Skip to content
The Chat Archive
gemini-2.5-flash-preview-04-17-grounding· Google LMArena Search Arena 24K

I am trying to make a game where people have to guess which products is to hardest to…

  1. User

    I am trying to make a game where people have to guess which products is to hardest to make. <i would like a benchmark of current games like that. please do an extensive and detailed online search for alternatives.

  2. Assistant

    Based on the extensive online search, there isn't a direct benchmark of games where the primary gameplay is guessing which products are the hardest to make in a manufacturing or crafting sense. This seems to be a relatively unique concept.

    However, the search results reveal several related game genres and mechanics that could serve as inspiration or provide alternative approaches for your game:

    Games with Complex Crafting Systems:

    • Many survival, RPG, and simulation games feature intricate crafting systems where players combine various resources to create items [1, 2, 3, 7, 10][1]. Games like Factorio, Gregtech (a Minecraft modpack), the Atelier series, and others focus heavily on the complexity of production chains and recipes [2, 3]. While players aren't guessing the difficulty, they experience and learn the complexity through gameplay[2][3].
    • Some games, like those in the Atelier series, make crafting the central focus, with each game having a slightly different, deep system [3].

    Games with Guessing or Ranking Mechanics:

    • There are various guessing games, although they typically focus on guessing words, prices, or hidden objects, rather than manufacturing difficulty [4, 5, 6, 9, 22, 24, 25, 26, 27].
    • "Guess The Price" games involve players estimating the cost of products, which shares a similarity in requiring players to make an educated guess about an item based on potentially limited information [20, 24, 26][4].
    • Games with hidden stats or skill ratings require players to make decisions or evaluate based on imperfect information, similar to guessing difficulty [28, 30]. Some games intentionally blackbox certain information to encourage experimentation or focus on other mechanics [30][5].

    Games Focused on Difficulty and Challenge:

    • Many games are known for their high difficulty, requiring players to master complex mechanics or overcome challenging obstacles [12, 14, 15, 17, 18][3]. While not about guessing difficulty, they highlight the player's perception and experience of challenge.

    Manufacturing and Simulation Games:

    • Factory simulation games like Factorio, Satisfactory, and others involve building and optimizing production lines to create products [1, 13][6]. The complexity lies in designing efficient systems, not necessarily guessing the difficulty of individual items.
    • Games like Big Pharma involve managing the production of goods (medicines) with varying complexities [2][7].

    Insights for Your Game:

    Since a direct benchmark doesn't appear to exist, your game has the potential to be quite novel. You could draw inspiration from:

    • Complex crafting systems: Implement a system where products have underlying "complexity" values based on the number of components, processing steps, or rare resources required.
    • Guessing game mechanics: Design a core loop where players are presented with a selection of products and must rank or guess their relative manufacturing difficulty[8].
    • Hidden information: Keep some aspects of the manufacturing process or required resources hidden, forcing players to make educated guesses based on visual cues, product descriptions, or perhaps a limited number of "hints" they can use.
    • Progression: Start with simpler products and introduce more complex ones as the game progresses, allowing players to learn and refine their guessing skills.
    • Feedback: Provide clear feedback after each guess, revealing the actual difficulty and perhaps some information about why a product is difficult to make (e.g., "This requires a rare earth mineral," or "This involves a complex multi-stage assembly process").

    In summary, while there are no direct competitors identified, you can look to the mechanics of complex crafting, various guessing games, and manufacturing simulations for ideas on how to structure your gameplay and represent product complexity[6].

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.