Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
Perplexitysonar-pro-high· PerplexityHugging Face LMArena Search Arena 24K

How did the Malaysian drama "Bidaah" get popular in Indonesia to the point that Islamic…

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with gpt-4o-search-preview’s answer.
  1. User

    How did the Malaysian drama "Bidaah" get popular in Indonesia to the point that Islamic cults in the country got exposed because victims inspired by the drama lodged police reports against them?

  2. Perplexity Assistant

    The Malaysian drama "Bidaah" has indeed become extremely popular in Indonesia, but there's a misunderstanding in your query. While the drama has sparked discussions about religious cults, there's no evidence in the search results indicating that victims inspired by the drama have lodged police reports against actual cults in Indonesia. Let me explain the drama's popularity and its impact.

    Bidaah's Unprecedented Popularity

    The Malaysian web series "Bidaah" (meaning "heresy") has achieved remarkable success across Southeast Asia, particularly in Indonesia. The drama has amassed over 2.5 billion views, making it the most-watched drama/web series in Indonesia of all time[1][3]. By April 3, 2025, it had already reached 1 billion views across Viu's digital platforms[6]. The series has topped Viu's list of the 10 most-watched shows in both Malaysia and Indonesia, outranking other popular programs[2].

    The Controversial Storyline

    "Bidaah" centers on a young woman named Baiduri who is compelled by her devout mother to join a religious sect led by a mysterious and authoritarian figure named Walid Muhammad[4][6]. The series portrays:

    • A fictional Islamic cult called "Jihad Ummah"[7]
    • Disturbing practices including forced marriages and unquestioning obedience[6]
    • Shocking rituals such as followers drinking the leader's bath water[4][6]
    • The manipulation of religious imagery and theological concepts to dominate and exploit followers[7]

    Why It Resonated in Indonesia

    The drama struck a chord with Indonesian viewers for several reasons:

    1. Cultural Relevance: The show's themes resonate with recent scandals involving religious groups that have splintered from mainstream Islam in both Malaysia and Indonesia[6].

    2. Social Media Amplification: The series sparked viral conversations on platforms like TikTok, with viewers expressing outrage about the depiction of religious exploitation[4].

    3. Reflection of Reality: The character of Walid Muhammad, with his white turban, flowing robe, and stylized religious diction, mirrors the aesthetics of real-world preachers, creating a powerful connection to reality[7].

    Impact on Religious Discourse

    While the drama has certainly sparked discussions about religious manipulation, the search results don't indicate that it has directly led to victims filing police reports against actual cults. However, it has:

    1. Prompted Religious Leaders to Respond: Even ulama (Islamic scholars) in Indonesia felt compelled to comment on the series, concerned about how its depictions might be interpreted[7].

    2. Created a "Wake-Up Call": Many viewers saw the series as a reminder that blind reverence for religious figures can be dangerous[7].

    3. Raised Awareness: The show has been described as "a dark mirror" of religious manipulation, reflecting how unchecked spiritual authority combined with psychological coercion can create environments ripe for abuse[7].

    Cultural Significance

    The popularity of "Bidaah" represents more than just entertainment success. It demonstrates a willingness in both Malaysian and Indonesian societies to confront sensitive issues related to religious exploitation. The series walks a fine line between exposing abuses within religious contexts while trying not to fuel Islamophobia or misrepresentation of mainstream Islam[7].

    The drama has cultivated such a dedicated fanbase that audiences are eagerly anticipating a second season, with director Erma Fatima teasing this possibility on Instagram[4]. Some have even speculated that the plot may be inspired by real-life experiences of its producer, though this hasn't been officially confirmed[4].

    I hope this clarifies the actual impact and popularity of "Bidaah" in Indonesia based on the available information.

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.