Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
Geminigemini-2.5-pro-exp-03-25-wo-search· GoogleHugging Face LMArena Search Arena 24K

What is the best local AI Co Scientist with code available ?

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with Perplexitysonar-pro’s answer.
  1. User

    What is the best local AI Co Scientist with code available ?

  2. Gemini Assistant

    Okay, let's break down the concept of a "local AI Co-Scientist with code available."

    This is an emerging area, and there isn't one single, perfect, universally acclaimed "AI Co-Scientist" application that runs locally and is open source yet. Instead, the "best" approach currently involves combining several open-source components:

    1. A Local LLM Runner: Software to host and run Large Language Models on your own hardware.
    2. A Powerful Open-Source LLM: The actual "brain" – a model trained on vast amounts of text and code, capable of reasoning, coding, and analysis tasks.
    3. An Interface/Integration: How you interact with the LLM (e.g., a chat interface, a code editor plugin, a dedicated script).

    Here are the best options and combinations available right now, focusing on local execution and available code:

    Core Components (The Building Blocks):

    1. Local LLM Runners (Code Available/Open Source):

      • Ollama (Highly Recommended):
        • What it is: A fantastic tool that makes it incredibly easy to download, set up, and run various open-source LLMs (like Llama 3, Mistral, Code Llama, Phi-3) locally.
        • Code: https://github.com/ollama/ollama (Go, MIT License)
        • Pros: Very easy to use, manages models well, provides a local API server, integrates with many other tools (VS Code extensions, LangChain, etc.). Cross-platform (macOS, Linux, Windows).
        • Cons: Primarily focused on running models via command line or API; UI is basic but improving via community projects.
      • LM Studio:
        • What it is: A popular desktop application with a nice GUI for discovering, downloading, and running local LLMs. Offers configuration options and a chat interface.
        • Code: The application itself is not open source, but it runs open-source models.
        • Pros: User-friendly GUI, easy model discovery, built-in chat, local server compatible with OpenAI API specs.
        • Cons: Not open source itself. Can be resource-intensive.
      • llama.cpp:
        • What it is: The foundational C/C++ implementation for running Llama-based models (and many others converted to its GGUF format) very efficiently, even on CPU or with GPU acceleration.
        • Code: https://github.com/ggerganov/llama.cpp (MIT License)
        • Pros: Highly performant, low-level control, broad hardware support (CPU, Metal, CUDA, OpenCL), the backbone for many other tools (including Ollama and LM Studio).
        • Cons: More technical to set up and use directly compared to Ollama/LM Studio. Requires compiling.
      • GPT4All:
        • What it is: An ecosystem including a desktop chat client and curated open-source models optimized to run well on consumer hardware (even CPUs).
        • Code: https://github.com/nomic-ai/gpt4all (Apache 2.0 License for backend, MIT for chat)
        • Pros: Focus on accessibility and running on average computers, includes RAG (Retrieval-Augmented Generation) for local document Q&A.
        • Cons: Model selection might be slightly more limited than Ollama/LM Studio, performance depends heavily on the specific model used.
    2. Suitable Open Source LLMs (Models to run using the above tools):

      • Llama 3 (Meta): State-of-the-art open models (8B and 70B instruct versions are excellent). Great reasoning and coding capabilities. Requires requesting access but weights are widely available via Ollama/Hugging Face. (License: Llama 3 Community License)
      • Mistral 7B / Mixtral 8x7B (Mistral AI): Very strong models, especially given their size. Mixtral is a Mixture-of-Experts model, often performing close to GPT-3.5 level. Good coding and reasoning. (License: Apache 2.0)
      • Code Llama (Meta): Specifically fine-tuned Llama 2 models for code generation and understanding. Excellent for coding tasks within scientific workflows. (License: Llama 2 Community License)
      • Phi-3 (Microsoft): Surprisingly capable small language models (SLMs) - mini, small, medium. Perform very well for their size, especially the instruct versions. Good balance of reasoning and coding. (License: MIT)
      • DeepSeek Coder: Models specifically trained for coding, often topping benchmarks. (License: MIT for smaller models, specific license for larger ones)

    Putting it Together - "Co-Scientist" Approaches:

    • Approach 1: The Ollama + Versatile Model Setup (Recommended Start)

      • How: Install Ollama. Download a good general-purpose instruction-tuned model (ollama run llama3, ollama run mixtral, ollama run phi3).
      • Use Cases: Use the command line (ollama run modelname) or a compatible GUI (like WebUI for Ollama) to chat with the AI. Ask it to:
        • Explain scientific concepts.
        • Brainstorm hypotheses.
        • Generate Python code snippets for data analysis (using Pandas, NumPy, Matplotlib).
        • Debug code.
        • Summarize text/abstracts (paste text in).
        • Help structure reports or papers.
      • Pros: Easy setup, flexible, access to many SOTA open models, large community.
      • Cons: Requires good prompting, AI might hallucinate (always verify!), performance depends on your hardware.
    • Approach 2: IDE Integration for Coding Focus

      • How: Set up Ollama (or another backend providing an OpenAI-compatible API). Install a VS Code extension like Continue (https://github.com/continuedev/continue) or CodeGPT (https://github.com/carlos-gg/CodeGPT). Configure the extension to point to your local Ollama API endpoint (usually http://localhost:11434). Use a code-focused model like codellama or deepseek-coder, or a strong general model like llama3 or mixtral.
      • Use Cases: Get code suggestions, explanations, debugging help, unit test generation, code refactoring directly within your coding environment (e.g., Python scripts for analysis, simulations).
      • Pros: Seamless integration into the coding workflow, context-aware suggestions.
      • Cons: Primarily focused on code, less on broader scientific reasoning or literature review directly within the editor.
    • Approach 3: RAG for Local Document Research

      • How: Use tools like privateGPT (https://github.com/imartinez/privateGPT) or build your own using frameworks like LangChain (https://github.com/langchain-ai/langchain) or LlamaIndex (https://github.com/run-llama/llama_index). These connect a local LLM (via Ollama, llama.cpp) with local vector stores (containing embeddings of your PDFs/documents).
      • Use Cases: Ask questions about a collection of research papers stored locally on your machine, get summaries based only on those documents.
      • Pros: Query your own private data securely, reduces hallucination by grounding answers in specific documents.
      • Cons: Requires more setup, effectiveness depends on embedding quality and the LLM's ability to synthesize information from retrieved chunks.

    Conclusion & "Best" Recommendation:

    For the "best" balance of ease-of-use, flexibility, performance (relative to local hardware), and open-source nature currently available:

    1. Start with Ollama. It's the easiest way to get powerful local LLMs running.
    2. Download a strong, versatile model:
      • Llama 3 8B: Excellent performance for its size, runs on moderate hardware (8GB+ VRAM recommended, or decent CPU + 16GB RAM).
      • Mixtral 8x7B: More powerful but needs more resources (around 48GB RAM/VRAM).
      • Phi-3 Mini/Small: Great option for lower-end hardware (laptops, less RAM/VRAM).
    3. Interact: Use the Ollama CLI or a compatible web UI for general scientific Q&A, brainstorming, and code generation prompts.
    4. Integrate (Optional): If coding is central, add a VS Code extension like Continue connected to your Ollama instance for in-editor assistance. If querying local papers is key, explore setting up privateGPT or a LangChain/LlamaIndex RAG pipeline.

    Key Considerations:

    • Hardware: Local AI is demanding. More RAM (system memory) and VRAM (GPU memory) allow you to run larger, more capable models faster.
    • Model Choice: Bigger models are generally smarter but slower and require more resources. Choose based on your hardware and needs. Instruction-tuned (instruct) models are best for chat/Q&A.
    • Verification: **Never

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.

Identical first prompt