Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
Perplexitysonar-reasoning· PerplexityHugging Face LMArena Search Arena 24K

Which version of Magisk is the best: 1. the OG 2. Kitsune Mask 3. Magisk Alpha?

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with Perplexitysonar-reasoning-pro-high’s answer.
  1. User

    Which version of Magisk is the best: 1. the OG 2. Kitsune Mask 3. Magisk Alpha?

  2. Perplexity Assistant

    The best Magisk version depends on your specific needs, such as root hiding capabilities, module compatibility, and customization. Here's a breakdown of each option:

    1. Official Magisk (OG)

    • Stability & Updates: The official version receives regular updates (latest v28.1 as of 2024) with bug fixes and new features like Zygisk for hiding root[2][5].
    • Module Compatibility: Works seamlessly with popular modules like Shamiko for bypassing root detection in banking apps[1][6].
    • Root Hiding: Requires Shamiko or DenyList configurations for effective hiding, but some users report issues with stricter apps[1][5].

    2. Kitsune Mask (Magisk Delta Fork)

    • Superior Root Hiding: Built-in hiding methods often bypass banking app detection without needing Shamiko[1][8].
    • Open Source: Forked from Magisk Delta, it prioritizes stealth and customization (e.g., renaming the Magisk app)[1][8].
    • Drawbacks: Shamiko is incompatible, and switching from OG Magisk may require reinstalling modules[1].

    3. Magisk Alpha

    • Advanced Features: Retains Magisk Hide (removed in official builds) and offers granular root permission control[6][7].
    • Module Support: Compatible with Shamiko, making it effective for some banking apps that fail on other versions[1][7].
    • Stability Issues: Users report occasional app crashes, and updates are less frequent compared to OG Magisk[1][7].

    Comparison Table

    FeatureOfficial MagiskKitsune MaskMagisk Alpha
    Root HidingRequires Shamiko[1]Built-in[1][8]Shamiko-compatible[1]
    UpdatesFrequent[2][5]Moderate[8]Less frequent[7]
    Ease of UseUser-friendly[5]Requires setup[1]Advanced controls[7]
    Module CompatibilityBroad support[1][5]Limited by fork[1]Broad support[1][7]

    Recommendation

    • General Users: Official Magisk (Canary) with Shamiko[1][2] for balance between stability and functionality.
    • Strict Root Detection: Kitsune Mask for better out-of-the-box hiding[1][8].
    • Power Users: Magisk Alpha for advanced customization, but expect potential instability[1][7].

    For banking apps, Kitsune Mask or Magisk Alpha may perform better, but results vary by device and app[1][7]. Always back up data before switching versions.

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.