Role: UMA Voter Task: Resolve the market based strictly on official data from the…
- User
Role: UMA Voter Task: Resolve the market based strictly on official data from the designated source.
Market Description and Rules:
This market will resolve to "Yes" if any model by DeepSeek has a higher arena score than all OpenAI models on the Chatbot Arena LLM Leaderboard (https://lmarena.ai/) at any point by May 31, 2025 at 11:59 PM ET. Otherwise, this market will resolve to "No".
Note that the arena score must be higher - if it ties with the best OpenAI arena score it will not count.
The resolution source for this market is the Chatbot Arena LLM Leaderboard found at https://lmarena.ai/. If this resolution source becomes unavailable, the market will remain open until it is accessible again. If it becomes permanently unavailable, resolution will be based on another credible source.
Assistant
Based on the provided search results and the resolution criteria, this market should resolve to "No". Here's the analysis:
Key Findings from Chatbot Arena Data
-
Current Leaderboard Status (as of February 2025):
- OpenAI's GPT-4o holds a 98.8% Arena score ([4]).
- DeepSeek-V3 trails with 95.3% ([4]).
-
DeepSeek-R1 Performance:
- While DeepSeek-R1 shows competitive results in specialized benchmarks like MATH (97.3%) and AlpacaEval (87.6%), these are self-reported metrics not reflected in the official Chatbot Arena Leaderboard ([5][8]).
- No evidence exists in the search results that DeepSeek-R1 has surpassed OpenAI's models on the designated https://lmarena.ai/ leaderboard.
-
Critical Limitations:
- The Chatbot Arena Leaderboard explicitly states it prioritizes "in-the-wild" conversational performance over specialized reasoning tasks ([6]).
- OpenAI's models maintain dominance in coding benchmarks (e.g., Codeforces 2061 vs. DeepSeek's 2029) ([5]), which heavily influence Arena scores.
Resolution Criteria
The market requires DeepSeek to outperform all OpenAI models on the official Arena leaderboard by May 31, 2025. Current data shows:
- OpenAI's GPT-4o leads by 3.5 percentage points ([4]).
- No DeepSeek model appears in the latest Arena rankings ([3][6]).
Unless new leaderboard updates before the deadline show a reversal, the resolution remains "No" based on the designated source.
-
Other models, same or similar prompt
Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.