Skip to content
The Chat Archive
Perplexitysonar-pro-high· PerplexityHugging Face LMArena Search Arena 24K

Write a “The Reason You Suck” speech targeted at Juan Miguel Zunzunegui

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with gpt-4o-search-preview-high’s answer.
  1. User

    Write a “The Reason You Suck” speech targeted at Juan Miguel Zunzunegui

  2. Perplexity Assistant

    Juan Miguel Zunzunegui, let’s get right to the point: you’ve built your reputation on being a “revisionist” historian, but your work is a masterclass in trading one set of myths for another, all while cherry-picking facts and sources to fit your personal narrative. You claim to be dismantling the dogmas of Mexican history, yet you simply replace them with your own—often unsupported—assertions, like suggesting Hernán Cortés should be the “father of the nation” while glossing over or outright ignoring the atrocities he committed, such as the massacre of thousands of Cholultecas and the destruction of Tenochtitlán[11]. You elevate figures like Porfirio Díaz as heroes of modernity, conveniently omitting the brutal repression, indigenous exploitation, and staggering inequality of his regime[11].

    Your books are riddled with contradictions: you denounce historical myths, then manufacture new ones. You criticize others for lacking rigor, yet your own work is often light on citations and heavy on personal opinion, leaving readers to wonder where your facts actually come from[11]. When you do reference other scholars, you sometimes fail to credit them properly, as with your unacknowledged borrowing from Christian Duverger’s work on Cortés[11].

    As a storyteller, your attempts at historical fiction fall flat. Your characters are clichés, your plots predictable, and your dialogue stilted—more like a history lecture than a compelling narrative[13]. Instead of weaving history and fiction seamlessly, you bog down your novels with infodumps and transparent authorial opinions, sacrificing character development and dramatic tension for didacticism[13].

    You present yourself as a champion of critical thinking, but your selectivity with evidence and tendency to present your views as the only rational perspective betray a dogmatism of your own. You rail against the “Black Legend” and Anglo-Saxon colonialism, but your defense of the Spanish Empire is so one-sided it borders on apologetics, dismissing legitimate critiques as childish or ignorant[4][9]. You claim to offer a “broad” view, but your work too often reduces complex historical realities to simplistic binaries and self-serving narratives.

    In short, your brand of revisionism is less about uncovering truth and more about replacing one orthodoxy with another—yours. You challenge the status quo, but only to install yourself as the new arbiter of historical meaning. If your goal was to spark debate, congratulations. But if it was to enlighten, you might want to start by holding yourself to the same standards of rigor and honesty you demand from others[11][13].

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.