Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
Perplexitysonar-reasoning· PerplexityHugging Face LMArena Search Arena 24K

Please give me a step by step tutorial of how to turn on cargodist in openttd please…

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with Perplexitysonar-reasoning-pro-high’s answer.
  1. User

    Please give me a step by step tutorial of how to turn on cargodist in openttd please assume I start on the title screen

  2. Perplexity Assistant

    To enable Cargodist in OpenTTD, follow these steps:

    1. Start a new game or load an existing save
      From the title screen, select "New Game" or "Load Game." Cargodist works in both scenarios[4].

    2. Access Advanced Settings

      • Pause the game (Spacebar).
      • Click the Settings button (wrench icon) > Advanced Settings.
      • Under Category, select Expert to view all options[1][2].
    3. Enable Cargodist for specific cargo types

      • In the search bar, type cargo distribution to filter settings.
      • Adjust these key parameters for passengers, mail, or other cargo:
        • Distribution mode:
          • Manual: Classic behavior (no destination routing).
          • Symmetric: Balanced cargo flow between connected stations.
          • Asymmetric: Demand-based routing (recommended for realism)[1][2][5].
        • Link graph update interval: Reduce to 10-20 days for faster route adjustments[1][4].
    4. Configure vehicle orders

      • Create routes between stations without using transfer/unload commands.
      • Use non-stop orders (Ctrl+Click stations) to prevent unnecessary stops[4][5].
      • Example train orders:
        Go to Station A (non-stop)
        Go to Station B (non-stop)
        Go to Station C (non-stop)
        
    5. Monitor cargo flow

      • Use the Link Graph Overlay (smallmap > cargo type) to visualize routes and capacity[1][5].
      • Check station cargo lists to see destination breakdowns (click station > Cargo tab)[1][5].

    Pro tips:

    • Larger stations with multiple transport connections naturally attract more routed cargo[4][7].
    • Avoid mixed cargo types on vehicles for clearer destination tracking[6].
    • Adjust station catchment areas to balance supply/demand using Coverage Highlight (query tool)[7].

    Cargodist automatically calculates optimal routes based on your network. Passenger demand typically stabilizes within 1-2 in-game years after setup[1][4].

  3. User

    I have a setting called "Distribution mode for passengers". Is it that?

  4. Perplexity Assistant

    Yes, the "Distribution mode for passengers" setting controls Cargodist behavior for passengers. Here's how it works:

    Modes:

    1. Manual

      • Classic OpenTTD behavior: Passengers board any vehicle without destination tracking[1][4].
    2. Symmetric

      • Balances passenger flow between connected stations (e.g., if 100 passengers go from Town A to B, ~100 will try to return)[1][7].
      • Uses "Returning cargo percentage" setting to control balance strictness[1].
    3. Asymmetric (Recommended)

      • Realistic demand-based routing: Passengers choose destinations based on station size/distance[1][4][7].
      • Creates complex network flows requiring transfer points[4][8].

    Key impacts:

    • Stations show destination breakdowns in Cargo tab[1][5]
    • Link Graph Overlay visualizes passenger flows[1][5]
    • Vehicles automatically handle transfers without manual orders[1][4]

    For active destination routing, set this to Asymmetric and configure other cargodist settings like Link graph update interval[1][4].

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.