Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
Geminigemini-2.5-pro-exp-03-25-grounding· GoogleHugging Face LMArena Search Arena 24K

Mixtral-8x22

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with gpt-4o-search-preview-high-loc’s answer.
  1. User

    Mixtral-8x22

  2. Gemini Assistant

    Mixtral-8x22B is a large language model (LLM) developed and released by the French AI company Mistral AI in April 2024. It is characterized as an open-weight model, available under the permissive Apache 2.0 license, allowing broad use without restrictions.

    Key features and characteristics of Mixtral-8x22B include:

    • Architecture: It employs a sparse Mixture-of-Experts (SMoE) architecture. This means it uses different smaller models ("experts") for different parts of a task, activating only the necessary ones.
    • Parameters: While the model has a total of 141 billion parameters, its SMoE architecture means only 39 billion parameters are active during inference (the process of generating output). This makes it computationally efficient for its size. Some sources mention 176B total parameters, potentially differing in how shared parameters are counted.
    • Efficiency: Due to its sparse activation, Mixtral-8x22B is designed for cost efficiency and speed, performing faster than dense models with significantly more active parameters (like a 70B parameter model). It aims to deliver a strong performance-to-cost ratio.
    • Context Window: It supports a context window of 64,000 tokens, allowing it to process and recall information from large amounts of text.
    • Multilingual Capabilities: The model is fluent in several languages, including English, French, German, Italian, and Spanish. It demonstrates strong performance on benchmarks across these languages.
    • Strengths: Mixtral-8x22B excels in mathematics, coding, and reasoning tasks. An "instruct" version showed particularly high performance on math benchmarks like GSM8K. It also natively supports function calling, which allows it to interact with external tools and structure its output for specific applications.
    • Performance: Benchmarks indicate that Mixtral-8x22B outperforms other leading open-source models like Llama 2 70B and Cohere's Command R+ on several reasoning, knowledge, math, and coding tasks. It sets a high standard for performance among open-weight models.

    Availability:

    • The model weights were initially released via a BitTorrent link on April 10, 2024, followed by releases on platforms like Hugging Face. Mistral AI officially announced the model on April 17, 2024.
    • It is available through various platforms, including Mistral AI's "la Plateforme," NVIDIA API catalog (powered by NVIDIA NIM microservices), Amazon SageMaker JumpStart, and others.

    Mixtral-8x22B represents a significant advancement in open-source LLMs, combining high performance, especially in technical and multilingual domains, with notable efficiency due to its MoE architecture.

  3. User

    8× 22vs deepseek 70B

  4. Gemini Assistant

    Okay, let's compare Mixtral-8x22B with the large models from DeepSeek AI, specifically DeepSeek Coder 67B and DeepSeek LLM 67B (often referred to generally around the "70B" mark).

    Here's a breakdown of the comparison points:

    1. Architecture:

      • Mixtral-8x22B: Uses a sparse Mixture-of-Experts (SMoE) architecture. It has 8 "experts," but only activates 2 per token during inference.
      • DeepSeek 67B Models: These are typically dense Transformer models, meaning all parameters are active during inference.
    2. Parameters:

      • Mixtral-8x22B: Contains a total of 141 billion parameters, but only uses approximately 39 billion active parameters during inference due to its SMoE design.
      • DeepSeek 67B Models: Have around 67 billion parameters, all of which are active during inference.
    3. Training Focus & Specialization:

      • Mixtral-8x22B: Designed as a high-performance general-purpose model with strong capabilities in math, coding, reasoning, and multiple languages (English, French, German, Italian, Spanish).
      • DeepSeek Coder 67B: Specifically specialized and trained extensively on code (2 trillion tokens of code and relevant text). It aims for state-of-the-art performance in code generation and understanding.
      • DeepSeek LLM 67B: A general-purpose chat and reasoning model, trained on 2 trillion tokens of diverse text and code.
    4. Performance:

      • General Tasks (Reasoning, Knowledge): Mixtral-8x22B shows very strong performance, often outperforming other large open models like Llama 2 70B on various benchmarks. DeepSeek LLM 67B is also highly competitive in general tasks. Direct comparison depends heavily on the specific benchmark, but both are top-tier open models.
      • Coding: DeepSeek Coder 67B is exceptionally strong, often leading benchmarks like HumanEval and MBPP due to its specialized training data. While Mixtral-8x22B is capable at coding, the specialized DeepSeek Coder likely has an edge specifically for coding tasks.
      • Math: Mixtral-8x22B is noted for its strong performance on math benchmarks. DeepSeek LLM 67B also performs well on mathematical reasoning.
    5. Efficiency & Inference Cost:

      • Mixtral-8x22B: The SMoE architecture makes it significantly more efficient during inference than a dense model of its total size (141B). Its computational cost is closer to that of a 39B dense model, offering a better performance/cost ratio compared to similarly performing dense models.
      • DeepSeek 67B Models: As dense models, their inference cost is directly related to their 67B parameter count, which would typically be higher than Mixtral-8x22B's inference cost for potentially similar or slightly lower general performance (excluding specialized coding).
    6. Context Window:

      • Mixtral-8x22B: Supports a 64,000 token context window.
      • DeepSeek 67B Models: Have a base context window of 16,000 tokens. DeepSeek Coder 67B can be extended up to 128k tokens using specific techniques (window attention).
    7. Multilingualism:

      • Mixtral-8x22B: Explicitly trained for fluency in English, French, German, Italian, and Spanish.
      • DeepSeek 67B Models: Primarily trained on English and Chinese data, though capable in other languages. Mixtral likely has stronger native support for the listed European languages.
    8. License:

      • Mixtral-8x22B: Apache 2.0 license (permissive, open-weight).
      • DeepSeek 67B Models: DeepSeek Model License (allows research and commercial use, generally considered open-source but check specific terms).

    Summary - Which to Choose?

    • For dedicated, top-tier coding tasks: DeepSeek Coder 67B is likely the stronger choice due to its specialized training.
    • For general-purpose tasks, strong reasoning/math, or better performance/cost efficiency: Mixtral-8x22B is an excellent option, potentially outperforming DeepSeek LLM 67B in some general areas while being more efficient at inference.
    • For tasks requiring strong native support in French, German, Italian, or Spanish: Mixtral-8x22B has an advantage.
    • If inference budget is a major constraint: Mixtral-8x22B's SMoE architecture offers significant efficiency benefits over the dense DeepSeek models.
    • If needing a very long context window beyond 64k: The extended capability of DeepSeek Coder 67B (up to 128k) might be relevant, though Mixtral's 64k is substantial.

    Both represent the cutting edge of open-weight large language models, but their architectures and training focuses lead to different strengths and weaknesses depending on the application.

  5. User

    For fine tuning

  6. Gemini Assistant

    Okay, let's compare Mixtral-8x22B and the DeepSeek 67B models (LLM and Coder) specifically from the perspective of fine-tuning. The choice depends heavily on your specific goals, resources, and technical expertise.

    Here's a breakdown of factors to consider:

    1. Architecture and Fine-Tuning Complexity:

      • Mixtral-8x22B (SMoE): Fine-tuning Mixture-of-Experts models can be more complex than dense models.
        • Full Fine-Tuning: Tuning all 141 billion parameters is extremely resource-intensive (requiring massive amounts of VRAM and compute) and generally impractical for most users.
        • Parameter-Efficient Fine-Tuning (PEFT - e.g., LoRA, QLoRA): This is the more feasible approach. PEFT methods adapt a small subset of parameters. Applying PEFT to MoE models is an active area, but common strategies involve adding adapters to attention layers (often shared across experts) or sometimes targeting the gating network. While you only train a small number of parameters, the full model (141B params) still needs to be loaded into memory during training, demanding significant VRAM, though techniques like QLoRA drastically reduce this. The efficiency benefit of MoE (only ~39B active params) is primarily during inference, not necessarily during the fine-tuning training process itself unless specific MoE-aware optimization techniques are used.
      • DeepSeek 67B Models (Dense): Fine-tuning dense models is a more established process.
        • Full Fine-Tuning: Still very resource-intensive for a 67B model, but less so than Mixtral's 141B total parameters.
        • PEFT (LoRA, QLoRA): Standard PEFT techniques work directly and are well-documented for dense transformers. You would load the 67B parameters (quantized with QLoRA for memory savings) and train the adapter weights. This is computationally demanding but more straightforward than MoE PEFT.
    2. Compute and Memory Requirements (VRAM):

      • Mixtral-8x22B: Requires very high VRAM to even load the model for PEFT due to the 141B total parameters, even if using quantization (QLoRA). You'll likely need multiple high-end GPUs (e.g., A100 80GB or H100).
      • DeepSeek 67B: Also requires significant VRAM for fine-tuning (likely multiple GPUs), but less than Mixtral-8x22B's total parameter count would demand. QLoRA makes it feasible on configurations like 2x A100 80GB or potentially even high-VRAM consumer cards for smaller batch sizes/ranks.
      • Winner for Lower Resources: DeepSeek 67B is likely more accessible for fine-tuning with relatively fewer resources compared to Mixtral-8x22B, especially if not using advanced MoE-specific optimization strategies.
    3. Base Model Suitability for Target Task:

      • Fine-tuning for Coding: Start with DeepSeek Coder 67B. Its base training makes it the superior starting point, likely requiring less fine-tuning data/effort to achieve high performance on coding tasks.
      • Fine-tuning for General Reasoning, Math, or specific European Languages (Fr, De, It, Es): Start with Mixtral-8x22B. Its strong base performance in these areas provides a better foundation.
      • Fine-tuning for General Chat/Instruction Following: Both Mixtral-8x22B and DeepSeek LLM 67B are strong starting points. The choice might depend on compute availability (favoring DeepSeek if resources are tighter) or if Mixtral's specific strengths (math, multilingualism) align better with the desired chat capabilities.
    4. Ease of Implementation and Community Support:

      • Mixtral-8x22B: Fine-tuning MoE models is less common, and best practices might still be emerging. You might need to rely on more recent research papers or specialized library implementations. However, Mistral models generally have strong community support via Hugging Face.
      • DeepSeek 67B: Fine-tuning dense models using standard libraries like Hugging Face transformers, PEFT, and TRL is very common, with many tutorials and examples available.

    Summary Table for Fine-Tuning:

    FeatureMixtral-8x22BDeepSeek 67B (LLM/Coder)Recommendation Considerations
    ArchitectureSMoE (Sparse)DenseDeepSeek is simpler/more standard for fine-tuning.
    Total Parameters141B67BMixtral needs more VRAM to load, even for PEFT.
    Fine-Tuning ApproachPrimarily PEFT (e.g., QLoRA)PEFT (e.g., QLoRA) or Full (costly)PEFT is practical for both, but easier workflow for DeepSeek.
    VRAM Requirement (PEFT)Extremely HighVery HighDeepSeek is likely more accessible.
    Best Base for CodingGoodExcellent (DeepSeek Coder)Start with DeepSeek Coder for coding tasks.
    Best Base for Math/ReasoningExcellentVery Good (DeepSeek LLM)Start with Mixtral if these are key.
    Best Base for Multilingual (Fr/De/It/Es)ExcellentGoodStart with Mixtral for these languages.
    Ease of TuningMore Complex / Evolving PracticesMore Standard / EstablishedDeepSeek likely has a smoother path for standard PEFT.

    Conclusion:

    • If your priority is coding, fine-tune DeepSeek Coder 67B.
    • If your priority is general reasoning, math, or specific European languages, and you have very significant compute resources (especially VRAM), fine-tuning Mixtral-8x22B (using PEFT) could yield top results.
    • If you need a strong general model and compute resources are a major constraint (though still substantial), fine-tuning DeepSeek LLM 67B using PEFT is likely the more practical and straightforward option compared to Mixtral-8x22B.
  7. User

    Is possible to fine tuning one of 8 of 22

  8. Gemini Assistant

    That's a great question about the specifics of fine-tuning Mixture-of-Experts (MoE) models like Mixtral-8x22B.

    Here's the breakdown:

    1. Theoretical Possibility vs. Practicality:

      • Theoretically: Yes, with very low-level access to the model architecture and the training loop, you could technically freeze all parameters except those belonging to a single expert's Feed-Forward Network (FFN) and attempt to train only those weights.
      • Practically & Recommended: This is not a standard or generally recommended fine-tuning approach for MoE models, and it's likely to be ineffective or suboptimal for several reasons.
    2. Why Fine-Tuning Only One Expert is Problematic:

      • Gating Network (Router): The core of an MoE model is the gating network that dynamically decides which experts (usually 2 in Mixtral's case) process each input token. If you only fine-tune Expert #3, but the unchanged gating network rarely routes relevant tokens for your fine-tuning task to Expert #3, your training efforts will have little impact. The model relies on the combination of experts selected by the gate.
      • Shared Parameters: MoE models often share parameters across experts, particularly in the attention layers. Fine-tuning only one expert's FFN ignores potential necessary adaptations in these shared components, limiting the model's ability to learn the fine-tuning task effectively.
      • Expert Specialization: While we call them "experts," their specializations aren't necessarily neatly defined human concepts (like "the history expert" or "the coding expert"). Their roles emerge during pre-training based on data distribution and router behavior. Targeting just one might not align well with how the model actually processes information for your specific task.
      • Standard PEFT Approaches: Parameter-Efficient Fine-Tuning (PEFT) methods like LoRA (Low-Rank Adaptation) are the standard for adapting large models. When applied to MoE models, LoRA adapters are typically added to:
        • The shared attention mechanisms.
        • All the expert FFNs simultaneously (adding small trainable weights to each expert).
        • Sometimes, the gating network itself. These approaches adapt the model more holistically and are generally much more effective.

    In Summary:

    While you could technically attempt to isolate and update the weights of only one specific expert in Mixtral-8x22B, it's highly impractical, non-standard, and unlikely to yield good results. The model's architecture relies on the interplay between the router, shared components, and multiple experts working together.

    Effective fine-tuning typically involves using PEFT methods (like QLoRA) to adapt either shared components (like attention) or add small trainable adapter weights more broadly across the model (e.g., to all experts), rather than trying to surgically modify just one expert in isolation.

  9. User

    Is possible to fine-tuning each one 1 of 8 of 22 mixtral

  10. Gemini Assistant

    Okay, interpreting your question as "Is it possible to fine-tune each of the 8 experts within Mixtral-8x22B individually, one by one?"

    Similar to the previous answer about fine-tuning just one expert, attempting to fine-tune each expert individually and sequentially (e.g., tune Expert 1, freeze it, then tune Expert 2, freeze it, etc.) is generally not a standard, recommended, or effective approach for fine-tuning MoE models.

    Here's why this approach is problematic:

    1. Interdependence and the Gating Network: The experts don't work in isolation. The gating network routes tokens to specific experts (usually the top 2) based on the input and its learned parameters. If you fine-tune Expert 1 for a specific task, the gating network hasn't necessarily learned to route relevant tokens to it. If you then freeze Expert 1 and fine-tune Expert 2 for a different task, the gating network is still operating based on its original pre-training (or perhaps adaptations from tuning Expert 1), and may not route appropriately for Expert 2's new task. The experts and the router need to adapt together.
    2. Shared Parameters: Critical parts of the model, like the attention mechanisms, are typically shared across all experts. Fine-tuning only the Feed-Forward Network (FFN) part of one expert at a time ignores necessary adaptations in these shared layers, limiting the model's ability to learn effectively.
    3. Catastrophic Forgetting / Interference: Fine-tuning one expert for Task A might disrupt the delicate balance learned during pre-training, negatively impacting the performance of other experts on their original specializations. Sequentially tuning experts could lead to the model forgetting previously learned adaptations or tasks.
    4. Inefficiency: This sequential approach doesn't leverage the collaborative nature of the MoE architecture. The model's strength comes from combining the outputs of the selected experts. Trying to force specialization sequentially onto individual experts is unlikely to be as effective as adapting the whole system cohesively.

    The Standard and Effective Method:

    The effective way to fine-tune models like Mixtral-8x22B involves adapting the model more holistically, usually with Parameter-Efficient Fine-Tuning (PEFT) techniques like LoRA or QLoRA:

    • Adapting Shared Components: Add adapters to the shared attention layers.
    • Adapting All Experts Simultaneously: Add small, trainable adapter weights to the FFN layers of all 8 experts concurrently. This allows each expert to adapt slightly towards the new task while maintaining the overall MoE structure.
    • Adapting the Gate: Sometimes, adapters are also added to the gating network itself to help it learn better routing for the fine-tuning task.

    In Conclusion:

    No, it is not practical or effective to fine-tune each of the 8 experts in Mixtral-8x22B individually or sequentially. Fine-tuning requires adapting the interacting components of the model (router, shared layers, multiple experts) together, typically using PEFT methods that apply small changes across the relevant parts of the architecture simultaneously.

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.