Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
Perplexitysonar· PerplexityHugging Face LMArena Search Arena 24K

The following is a guide to get all endings on a game:…

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with Perplexitysonar-reasoning’s answer.
  1. User

    The following is a guide to get all endings on a game: https://steamah.com/maid-mansion-complete-walkthrough-with-all-endings/. Optimize the guide by comparing the different paths and then grouping the same choices together up until points of divergence so as to reduce the number of saves to the minimum required to get all endings.

  2. Perplexity Assistant

    To optimize the Maid Mansion all-endings guide by grouping shared choices and minimizing save points, we analyze the decision paths leading to the 22 endings as detailed in the comprehensive walkthrough from SteamAH and Gameplay.tips[2][5]. The goal is to identify common early choices and only branch saves at divergence points, reducing redundant playthroughs.


    Overview of Key Divergence Points and Shared Paths

    1. Initial Major Branch: Choosing Between Umeko’s or Takako’s Route

    • The game’s endings split early based on whether you side with Umeko or Takako.
    • This is the first major save point:
      • Save A: Choose Umeko’s path.
      • Save B: Choose Takako’s path.

    2. Within Umeko’s Path

    • Early choices like punishing Takako or not punishing Takako lead to different endings.

    • Most Umeko endings start with:

      • Punish Takako (leading to endings like Stairway to Heaven, I’m a Loser Baby, It Ain’t Me Babe)
      • Don’t punish Takako (leading to endings like You Give Love a Bad Name)
    • Second save point within Umeko’s path:

      • Save A1: Punish Takako
      • Save A2: Don’t punish Takako
    • After this, many choices are shared, such as:

      • Giving a quick kick
      • Whether to tell Umeko or not
      • Trusting or not trusting Takako
      • Whether Misaki stays or leaves
      • How to handle confrontations (reprimand or accept silence)
    • Divergences occur mainly at:

      • Trusting Takako or not
      • Whether Misaki stays or leaves
      • Accusing Takako, Narumi, or others
      • How to respond to demands (give nothing, tease, force, etc.)
    • These can be grouped to minimize saves by:

      • Saving before the trust Takako choice
      • Saving before the Misaki stay/leave choice
      • Saving before the accusation choice

    3. Within Takako’s Path

    • Early choices include:

      • Making Takako apologize or not
      • Interfering or not
      • Telling Umeko or not
      • Punishing Takako or not
    • Second save point within Takako’s path:

      • Save B1: Make Takako apologize
      • Save B2: Don’t make Takako apologize (if applicable)
    • Further branching depends on:

      • Trusting Takako or not
      • Misaki staying or leaving
      • Spying or interrupting
      • Handling reprimands and lessons
    • Save before these key choices to cover all endings:

      • Trust Takako or not
      • Misaki stay or leave
      • Spy or interrupt

    Summary Table of Save Points and Branches

    Save PointChoice to MakeBranches CoveredNotes
    Save 1Umeko’s vs Takako’s pathAll endings split hereFirst major divergence
    Save 2APunish Takako (Umeko’s path)Endings 1,2,3,6 etc.Within Umeko’s route
    Save 2BDon’t punish Takako (Umeko’s path)Ending 5 etc.Alternative Umeko endings
    Save 3ATrust Takako or not (Umeko’s path)Multiple endingsSave before trust decision
    Save 3BMisaki stay or leave (Umeko’s path)Multiple endingsSave before Misaki decision
    Save 4AMake Takako apologize (Takako’s path)Endings 20,21 etc.Within Takako’s route
    Save 4BDon’t make Takako apologize (Takako’s path)Other Takako endingsIf applicable
    Save 5ATrust Takako or not (Takako’s path)Multiple endingsSave before trust decision
    Save 5BMisaki stay or leave (Takako’s path)Multiple endingsSave before Misaki decision
    Save 6Spy or interrupt (Takako’s path)Some endingsFinal branching

    Optimized Playthrough Strategy

    1. Start game and save before first major choice: Umeko’s or Takako’s path.

    2. Play through Umeko’s path:

      • Save before punishing Takako.
      • Save before trusting Takako.
      • Save before Misaki’s stay/leave decision.
      • Save before accusation or confrontation choices.
    3. Reload and play through Takako’s path:

      • Save before making Takako apologize.
      • Save before trusting Takako.
      • Save before Misaki’s stay/leave decision.
      • Save before spying or interrupting.
    4. Use these saves to quickly jump between endings by changing only the choices at the divergence points.


    This approach reduces the number of saves drastically compared to saving before every single choice, as many early choices are shared across multiple endings. By focusing on the major branching decisions—Umeko vs Takako, punish vs don’t punish, trust vs don’t trust, Misaki stay vs leave, and key confrontations—you can efficiently unlock all 22 endings with minimal reloads and saves.

    This optimization is based on the detailed choice lists and endings from the Maid Mansion walkthroughs on SteamAH and Gameplay.tips[2][5].

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.