Using flux from diffusers library. I put pipe.setprogressbar(disable=False) to see…
- User
Using flux from diffusers library. I put pipe.set_progress_bar(disable=False) to see progress. I used the logging from diffusers.utils to log to a file with verbosity set to debug, but nothing came after starting gradio. Calling res = pipe(...). But the progress does not even show until a whole night (~8h)
- Assistant
You're encountering a few issues with the progress bar display when using the Flux pipeline from the Diffusers library. Let me help you troubleshoot this problem.
Correct Method for Setting Progress Bar
First, there's a syntax error in your code. The correct method to enable or disable the progress bar is
set_progress_bar_config(), notset_progress_bar(). The proper usage would be:pipe.set_progress_bar_config(disable=False)This enables the tqdm progress bars during inference[7][11].
Progress Bar Issues with Flux
The extremely long delay you're experiencing (approximately 8 hours) suggests there might be a specific issue with Flux. Based on the search results, there are a few potential causes:
- Torch Compilation: If you're using
torch.compilewith Flux, this can cause significant delays. Compilation can take up to 20 minutes on first iteration, and the artifacts cannot be fully serialized, meaning some compilation work must be re-executed every time a new container is started[10]. The proper configuration for Flux with torch.compile would be:
config = torch._inductor.config config.disable_progress = False # show progress bar- UI Visualization Issues: Sometimes the progress bar is actually running but not visible due to UI rendering problems. This has been reported in web UI implementations of Stable Diffusion where the progress bar is covered by other elements[3][16].
Logging Configuration
Regarding your logging setup, make sure you're using the correct logging configuration for Diffusers:
from diffusers.utils import logging # Setup file logging logger = logging.get_logger("diffusers") logging.set_verbosity_debug() # Set to most verbose level # To log to a file, you need to set up a file handler import logging as python_logging file_handler = python_logging.FileHandler("diffusers_log.txt") logger.logger.addHandler(file_handler)The Diffusers library has verbosity levels: CRITICAL/FATAL (50), ERROR (40), WARNING/WARN (30), INFO (20), and DEBUG (10)[2][4]. The default verbosity is set to WARNING[18].
Additional Troubleshooting Steps
If you're still experiencing issues after making these corrections:
- Update your tqdm library:
pip install --upgrade tqdm[1] - Check if there are any GitHub issues for the specific version of Flux you're using[12]
- Try running a simpler example first to confirm basic functionality
- Ensure you're not hitting memory limitations that might cause processing to slow down
For debugging purposes, you might want to temporarily disable the progress bar (
disable=True) to see if it affects the overall execution time, which would help determine if the issue is with the progress display or with the actual processing.If you're using Gradio, there might be specific issues with progress bar visualization in that environment, as noted in several discussions about progress bars in web UIs[17].
Remember that if you're using the latest version of Flux with torch.compile, significant compilation time is expected on first run, though 8 hours seems excessive and suggests there might be other issues at play.
- Torch Compilation: If you're using
- User
Latest diffusers since taken from git repo. Pipe is FluxControlNetInpaintingPipeline.from_pretrained(pretrained_midel_name_or_path=base_model_path, controlnet=controlnet, transformer=transformer, torche.dtype=torche bfloat16). Not GPU since not enough vram so using CPU. It uses around 8.5Gb. Input image is a 900x512 rbg image. Pipe is called as such: res = pipe(prompt="There's nothing here.", control_image=input_image['image'].convert('RGB'), control_mask=input_image['mask'].convert('RGB'), width=W, height=H, num_inference_step=28, generator=torch.Generator("cpu").manual_seed(seed), controlnet_conditioning_scale=scale).images[0]
- Assistant
Running Flux Control Inpainting Pipeline on CPU: Performance Issues and Solutions
You're experiencing a common issue when running the Flux model on CPU—extremely slow inference times without visible progress indicators. This is expected behavior given the model's complexity and your hardware constraints.
Understanding Your Current Setup
Your current implementation is:
pipe = FluxControlNetInpaintingPipeline.from_pretrained( pretrained_model_name_or_path=base_model_path, controlnet=controlnet, transformer=transformer, torch_dtype=torch.bfloat16 ) res = pipe( prompt="There's nothing here.", control_image=input_image['image'].convert('RGB'), control_mask=input_image['mask'].convert('RGB'), width=W, height=H, num_inference_steps=28, generator=torch.Generator("cpu").manual_seed(seed), controlnet_conditioning_scale=scale ).imagesKey Issues
1. CPU Processing is Extremely Slow for Flux
Flux models are extremely computation-intensive. A full-sized Flux model typically requires around 24GB of VRAM even for basic operations[2]. Running on CPU will be orders of magnitude slower than on GPU. The 8-hour processing time you're experiencing is not unusual.
2. Progress Bar Configuration
You need to use
set_progress_bar_config()instead ofset_progress_bar():pipe.set_progress_bar_config(disable=False)However, even with this correct configuration, the issue is that the progress bar won't appear until the model begins actual sampling steps, which happens after model initialization and prompt processing[3].
3. Memory Efficiency vs. Speed
You're using around 8.5GB of memory, which indicates you've optimized for memory usage, but this comes at the cost of processing speed. Using bfloat16 on CPU might also not be optimal since not all CPU hardware has efficient bfloat16 support.
Recommended Solutions
1. Implement Group Offloading for Memory Efficiency
If upgrading to a GPU isn't possible, implement group offloading to improve memory usage patterns:
from diffusers.hooks import apply_group_offloading # Apply to each model component apply_group_offloading( pipe.transformer, offload_type="leaf_level", offload_device=torch.device("cpu"), onload_device=torch.device("cpu") ) apply_group_offloading( pipe.text_encoder, offload_device=torch.device("cpu"), onload_device=torch.device("cpu"), offload_type="leaf_level" ) # Repeat for other model componentsThis approach was mentioned in issue #10790 and helped users run Flux models with much lower memory requirements[2].
2. Use FP8 or Quantized Models
Consider using FP8 versions of Flux models which require less memory, though they may be even slower on CPU. A Reddit user reported that even on a 4070 Ti GPU, Flux Dev FP8 took 40 minutes for one image[7].
3. Add Custom Progress Reporting
Since the built-in progress bar isn't showing up until very late in the process, implement your own progress tracking:
# Add a callback function to track progress def progress_callback(pipe, step, timestep, callback_kwargs): print(f"Step {step}/{pipe.scheduler.config.num_train_timesteps}: Processing...") # Use it in your pipeline call res = pipe( # ... your existing parameters ... callback_on_step_end=progress_callback, callback_on_step_end_tensor_inputs=["latents"] ).images4. Consider Lower Resolution
Your input image is 900x512. Consider reducing this further for testing to speed up the process[5]. Flux models typically work best at specific resolutions (768x768 or 1024x1024), so adjusting your dimensions might help[4][5].
5. Try Simpler Variants
If available, try using
FluxFillPipelineinstead of the full ControlNet version for inpainting tasks, as it might be more efficient[3].Expectations for CPU Inference
Even with all optimizations, expect:
- Very long processing times (potentially 8+ hours) for a single image
- High memory usage
- Limited ability to see progress until near completion
Flux is designed primarily for powerful GPUs, and CPU inference is dramatically slower. If possible, consider using cloud GPU services or other lightweight alternatives for inpainting tasks when GPU resources are limited.
- User
The thing it that the progress bar does not show until a very long time meaning no actual work is being done by the model but by something else. Already tried offloading Hook but still run into Out of Memory error
- Assistant
Flux Memory Management and Progress Bar Issues on CPU
You're experiencing a common but frustrating issue with Flux models running on CPU. The extremely long delay before the progress bar appears isn't a UI bug—it's a symptom of how the model handles memory and initialization, particularly on CPU-only setups.
Why Your Progress Bar Is Delayed
The long delay before seeing progress is primarily caused by several factors:
-
Intensive Model Initialization: Flux models require significant initialization time, especially when running on CPU. What's happening in those first several hours is the model is loading weights, compiling computation graphs, and preparing tensors—all before the first actual inference step begins[10][8].
-
Limited Memory Management: When running FluxControlNetInpaintingPipeline on CPU with 8.5GB RAM usage, you're in a memory-constrained environment. The progress bar typically only appears once the model begins the actual denoising steps, but it has to complete substantial setup work first[3][11].
-
Memory Swapping: Without enough VRAM, the system is likely heavily swapping memory between RAM and disk, creating significant overhead before the first inference step can even start[15][8].
The Underlying Memory Problem
Even with offloading hooks, you're still hitting Out of Memory errors because:
-
Flux Model Requirements: Flux models typically require at least 24GB of VRAM in default precision[8]. Running on CPU means the entire initialization process is dramatically slower and more memory-intensive than it would be on a capable GPU.
-
Control Network + Inpainting: The combination of ControlNet with inpainting significantly increases memory requirements compared to standard text-to-image generation. This is why you're seeing speeds of "40 s/it" for inpainting compared to much faster times for text-to-image[15].
Effective Solutions for CPU-Based Inference
Since upgrading hardware isn't an immediate option, here are more effective approaches for your CPU-based workflow:
1. Use More Aggressive Memory Optimization
# More effective CPU offloading pipe = FluxControlNetInpaintingPipeline.from_pretrained( pretrained_model_name_or_path=base_model_path, controlnet=controlnet, transformer=transformer, torch_dtype=torch.float32 # Try standard precision instead of bfloat16 ) # Use this instead of the standard offloading hook pipe.enable_sequential_cpu_offload() # Add this to minimize peak memory usage pipe.enable_attention_slicing(slice_size="auto")These changes create a more memory-efficient pipeline that should reduce the likelihood of OOM errors[17][5].
2. Use Quantized Models
Search for 8-bit or 4-bit quantized versions of Flux models. As mentioned in search result #18, there are versions designed specifically for GPUs with less than 12GB VRAM, which would also perform better on CPU[18][15].
3. Implement Custom Progress Reporting
The standard progress bar won't appear until actual inference steps begin. Add custom logging to track initialization:
import time import logging logging.basicConfig(level=logging.INFO) logger = logging.getLogger(__name__) # Before calling the pipeline start_time = time.time() logger.info("Starting model initialization...") # Every few seconds, log progress def print_initialization_status(): elapsed = time.time() - start_time logger.info(f"Still initializing... {elapsed:.1f} seconds elapsed") # Set up a timer to call this function every 30 seconds import threading timer = threading.Timer(30.0, print_initialization_status) timer.start() # Then run your pipeline res = pipe(...)This won't speed up the process but will at least give you visibility into what's happening[5].
4. Reduce Image Size
Your 900x512 image is already relatively small, but reducing dimensions further for development/testing will significantly reduce memory requirements and initialization time[5][14].
5. Set PYTORCH_CUDA_ALLOC_CONF
Even though you're on CPU, setting this environment variable can help with memory management:
import os os.environ["PYTORCH_CUDA_ALLOC_CONF"] = "expandable_segments:True"This helps avoid memory fragmentation during the allocation process[8].
Expected Performance on CPU
Even with all these optimizations, you should expect:
- Very long initialization times (potentially 1-2 hours)
- Per-step inference times of 40+ seconds once started
- Total generation times of 8+ hours for a single image
This is simply the nature of running complex diffusion models like Flux on CPU. The combination of ControlNet and inpainting makes this particularly challenging, as noted by users experiencing similar issues in search results #11, #12, and #15.
If possible, consider cloud-based GPU options for faster inference, as the performance difference between CPU and even a modest GPU is substantial for these types of models.
-
Other models, same or similar prompt
Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.