sonar LMArena Search Arena 24K
Read this scenario: "The buyer purchases the property and alters the contract to extend…
- User
Read this scenario: "The buyer purchases the property and alters the contract to extend the closing date without the seller’s consent". Is this scenario an example of "Impossibility of Performance" or "Operation of Law"?
- Assistant
The scenario where "The buyer purchases the property and alters the contract to extend the closing date without the seller’s consent" is neither an example of Impossibility of Performance nor Operation of Law.
Here’s why:
Impossibility of Performance
- This doctrine applies when an unforeseen event occurs after the contract is made that makes performance literally impossible or commercially impracticable without fault of the party seeking excuse. Examples include destruction of the subject matter, death or illness preventing performance, or new laws making performance illegal[1][2][3][7].
- In the scenario, the buyer unilaterally changes the contract terms (extending the closing date) without the seller’s consent. This is a voluntary act by the buyer, not an unforeseen event making performance impossible. Therefore, it does not qualify as impossibility of performance.
Operation of Law
- Operation of law refers to rights or liabilities created automatically by legal principles, regardless of the parties’ intent or actions. Examples include property transfer upon death without a will, joint tenancy survivorship, bankruptcy, or contract termination due to destruction of the subject matter by law[6][8].
- The buyer’s unilateral alteration of the contract is not an automatic legal consequence imposed by law; it is an unauthorized modification by one party. Hence, it is not an operation of law.
Conclusion
- The buyer’s action of altering the contract without the seller’s consent is a breach or unauthorized modification of contract terms, not a situation excusing performance due to impossibility or a legal consequence arising automatically by operation of law.
Thus, this scenario is neither "Impossibility of Performance" nor "Operation of Law." It is a contractual breach or unauthorized amendment.
Other models, same or similar prompt
Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.