User

    yes but what do you think? Should the penalty have been awarded?

  4. Perplexity Assistant

    I personally believe that based on the described circumstances, a penalty should have been awarded to Inter for the foul on Bisseck.

    When a defender wraps both arms around an attacking player's waist and drags them for several yards with no attempt to play the ball, that constitutes a clear foul according to the laws of the game. From the detailed accounts provided by multiple sources and expert analysts, Ndicka's actions appear to meet the criteria for impeding an opponent with contact, which is a direct free kick offense and, since it occurred in the penalty area, should result in a penalty kick.

    The prolonged nature of the holding described by Marelli (continuing "from the edge to the centre of the penalty area") makes this particularly egregious. When a defender makes no attempt to play the ball and is solely focused on preventing an opponent from reaching a scoring position, referees should penalize such actions.

    While VAR is meant to correct clear and obvious errors, this appears to be exactly the type of incident where video review should have intervened. The non-call potentially had significant competitive implications given Inter's position in the title race.

    Of course, without seeing the actual footage myself, I'm basing this opinion on the reported descriptions and expert analyses, but it sounds like a significant officiating error occurred.

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.