Azur lane - San Diego or Scylla stronger in surface DPS not comparing AA, and which CLs…
- User
Azur lane - San Diego or Scylla stronger in surface DPS not comparing AA, and which CLs have a higher DPS/clear, if any?
Assistant
Okay, let's break down the surface DPS comparison between San Diego and Scylla, and look at other top-tier Light Cruisers (CLs) in Azur Lane for damage output.
Remember that DPS can be complex, depending heavily on equipment, skill levels, fleet composition, limit break status, retrofits, and the specific enemies you are facing.
Based on the search results and general Azur Lane community consensus:
San Diego (Retrofit) vs. Scylla - Surface DPS:
-
San Diego (Retrofit):
- Strengths: While legendary for her Anti-Air (AA) capabilities, San Diego's retrofit significantly boosted her surface damage as well. She has good gun efficiency, decent base Firepower, and skills that buff her own stats (including Firepower and AA which indirectly helps survivability allowing more uptime for damage). Her All-Out Assault (AOA) barrage, while needing more shots to trigger post-retrofit, adds to her damage. She is often considered a very strong generalist CL, providing both top-tier AA and solid surface DPS, especially valuable in mixed-threat environments like Chapters 12, 13, and potentially 15.
- Weaknesses: Her surface DPS, while good, isn't specialized or top-tier compared to dedicated damage dealers. Her retrofit is very expensive[1][2]. Pre-retrofit San Diego has very weak surface DPS.
-
Scylla:
- Strengths: Scylla is noted for having surprisingly good surface damage, often keeping pace with strong CLs like Harbin in certain tests, especially in barrage-heavy environments like Chapter 14 where aimed shots can miss stealthed enemies. She has strong barrages and decent AA as well (though not at San Diego's level)[3].
- Weaknesses: Her overall utility might be slightly less broad than Retrofit San Diego due to the sheer dominance of Sandy's AA. Her performance can depend on procs and enemy types.
Direct Comparison:
- Generally, San Diego (Retrofit) is considered to have higher consistent and reliable surface DPS compared to Scylla in most general-purpose scenarios. Her combination of good gunnery stats and self-buffs often leads to solid performance across various situations.
- Scylla can potentially spike higher in specific situations, particularly where her barrages are highly effective (e.g., against waves of lighter enemies or in specific chapters like 14). Some analyses suggest Scylla's surface damage keeps up with or even slightly exceeds Harbin in specific tests, placing her potentially above San Diego in pure surface DPS in those niche scenarios.
- Pre-Retrofit San Diego is significantly weaker than Scylla in surface DPS. The comparison really only makes sense for Retrofit San Diego.
Conclusion (San Diego vs. Scylla): For general surface clearing and contribution, San Diego (Retrofit) is often preferred due to her strong overall package and consistency. However, Scylla is a very capable CL with high surface damage potential that can rival or exceed Sandy's in specific circumstances.
Other CLs with Higher Surface DPS/Clear:
Yes, absolutely. Several CLs, particularly Priority Research (PR) and Decisive Rarity (DR) ships, significantly outperform both San Diego (Retrofit) and Scylla in pure surface DPS and wave clearing (mobbing) potential:
- Plymouth (DR): Widely considered the pinnacle of CL surface DPS. Her damage output is monstrously high and consistent, often rivaling battleships. She excels against light armor and performs exceptionally well against medium armor too. She also provides a powerful flagship buff[4].
- Harbin (PR): Another top-tier PR CL known for exceptional mob-clearing capabilities and very high surface damage, particularly with her torpedoes and strong barrages.
- Mainz (PR): An Iron Blood CL known for her tankiness and strong gunnery DPS. Very solid and consistent damage dealer[3][4].
- Seattle (PR): A strong USN CL focusing on gunnery DPS with consistent output.
- Shimanto (DR): Excellent mobbing tank with high raw AA damage and strong torpedo output. Her overall damage contribution is very high, especially in AA-heavy stages.
- Bayard: Known for exceptionally strong performance in campaign mobbing, potentially rivaling or exceeding Plymouth in that specific context due to her skills and barrages.
- Helena (Retrofit): While her personal DPS isn't the absolute highest, her "Radar Scan" skill provides a massive debuff to enemy Evasion and increases damage taken, drastically boosting the entire fleet's DPS against bosses. This makes her arguably the single most impactful CL for boss fights, even if others have higher personal numbers.
Summary:
- Between San Diego (Retrofit) and Scylla, San Diego (Retrofit) generally offers stronger and more consistent surface DPS for general use, alongside her unmatched AA. Scylla is still very strong and can peak higher in specific situations.
- Several CLs, especially PR/DR ships like Plymouth and Harbin, boast significantly higher raw surface DPS and clearing potential than either San Diego or Scylla.
- The "best" CL depends on the specific task (mobbing vs. bossing), enemy types, and fleet synergy (e.g., Helena for boss debuffs, Kazagumo for carrier fleets).
-
Other models, same or similar prompt
Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.